← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22546/2012disposed of

Supinderpal Singh v. Punjab State Civil Suppli. Corp. Ltd. And ORS.

2025-08-05Mr. Justice Rohit Kapoor12 pages



             

 !"#"$%     &'("$) *( + &"$,- ......

"

"$ * /#.

'$0 &

"2"+ &'((+"

# *(*

"$ ).

$)

$ - * ...... #($) $ #    &'("$) *( + &"$,- ......

"

"$ * /#.

'$0 &

"2"+ &'((+"

# *(*

"$ ).

$)

$ - * ...... #($) $ # 4%  53 4.

& 

 6

   

     

 

  

     

   !

"

#$"

%

 &

 '  

 (

)* +   

   !

"% %#"

% """"

 6

.

738 ,



    

    * 

*

  *-+-

   -    

.  

+

* +

  



 ,

-

 !

"

#$"

%        

    # %%  / 0

"%1  +

*-  



      

 

+



* + 



 

 

 2



- 3 

-

*

   

  

 

 



*  

 

 +  

 4%56

 7 ,  

   *



*-

 

     * .    "

 7# %/ 0

"

1 + 

 . 



    + - '

   #

       -    '        

 

  

*-

 





 

++ ) + 

 " 

      '* 



 

  9   +



 

  # %%/ 0

"%1 

   

 7# %%     



# %%  +

 

 

    



-

 



*  

* + 

 



 

* *'

   

 

    +

*'

-

      

  ,

 

 

     

    # %% / 0

"%1 0  



*  +

+ 

       +   / 0

"

1 



 -



+

   

 "



    -+  



*   0   

 *

- 

 0

 "% "%%

 

-

   

   

 

 *      

       * +



 



 " 

    !

"

#$"

%  

     +  :   %#%% $ 

 

+



*

  

   ;%  2"

 " 

  <



    %7% %  

    *     

 " 

      *      -  

   ;5 #2"

-



 

 

 

 



*



 *  ;= 2" 



*-

   



  *   

   

+  

 $ 

       !

"% %#"

%   *    '  *- "  8     * +



       !

" #"

  7> %> ? 

   

   

+

   *

   

       *     - 

 

 "



           -  '

         +    

 -









      

 -



  



 

-

 =   

   

 

  

       

 

  

  "*:

+ &"$,-;#  < 

   

  + *  

 " 

    *

) 



   "

 + 

   



 

-

   

 -



  *

+          

   +   

 *

  

      







-

    "

 +

* .

 

  

.

- +

 

-

      

    -

       



  

  +

 





 

 

 



     

 .

-   

-

   

    2

        -*  5 @

+

 



 

 

*  * .   "

 7# %/ 0

"

1 

.

* 



- *-

 " 

    !

" #"





 *  

 

*

     + 



 

   *  ;= 2" > 



*  

 

*

   

  

           "

     7# % / 0

"

1 

.

* 

*

    

-   

-

       "*:

+ &"$,-A  

 

      ;5 #2"

-



 

 

 - ;= 2" 

.

*





  

-       %7% %

*  

 " 

  @ + 

*  

*

-*   

 " 

      .

-



-  + - *

 *-

 

*- 

 

 -

*



     +  + % @  



  



 

 



-



%% @    

      "



     7# %  / 0

"

1   

   

  -  *   +  

 

-'  *- "  8    "*:

+ &"$,-A /

1,

      7> %>

 

"

           

                                 

  !!

                    "

#         $ %&#&%   

          "    

 $%&#&%        

  " 

   !

"    '    !

"    #  !

"   (    $!

"                               

              

                      " )   

* +"+%   *     $%&#&%  

                                                     

 

 %&#&%",  +"+%  *                        - %&#&%   " )   !

%&#&%

  %&#&% 

=

                                      -  

   .  

                      

                  "

 !%&#&%



 /%$+01+2+345% 

  &  ' 

 &'

 +5"34"+341

   

              

           

   

                                "6    -  !%&#&%

>

   %  !

7

("

.

.

.

.

.

6 

  %&#&% -     

 %&#&%                       

                  .    %&#&%  

                !%&#&%      %&#&% !   "

.

.

.

.

.

  

               %&#&%                                   

?

                 $%&#&%  "   ! 

   "8    !%&#&%                             "8     

              

                 

        

  !

                & $ (!

7

("

.

.

.

.

.

,

                

       



   "       ""                        "     

  "*   "  

 

                               

             !    - "*        "

%7(91:

       "    .

           7(          "

6

   7(   

  



   

7( "

  $%&#&%                   

          ",  



     ";

%  @  

+      " 

               

 

.

-

*-    "  8    "*:

+ &"$,-A /

1 



  



+ 

    "

 7# %/ 0

"

1  !

"% %#"

%

   

  # %%     !

"

#$"

%  

- + 

 

 

 

 + 

  -2



*  

 

 





 



   

   *  ;= 2" %7 ,

 

 

  

 

4=6 

-

 



*   *-

  + 

*        

-+



 

 



  

-

    ,    

  + 

 

  

 

*  +  

+   





 

 - 

 -      *

 

 

+  

 





%# @  



 " 

  

* 

*

-



- - *

 *-

 

*--      

    .

- 

  - -*



*-





  

 * 

 

    + % 

 

 /1  -    

7 68

        ! 



) 2

   ! 

 *