Bhavesh Shah v. State Of Punjab
-1-
!"!
#$%&&' ()) **
!
!
# + ( +"," ) **
"- #.
# /' 0)&)& &
) (&1&2 )& **
!
!
# +" ( +"," ) **
"- #.
# $ 31 & )))
!
"
))4& # " $ % & & '(')*&'+,) - . !
" % & & /)')0&'+,) 1
2 3. !
"3 4 5 " 56% & &'(')*&'+,) " 66 66 '
# " /(' 7
6 $ ,''+,( '0 +0 '+,( 8 &, 0
,* ,( 00 " ') '
9 ,):( % '* ;
9 % ,)*, < . 1 -! - 3 => 66 '0 +0 '+,( 8 &'
-2- "7 6 #" 6 6 ') ,'
'+,'?
99
6 1 -!- $ ,,0$ 5 6 6@ & @ ,;A B - $
%&+,+ +) ,'
'+',8@ +( ,'
'+,0 ,:+ 6 5 # @6 "@
16 @ 1
2 /+/ 2 68 0';10 % % $ 6 "
!
# 99 5,:+ 6 :+ 6 6 6 '+ 6 / # +'
+, '+,0 " +0 @6 6 6 5 @ 9 # 2 " @ -
@ 6 " 6" @
@ ') +, '+,0 # 6 " 6" @ "@ 9 2 " @ "
" ,0 *) A ,;A @ ,/ +0 '+,0 #
@ ') +, '+,0 9# 2 " @ - & @ ,/ +0 '+,0 9 " @4 "
8 8 &0 &/
% & &'(')*&'+,)
;
#
" "@ = 5 "
-3-
<= 5 "> 6 6 @ @ " "6"@6 @ "@= 5 "
:
- 6 @ 6=
< = > $ :)( +( +) '+,/= 5 "5 " "@C !
" <C !
"> # @ "@ ?
=
8 8 %&, @ ''
,+ '+,) * # $ ,(:' 0+ ,, '+,; = ?
@ =
5 "5 "" 6C !
" " 6 #@ 8 8 %&' @ ''
,+ '+,) ( # ?
9 9
9=4 D5
= 5 " C !
" +* ,'
'+,*5 9 " 6 "
" # @ @ C !
"
@ 8 8 %&0 @ ''
,+ '+,) '; @ 6 "@ 9916 ?
) - 666 8 %&0
-4- 1 ,:
+'
'+,("@
@ C "
+( ,'
'+,* # @ 1 8 8 &; ,+ # '0 +0 '+,( 6 6 "& C
5 " 5 D 6 '0 +0 '+,( 66 # 6 $ ,''+,( '0 +0 '+,( 66 '0 +0 '+,( "@ "& C
5 " 8 8 &, &' ,, # 6 6 $ ,' '+,( '0 +0 '+,( 8 &, 66 '0 +0 '+,( 8 &'
6 " ,'
#6 @ "7
6 66 @ 6 6 +;@ +,6 '0 @ 9
" -
% & & '(')*&'+,) =1"16 4D% 76 & $ 0 % & &/)')0&'+,) 9 E
@ " 66 # ,0 B % & &'(')*&'+,) 7
6 @ +;
+* '+,)
-5-
99 5 6 5" @ 8 = '+ +) '+,) ?
99 5 "
6 "68 7
@ 6 # 0+ ,+ '+,) =- 5 " " "" @ # '( ,, '+,) % , 5 699?
" 2 @ 5 " ,; @6 5 # =- 5 " 8
@99 @5 # 6 ! 6 66 ,/ ''
,+ '+,) @ "6"@ @
?
99 = 5 " " 6 8 @ 6 "@ +( +) '+,/ 8 %&, 0+ ,, '+,; 8 %&'
= 5 " " 9 6 = 5 " 6 6 6"'+,* # 6
@ = C !
" - $
-6- +*1+( ,'
'+,* 8 %&0
,:
+'
'+,( 8 &;
9 +( +) '+,/ ,:
+'
'+,( 8 @ 6 9 6 00 9,):( "@ @ 9 " "
6 @ " ,;
# " @ +; @ +, 6 '0 @ 6 # ""@ 6 86 6+' @ 66 6 "@ +0@ 6 5 66 # " @ "') +, '+,0 6 '0 +0 '+,( F"+( ,'
'+,* 6
@ 6 ,:
+'
'+,( "@
@ 8 6 @ 6 "
? +( +) '+,/ 8 %&, 0+ ,, '+,;
8 %&'
"@6 &?
=
@ @6 6 "@8 6 9 66
@ +( +) '+,/ 8 %&, ,:
+'
'+,( 8 &;
"8 6 ? 6/*+ " 8 @ 6 6 6 " 6 " 9
-7- 8 &;
6
@ =
5 " @ +( ,'
'+,* 8 %&0
,:
+'
'+,( =@ " 8 ? 6 @ 6 "
" "
!
6
!"##
$"%&
'
( )" *+ $!!,- . .
#//)%))/
( .
-
( 0 1
, "##
$" (( ,:
# @ ''
,+ '+,) "8 "6+( +) '+,/ = = 5 6 C !
" +( +) '+,/ 8 %&,
,:
+'
'+,(
8 &;
9 8 6 6 ? @ 5 "6 ? 6 8 %&,
%&' @ ? 6 " = 5 "
@
@ " C !
"
? "6 = = 5 ""
56 " 6 C !
"
? +( +) '+,) 8 %&, " ,:
+'
'+,(
-8-
8 &;
"8 6 6 ,* 9 ,( - 6 " 8 6 & ')9,):( & & # "#.-,#!"56 #
& , B&
!
!
" # $
%
&' (
#
-9-
'& (
"
$
#
'
% #
'& )! "
%
*
& )
!
#' #"
! !.
" 4%4+ ."",#.
+$ +&,
- &+. "
/ 0 / 0 & . +#1 1
21
'
" & )
!
#'' #"
! !.
" 4%+ ."",#.
+$ & 3 &+ ( "
-10-
4 5
"
& .
+ "
6 1 / 6 1 /
& 7 &$8
$ 9 :
9 :
& )
!
#/% +& &&+ ."",#.
+$ );<& =
- 6 &+7
, ,
-
& >
-11-
& 8
&' )
!
#/% +& &&+ ."",#.
+$ );?&, &+>
& !
& )
!
#/ +& &&+ ."",#.
+$ ) @&7 &+!
,
,
4 5
A
, B & (
-12-
B
B
& (
0 %
%
& 7 &!
%
0
0 & )!
!
!
, 0
& )
!
#/' +& &&+ ."",#.
+$ ) & 7
& .
, ,
-
B
& ,) 9 " 8 6 !
6 6
-13- # ?G" 6
& 9+@& !
+)&@& @++ !
>
C C D&@& @+) +)&@& @++& >
/ , !
>
C @?&+ & @++
& (
/ & (
/ );?
, &5,
, !
>
C 8 &"
/ && !
"
+?;< !
>
C C
+ &@ & @++
+@&@ & @++ +)&@& @++ &= +)&@& @++
)& @E
)@E
&1 %
, !
>
C / )) "
@?&+ & @++
@?&+ & @++
& >
-14- !
>
C C +)&@& @++
/ );?
, &5, +)&@& @++ &!
&>
%
&:
6 # '
& +& !
/ B F * G * / ,
5"
6 !
& / , 3 5 "
*
" / 5"
H
/ );< , &5&,& +? & +)& !
+<&@ & @+ &@<& @+ , @+&@ & @+;
"
5+& > ,
& 1
%
&>
-15-
& +D&!
,
& > ,
/ )< , &5&,& +? &!
, 5 , I / HB
@+;) H,H , @
G */ , %
1
/ ? , &5,
/ )< , &5, & +;&>
, % @+&@ & @+;"
5+
@)&@<& @+; "
5
,21
/=/. &:
6 9 . .
& ;& G
,
4 +& J 1K / C H 5 +;&@ & @++& H %
D&@ & @++ 8
@+&@ & @+ &>
&@ & @+D&&
D
-16- +@ & >
/ );<, &5&, +? &>
& /
5
+?&@<& @+) +@&++& @+)&& &!
&@ & @+D
& & !
"
&:
6 9 0 1
& +@&G
, %
&"
0 "
;&@;& @@ &7
+ &@+& @+@ + &@?& @+@
& G / );<, &5&, B / , / HB
/
@ 0 "
& G @< & G
& LLLLL LLLL LLLL +&/
- ,
%
-17-
& > ,
/ /
& >
& C /
/
&!
B
&:
6 '+ 6" 6
!
6 6 5 6 " 6 @ #6 +0 @ 6 ? 6 " "8 ', 6 "
5 " " 6 " "
6& HK K ?&+ & @+ /
@ &@+& @+ +
!
M , C = & ?&@+& @+ "
5
/ , !
C .G!I 8 & +)&@& @+ "
5) C
.&;?< G
/
"63 55 1 ,"3 / 1
/
26" 555 B& @<&@?& @+) "
H+ C
.&+<; G
/
"
& 5 5 3 1
6
& @&++& @+D "
H
-181
/ ,"3 / 1
/
26"
555 B& @ K@<&+ & @+ "
H C
G
/
!
!
!
3 8-
,"3 / 1
/ 26" 55 5 B
& / 26" 555 B& +;&@ & @+< "
5D , .&+ @+< &@& @+<
/
+ +< / ? !
"
+?;< H D !
H
+? +& &@& @+< "
5+ /
&@& @+< "
5 ''
6 /*+ @ " +*1+( ,'
'+,* ,:
+'
'+,( " 8 6 D " = 16 "+( +) '+,/,:
+'
'+,( "8 6 5 6 6 8 %&, %&' 66 " "@ = = 5 "
# = 5 "
@ 6 6 #
@ C !
"
$ = C !
"5 9
+* ,'
'+,* "@ 6 1?
C !
" = 5
-19- "
9 @
@ 8 /*+ 8 6 "8 6 6 " 1 "@ 6 9 8 &; "
66 +*1+( ,'
'+,* 8 %&0 66 +( +) '+,/ 8 %&, 0+ ,, '+,; 8 %&'
9 6 8 %&, 8 %&' " " " #6 @
@ 6@
@ "@
@ 6@ # " +*1+( ,'
'+,* 8 %&0 " 6 6 @ " 6 68 %&,%&'
4 6 8 @ 6 " 6 666
/*0 5 8 6 9
@ 66 " @"
? 68 " " # "8 6 @ @ " +*1+( ,'
'+,* 8 %&0 ,:
+'
'+,( 8
-20- &;
+( +) '+,) 8 %&, ,:
+'
'+,( 8 &;
" "@
"@ 6 6 " 6') +, '+,0 6 " 6 9 E
@ 2 " @ - 6 !
"
?6 " '0 +0 '+,( F8 +*1+( ,'
'+,*,:
+'
'+,( " 6 " 86 @@ "@ 6') +, '+,08 6" #6 $ ,''+,( '0 +0 '+,( 8 &, @"
"@6 '0 9 6
6 $ ,''+,( '0 +0 '+,( 8 &, 0
,* ,( 00 " ') '
9 ,):( % '* ;
9 % ,)*, 66 '0 +0 '+,(
8 &'
"7 6 "@7
%&&' 7))8 C B 5 1 & H1$ B% "& H1$