High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15230/2016allowed

Angad Singh Chohan v. Central Board Of Secondary Education Th Its Secretary And ORS

2016-12-19Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari6 pages

!"#

%&'!%()*+'*# ,!#(-##!

".))*!/*+'*# ,!!"-#

##!"1"#(!!#,#(*#,2!#(*"-!#( 2!#(!#,*#*#0

34&! 56/(!("*#, 2!#((*"2-#*"

#"-!###.##(*##( "*!#,*#/*"!)"#!

/((#(!"*#!7 #(*# !#-*+%)(*$*(*!)"#!#(2!#(,*.*+(+

(!)"#!*#*#",&#."#.-!#*##(-!"#*"" #("*./*"/#(#/*7",#(*#,2!#( #(*"2(+#. **)*27#(-4&!##(*#'#*!7'*+&,#(!#,*# ""&27#()"#!*!3!#(**#(6",.&('#*!7'*+& *#("*!#,*#*#22!&"(*"+)(#+7 +**2 -+*&-#(2"!'*#.*8"

36%90:

(!+'*#-*!# !*"*"&!

;

< (.*!*"*"")27#()(&!#,! "."")#(/!#-##,+27#(*--++*#"#(*# #(*--++*#(*,*+#"(/"*#",*#!+7#(*#"( (*##*1*7*'*#*),#(!!*#, 2!#( #/*",&!#(!(+27#()(&!##(*##( *--++*#2+)#*.*#&!+*""*(!*)*" +*!#(*--+*# !.,!"+#.&"#(*' ,+&#(.,#(%+#..##* #(!,!#(-!-+,"#--+/&+*--+7##( ,*#" , #( *" ( )( &!# *+" (+ #(*# #,*#*#0 = ""!#*!7*#&! *#(*--++*#"###+#(*)(!2!#( *##(2*"",#("*#,*#

= #.*72.##(*##(%#*#, &>*2*

&>*2**!7**)(&!#(*,+!-+7*,,*'# 2,! #( )( &!# /'! .*#!*+ /*"

-!&#(!!,#(*"#"(/#(*##( *--++*#(*#*1&&*'*#*),#(!! *#,2!#( (-!)"!+*#)##("+#, #(*--++*#*"'+ &)'!,!.-*!#,#( "#*#*"*#(!,!#/*"-!-"#!&"#( -*!#,#()(&!##*""&.#(*##(+*!)( &!# &)" /( /! ..2!" , #( %+# ..##/(+"+#)#(*--++*#*"'+ &)

6 .&"# (*' 2 ,+& 27 #( *) , #( *--++*#*"+*!27(!#(*--+*#,!.,! "+# (!!"#*##(*#*,#!!-# ,#(*--+*#,!.#(*--++*#!)*!)(*), (!2!#(*#*7?&!7.&(+""*"-*+?&!7*" #.-+*#27*.&+",/*"&!#*1 27#()(&!# #"#!&#(*##(*.&+", *!"!#*!7*#&!2&##(*#,*#27#"+, "#>&"#,7#()(&!##"*."#!*#'" # )! #(. *+#)#(! * #( # . # #( +&"#(*##(2*"",#("!#*!7!&+" #(*--++*#"###+#+*.(*)(!*# ,2!#(

#(-!"#*--*+!

%)(!#! *+#(@ *.+7A+,*!;&.;(,)"#!*!!#("@ *#(" &>*2 (*" ,+ * *,,*'# = .#) #(*# *" -!#( !! .*#* 27#( ,,,B*+)"#!*!!#("@*#("$&-*+ &+*>-&!* ("+*>-&!*"## *#*+* &>*2 #(#!7,#(2!#(,#(*--++*#"!!/#( -*!#&+*!"*"&*+%!

*#,)"#!*# *#,!#(

(&"#(%#*#,

&>*2(*"/*.###("*,,*'##(*##(!!# *#,2!#(,#(*--++*#*"-!2!#("**#(" !!/*"

(##",#(*,,*'#,+ 27!

%)(!#!*+#(@ *.+7A+,*!;

&.;(,)"#!*!!#("@*#(" &>*2*!# "-&#!#!'!#*7.*!27#( &>*2 **!7**)(&!#

'/,#(-!"&.#''*+&/((*##*("# #(2!#(**#(!!"#("&!#",#(- #(*#*--*+"!'"#2*++/

!#(,!))!*""#(*--*+"&"

( >&).# *# :

!! 27 '" ( , #()( &!# , &>*2 * *!7** *# (*)*!(A 9,0"(!27"# *" A 9,0,+27#(*--++*# #()(&!#"*++/ (!!*# -*"" 27 &>*2 * *!7** )( &!# #" ."#!*#' " !>#) #( *--+*# *# :

.*27#(*--++*###()(&!#/#( *!?&"##(*)(!*#,2!#(,!. #

" *+" "# *" ( *--+*# *# :

.*27#(*--++*###()(&!## (*)(!*#,2!#(,!. #

"#*"*++/ #(#(!"-#"*!(!27!# #*!!7&#""*!7(*)""!'!!,#( *--++*#27.#)(!*#,2!#(#2

(*--*+*!)+7"#*""-",

--*+"-", ( !># 2(*+, , #(!"-#;2*! #( -!"#*""#(#(*+)!&#(*##(!-!"#*#,! !!#(*"#2#*#/#(7*!,#(+*!*#, #( !"&+# ( "*. " 2*" #( *. 27;+*/" , #( !"-#2*!/((*.#,!/#(,,#,!.0 9

3'6*"*.-!'"#(*##(#!#*.#,#( *--+*#"+7/#(7*!,!.#(*#,+*!*#, !"&+# ("*."!*"*"&!

;

(*)#(*#,2!#(!! #(*!D"!!""(*++2.* /'! !!#"#!!##7-)!*-(*+*#(! !!!"#.*1#(!#,*#""##/#( #("(+!!"*2.*-!'#(*# !!#"#("(+!!""(&+# (*' 2 .* *,#! #( "&2."" ,

*--+*#,!.,!*.""#E4*.*# ##(*!

3'6 ( *--+*# ,! !!# *#,2!#(&+7,!/*!27#(*, "(+*+)/#(&.#".#27;

+*/"

36"(*++2#!#*27#(*! +7/#(7*!,#(*#,+*!*# ,!"&+# !!#/(*#"'!"(*++2 .**--+*#"&2.##*,#!#("* -!,7*!

#(-!"#*"#"#2##(*##(!#,*# /*"""&27#(!"-#2*! :34&! 5=6 /(! #( *# , 2!#( , #( -##! (*" 2 -# *"

"#* ,

( !#,*# 2*!" #( "*. -*!#*)*"#(!#,*#""&27#()"#!*!3!#(**#(6

"-!#(!)&+*#"#(-##!(**--+#(!&)(#("(+ *#("(+,!/*!#(*--+*#

934&!

6/((/*"#(*&",!>#2)27#(-!, 7*!,!.#(+*!*#,!"&+# #"#"-&##(*##(-##!D"

.#(! #(!*,#! *+" ,+ #/ *--+*#" *# = 34&! 56 * 34&! 56*"1),! #( *##2#*1*"-!#(!?&"#/(((*2,!/*!27#( "(+ &"+,!#(-##!(*"*+"-+*!! #( !#,*#*# 34&!" 596**#9

9 34&! 5 6#"(/#(*##("(+(**+"#"!!"(/#( *# , 2!#( *" -! #( !!# "&)(# ( !#,*# *#

34&! 596"/++2,!#("(+.*#(!?&"#

*+"#(7*!9 (%(+(/'!(*"#.,!/*!# "&--!##(*",#(-##!

(!&+?&"##(2*"",!"-#;2*!(* !+&--!#*"##(+*!*#,#(!"&+#*#(&#,, ,4 #(-!"#*"#"#2##(*##(-##!(."+, /*"*""*#/#(#(!"-#;2*!*#&"#&7) #("*."(+*.-+#("F"&2"?&#+7#/7*!"+*#!

"!"&+##(!,!,!F/*"+*!+7 /((/&+2 +*! ,!. #( ..&*# , #( .#(! *# = 34&! 56 (-##!#(!,!-*""&#+7#(7*! *#(!"&+#,#(2*!/&+(*'2+*!#(7*! (-&!-",#(!&+#(&)("*+&#*!7*#&!"##(,,# #(*##"#*'2+*#+*."/((*!!*"27'*!&"-!"" "1)!!##(*#,2!#(/((.)(#2*,#!*" #(-!"#*"#(*--+*#(*"2.'4-#&"+7' /(#((+/*""#&7)#("(+*(*7##)'("F 4*.*#

"&( !&."#*" !+* &- #( #(*+#7 /#(&##*1)#*&##(*##(*--+*#(*2,+>&"#*,#! -!,7*!"/#(&#*7>&"#,*# !)+7#(/!# -##"*++/*#("*!!*#:

34&!

5:6 " ?&*"( "-#;2*! "(*++ -!"" #( *--+*# #!*#)#(+*!*# , !"&+# #(7*! *#(

*--+*#,!(*),#(*#,2!#(.!#"/#(*-!, #/.#(",!.#(*#,!-#,#(!#,-7,#(!! # " *+/*7" - # #( !"-#;2*! # *++ *7 *#*+&.#"#'!,7#(*#,2!#('/,#(*2' ,*#"

,*7*'!"!!"#2-*""#("*."(*++#* !*""*2'7##(-##!

" A(#(!"-*1)5!*" "5 A(#(!-!#*2+ "5