High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19326/2013allowed

Sachin Tayal v. Baba Farid University Of Health Sciences & ORS

2015-11-28Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan12 pages

!"!#$%&'()* + , -!# .

!#( 0("1"

(!2 . / - , !# " #2 -(" "3#2#

("# $4 5( 67/ #.*2%

( -3 !#( 5(6 #,!#8-, #2-1*2%

(("3#2# " -3 !#(!# -3("# 9(!

3 !#- "3( .2 (:1 "-!#8 -"/ !#("3#2# #; -3"

< '

-#! !

#" 3( ."

!# 1(# - !" /!

'/ - % '#

33!# 2'!#8&(&(!

(!1" #("3#2# #;

"3#2# 2%( !"2 9 3"

" < ' -#! !

# %!2 2%( !"&# 2

2 ##=1( 4 - !#( (2'( -,/ !#&&!

(!# (%!9 # 1 -9 "# "/ 2"3( -3( 2!#8"

-,/ !#&&!

9-! - -3 !#(- "( !%21#2(

*5"# - 9/ 9 ""/ 2!# -#( /

8(.

#2 5" &!#!2( 6 1( 9 " "/ 2 !#"

- ("(%2

8(.3 7

"(! - >("3#2# ;?9 "73 !#

!#8/!"

"5"# - 9/ 2!2# @!#*("3#2# ;

" "72 @!#*9-! --2!2# -3 !#( ""

!/" -"/ !## -8(1#2

!# (&"

2&! :1 /!!

!#"* -3 !#(!"&( &(!

(!1" # ("3#2# ; 1( -( "

3( 2!#8" -,/ !#&&!

2# !#2!

9 "//92'. -&&!

!#& 7!#8 -"/ !#

#2-# -"/ !#!"%!

2 # - 9(!

# "

&# !/2 # '- / ("3#2# "!

- "'#"

-"/ !#!" '"/1 /. !(

#23(3( !"&# !#2

+) #2!2

" 33/!2( 3"

< ' -#! !

#1 9-! -#/. #2!2

"9( 1#2/!8!'/ #29( //2( -!# (%!90!2! (2(

2 * - 0! - # //( - .* !#

(2 # 9!

- - #(&" #2 3( 21( / !2 29# '.

. (2 5 # 8&# * #"

2 ,/ !# &&!

#21 -!# (%!9" -3"

" -&&!

&3(!"2 -//9!#8$ (,,!2-1 - !(& #

8!"

(* '

(!2 . / -, !# "*

(!27

(( @!#2 / 5&'(

(""(>5! ('!/8.?*1(1'!#2 ,!#8- 52!

/ //8 A "3!

(!27

((1#61& 5&'(

(!# !3 /* . #"

(& .*

(!27 ( % @,!#85&'(

(""( >

-/8.? 1(1 '!#2 ,!#8- 52!

/ //8 A "3!

(!27 ( (&!#2(,!#85&'( "" !

(""(* 3 &#

(& /8.* 1(1 '!#2 ,!#852!

///8A"3!

(!27 !"

/ ( ! (*

(!27

5&'( // - 9/% #2!2

"!# /12!#8 -3 !#( #2 ("3#2# ; (2( -!# (%!9 (!# (%!9!#8

- #2!2

" #2

7!#8 !# #"!2(

!# -!( 9(7 =3(!# #2!# (%!93((& # * -,/ !#&&!

1# #!&1"/. ( &&#22 #2!2

" ># !# 8#( /

8(. #2#!#, -21/2

8(. "3#2# ;9 "73 !# -9 !#8/!"

#.!#8 - //8

!#" #. 1# !(#"" !# "/ !#*!

- "'#"

-"/ !#9 "& 2'. ,/ !#&&!

!# '"/1 82 - #29!

- &3/

!(#""*31(/.# -'

"!" -3((& # - #2!2

#2 """"&# '. -,/ !#&&!

// "3 ""1 -

" -!( 3("# /!

.* 7#9/28*

2&! :1 /!!

!#"* 9(7 =3(!# #2 -( "7!//" #- # !#8 - "1!

'!/!

#2!2

"( -3"

< ' -#! !

# -2

!/" -:1 /!!

!#"("3#2# ;

( "1#2($

"#$ 2&!

B1 /!!

!# ( #

.C#"

!# / ""

1#@ ', -/ 21

!# (2

81/ (!3/&

1#@ ',

(2 -#!

/21

!# #2 #21"

/( !#!#8 52!

/< '

-#/8.

-/( , ! #

1#@ ' -#!

%"&'

()& #

(7 (!2 &3/.( ( !#!#8 "52!

/ < '( !#!# 3 &#

-/8.

&# -"

#( /"3!

/* , (* - #2!8 (- < ' -#! !

/ "3!

/ >.

(" #2 &# -"?

- %- (2<21#"/( -3 !" #23(1"2

-( (2 -:1 /!!

!#"( -3"

< ' -#! !

# "3 !!2!# - 2%( !"&# ( "1#2($

! " # $ % !

(% ) * +

,+ -

* .

% ! / 0

- % 1 - :1 /!!

!#" #29(7=3(!# -3 !#( ( 1#2($ = &!#

""2 ( ""!#8 =& (7"

(7"

!#2

.C #"

;

+D , 5<

)

, >-2?

, 5<

;

) ;

#!% -:1 /!!

!#" #29(7=3(!# ("3#2#

;- % /( 2.'#!#2!

2 '% <2 1#"/ ( - 3 !#( - " (812

3( 2!#8" -,/ !#&&!

!#2!

#'@ !% - "'#//92'. -,/ !#&&!

-(!"

#!#2!

!# -(!# " #9-

3 & (" - #2!2

9( """"2-

/7"3

& (7"1#2(% (!1"

2"*%#/1&3"1&& (7"- %# '# (225(!

/!"

- #2!2

"- "# '#3(3 (2*#/. -# &" -"

"/ 2- "'#!#2!

2 -('. # #2"

"/ !#!"

//. ('!

(. - # (.* -<21#"/( -("3#2#

-"/ !#9 "& 2'. -,/ !#&&!

!# '"/1 82 - #29!

- &3/ !(#""*31(/.# '

"!" -3((& # - #2!2

" #2 """"&# '.

-,/ !#&&!

// "3 ""1 - " -!(3("# /!

7#9/28*

2&! :1 /!!

!#"*9(7=3(!# #2 -( "7!//"#- # !#8 -"1!

'!/!

. - #2!2

"( -3"

< ' -#! !

# "

- ,/ !# &&!

&3(!"2=3(!# 2

2&! !

#" #29 " #"

2'.

-0! - # //( "3( -#(&" #23( 21(/ !229#'.

- . (25 # 8&# -3("# "/ !#9 "'

"2#/.#!# (%!9 -18-!# -9(!

&# !

- "'# ""( 2

"/ !#9 "'

"231(/.# -'

"!" -3((& #

- #2!2

" #2 """"&# '. -,/ !#&&!

"3 " "1 - " -!( 3("# /!

.* 7#9/28*

2&!

:1 /!!

!#"* 9(7 =3(!# #2 -( "7!//" #- # !#8 "1!

'!/!

. - #2!2

"( -3"

< ' -#! !

#'1

-(!" #1( -( / '(

!# !"# 7#9#9-

9 " 9!8-

8 8!%# - 2!(# "3 " #2 9-

9 " 3((& # - #2!2

"!#(/

!# - "3 !"9//"

#.31'/! 33!# &# #'

& 2#/. ( 3(3( 2%( !"&# !#%!

!#8 33/!

!#"(& /!8!'/ #2!2

"!"!""12 #2 -( ("/ !# -(18-

!( #2 !&3 / '2. =3( " ( "3 !

//. #"

&&!

!" -/2 - "/ !# & . ' -(18- 9(!

# = &!#

!#(!# (%!9("& -((

!# / (!

(@128!#8

-!# ("&(!

#2!2

" # -!"(8 (2*!

9 "'"(%2!#

)* +,-

2 3 *

/ ))) !

4 & !

& %

$ ! !

! 2 3 &

$ !

! %

5 & !

! "! !

#$ %!&"$' !

$ " & "$ % ! '

!" &%$ $ $ !$ !' % !&&!$!'( !

% %! #$ %!"" ) ""&

$ "

!# ) (" ! !

) !

!" ! ! % '!

*#$ " !'%$ $ ) ! $ ! ! $ ""$ 1 -

%(' -& -2*!# (%!9*9(!

# (

&'!#

!#' -*9- -(!#(/

!# 2&!""!#"(31'/!

33!# &# "* - # ""!

. -=!"

# (

!# / #2 '@ !% (!

- " '# (3

2/. "

(""2 # + , !' - ./

+ 0 !

9 '"(%21 )

! !

% &

% * &

! &

& 6 .

% * !

6% * 0 & *

5 % *

! *& 5

* . )

* %

! 0

% %

* % !

! & ! $ & !! !

$!) !&*% % $ #

!' % !!2# ' $

!# %! !& !# " )

*& 5

% *

0 &

! !

844 4

! 5

* %

% !

&& !!

! &

) ! *

% ! 2 9 !

! &

! % *

:& 4 ;

! *

% *

* . ! !!

& 2

9 !

4 1 -# # '@ !% (!

- " '# !=2* - !&3(

(2!#8 "3

& (7" " 3( - (!

!=2 - " '# (""213##3 , # - !

!'4 ./5.

.0 9 '"(%2 "1#2($ 6. ) * . & 0

* !.

! % * ;

* 5 % *

!! 0

+ *

% 4 ) .

% 5 844

& 0

) * .

2 ! <= % * 5 *

! !

* 5

& *

* +

* *

* ;

<= 5 %

% !

! !

)

5 !

5 >

2 % ! 9?= ! 2

% *

$ * *

B !! !

. C !&

$ !

2 %

! !

- :& 4 D7 A* % 4 +

! -

% "

) 2 . )A

5 !

, !

& *

)

! !

5 !

2 . )A & $

)

* *

% !

= !

E) % *C 51 .5 7 " ! %!"" $ ! $ $$ )" , #$ !# $

) " , ! "

" , !$#%$ &'!

!) " , ) #"

8 (1* -(& .'"& ""*9-( #"!2(!#8

-3 1/!

1( #2(:1!(&# " -3"

*## (2!#8 "3

& (7"( -!

&& .- %'#-/2 # %!

-"/ !#*>8*F 7 % + ! (/ < +44 <G*9-( -"/ !#9 " -3"

(!# !3 /?1 * 3("# ## ' #"!2(2 '"1 - " # "!&!/ ( "! %.

"/0+12 34/4

/2 56&7 #*8 9$ .

#7:

# 9&$ !; .!

< 9-( "/ !# -3"

< '(

#2 # 9 "!#!""1*

(2!#

# - :1 "-2 - "/ !# - #F'/ # - '"(%2 "1#2($4 ,

! + 2 $ &

& )

5& ! ! !

(% *

! !

>% !

$ ! ! *

! 2 9 !

4 (!

! &

! ) * ! 0

% ! *&

! H

% $

! ! &

! &

& *

H @ G

* ! H !

* * *

1 (2!#8/.* -!"9(!

3 !#!" //92-"/ !# -3(!%

("3#2# ;!":1 "-2 - .!"

2!( 2 & 7 ("-"/ !# (( &!#8 33(3(!

( """"!#8 -(/

!%&(!

" - #2!2

"(&

&#8"

- 9/%3("#"*9-- 2 (2( -!# (%!9 #21 2 '. - ,/ !# &&!

# -!"

=( !"' ((!29!

-!# 3(!2 -(&# -"(& -2

( !3 ( !!2 3. -!"(2( "9:& 3, 34/1 = >