High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-M/187/2008dismissed

(O&M) Ram Sharan v. Kanchan Manju

2015-01-30Mr. Justice A.K. Sikri,Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta12 pages

!" #$%& '

((( )* +* )* ((( #,-,!. #-/0 !1/ #20 3&245 ., #./, 66,77 !. #1!8/6"#1 &245 ., #./,#,-6!2,!. ((( &

" #$

% %&!'()) * +$ ,$! #())-.# ++ /

#0% %&12%! 3 !4%+#/12%//% 5$ +1% %0 $% % %&% +$+4#5 +

% !$% % '4$!$4%++0++12/%

%/ + ! & *$ !.' %%/%' 3 6 &0 % ! % 7888++%/ &$+%6 &0 ! '$ +% %%/ 4%+ # 12%//% 5$ +1% !+'$#%!+4$!$ 1

!% %+

:5 $ 0% %& 14 $ % + 4%+ + /0 ;

88(% % +%'+ !<%$ %'%!!

! 0

+# 0% %&'$2!

$%1%+$ +1% 4#% $ =% &% %&% % %% &$ %0/2' >%4%+1

?8(7

#$4/ !>% 4%+ + /2 !

+ 2 #0 $ 5% !$% % $ %//% /% $% $ + % ! 12 #++

$%3 & @ %/#!%

+ << ' ' *

.% +0/ 2%+ !%/##! %/$% 0 '= 3 # % 2% %$ 0 #0% %&'$4%+ + + ! +% # 04$ $4%+ % +# +% /2'(" %/

&4$$ +

+$#

+%4$ $% &$ 4%+1

'%+

%0/2'+$+$4%+

((4$ $24 +% $%>*$+

4%+%/+ +%

1 !

+ 2 #0 $ 5 +

.$ +

4%+$%3 &%&

# < % +$ & 0/ 20 = 3 2 3!

+ +% 2%%0% % '<%$ %'4$ +$6

)8(" $ %//&%

# $ %//% 4%+ $% # 0 $ 3 2 !

#0% %&$!

!% 1$%3

#$ +

$% 1

0 & #%

4# $ # /#$0% 0

%/$ # +%2%$ % +A/%!% % +%% %

$0$% +$1/

& %$&$+% % #%0/2$% $0 $ # @ 3++ $ % +'+$ 0% %1+ # 0 2%

$%&

$ + 3!+4 0 %

8(7 $%&% & 0/ 20 % = 3 2 3!+ +% 2% $ 0% + !0 +%

01 '((%

'+$4%+ % +# = 3 2 3!

+ +% 2' B%% + !<%$ %# 04$ +$4%+%&%

% % +# = 3 2 3! + +% 2' />' + ! <%$ %'1 4%+/%!

+ + +

# 1 &# @ /2%1+ 0 2# + 00'+$4%+ +%% 4%+ % +#

= 3 2 3!+ +% 2'1$% + ! % +%'4$!$4%+

% $ % %/$ 0 94%+# $ /%12$

$!01 '

(('$%/

&4$$ +

$!$/ $%&

% +%

% 0% %& # + %6' 1 $ # +

' #C # 8$ !01 '(( %// #%+ !3%0++%&$%$+#%$ $% + ## %$% %%!>'

4$!$$ +$1%!> $+$

+4$ %+$ +

0% %$ % %/$ 0%/

&4$$!$/ #

% &$0% %&# $0% %&'%$ +% ! #$ 1 $ '

$ +

$0% 0

%/$ 0+$#%!$% $# %/C%0+ #$!$/ 4 1$/# 07(( $0+/#4 % +%

)(( 1 &$ % $!$/ 1%!>'

+ % @ +++$ # + %!!

0% 2$0 + $ !$/ + /% /2'

4$ /%!%0!2% #% &$ >%4%+ 4%+9 $%0%

'$ +

+ $04$

2+ ##! !% +% %/+

/%4# //2>$0

!$/ 4$$ $

/%$%!

0//4$$! !

0+% !+ $#/%

( #$! #())# +

&%/ &$+ $

% $ =% &% %&% % + 1+@ /2#/%

" #$! #())%$+%0/%! & !2 #$

'%!

0 0+4%+##!14 $0% $

9 +

8888123 #4$!$$ +

$+!

&%/!

0% 2B !

3 ! #$ +

'$& $ +

% +# = 3 2 3!+ +% 2' $ 01/'

+ ! %%/%4$!$+%%+% ! #6 +0+# 001%/%%+%$ /3% 0$4%+ +%

'%/+% %'+ !

>+$ %

$%3%+0

$0% 0

%//#'$

>%$

9 %&% '

01%/%2% !$%+%//3%/ %1/% !/+# %/2 + $$

+ %/+ & $!$/ %0 !$

/'01%/%2 $ %//% %//& $% 4$/ $ 4%+ 0 & %// $ $

+$ / C ++' $ 4%+

3 0% 12 $ +

+ #$ 1 & + 3!< $ #$ +

'4$

$%1

+ !!++# / 1 + ++ #/%+!#

' C %!

2# 0$ '+% # & $ %2 %20% 0

%//#

/3+$ +

3 20

$%$ 4 > &/%!% 4

/ %> %4%2 $ !

0/ +%/% 2 3 0% /% $ % +# % = 3 2 3!+ +% 2'1$%* % +%.4$%

1 %>$ 0% 0

%/ (8?88'4$ $*%//% .4%+%4%2 $+ ##!%

'%/+% %'$1 $ #$ +

&4$$+ /%

+!%0 $+ + ! 01%/%2 $+%1+ !%

> %4%2$ +

$ !$/ %/+ $3%/ %1/$

+$ / % !/+ !/ &

%0 +'!%+$/%!+!'4$!$$$%4$ %4

0$1% ># !$%+ &%$

+D$ $

$ 0% !%0 >

4$%$ +

$+!$/ $%/#$ 0%/

&4$ $ % $ /%3+ #$ +

%3$!/' +%

' &$0% $ /! 34 # $ /%

+$ 4$$ +

'$$

&$ %/> $+#%$ 5 5/%4 0% 3%

+!%//+ $0% %/+ &%3%/& %0

4$!$$+#%$ 5 5/%4 %++ $%$ +

4//

4$$!$/ 3 2+

+%++ !&3 $ +

01%!>% %/+

+ $!$/ '$#/%

7888

? % 4$ !

) #$= % % D% +!# $!

+ 2 #$ 0

!$/ $ +

+$%

%/+ #/%

#$ #3/

! # % +# $

# 001%/% % +%

43 ' $ +%

4%+ +0++12$ &$

+## +0%12$0'$ +

01%!>%$ '$ #%0/2001 +0+1$%34$$0%

$+ /%

+% # +4$ 3+$0 //& &$%$ +

$%/#$0% 0

%/$ 4$

2+ ##! !% +% / % %&% /2'88% $% + $0 % %/+ $% $ $% 1 % 4$ !

/2 12 $ +

%++$$%1 ++ &

$+#%$ '%&() 2% +# 0$ $

+'$

%2# %! #3 ! ++ /3 &$ 0% %& " $

4%+ !

+ 12 $ +

$ /0 % 2 16!

%+12$ 4%+$%$

4%+1%+

&% #%1 !%#%!+ $%//&$%4%+$%//% 4$ $% 0%/ %$ % $%

#$0% 0

%/$ 0%/

&4$ $0

!$/ %# &3 &$0+3 1% &+$

&$$$%1

: 1% &C ++ #$!$/ '1 $$% 3 1 1 $ %1

$0% +$$%1 1 & &$0 + &/$% /2 $0

$% $ % &$ 4%+ + 2 & << = 3 //&'

0 +% % $+

4%++ 2 & % +!$

/% % +% /2 &% %4+'$#%!+ /% & 0% %&'1 $ !$/ % 0/ 20 # $ % + ! 4 %0 12 $ +

$%0$%+$4%+/%!

+ + +

4%+ /%

+% % % +# 3//%& 1%' + ! % +% !!

& $ '4%+$ % +%

'4$ & $ % +# = 3 2 3!+ +% 2' $ 01/ # $ !

3 !$ +$4%+

&$$

+4$$ +%/% 2% 4%+ /#// &%//%/2 @ 0 + #$!$/ 4$ %+$%//% !

%+ &/

2 %/2C ++ $# $ /%$% %# +$4%+&3 +3 1% &+% 4%+

#$0% 0

%/ $ 0%/

&4$$!$/ 4% &!/ $+$%//% #/% !

0/% $!

# !%/ %&+ %'01%/%'%//& &$%+$ $%%> %4%2%//$$

+$ /% !/+%

%0 +%+4//%+!%+$ /%!+$ /!$/% @ 2 $%//&%

+% # &$ +%0 1 #%/+' + 10 % !% !//%

$ %&+ % 2 &%// $ %//&%

+ #$ %//% '$ +

' /% & $%++$4$ $%1 $% %++% 0%/ %12$ %//% '

%2# +0++%/ #$

$ /% &+ # $ % +' # // 4 & ++ + 4 # %0:5

D$$ $

+ / ! #3 !

+ #!

/2% +

/# ) < $ $ % + % ! 3 ! + # $ +!3!

+ 7

+ &$3 !% !12$% +% $ + 10++

+ 0%

$ 1$%/#' /% %/ !

!%0 $ !

!/ +

$%$%//&%

+ #$%//% 5$ +1% #A!

/2A%

A+

A%&% + +

54#4

1/3%1/% !9++

%&% +$%//% # $+%0 %+

+0++$

? B/ & %&& 3 12 $ 6 &0 % ! % 7888'%//% %0 $% % # $ +% %%/ $+ 10++

+0%12 +$4% <$% 4%6'/% !

+/ + & $ %//% % = &$ %' /% !

+/ + &$ +

$%31 $% % !

$%+1

+ ( $3 2

+'/% !

+/# $%//% % & $%1++$0+/#%% & $4 ++1 C%+ D'$%//% C%0 D0% 6 &$% D" =% 9 &$'4$ 1 $ !

%$+3 +

+#$%$%//% $%1 $% %++ // %12$ +

4$!$!% +$0+3 0 %/!

/2 %##! &$+0 %/$%/$$ 0% %//#$% 0% + 1 1!% ++$$%$% /21 /3 & $+!

&%/!

0% 2 $/3 %$ % %/$ 0$% 4$$%//% $+4%+%0

12 $ $ !

++5C%0 %

$ %0 $% %# +$ 4%+ +%'+$& $ +/# +%1$%'+ ! % +%'4$!$4%+ % $ % +A$ 0 $%/+ %0$%+$4%+$ !!%//#

34122 3! !%/< % # % 2% %'1 +$

%//2

%% # $ 34 %+ +$ 4%+

+ 6

0/ 20 % 2% % $# $ %0$%

8(('+$ %/

&4$$%//% !$/ $%&

% $0% %& $ 1 $ +%6% $%4$/$%//%

8((('

01%!>%# $0% %& $%//&$%$%//% $%/#%# $%3 &@ % //4$$ '1 +$#%/ %++& %+

# $@ % /94%+# $ $ +%0 $%$%//% $%#/%

( #$! #())# +

&%/ &$+'1 +$ # + 6 $0%# 4$!$$%//% #/ %

" #$! #())# 3 ! % !

+/ !

$% + %% # 0 $ +%0 #$ +

$%+$$%1

%//2/3 &%4%2 0$%//% $%%/+ 1 > &$!$/ %4%2# 0$0 4$!$%0

0 %/!

/2 4% +$%//% 8 +'$ %% + 1

0 $% & + /% !

+/# $

%/2; &$3 !/12$ % +

$ !

3 +

+'$# &+ #/% %/!

% %+

:5 ,

;

## ## ## ## ## ## ## ## $

%&&" '

( "

! !

%&&"

)

* ""%""+

" ,-."/ +!

0% $3 ! #$%//% '/% %/

$/$%$3 ! # +

% !$% % D% $

$ +%6D4%+!

++ 1/3%1/9 '$B + 0%

C / & 12 $ %//% %&% + $+ 4# %//& &!

00++

#$#12$ $ $

+ 3$%$4%+ 1

$% %++% $ $ +

4%+1 & & $ !$/ + &/$% /2% $ &

# 0% ! $+ + 3 $%+%// +$ +

4%++ ! /2%> &!% #$012 &3 &$0$ 1+$%//% 4%+

3 %4% #$#%!$%$+ &$ 4%++ 2 & << % +

$%3 &&

%!%0! !

4%+%/+ + 2 & %&

+!$

/ /++ +%2$%+$%//% 4$ 12$+

4%+> &$0+/#%4%2# 0$+4#%

!$/

1'$ +

%0$%$%//% $%/#

8(((4$ $0% %& #$ 1 $ 4%+#C# 8(( +$ $%$%//% $%/#1!% +$+#%$ $%+ ## $% %%!>!!

& $ '$%//% $%/#%# $%3 &@ % / 4$$0 $

+%$ %+

# @ % /1 +$ +$% $%//% 4%+ $$%1 #!> & @ % /+4$

2 %+

C/% &$ %+

& $%//% '$ +

+%$%+$

01%!>1!% +$%//% + %1 +$ $ + ! # /%

+% # +% $ 4%+

%0 +$ #

$ /3 $+!

0% 2

4%+

!12$%//%

3$%$+#%$ + ## $% 5%%!>

8((( +$%3 &/# $$

+ #$ +

%%2 0% %& #$ 1 $ +$ 4 $C #$+ % $% +$1$%3

4% +$ +

" 2!%+'+% %0#%!$% %

" #$! #()) # %! #3 !#/ 12$ %//% '$% $ +

0 0+'123 #4$!$$ +

$0% 0

%/$ 0$2/3 &$ $

+ 01%/%2%+$%//% 4%+ +%

>+$ % $ +

% $ 01/$!$/ 4 %/+ %0

1/! !$

/ 01%/%$ +

3 /

+$% +$4%+&3 +3 1% &+

(8?88% 4%+

#$ $

+B 001%/%+$4 $ + +% 2% $ 01/% # $ +$ !%0 % +% $ +$ !3 % /& %0 # 0 $ %//%

88?88/3// &#%/+%//&%

#$#%&% +$ $ %//% !

2$%$ #$#/ &12$0%&% +$+ 4#4%+#

1#%/+12$ /!%# 3+&%

+B 0$+ ! %/+ $!

/% #$%//% 4% +$+4#%

!$/ !% 1 # //&%

+ #A!

/2A#% 2' $% #!

0 0+ 8888 +

12$ % + 4$ $2 6 $ !

&%/!

0% 2 #%!$ $

%+ &/ ! !

/1 % % 12 $ %//% 4$!$ !

/ 1 0 %+ A!

/2A

$ % +

%$ '%+

!%1 3'4%+$1$%3

! $ %//% 4$!$ 4%+ $% +$ %

+ 4% + $ +

1!% + #4$!$$24 + &+% %/2+ ! /2'88 ) $ +'/% !

+/# $%//% !

+ %

//&%/2 $# &+ #/% %/

$%1 3 0++'$ 1 &

0 $%%/'+ $ 12+0++ < +*= <= !" #$%& '