Jagjit Singh And ORS v. Union Of India & ORS





 






 


!

"#
"$
"%
 

 

 

 

  

     !!"  #$ %  &   '''
(   &'

()
&$
* 
 +
*&,







()
&$
* 
 
* 
*  " 

')'"' '&*  ( '

'*   *  (  +'' ,,, )*
&+ -
 &+.) & )% '

/  (      0   ($        ''1 2 0*  /$ 02  3  4'*'  +'152)56  78    4  0  *((0   0  8 (   ' "   +'    9        4(  / * 70( +'99 4( / /          "  .$  & $     0  -$    
 2   :".&;' /80 4  0*((0   ($    5(  +'    0 

 (8! 07'''''

9  008 7''''6'  $0087  0 5(8 ( *00& 



& $ 0  +7 0:*&& ;'&7  *&& (8 04( /*  
'6!

1 1!7''''6'  $ '''&

  $    $  '6'7$ 7 4( /* *&& 7   (8 07'''''

9  008 7''''6' $0087   0 '*(8 4( /*  :4/*;    *&&        (8      4/*    ".& 2  $  ( 4/* & $  7   0       0'  /  $0  (8    0    

 (  (8 07 $  !





  

    

 

   ! 

  " #  $ 

 

< /( 0 0  $( (        (8'   #      6''6  (    +'!  8)0 = 08>0+7 0  0 8   7 8=  7 

 8(0 8 00$   08((   ? ') 7  ?  (  ' & 7   08(  +'@".&7 ".&007(  $ $   ((8 0 (08 ( (?  & $ ( *&& ((0   =  2

.  38& $ $A$ 087

-

((02 0.  '&B $(

 ( 7 87  008((   ((0    '6'       (8   0    4/*  7   

 08'6''& (08 0  (  7 ".& (  +' 100  0((0 (8 07

' /(080 0(  +' 600 (    ((000

( '308  7".&7((0 9$ $

4( /*   (( 4( /* *&& +7 0 ((0  

=  2

 .  8".& ( 

 0 9''9  '

'9'/ 8=    ((0'2 A$ 08".&((((0   $ $ B (8 04/*.!

&5&& &&&(7*&& +7 0'/((07

(  -?( $  8=    *$ $'

/ (  -?( $(( 08$(!

 (8  04( /* .!&8 $ 

#% %#& #'% (# )(%*# #%% #*%+ %  $,  %#%









  # (( # (&(& +#(% -## #

.

*$(!

 (8 04/* .!&&5&&&

.

7    ((  8    (      -?( $    0           ((0    $(!     (8! 0    4/ * .!&& &&& (8 0
'6!1  1!9 ( 08   (8 0
'1!7    (  -?( $ + '/ (   -?( $ 007   !

#  (  -  /(    #  '% (    # (    








 .

/ 7   $ .$(4  

0    '''  &  7     B  $(  7    (     -?( $  (  7  ((((08  $  !

C#% %#&/(#'% (%

#0"#) ) ((#& # '% ( -1 2 #% ((&##) ) #%   ,  &2 #%

#&%% & 

# --#*&+%%% #

 ( 2 #  %    % %    *&  #+#   (% # ((&# ) ) #  3# % % ( ++#%

  

 %+#(#%



+  2 #"#) )%  $45    2#

((#%(#% # 52  4-#

 4!, 

%+     !   #      *%+   #  &

((&#"#) ) #((+ % % # 52 *%+ # %#-* &## 7  -&3#  %( #%

 5  !2

 5 "2   

83  )#+ #    #     

, 5% 

2% # (( #) )"#) ).

4  

  & $38".&   0 '6' 7  B $(7 8=    '/ 8$   $  !

#( #&/( #&+ % #%

#%& 4-#+ % 4!

 #%& 4-#

 %9 # % **   4-#

%9$ (#*  

 

 

8)#+ #3--& ( ++ .

*

 08(8 04'/'* .&& &&&7



 "3!7."8
'  "3!7."8
'

1(8$ $"3!7."8
'5! $ '''6''' /  ".&  A$         (    '  / ((07  B $(7 (  -?( $ 8 7  0 A$8 $  !

C#( #&/(#'% ( & ##'% (:;44 9443 

 

 

83)#+ # ( +  +   -##         &*    %

  3#% % (  <#0=( > -+ ( -& % ((#) )%3*# 3% %& /#%   -    #  &3  #           /+  #

 %&#% <3*    ((*#'% (: 44 944

  .

/  0   /$ 0  0          0  ( $ $ 7  (8  (08".& ( '*((0  .  8".&  8)0 = 08>0  008  (   -?( $ 8=  '*$ 8$((".& (8 8)0 = 08>0.   &      0   0 (0  $ 

/

(8 0 (087 0           B  7$       0B08  ?( $       $ 8 00  ' ".& *&& ( $   8(* '/80  0  '/8   (  -? $     .   3'      

  0 B (08 ( & $ '

/8      0 00( '&7

 0 8)0 = 08>0 $ 007   07& $   '

*

 084  0*((0  7 ' /((   87/$ 0'

/(  0    ".&007 ( *&&    $ $(8    (4( /*  /       (8 08*&&   0087'''''

9   $0087''''6'(8'/(  0    (8   0  7         7'''  '6'     ( 08     (    *&& 7 (0  

(8/$ 0' ) D0 $( 2$  08   
    

   !"#$""%&?$087   07 7( (0 DA$0 (8A$07BD  7 B 

 0 ( ((0  ( (0'&

 0$   $

E ( (1$

 '

& 0( (0   B7(  0        '&  0  B70      ( 00   $ 7 8     ' /0 ?  ( ($ 

'%    #  ?*+(      %      9 # &3% (%++ +* &3 -#- (+#+# -+3* #% %
@* % @*- A.#( &*#(%- % (#+ *3##* %&

 &#(- +#(% -## #+#  %    -  &+  -    #  + ( % (  3# * %& - #(# %-# +3&* #- %- <+&%A+ A# *+##% ( -&#)* 3-#  #% %
@*% @*- A.-A  3-*&?*%% % # % ( -&#)*    +# % ( 3-# (# ?*+( % +(%  (%5-#3# ?*+(23-# 3#)* ## /% #+%-#  #% %
@*% @*- A.*  3#* #-+*1 % "#
*% .% #*  %&#*&?%-##   %* #% %
@*% @*- A.

#% -#(<-#%% ## * #&###*&?%*%& #( @* #(# +@*- A@**3   #     %  5     ;   

+ ** 0#+3;)#+ #3(  ?* #* 3  BC*(*( )B2  /// /// /// % "!(% &-#*&?% #  %* #% %
@*%

@*- A.&(-# #*&?% #  %  &#(3#+      (+(    3  -#   # &#(  ++ %#3 #*+#-&#(( 5< &B 2  ++ 3&+%*  *3-*&%% 5 B@* '2 /// /// ///.

 *

 08   (     ' 2 +
*&3


2 
* 
* 3 

















 &456
/,
 1

 > (B 5
  F >
(0 F5+