← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-M/214/2008allowed

(O&M)Rajinder Singh v. Kamaljit Kaur

2015-02-04Mr. Justice A.K. Sikri,Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta15 pages

 

       

  ! "#$$%

& "'

() "*+ $$$$,, $ .

(!/!

-& 0 /( $$$

$      

        

)#

$ (  1)+ (1 2'3

( ,, $ ($4+ &

,2'3

( $ 

    $  3 "*  ( '  /"!/ !!/-  "   ,

"   - '  /"'

)

"5  "'/  26%%7 "!+( 8  9:( ' !!-/ "1 4;

' 3( 2 ,, +/!4 !+ "* &/'*1 "''

'$<$, !!

''

- !

/'* 7:2

( =/( 2) "*(/(4;> ; "!

,,

-$ $ )+("    /""

!!

(;  '

-!2    

!  (  (

'&/'

" ,( ,,

- !"

"1 ;4 "

'$

>

!> !!- 1" ?

'"$%$66<4;

"

"'0 & 1";

3 -- + "$ 

2

!+

!+/!4 "'> 

3 --  "*- "'(1 - "!2  >  + -'( "2  "

-;2 

",(

 0 /(  7'

/*+

(:  /(3 ( "'

() "*+7!":> !4(">+> ! ' "*> ,, $



!> ! ' "*

3 --   "*- -"*>  , !2 ! !

(! "'4( ( ,, $+ ! !

(! ,,

"'+ !4( (> !( ! ' "* " (1 ";> ++ ! 1 -;$ (- (2

!( ! ' "*+ ,, -;> ,, "'+ ! 1 -;

4/   !+  !

'  ,( !!/( ? "*  + 1  (  !

 ( ! '

 (1  + !

!$  "+ !( /!

-2

'1 !4 3 "*>

,, "'+ !, !$ 3 "!+ ,( !!/( ?

,, *

4( '$)+ ' '" --> ,, (!

@/ - "

(/(!

+/*+ !+ !( ! ' "* "+ !+/!

"'+ ''

'+ 1$)+ /!

3 !

(,

-+/!

+/  "(1 "* ,, (+ !, !$ "



(2%2 !,( "=- '= (!

 - 11-

(!

- "'!+ !!

,, "'+ !1 ($

(2

( ,, "3 "+ ;

 !=

>+;!+  11-

(!

-/,">+ + !+

,, !"

'; * 4( -!> "

';(!

! '

(1+ !, !$ (' "*-;2

,,  -

"/"'

()

"5  (' !!-/ " 4;

' 3( $+ ',

"> !( ! !

4; - "* >(

"!

$  !,-

 "

3 -/ 4- !> * 3

1, ' %, (!"!$+ ! ,, -> ;!'

''>(; "

!+ !+$+ ;/!

!

 !+ ' '" 4( "*- (1+ (

(2 ;>/-'( ((; ,, * (-( + 1 -;$ +  (1 !1  "

">

,( ;

(  (  ' !1 !!

-     !

 > !  1 $ 

,-

"  > !   - (3 "* (1 !1  " >(

"!

$ (1

,-

' "*!

!2 -/( ( --> "* !!/ !#

! $ A+

 !*/ - ;(/ ; !



B

$ A+

(   (  + !  '

(( - 1( >;

(!B

5$ A+

(   ,

(  ! 

'  ( 

' 3( B

$

$ 5$ " !/,,(  + ! 2 ,, ! '

@ 1 " "* + 1!

- A5

( "*+ !  '

!@$ A5C -! @ 1 "

 (!+ ") "*+ A>+

'+ !  '

@$ AC20 1&

) "*+  ) (, "+  A  >+ 

'  + !   '

 @$ AC + " A>+

'+ !  '

!@$ AC$ -!

', !  

    @$ $ "  (+ "'2 ( 4/ 3 '

,, 2

@ 1 "

'+ (!

- A

'+ (   '

@$ AC2  + "'

(  ) "*+  A  >+ 

'  + !   '

@$ AC "'+ "'

() "*+ A5>+ -!

'+ !  '

!@$ A5C$ $ -  /( =  !!/ !  $    5  *

(  "'  "

,,(

" 3 '

-

!2'

"!

,, +-' "*

,, ' ,(3 (/ !/+ @

!" (+ 1 - 3 $

/( (2 /("

'/

( 1"

-+1 4;

,, "'2 ( 2+ !"

' 3( $ (' "*-;2 -/( 3 '

&/'*1 "''

'$<$ ' !1 !!

' 3(

"$ 2 ,( ,,

-$ %$

("

'/"!

-( ,, !/41

(1



3 '

"( ('2 !1 /

,, +(/ ;4/ -/( '+ -' "

(;$ /( (!/41

-/( ' "- > "' !1 !! "*

/"'

(!

"5   - ,, > 

> !- 3 "*!

-;$ (4 3 /( > ('! ,, "'+ ! 1 -;

(!> !" *'(1 3 (;4 * "" "*$)+ '" "

" - 3 ,, $)+ /!

,( !!/( ?

,, (+ 3 "*

+/!

(1+ !, * 4( '$+ 3 /(

/!

'1

-(/ ,, !!+ '( /!

(,+;!

-(

"!+ ,$ !/( ("

-

("

'/"!

(/ ;> /!

>  ! -!

( 1 "

-

 - '4;+ "!

,, "'+ ! 1 -;1 (!+ '( !/-

' "

E/

- ",(

' "*!/"'

(!

"F26255 "'

-  '

"'  ,,

-  "!

 !

'  &/'*1  > -! ' !1 !!

'$   A +   "

"!2  -

("

'  /"!

-  ,( ;

'  ( ' !!-/ "1

>

!4;

' 3( "

*(/"'(/ ;$ F$ "    (  + "'2  -

("

'  /"!

-  (   (

!/41

-/( '( *+ -;' !1 !!

' 3(

 - ,, 4;, !! "*

"'> --(

!"

'&/'*1 $   > !  /( (  !/41

  -!

"!  >  - '  4; 

,, !"(/ ;> !11

$ <$ 

(+

( "*-

("

'/"!

-(

!2>  "'(

"

"!-

("

'/"!

-( ,, $ $ ,( 1 (;E/ "

( !

!("! '

" " + !

,,

- !>+

E/

- +/!4 "'+ ! 1 -;1 (!

1

( 1"

- !/"'

()

"!F26255 "'

"

-'

>/-'4 !/ +-'

/!

'1

-(/ ;

+/!4 "'!

+ 1

' 3( /"'

()

57:7 :  $ 6$ )

"57:7 :  1,> (! /( ' !!-3

( 1"

-

!4

>

!4;

' 3( "

"4;

(!,/!

>+ '!,/!

!4

'> (/

!- 1" ?

" $ (/ ;+ !"

 "

' "  4/ 3 ( /!,("/"

! , @/( ( *+/( !+ / - "

!,

(1G(/ ;G$(/ ;

3 '

 >+  "

 !,/!

  (  "'  1 "  !  !/+

- "*! > ('!+ 1(+ /!

!"

4- ,,( "! "

> --4 (1/-( "&/( /! - 3  (!,/!

$(/ ;1 ;4

,+;!

-(1

-$A+

!,/!

 ! "-

'> +,+;!

-(/ ;( " 2 "4 &/'* '" ! !' (

3 '

>+

!1

(/ ; ! 4  " '" -;? "*

/ -1

( @

'( > "*"-/! " "$ $ , @/(  "#$%&&' &()# % '*&$+,) &()# 

-!.  -,%,/. "0 + '  3 (;  4(

-;  -;?

@,( !! "

G(/ ;G *(/"'' 3( /"'

 $ + ,(

(

'! +/!#

/ (;,(3 ! "(/ ; "-/'

!4 ,+;!

- "'1

-(/ ;$+ - -"

" (/ = "''

*(

(/ ;"

!!

(;

1/"

( 1"

- !"

"'

 "

/"'

 $ (4 4-;2 D * !-

/( '3 !

'-;

( '  (1  1 = "*  "; 

1,

 * 3 "* 

1,( "! 3  "

" @,( !! "

;

1 3 -- !2(

- ! "* "* ( "1 = "*!/+

1, $+

'- -1

" "* ""*-

-! ""'

+ ! @,( !! "2>+ + !(

('  /-

'

 "

2+ '4

"G"'/ !/++

/!

''

"* -  2- 14(+

+74' -;(

-:2  (    * 3  ( !

   (

!"

4-

,,( "! "!/+'

"* ($ HH HH HH HH HH HH $ (/ ;( ,/(,!

)

"57:7 : !

= 3 (4;"

!,/!

> ('!

(>+ + /!

!(

!"

4- ,,( "! " "

1 "' -

 !" (+ 1(+ "/

( 1"

-(

"!+ ,>  ($ 

-(/ ; !

1 "' "'

- "*> +"

 !,/!

!'/ 3 /((4 3 /(

("  4;    ($  "- =    ,+;!

(/

-(/ ; !'  /-

4- !+4;

' (

3 '

$  !"

!!

( -;

( "

4 '( >"(1

"' (/1!

!

$    

- "*    "*/ !+2  ' !

,, "

(/!

" ""

!,/!

/!

"'/

(  "  "-;  4 ,,(

'  "  !!

!! "* 

"' "*

"' (/1!

! ">+ + > (!    1

( 1"

-  -   +  4

"  - 3 "*$  +

" 4 '( >"(1

"' "*

"'   (/1!

= "  /1/-

-;$  "   

2

-(/ > --" ((

,,(

=

"  "!

   1 !4 3 /(  "  !-

"  "'  ,!

E/ ">+

(!/+4 3 /( !!/

4; - /!

-(/ ;$+ ,,( +!+/-'

 

=  /1/-



    

 (/1!

(* "*(1 3 '

"( ('

"'( > ( " >+

' 3(

"+ !4

"!/4&

1

(/ ;'/ "'/  ($9 $

/( (2!

"*/  --/!

!1

-(/ ;2

)/,( /(  "#3#$ 4( 5( % #6# 4( 5( -

2.   "+ -' !/"'

(# 8  /" (1  !

('  "  (  4  - '  '>"  ( */ '

2;

1 ,,(,(

"/1

!1  "!

!+/1 "4 3 /(>+ +1 ;4

 "'

- "*> !G1

-(/ ;G$  "!

! "'

' " !/

' "*, *( ,+!

"-; --/!

"'" @+ /!

$ 7 : ""! '

"1,-

( 1"

--  

!2 /

-, "2 *"; "'!/ ( "* >/-'" = ,!! 4- (

- 3

+ (/-'1 + " 4( ',

(!

-(/ ;$ 7 : "  1,( "! 3 ,,( -   

( 1"

-- 

!2 1 4/"'

-;

/

" !!/+

>("* ', ;

""  (

!"

4-;  4 !=   ,/  /,  > +  !/+

  "'/ "'"

"/ - 3 + (, ;$ 7 :   -'"

!!  (  - =    

"  ""

1/"

  (/ ;2  ( E/  (/'

!!    - "*/

/- 1 ""

(2 "'  "'"

*-

;

+!/+ *(

= '-  (

 (!,/!

4!-/

-; "

- 4- $ 7 3: 

-(/ ; !

1 "'$+

- "*

,  "*/ !+2  ' !

,, "

2  (/!

"  "  "

!,/!

/!

"'/  (( -"*

;-

1

-(/ ;$ 73: !/!

'/(!

4/! 3 "'+/1 -

"*

-/-

( /( 2' !11'

(( 1 !

4- -  !,/!

$ 73 : )/!

'/"&/!

4- "'/ "'4 3 /( "

!,/!

/ --; 

"*,+;!

- "'1

+  (!,/!

$+

1,-  !/-

"* (( ,,( "! "1/!

(;*( 2!/4!

- "'> *+ ;$ 73 : )/!

'  ( ,( "! 4-  "'/ 2  !

/'

*-

2  "'   ( 

-  '

/(  (1 

"(1 -!

('"&/* -= "'"

!! /! "* "&/(;

1

-+

+('

( 3 "*!

' !

,-

!/( -!

1/"

1

-(/ ;$ 73 : + "'/ 1/!

1/+1( "&

-/!;2 - !+"

!!2 ,!!

!! 3 !!2 >+ +

/!

/"+ ,, "

!! "'' !!

!

" 1 -/,!

; "  4  *(/"'  (  *(    ' 3(  " 

0 *(/"'1

-(/ ;$ 7 @:  ( 3 -  ((

"!2  E/ -!2  "(1 -  >

( '-  >+ ++ ,, "! "'

;-  >/-'" E/

(*( ' 3( "

*(/"'1

-(/ ;$ 7@: '-  !+/-'4 > >+-

> !-

' "!

!3 ( ';

(!

> --" 1/"

(/ ;$+  --"'/ 1/!

(! !

 (    (-;  - "* +;  , ( '2  >+

"!+ ,  + !  '

( (

  "  @

/!

"'4 3 /( !,/!

2

>("* ', ; "'! @ -;'  /- - 3

 (, ";-"* (21 1/"

1

(/ ;$ 7@ :  +/!4 "'!/41 !+ 1!

-( ",

"

( - ?

"> +/ -(

!"! "'> +/

"!

(=">- '* + !>  "'! 1 - (-; 

>   /"'

(* !  3

1;  (  4( "  > +/

-(

!"(> +/ "!

(=">- '*

+ (+/!4 "'2!/+

!,/!

;-

1

-(/ ;$ 7@ :

" -

-  '

 ! "    ( /!

-    +

(/(!

 (  "! '

4-  , ( '  > +/

"* ";,+;!

- "

;(3 - ' (

!"1 ;

1/"

1

-(/ ;$ 7@ : " -

-  '

 ! "   

(  +/!4 "'  (  > 

(1 " + + -'(1

  1/"

(/ ;$ 7@ 3: A+  + !  4

"   -"*  , ( '   "//!!

"2 ; (-;4 "-/'

( 1"

-4"' !4 ;"'( ($+

1 " +/*+!/,,(

- -

$;

/! "* !

2 - > "!/+ !2' " (3

;1 I" "

(;2

!+>!!

('(

- "*! 1 "!

 ,

!$  " !/+ - =  !

/

"!2  ; -

-(/ ;$9 $ " ''

" ( '2

" ( --/!

"!>

''

, @/(  "   $,',%#5 # % 7 7&&8# - !. "

 1 !/"'

(# 8 = "*/"/"'

' "'

(;

"!

"!

 !,/!

 (  + !  (  + (  (

!  " 

,-

' "*!2 - "*1,- !( !!/ "*"

!( >!

1!>+ +1 ;+ '3 (!

 1,

"

4/! "

!!,(!,

( &4 !,/!

"' - "*

'   -!

 1,- "'  !  "   /(

"!

 !,/!

>/-'2 "   

!  

1/"

  /! "*  1

-  (/ ;      !,/!

$9 5$ -/ '

"*G1

-(/ ;G , @/(  "   $,',%#5 # 5 9#5& -5:8$#."-/'

  -!

( 1 "

-1,-  ! -

"!

!,/!

"'+ !C+ ((

!( (' "*1

( 1"

- !2

 >/-'  4    1

-  (/ ;$   --> "*  ( ,("/"

2  3 ! " "+ + !/(  " 3/&5( % 3,)  

  :'+#; #'* #$6#'# 024!

(3 !/"'

(# 8)   (    "' "*    -  /(  ( (' "* (/ ;" ! ! "3-3  " -!

( 1 "

 ! "

("

'2   1 ; 4  !

 "  - "!

/

!!/ *(/"'(*( "*' 3(

1/"

(/ ;$

 " + !( ('1 ;4

 "  $,',%#5 # % 7 7&&8# - !. "  1    !  212>+ -'  4;  "G4-  )/,(  /(

 >+

C  '

(;  !

 1  " 

1,- C( 1 "

-,(

' "*!2 ! "*-; /1/-

-; 1/"

1

-(/ ;> "* *( ' 3( $ -!

1,-  ! - "!

!,/!

(+ !C+ ((

!2 1/"

1

(/ ;$" -!2>  ' -

/"'

()

"6  +/!4 "'+ !

1 -;1 (!> E/

"''

' 3(

> !*(

+/!4 "'"

*(/"'2

1/"

1

-(/ ;$9 $ ) 1 - (3 >> !(

)/,( /(  "   $,',%#5 %  :',)# ,%,/ 88&#/   !

1 '

'  "

6$$> --> "*4!

(3

"!# 8$ "  "+ "'2-

("

'/"!

-(

A  !3 -;"

 !

"  ,!! 4-   - -   >  J!  ( 1 "

-  1,-

43 -!

( 3 "'

"$"

(>('!2 E/

- ,, "'+ !

 1 -;1 (! " ( 1 "

-1,- ' !" 4;

-2  / 1

--;  "'  &/!

4-;2  -

 

"-/! "

1,- ! -!

I

"-;"

1,-  > !  ,( '  4; 

A  >+

!2  "  "

' !

"2  "  $,',%#5 #

!1,- !4; >  '4

",( '$ (*/1 !,( 1 !

'" (1

"3

"1 ;+

" /- ;( ,(!

/ ;+

"! !! -

E/

-2 4/ E/

->/-'" -> ;! "'

1,- ' "

--; - -!

$A+

!+/-'4 =  ", (!,

2  !(

!"

4-; (*/ '2

1,-  !" "

(-- "*"'/ ( + ! (+ 24/ "-;"

1/!

"!>+ 1/!

- 3 (+ (( " "'>+ "'+>!+

'  /,"    '$  ) "'-;2  (' "*   

("

'  /"!

-2   ,!

"  >/-'  +  4

,,(

4-;'    !,    "' "*( (' "*

-!

; ( 1 "

-1,- !(

/("

'2( 

1,-  (   > !!  "  + (  4 -  + 11

', (&/(;(+ '( ('

"

(;( "( ' 4-

1";$  D

("

'  /"!

-  ( 

A 

 "

( ,!! 4 - ; + " 

-  + "'2  ( 2   >/-'  4

/"

A  "-/'

!+

@+ 4

'!/+(/ > ('! ,, ( "- >!

>/-'&/!

; ' !!-/ "+

! $ %$

A   + '1

'  "  + (!! @ 1 "

"

!+ ' '" " --

" '

!">+ ++ (1,-  !,(

'2 "+

/"'

()

"F ($ $$  !"

!+

/ --;"

--

"3

"*  (24/

'"

*-

  1 "  1$  + !2   !

1!    /!2  !  -

(-;

( 1 "

-1,-

( 3

+/*+ $A  (1 3 >  *+ /(

( 1 "

-1,- !8 -- '3 !

'9$ '' "*

 !

(

 *+/(

"  "(1 '    E/

-     ,,  /!4 "'  "'  1 (!    + !   1 -;$  " 

 (/1!

!2    *+  /(  /*+   +

"-/'

A  ="> "*-;

--;   -   -!

 1,- 2  -/-

!! "' "

,, "'!

(!    + !   1 -;  "' 

 !/+  "'/

/"E/ 4-;  "!

/

!  (/ ;  !  ,!

/-

'  "

)

"57:7 :  "'/  $ F$ " (*/1 >+ ++ !4

/-

"4 - -

("

'/"!

-(

 !

 - "* ( 1 "

-1,- !"

,-

' "

" -$!>

2 ( 1 "

1,-  > !   - '  4;   > 

(   - "*   

+/!4 "'J!  ' 3(  ,

"2  "'  4 "*  !/4!

E/



!/-'+

"-= ' "

4; /( $"

"; 24

!> /--; > + !

(/ ;>+ +> '-;!/

+/!4 "'$A+ "  3 '

! -

'2 -!>+

(*/1 !> ''( !!

'24&

"+ '"

'  "  4 -   

A 

+ !

!,

(/ ;> !4 ;"' ,-

' "*!$A

( 2"  1,( !!

+ ! (*/1 '"

(4 -$ <$ "  (/1!

!2>  "'

,,

!  > -- /"'

"'  '

(3   4 --> '$  A

/"

E/ 3 --; "'

A  ' -

  -!

 ( 1 "

-  1,- 2  "'  "  "

 !/+ 1,-  !  !/   "!

/

 1

( 1"

(/ ;$9 %$ @ 1 " "*   

/ -  1

( @  "   ,( 2 

,, "'+ !1 (> E/

'3 '

&/'*1

'$<$ 7""

@/( : " '>(; * * !

'3 '

 $<'

$<$F2/"'

()

"!62F255 "'

-'

$ * "!

&/'*1 E/

-2 ,,

- - ' !1 !!

'  4;  ,,

 /(  3 '

 &/'*1  '

'  <$%$ 7""

@/( :$+ ( ''/1 !2""

@/( ! "'+

--> ''

- 3 '

/"'

( ('

( /- <(

'> )

"% '

 3 - ( '/( 4;> ;('

( "'

!!

' "$6%$"!/+ (/1!

!2 >/-'

/!

!"

4- ,,( "! " " 1 "' +/!4

"  !

(  + 1   - 3  > +   >  $    ! '

!2 ( /! "* 

" +/!

+-'  +( "'  !+> "*  ' !( !,

  ,, "'  + !

1 (   1/"

  (/ ;  > ('!   ( $  +/!2 

! !

4- "-/! ">/-'4

> 

+/!4 "' ,, +(/ ;$ F$ "3 > 43 2 ,( ,,

- ! -->

 "' "*" !!/ $( (' "*(/ ;( ('

'3 '

&/'*1

'$<$, !!

-/(  !!

! '

$ +

" - ,, /"'

()

"5  (' !!-/ 1 4;

' 3(

"'! --> '" *(/"' (/ ;$ -

  .

74 &;$:#$6   " - . *4!

74