High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16892/2014disposed of

Satish Kumar & ORS. v. State Of Haryana & ORS.

2017-09-05Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal,Mr. Justice Gurvinder Singh Gill6 pages

! "#$%& "&

("! )&* "& + ,

!"# $ %"& !"# '"& (")%" &

&+- "& ./&! -*0/ &! -*1 " "/ &! ,!"&%/2' /

&", &2 3$&0/2 02'/4 &0/)&* & -" 3"&/2

2'4 &0/)&*

$ %"&* (" &&500 , 5&,

6& .

/ / /

7 / %%

05 & '0'"& (", "& "'"00 ."8$

&5""

"9 28$ 2/

& "&/:"

2:5&

/ & ,'0*("0 $ "& '00.5 /)6 /'00.5&/)6 /("

0 &+5&/5 $." 68$& &'0,% %&5&' .!&

!& ' .!& !& &5& +5& 9& $

0 & " , $6% " " 8$ 8$ 0, 0*

$,&&" % "+.";& %,

,& * 9 28$ /+"60 + 0% 2/ 7 & "&/:" 72:< &% 72/ 8$ 6"&$ &"02/

%0*/"

2/5"" 5"

$ "& < ",& /

2 5

$" . 6*;$00= " " $& 7

1-$.% 7 /"

, " 0*" 5"&

2"6

$,&& /" $&"&,& 6 && &% 72/ &"&,0

2 ! 72 &,&$"&$ & >

+&#," "!"-# & #! ./ .012 % &

& ! %'

- & " # !" #

3 5"

. *" .

" 2/ *

$ &"9 28$ 2/

/> 5"& 5&$ & 9 28$ 2 " 6 %/ " / 00 ,&'

" 2&0 ."&% %,

"00,,0*?& 65"& 5&$ & "

%/" $",& "00 $$ &" ,&'

9 28$ 2/

2" 6 &,0@ (" 0, A,&

6*";$00= " " $&

$,&/ A&605 >

7 (" ,& ,$& $

2&0% 0*

&,$&, $ .,&0% &* 8$&* &&* . $ " $&'* $60* " 0 ,&, 6 8$& = / ,,& " 0 ",,&,&4'& % B

8$&"0 ""* 06-

/ * 0 "&"6-

6 ;&",$&, ,*% %,

/ " "0

2 63 &",$&, A ." &6, &,$60 0 ,& &C "&& $&"&&

/ / "&& 0 " ./" & % 0* &

0 ("& &/' "$." "

2 3 " &"&% & %,

6$ '&"0

6 3 " &"

2(",& &8$ 6 6 0* &$,,0 % 5"" . 0&

2 ("9. 0$&6*!

72" ,&' &"0 ,&

%"'0, & &"0

2< ,&'" 5"

. *" 72 * "0 8$ D B$

25"& 5&$ "& "6

%/" 00",&'

72 &0 .&% %,

&,,0* (",,060* ",&'

7 2 &,*% %,

5$0 0*6

& 5"" ",, * &"

&% 72 (",,060* !

725""0 5"&,0 ' 0& "A ' . ""0

2 "00

&,0("

!$6! "

' "&5 ,&' 72/" &,0 $ & !$6 ! "00 6 "0 ,&-$&

". &0,,0

42+,0 %& %&

&%6$ $6 , . " " 9. 0$& < " "& A,&

0*&6*

&*%,0 7 25 6&.&5,

2 5"00*& ,&" 5$06 0& &,0("&,0 & ,

2 0

& !$6! 5 72,&' ?"5'&/6*!$6! ,&-$&

". &0,,0

42 (" 5 7 2 ,&' & '&0 %,&&*/ ,&.&

' 00* 6 0 0. 0'% $& 6&3 .5* &%"

", &"05 ,&' %" % &% 0 %, ,$60 ,$&, 5"" "&

2("5 7 2 60 5& ,&' . &"6 0 ,&'

0. 0 "0 5" 0 $."68$& ""*."6 " 50. 0' ,

26 &",, * &"5 725$0 $&%

,&' &% !

42 0* ",& &"0

2 "' 6 D B 6 & 5""5$06""&" $,,0 % 0056*0&

2 . 2 ,$60 "$ 0

2 "

0 4C 6$ "

5 ,,&0& &"%% %

72 5$0 6 60

05 "0 $",$60 ".' $",$60 63 " ,$60 " < 0* " ,$60 "0 " 6

""&5 "

60"% 06-

" (""& . 6-

>2 ",$60

25$0 6,&%

60 & &,0 &%% % 72 &% ",&

6 "' 6 D B$

2 " 0& $ & ! "& " 6

$ 0*5" "0&

$" "0 ,&

6 "'6

D B< "&5& / 0&

2 & /"0

6 "'6 "& &/ 5$00, 6*'&$

72@ 9& $

0 &"! ,$" & 0.0, ) $&"& $6%" &"8$&0 "5&5

/"5'&/"%,

6 ," , &"& .0& $

0 &",&

& " $6%

6' "'5A,&

6*;$00= " "

$,&/ $&'5/" & !

2/ 7/" 0, 8$", / 0&

$6 & &,0

2 % 72 < ,&

)5'&/"! "00606&*"& & "

,& &8$ & .5""0 ,$&" .E& ."0 & 5"05/ "0

8$ &8$& & %,0 * ,&- & "&5 (" , & "00% $ 8$&.& ."0 8$ & ,& A% "

60"!3 200"&

& "5&,

&0 , " $&" A,&

* , "& ("5&,

& , & .0* +- "= 0 F$. 4$&' &! ."400 '

F$. ""& ,3 .E& G E ""&+,&60 G E