Administration U.T. Chandigarh And ORS. v. Registrar Central Administrative Tribunal Chandigarh And ANR.




   
 
 

 
   

!
"

# "





% &$

"$%$#

 (
$

 )

*$+'

)(
"

# " %
%,- ./01,%2!
234!,%,1 ./01,%2!
%,%2 $

, + (*5 $(

 777

 
  "$ 6$ $ $6

* $  66)5

+8 

' 6'+)5 5$

"$6 8 5 )$ 

-

"$$

 )9' ) 5

,

*

"   )$

 ;   <   "$$  8$  $=6$$ 5$   .

85))$#$$ $$ 5$"  +$#*$

" * #56)$ $$ 5 5'

6

#$#$$ .$5$ 5$  5$

5$

'+$  66)5

"$ +*$$

 )9' ) 5

:$$  * ) +)$(

:$$$- *$ $ 

$$) = $

 )9' ) 5

(:"5":$$)  $ )$ *$

" $( "$$

 )9' ) 5 ,>,5> ,
: " ; < $5# ?$!

*$ 8"$5 $ 5 >'

#5'

$:$$ +$#*$ 6$ $$ 5$(+$ $ 6

- - $=6$$ $) '

"$"

$)  "$$'5 )


))$#$)$*$)


)8(  66)5

:$$5 ))$ 

$*$:

')8

"$$#  "$ $

$*$:'

(

 66$ $    

$*$:      (    '  5

$)8,  " "  @,   $4 ' #@, '

@ , $4 ' #(:$$ $.:$*$( $2 6 )4 '(:" :

 5 ))$    

$*$:  "$)   A (  5" ))$ #$  

 +8  ) #      

>
.> (  :"5"  :

  $  

 :")$

$ "$$5 "$$ :$$$5 ") "  55 ") ::  6$ "$$

"$ $ $5$6  568 "$$"$ $:

$+8 5'

*$$   6


  

56) 5$: $

$ +8   5'

(  "  

$*$:

 :$$  "$)   (    '

( #, ,   "  C$

"$$ D( :$$  $  # 

'  6

 $  <$    5  E$ $ ) $#8 F ##$*$+8  ( $,  " "  (:" :

$  "$  )  "$+

$*$:"$)

  ( "$ 66)5

)$B  ))$#

"$8:$$

 66$  "$

"$8" +$$

"$ 5') " *$+$$

9'

"$ "'

5 )) "$ 

$*$::

 B $$) # ##$*$+8 "$$ $  6

$+8

-F5'

 $ 6

 

>
.> (  "$$5  :"  :$$ $    6'

$*$: $   )$1 A +$ $ "$6$=
'

( :"5"6$ "$$  $    :

8$ ))8( 1:

 

"$6$=
'

   "$$

$( B )$+8,  " "  :

 )):$ A F(9'

6'

"$

$*$:"$) (

"$$5 '+)5

'5

C
))$#$DC6$ $ "$$ D:

$5 <$

$6 ") = 

 )) :""  66)$

"$ *$

 $ 

 + $*$  66

5

$*5$  )) '6$

C #$

"$$ D

" ))+$ '+G$5 "$') '

5$   "  

$*$:> (  $ "$$+8  "$8  " )) 5

'$ :< ) $%$

:":

 ))8 66

B  G

BA :

 #   66



"$$5$

5

$$  6'

B :

 )):$    5

'$   $*5$  .:$*$(  :")$  #

#  
 

  (  "$  $*5$  :$$   5'

$      B 55 #)8(  "$  # $*$  )$# )  5$   $    B  '6  ##$*$+8 "$)$

$ $  

#$

   "$:

 )):$
+$ 

-B56)$ B 8$ $*5$ B  )$  > A  (:"5""

+$$  )):$+8 "$
$

 )

*$ +'

)( 
"

# "  0$ 5"( 
"

# "(  *$  $   $   F  C

$='$-FD(") # $

  $

)$  "$ $*5$+$ # 5'

$: "$

BA  ))+$

"$6$ " *$ +$$ $5 

'$ $5$

8$ $#  $)$ 5

 )+$

$

:

"$  5$ $568 "$$+$ $*$'6 ##$*$+8 $ F C

$='$ -FD6

)( " *$ )$ 6$ '

 5)$

>

A "$


  ( $$< #

 :

'$ 5$   9'

"$6'# $$  1$ $5'

$)  #'$

"$8$  :

9'

"$+8 )*$$

 B "'#" )): #"$ 5

'$ :<

) $"$$ $*5$$ $$+8"$

B5') +$ $#')  $*5$ A 

$#* #' "'#"

')5

$

$+8)$ $5'

$) (:$ 8$

6$

 

$5 $ "$ $)*$

# "'#"  "$  65$

(  $

   :

 

'$ 66

)$

$ $B  55 #)8( "$G

BA "$ #'$

 )$ $5'

$) 

- - 5$ 

9'

"$+8

)*$$

B (

$*5$$ $$+8"$ B5') +$

$#')  $*5$( "'

8 '+

5$"$+'

)(*$$ F(:")$

$

 6'

"$  

$*$:  "$)   (  " 

6$5 5 ))8$$ "$$5 '+)5

'5

C
))$#$D " )) " )<

"$

$ <$

$6 ")

=  

 )) :""  66)$

 .

$)  '6$

   $

$  "$  *$

   

  ) + $*$ "$ 66

5

$*5$  )) ' $6$

C #$

D

" ))+$ '+G$5 "$') $'

5$

$*$:>  +$"$) 6'

 $5

"$$+8  "$8  " ))  5

'$    :<  ))   

)?$ 56) 5$: $5

"

$*$:

 ))

:""  66)$

9'$

*$

 $ 

:$$"$)( $

 # 

'55$

')"'

'$ $*$ BA ( "'

8  +$ <    *$:   "$  

$(  *$  6'# $  $(

"

#"

)8+$$ "$)$

)$ "$ $*5$+$ #5'

"$

BA  ))+$



*$: "$ +*$( *$8'5" 66 $

"$$  )

5

''

)8 $*$

 6$  +'

) 8$ : "$

 BA "$" 

--

'55$

'))8# "'#" "$65$

:55

:(

"$"

$ FF  6$ "$5 )5') "$$ 6$

6) 5$ $5+8 '#'

(

6'

5$  "$  

$  $   $  '#'

 (  ( 

5 ) 6)5 
 B(F >-($)$


 $) 5  $

$ 8 5

$ #

"$#"

')5)  "$$6)8$$( " *$

)$ *)'

6$ 5" ))$ # "$:$))$ 6$ < #$ $ F C

$='$-FD6

)1$ $5'

5') 6

'

8)$# ) ) : "$6'# $$ "$5'

 $ )$: '5" 86$ ) # (:

"$6$5'

$ "$5'

(:"5"5 +$'

)  ) $$

*$ #$ ' $  ) #   "$$ $(    '  6 (  "$  

5$ "$  

8:" $ * )$ '5"< *)'

6$

"') +$+'$ $: ""$ *85




)8( 6$  

$: "5

(:"5" $

$  
 (>-    +$  $5*$$    "$  

5$(  :"  "  $5$ $ ) # "$ '

5

+$$6 "$

$1$# )$*5$ '

" 8(!

$ 8(
"

# ""$ $+$ ) 5'

5 $$6

56) 5$  
!

   5 +$  "  
#!

G   "$ "$ 6$ < #>$ 3$ > "$ "$%$6 +)$ 3$