Mohit v. Haryana Staff Selection Commission, Panchkula
!"#"
$%&'& (
)
)* (()) (% +*( & ), )& & ----
, )& .&/ *0
!""# #! $% &' % ( ) * +'
)+,- $% . !" # #/ - ( &( 01#/!2* ), - ($ - ( (( ( %3 * 145# "6) 17, 8)&8 % $(
) # 8 (% &'
) 145# "6" 4# "6 ( ( 7" ( % 3 *) % 1 7, 9 $ ( $( 8 - )(&8*8)&8, %(
- : ("7 4# "4* , ( -)& ; / ( ( 4"## "4 . ((9 $& 8)&8 % - "! - - - "/2 ( $( : ( !
$;(% $( (- % )& ( ( ; - (- - $(% $% ((% 01#/!22 24 <7( $ (- ( $% 9 ) - % ; = 0 1!2 2 24 - ;1#/<7 & % - "!2 - ( - "!! 9 - (( - 01#/!
2 > ( - - % ?8. ?) (% (?)?@.
( $ 9 8%( % @
(
0!2 > ( =B
/C $ D/C E/C /C 6 F ( $ ( &) ( ; &( - @ ( . $G 9 ) $% ( )> 1#<!#7# "4- ; ( % % -( 7 F ( (% #4 ## # -( (( $ ; $ )
: - : - %9 ( ; $ - - % - ) : $(
1 - : " #/ 8 8 ) 8* ( 0 1 - " % - % - , # !2 @ ) @ @ / ) ) ! @ @ 6 <7 @ 4 ) ) ( )
: . 2 > - "< <# #/ '.$( ) - (
% -
% % - ($ % ( - -( $ $% < ($ % $ !" # #/ 0 1#/ <7 - - : H > - )3)1/627# #!-(- ( - " 3 !""# #! 3 3 !""# #!- "/2 ( ( $;(% "!! ((- '- & ( - % "!
2 9 ( - ($01<7-: * - - ?@., - 0 1 !2 - $ (% ?@. $% : - :($(% ( ) (- % 01#/ "" F - - - - ($ % (( ' () "# E ( $ ( (% &) % .
$G - ( - % $ % ( ( ("!
-: ( (( ;(% :( =( - "/ F $ "/2 - :((% - - (( & '- ( (- % $ ((% $% $ ($G; ( (%01#/!2 - -( $ & "!
2 > ( &) ((% $% : $ ( :($(% 01!2((% $G 01 #/ ( "!
F 0 1 #/ ( %&$ ; I J( A(- BK ; ( &&- ( ( 9 - % J9 8%(K * 8, $(% (- ( ( (J%@ K*),$ ( (( %- ( $ (- 9 - ; (% - ( % $ -G(% "6 > 01!
- -$% ) : : ($% '- ( %$( $% ) - EL+ %: - % 9 ( &( ( % "7 F $ '.$( ) "< <# #/ ($ % $ - - (- 9 (% $ !
" # #/ ((% $G '- !""# #! - ((% & % (% G . - ( - ( $%( ( (G "4 F $ ( - ((% - "/2 ( % - "!!'- $ - ;1#/!2 -( ("!2 - & 8)&8 % 9 ( .
"< 1 $ %G # F ( ( (- - $( ) #" 8 -($: (( ( )() :(- 9 '.$( ) ( ( (- ( ; : : )$ % $ ,"12 )"$34 5& )
& & /60)7' (
!
"
#
# $!
#
"
#
# #% &
!
"
#
# !
'
#
( # #$!
#
!
)
"
# ##%
$!
*
" #
## #% + # ,
#
%
- !
"
#
.
# # #
#
$ !
## "
#
#
"
#
!
#
! # !
#
/
## #
# #
0
# * "
& !
# ! ! "
#
"
#
!
/
# !
##
"
#
"
1
#
"
#
#
! "
#
"
#
# ,# ! #
#
,
"
#
! "
#
"
#
"
#
"
#
!
/ #"
#
!
"
#
* !
% ! ! % #
!
%
,
2 !
!
# '3# ( ## A (-((( ) : ((G ( -$ ($(% ( % 9 '.$(
) & & 89:"!) ;5"!
<<"##"
$5& 48:)"$34 /60') (% ( - % $%
(% $G : G% F - $ G( - : & - $: - (%- - ; -$(%- ((% $(% - -((&$( (
-( 9 &
#
,
# ,
,
0
0 #" #
,
) #/ F
!
"# $ !%
&'
( /0 ) 7= '.$( ) -((&( ( G( ( - % $% : $ 9 ) ( ((- 4 ! !
0
5!
6 !"
#
, #
# " ## # &$$& 7 86 #!9
& 7900.
: ;+ 4<
!
= 9! 0 ##
8 !
= 9! ##
'& >(>900> < # 0
" ##
#
!
) #! F $ !% )* +
( "# # $, $
( /06)'7' '.$( ) % : ( (% : : ( 9 ) $ ? 0 " 2
+& @ ,"
#
#
" 0
6 0 @ ! A !05B !
8/ 74-90+7 <'/ +74 (
#
"")
#
!
" # # #
!
0 C # A ! D E = 8'
77( & 900 ;+4< ? A# D ! D
B
, C
, 9 # 8'& (900;&<6 !
'5(!5D: #8'& ( >900;&<
9 D=!D=CF? ! ,=,
E 9
8'&
(4900-7;<)
#6 (- ) (( $(%G( - ( - (- %:9 ( - : (% G ) % % - ( $((- ((% G( $% '.
-( % G ( (M *, F (( - % (- %H(% $ ( % ( (% $( M *, G( $((% $ F :(- - - (&
- ; (: ( M *,
$ $(%$G(% : $($% -((& $G( $(% ( F - ) (% - $ $( G ( $(: #7 F - (- $($- % : $ % )() ( (% $( : > ( ) ( - - (% : ;((% :(- - (% ( $( G G( -(% $($ % ( ((- #4 ) N D ) $ '.
- " , "# $
./=670) 7=$ ((- -
D 0
#
## C #
!
$
"
# ,
$
@ !
.
!
,
@ !
,
!
! 6
,
# !
!
#
,
, #
!
#
!
,
!
@ !
9 B ! # #
,
! #
!
, # "
#
1
##
#
4 9 E ,
@ !
# ,
1
,
# !
# #
#
# $!
@ ! #
,
"
, ##
@= "
, !
#
!
,
)
; 9 ! # 6
3"
#
#
# @= 0
, # 6
3"
#
,
!! #
"
, "
,
!
,
6 #
#
!
,
#
) '3# ( #2 F- G( -$ ( $( ( : : $ (( - %$% )- 9 $ (; (% $( % $( ( - ( : ( -(%: $ #< ) $ $ $( % (( (% $( - % ($% & ) / 1- 01#/ - - ( $(- ?(.?(- . $(
?%@ .9 - -?9% 8%(. - ?(.% (- . $% ; ?(. - ?$. F -( ?(. ?(.? .?.?(. (( (- G?% . ?$%(.9 - - ' ( ; - ?
(. $ ( ?(. '- ( ( - -( $ (% $% ) - $% $$($(%( 3 - % ( - $ ((%( ) -( - $ ( -%($ 9 $ ( -( 9 (--( ; () : /" F $ ; 1!2 % .((%-($"!
$ ( : $% $( 9 (- %((( - - ($(% 1 ( $($ )
/# F (%: - (- % (% ( ( F (: ( ( ( % : ((% $( - *, $% ) 9 (( $((% .
$G G - $% ( ( ( ( G( - // ) ( $(% ) (- % ($ ;($(%( : ( ($G $ %-($( (% - $ (( % /!
G ) : G - $( $G O $( - (% ( $ - % - % 9 .
"
:
#*?#4244:5&)) ;#&: ( ( - % ( - % $ F $ (% $
( ((%G ( ( (% ( (%((& (( ( (% % : $%(%$$((- $ G(% ($(G( ($( 9 ( : +
#
#
!
# $
#
!
#
# # !
!
) /7 A (-( % # "4( %2%
( 9 - % ( $ ) : $ - % 9 : $ ((- - ($((% 9 $ (% (( ( ( $ -( ) :: - (F-($ ) $ &( - % . : -( - $( (( = ( $% % :
(% $ ($ (( . (( - % $
($- G( - (##7 ) /4 (% - # (VINOD S. BHARDWAJ) JULY 14, 2025.
JUDGE &'
1 ,
G
HGC 1
HGC