High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19273/2013dismissed

Subhash Chand v. Punjab Water Resources Management & Dev. Corp. Ltd & ORS

2017-10-12Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan5 pages

!"# #$%&%'( )*+,!&,,!'- ..

#"%"%'#/ 0#/&*&

*'1!+!"#/ #&*/$#&!'!2#3#'" #4#563#'"/6/!"%'7"-!'-",#/& ..

#&6'-#'"&

/#&#'"(.

/!'%&,!-8!59-4$!"# /",#6#"%"%'#/ /) */%9-4$!"# /",#/#&6'-#'"& :::

;< 665%$!"%'%&!558#-!&6/!=#- / $*3#'"&!"''#>*/#& .!'- .?!/#"!@#''/#$/- 365#"#$6= ",#!665%$!"%'!5'28%",''#>*/#& .!'- .?!5/#!-= &"!'-& */'%&,#-"",#$*'&#566&%"# !%'!&#

#"%"%'#/98,%&&#/4%'2!&!*+#8#55 6#/!"/*'-#/",#

*'1!+!"#/ #&*/$#&!'!2#3#'"#4#563#'"/6/!"%'7"-

,#/#%'!

"#/"+#/# #//#-"!&",#/6/!"%' 9,!& %5#-",#%'&"!'"

6#"%"%' !&&!%5%'2 ",# /-#/ -!"#- ''#>*/# .A 9 8,#/#+= 6/%4!"#/#&6'-#'"&';"<,!4#+##'6/3"#-"",#6&" *'%/ '2%'##/ #"%"%'#/$5!%3&,%3&#5 "+#&#'%/"",#6/%4!"#/#&6'-#'"& !'-!$$/-%'25=&##@&",#%&&*!'$# !/%" !'-!3*& /-%/#$"%'2",# /#&6'-#'"&"6/3"#,%3"",#6&" *'%/'2%'##/8# ",#-!"#",# 6/%4!"#/#&6'-#'"&,!4#+##'&6/3"#-8%",!55$'&#B*#'"%!5+#'# %"&

/%# !$"&98,%$,!/#'"%'-%&6*"#!/#",!"",#6#"%"%'#/8!& %'%"%!55=!66%'"#-!&!*'%/ 6#/!"/'? "#/!6#/%- '# =#!/6#"%"%'#/8!&6/3"#-"",#6&" *+#8#55 6#/!"/ 66%'"3#'""",#6&" *'%/'2%'##/%&24#/'#-+=",#

*'1!+)"!"#*+#8#55/6/!"%'365=##&)#/4%$#=#7!8&9

,#/#%'!

"#/"+#/# #//#-!&",#=#7!8& 66%'"3#'""4!/%*& 6&"&*'-#/",#/6/!"%'%'$5*-%'2",!" *'%/'2%'##/%&'",#+!&%& B*!5% %$!"%'&C#>6#/%#'$#!&5!%--8'%'66#'-%>DD ,#/#5#4!'" #>"/!$" 66#'-%>DD$4#/%'2",#6&" *'%/'2%'##/%&!& 558&(.

)/ #&%2'!"%'

",#6&"

)$!5# !=

& E*!5% %$!"%'

-%/#$"

/#$/*%"3#'"

>6#/%#'$#

/-%/#$"

/#$/*%"3#'"

%'%3*3 #>6#/%#'$# / 6/3"%'C/.

!'& #/C#6*".

"%'

#3!/@&C 3#'-3#.

'"& *'%/'2%'##/ A?

F += -%/#$"

/#$/*%"3#'" =#!/& %653!

5#$"/%$!5C%4%5C #$,!'%$!5 '2%'##/%'2

/3 /#$2'%G#- '&"%"*"# .

% AF += 6/3"%' /3 %'

&#/4%$# #365=##& ,!4%'2 =#!/& %653!

5#$"/%$!5C%4%5C #$,!'%$!5 '2%'##/%'2

/3 /#$2'%G#- *'%4#/&%"=C'&"%"* "# 8%", A =#!/& &#/4%$# #>6#/%#'$# %'

)

& 6#/ -#$%&%'

",# "!@#'%'%"& A", ##"%'2

"#3 A ,#5- '

A & 6#/ -#$%&%'

"!@#' += %'

%"& ", %% AF += 6/3"%' /3 %'

&#/4%$# #365=##& ,!4%'2 !"/%$ %$!"%'

8%", *'1!+%!'- =#!/& %653!

5#$"/%$%!'C %""#/ C)*/4#=//!-#& 8%", =#!/& &#/4%$# #>6#/%#'$#%'",# /6/!"%' ##"%'2

"#3 ,#5- '

< +!/# 6#/*&!5 ",# /#5#4!'" #>"/!$" 66#'-%> DD /#6/-*$#-,#/#%'!+4#&,8&",!" F6&"& *'%/'2%'##/&!/#"+#

%55#-*6+=/#&/"%'2"",#3-# -%/#$"/#$/*%"3#'" *" ",#+!5!'$#

F9AF 6&"& *'%/'2%'##/!/#"+# %55#-*6+=6/3"%' /3 %'.&#/4%$##365=##&,!4%'2!"/%$B*!5% %$!"%'8%", *'1!+%!'-=#!/& %653!%'5#$"/%$%!'C %""#/C)*/4#=//!-#8%", =#!/&&#/4%$# #>6#/%#'$#%'",#/6/!"%' ,##'"%/#$!&#&#"*"'+#,!5 ",#6#"%"%'#/%&",!",# 6&&#&&#&",##&&#'"%!56/#&$/%+#-B*!5% %$!"%'

*'%/'2%'##/*'-#/",#AFB*"! /6/3"%'*'-#/66#'-%>DD" ",#=#7!8&!&!5&#>6#/%#'$#%'",#/6/!"%'%'#>$#&&

=#!/&!'-+=4%/"*# +#%'2&#'%/"",#6/%4!"#/#&6'-#'"&8!&4#&"#- 8%",!6/%//%2,""+#$'&%-#/#- *'%/ '2%'##/ '& !/!&&#'%/%"=%&$'$#/'#-9$*'&#5!66#!/%'2 /",# 6#"%"%'#/ 8*5- $'"#'- ",!" ",# 25-#' /*5# $'"%'**& 5#'2",

&#/4%$#8*5-24#/'!'-&%'$#",#6#"%"%'#/,!&1%'#-&#/4%$#8%",",# /6/!"%'6/%/%'6%'" "%3#!&$36!/#-"",#6/%4!"#/#&6'-#'"&9 ,#8*5-/!'@&#'%/"",#3

#/ $'"/!9 5#!/'#- $*'&#5 !66#!/%'2 / ",# /#&6'-#'".

/6/!"%'8*5-*/2#",!"",#B*#&"%' &#'%/%"=8*5-'"+# !'= $'&#B*#'$# %'!&3*$, !& ",# 6#"%"%'#/ -#& '" 6&&#&& ",# #&&#'"%!5 %$!"%'"+#$'&%-#/#- /6/3"%'*'-#/",#AFB*"!!'-!& &*$,98!&'"#5%2%+5#!'-",#/#+=8!&4#/5@#-!"",#"%3# %&&*!'$#

",#%36*2'#-/-#/ 6/3"%'-!"#- !"''#>*/# .A !4%'2 ,#!/- $*'&#5 / ",# 6!/"%#& !" 5#'2", !'- ,!4%'2 6#/*&#-",#65#!-%'2&'/#$/-9",#&,/"%&&*#",!"!/%&#& /-#"#/3%'!"%'

+# /#",%&*/"%&8%",/#2!/-"#5%2%+%5%"= ",#6#"%"%'#/*'-#/",# =#7!8& *'%/'2%'##/

.;.

#"%"%'#/$5!%3& #5%2%+%5%"=!&/#2!/-& B*!5% %$!"%'& ' ",# &"/#'2", -$*3#'"&!"''#>*/# . $55= %#!6/4%&%'!5$#/"% %$!"# -!"#-? %&&*#-+=0%&,8!@!/3!'&"%"*"# #$,'%$!5-*$!"%'

!'-'-*&"/%!5/!%'%'2#'"/#9!58!/!9%&"/%$"&,%!/6*/!'-8,%$, $#/"% %#&,%3",!4#!66#!/#-%'",# %'!5#>!3%'!"%' !'5#$"/%$!5 #$,'%$!5/!-# $*/&# '#=#!/-*/!"%' #5%!'$#,!& */",#/+##'

65!$#-*6'''#>*/# .<9%&&*#-+=/0 !3!' '%4#/&%"=9%5!&6*/

,,!"%&2!/, $#/"% =%'2",#6#"%"%'#/",!4#!""#'-#-!#/"% %$!"#*/&# %'5#$"/%$!5#$,'%$%!'/!-# /",#-*/!"%'*5=9

"*'#9 #!4=/#5%!'$#,!&+##'65!$#-+=$*'&#5 /",#6#"%"%'#/*6'-$*3#'"

!" ''#>*/# . 8,%$, ,!& +##' %&&*#- += 0%&,8!@!/3! '&"%"*"#

#$,'%$!5-*$!"%'!'-'-*&"/%!5/!%'%'2#'"/#9!58!/! &,%!/6*/ -!"#- A < &"!"%'2 ",!" / 0 !3!' '%4#/&%"=9 %5!&6*/

,,!"%&2!/, %&!&"!"*"/=*'%4#/&%"=*'-#/&#$"%'

",# $"

!'-",!"",#"8=#!/&$#/"% %$!"#6&&#&&#-+=",#6#"%"%'#/*'-#/",# 5#$"/%$%!'"/!-#"+##B*%4!5#'""",#%653!+#%'2$*/&#&

&%3%5!/'!"*/#!'-"/!%'%'2 '",#$'&%-#/#-4%#8 ",%&*/"9%"%& /",##365=#/" 6/#&$/%+#B*!5% %$!"%'& /!6!/"%$*5!/6&" '",#6/#&#'"$!&#&*$, %$!"%'&&"!'-$-% %#-*'-#/",#=#7!8&,#/#B*%/#3#'" *'-#/",#=#7!8&%& /!'%'$*3+#'""6&&#&&!"8=#!/& %653!%'5#$"/%$%!'C %""#/C)*/4#=//!-#,#6#"%"%'#/8,%5#$5!%3%'2 $'&%-#/!"%' *'%/'2%'##/8*5-'"+# 4#&"#-8%",!'%',#/#'"/%2,""&##@",#+#'# %" #B*%4!5#'$#/3!"$,%'2 %$!"%'&%'",#!+&#'$# !$5#!/&"%6*5!"%'%'&#/"#-%'",#/#5#4!'" /*5#&C+=#5!8&%'-%$!"%'2",#68#/8%",",#/#&6'-#'"!*",/%"%#&"

.A.

$'&%-#/!'-6/3"#&*$,%'$*3+#'"&98,6&&#&&&*$,B*!5% %$!"%'&

'-#/66#'-%>DD ",#=#7!8&9",#/#%&'&*$,&"%6*5!"%' !'

#365=##6&&#&&%'2#B*%4!5#'"C3!"$,%'2B*!5% %$!"%'&"!"8=#!/& %653! %' ",# 5#$"/%$%!'C %""#/C)*/4#=/ /!-# " +# !5& $'&%-#/#- #5%2%+5# *'%/'2%'##/'"!@%'2&*$,4%#89 ",%&*/"8*5--/!8&*66/" /3!%4%&%'#'$,1*-2#3#'" ",%& */"%'

4#' ",#/8%&#9 %' 3!""#/& #5%2%+%5%"= !'- 6&&#&&%'2 /#B*%&%"#B*!5% %$!"%'&%"8*5-+#",#4%#8 ",##365=#/C/#&6'-#'"

/6/!"%'",!"&,*5-6/#4!%5,%&*/"5!$@&#>6#/"%&#"2%'"",# B*#&"%' #B*%4!5#'$#!'-"",#/#!

"#//#$/-!'6%'%'",!"",#"8 =#!/&$#/"% %$!"#6&&#&&#-+=",#6#"%"%'#/%'",#5#$"/%$%!'/!-#%&! 3!"$,%'2C#B*%4!5#'"B*!5% %$!"%'"",#'#6/#&$/%+#-!'-5!%--8'*'-#/ 66#'-%> DD ",# =#7!8& %#! "8 =#!/& %653! %' 5#$"/%$%!'C %""#/C)*/4#=//!-# " %& '" #4#' ",# $!&# ",# 6#"%"%'#/ ",!" !'= ",#/ %'$*3+#'"98,-#&'"6&&#&&",#"8=#!/&%653!!'-"",# $'"/!/=,!&!"8=#!/&$#/"% %$!"#$*/&#9,!&+##'$'&%-#/#-#5%2%+5#+= ",#/#&6'-#'"/6/!"%' *'%/'2%'##/

/",#/#!&'&/#$/-#-!+4#9",%&*/"-#&'" %'-!'= +!&%& /%'"#/ #/#'$#%'",#3!""#/%'

%/3%"=%& *'-%'",#!$"%'

",#/#&6'-#'" /6/!"%' %' "!@%'2 !4%#8 ",!" ",# 6#"%"%'#/%& '" #5%2%+5# *'%/'2%'##/*'-#/",#=# 7!8&

#"%"%'%&-%&3%&&#-

5*$@= ,#",#/&6#!@%'2C/#!&'#-( #&C ,#",#/ #6/"!+5#( #&C