High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/143/2005dismissed

Ranjeet Singh v. Commr. Of Income Tax

2016-01-13Mr. Justice R.C. Kathuria (Retd.),Ms. Justice Navita Singh11 pages

!"##$%&!'( (#))&**&!#+!,)# -. +&/ 0 / 12 34

%5

4 64

% % 4

!"# $ %

$ % !"# "

# $ & '

( ! )

*( + '

)'' #*+

'

%!

,- *+

+ " " 758) + &$$ 9. %

.%/0 1*

"

#

"

++

2"

*

"

( 1034.

%5 *63

*7 84 %

.%/1

11.

#

"

9 + *

#5 .% /01 .% /0 1

"

#

660*

5"

&

.

%5%

* ) :;:

/ 3 + *7%

84

.%/0<<0

666*

#

# ="

4

"

#

*

%

"

+

1.

%5 *6$

4

+ +

( 1 .

%5 * 6*

"

0><0? "

"

+

"

03434

""

+

$

4

+

( 134.

%5 *6*%

!"

#

"

( 0><0?

"

+ +

# # A

.

%5 + $

+4

* + B %

9 :9 #A"

*

#!"

#A"

*

3664.%?3&C94$ +4

#!

#

""

=" 5 1D

"

#+ +

$

)

* + .%/0 1 %

+ "2

666*

"

/ 0> 660

"

"

#5 ?*< +

'< ,+ B # 2

#3&4E

+

#

""

.

*

"

666.

03434

" 66 %

@

" 0> ?66?

"

#5

+

A&(

# 2

A

.

*

"

%

034

""

%

"

00 + 666*

5"

&

#5

+

##

+ *

A

.

%5 3 4 FA.%34G %

# +

#

*"

"

""

0> *

"

"

# +

134 * "

""

0> "

A A

A

" " %

"# "

+

"

A

% A.%34 + 60*

5"

&* #

# "

03434

##

+ *

%

660*

5"

&*%

.

.%/1*

1034 %

660

+ 11

9

0 +

"

1 %

"

"

"

""

( 0> 660*

"

( 03434

"

( 0? *

"

( 134

A A

A

"

" " . # +

# *

"

" ( 0? ?66?

@

* B

#"

# B " !

+

#1D* B

@ *

"

+ "

"

#

*A.%34 %

"

( 134 "

" 34 ( 1 . "5 ="( 1

#

:% !,$&!+&**8#!$&,# 34.

"

" 34 0 0? +

*

""

0>

*

B

A

" A

* "

-

A

"

" "

+;&/#/* 5

"

+

* "

"

A A

A

*

*

" " 34.

#"

" 34*

""

0>

@ *

B-

A

*

5

"

+

*"

-

A

*

"

*

" " H5 I2 + " *

-

A

*A

A A

* *

#

# @ "

" 0>*

" "

8 ? ( 1

"

2 ( 134 * " # 34

"

034

0? "

+ 5

+

* 0>

"

B

A.% " A.%"

#

"

*-

A.%

"

" "

34.* + *

"

5

"

034

0?*

"

A A.% A.%

" " % *

*

B

A.%

" "

# *

A.% A A.%

>

#( 134*

""

( 0>

B -

A

.

%5 5

"

+

-

A

.

%5

*

"

*

" " 6 %%

#"

#

4

3664.%0>3 4

4

! "

* 366?460%5 034

4 #$ % 34%5 06 , "

# "

( 03434 +

"

" ( 0? "

. !"# 9 #A"

& 3 " 4 =" +

5A"

" '

( )"* *3?46.%1@ *

" 34( 1 .

#

%

0> 660 +

?660

"

666%

"

" " 66

+ +

134

66*

:

"

666

"

( 03434 66@

( 03434

"

%"

*

#

" ?66?

"

+

A&(

# + % +

%

"

7?+

+

.

*

0>660 +

?660

"

666%@ +

"

+

# +

A&(

#%

"

" " 66

+ +

( 134

#

66*

@ "

:

"

666% * "

#

"%

""

0> ?66? + > !

#

#

"

134 +

*

"

"

0>@

03434

"%

A.%34

" " +

"

03434

% * +

( 134 " % *

"

134

" 0>

#

A.%34

8 /

# " "

%

"

H5

#

"

#5

1D

* #

+

76

# "

/1

:% " !" + # "

A.%34 !"

5 "

*1*>1<

"

" +

#

1 1

=" !

8 %

'< E2% "# '

A&(

# '< & CA&+E

+ +

+

'

A&(

#

#

@ 66 11*>0< @ ?66 *1*< *1*>0< %

A&(

#

"

+ E2%

# 5

34 ?6>6

"

*

"#5

666J34

+ K

'

=" *

"#5*

"

+

#

1D

* 1D " "# 5

'

*

% A.%34 !

#

7.+ "

.

:

" ?6>6

5 "%

#"

% 5

#

""

+ "

+

5

%

"

+ "

+ +

9 + *

+

11>0< 66 *1*< ?66%@ +

*5 "

**<

# 8 ) *

"

A.%34+

"

+

*

"

5%A.%34:

# 5

+

8 %

%

"

+ # +

"

#

A"

+

#!"# "

"

*

+) , " '

" '

-. /( " '

0 "

' "

34>1.%1>34*

0>

A.%%

# # "

B A A.% A.%

A.%%"

*

"#

+ .

( )"* & 3 " 4*

#

( 03434 ( #

( 0? " *

0? "

B ( 034

+

( 034

" %

+ "

"

++

" A

=" * ="

# )

" 758) + &$$ 9 8/'# !8 +7.<

" (89 +'

6'*6 8/'#