Varinder Pal Singh Dhoot v. Union Of India And Another





    
  
  

!"#$ 

!"!%"& !"#'$ 
 

 













   



    (#  )*(  +
+

+ ,

  )*( + +
+  
+ (  
!
 "#$

 %&#
'"
!
#"
#$
 %&# !
#"(
!#"#)#$
 %&#
# !
#%
"#$
 %&# *
"

!
+(#
#$

#(
,( *
"
 
---- +

+ ,

 -   . " "
"
#
'
$
"

" /
"
0#" 1
# 
*
&
*
%&
#
23234245 67
849$
#
&#+

 &
:
659
*
"
% *
!
# 
&$
4224
6"#*
*
"
&#((
#
;" !

;9$
%
'"*
#
7#&
"#*


                !   

  "# $  $

   %& $   !' 

 ( )"

  $  * +  & $'    ( )"      $& ! ,  - 4 "
(#
&(
*
"

 +$
"#
"
#

%&
&$

(( #(
#
%(#%
*
"
(
(#'$
#
&#


"
7
,

#
% &
 


&#
(
#
  
   



  !  "

#

$% #
& & "
(%#
## #"
*
"
#
% &
#
7#&
"#* '( ./                  0     /    &/ $)

*+  ,  -% +.%

  %/%*

 .%%*,  0

% *%



%  %   0%% -% % % *+  0%  % *

%

 % #% !"



 0%



%



1  % **%



  % 

   %

   

0 *

%

%% 

 %    % % *%

., *

%



 **% )% **%

%   #% !"

% 

 %%

 -% %/% %

%+% %  0

*+  0%  % 

0     % 

*

% 0 !  $/0 !  /                   1$ 

$       

1$ .&  $% $//    .     ,0   %     ( %  $   $  /" 0 3   $  /

( & $ $  /" 

$  4 $& 

  / $ 0 3  //

$

/ $"%  

 5  $. $

 $ $

 



&      0 
)!. /67"  

 $8(.8

 2 1 $  )%

  + - %

   0 % 

*%0

-% 

%

 1  %/%0% 

  

* 

 *

%



% *% 

0 % **%  %+%  % 1  -%  400%4- %



 %  % **% 

0  %

   

*

%

 % #% 5!"

 5!'"

% 

 ( " 0 3   / $  /  $  $    $/   $ / 6% %

  % 

*

%

- % #*%
  1

-%  %

%

0 ,%

% 

 - %

*%

 .% *  *

%



% **% %

-

 *%  "%  $/ &/ $ /  &    $ 3  1  9"%&$  %/0   ( //   $  /"  $  $ $ 

     $/          %      $        $

 %    ),7  %      $   /  %   7%  1% 1

0 * - - %+,  % *+   %

0

 #% 5!"

 -% % %

  - 1

 %/%* 



%./$%$67  3 #84 :(;< &=:40>:4"%      "  /    3; 

(  <
"$
"
#
%'
#/

"
7
,
"#
 #
"

#
% &
 

&#
(
#
;



    8* 9%0 + :  !  ("

( #

(
"
(%#
## #" *
"
#
% &
#
7#&
"#* ) )7<1$93 $:467"0?+ 3@ ,

 2 "3 %    / 0 +9$? / ( " 
+9?(-

0%

% **

#% 5!"

:

%, %0 *

%

 -  -% %  

   %/%*  %  .  3  /  % 5       //A/ 1 / "

1% %

% *  % % 

 %;%

% %/* ,   ***%  % 1 1 0

*% 

% 

 - **  .

/ 0&1 !/12 &0

 5 "



#
"( #1%
**&  
"
)# %+

.<
'#
  
 (#& =#$
!"#(
# #
"

#
"
 &
52>$ 542$
53?$
533$
53@$
5@.$
.42
=
 ,
#
 &
@$
@6#9
*
" %
*
,
&$
.>::
"
% #69

"
#

1&" (
**&
'
&+(
#
&"#((#
'#
*(
 422.424.
?
A"(
#


.<
6#9$
#
#
&" (
**&$

 
<22<
424.$
,1B C12@1424.
'#
  
"
  
48$
B#(# "#
*
#
**&
"# (
 &
<
#

'"
&
5
*
"
!


"

'#
# 
"  


"

&#
 
"
!


3 
% #
*
"
#
,$

2.23424<$
" %#(
##&"+
 

2:1424<
'#
# 
"  

 &
?
6.9
*
"
!

$
" 
##&"
" "#*
7#&
++%# (

*
"
$
'"( &
"
#+


5  
*
    + !

!3

14

& .31.!"

05 !/

6.

7"

. ?2
D
"#

 #(
 
.242$
&
:8,$
,"# #"

#
+
B#%
E# " 6!" * " 9 4 <2
D
"#

 #(
"
 .242$
&
:8,$
,"# #"

+
+#)
E# ,"#//#( 6!"88(#'

* 9 <  #(


?$
,
# $

"#

#
+
B#%
E# " 5  #(


45$
, # $
"#

#
+
B#%
E# "  #(


4?$
, # $
"#

#
+
B#%
E# " @ *
&+(
*
% #
'"&"
'

* #(+
<
#$
&
,+(#
#
.323424<
 & 5?
*
!


'#
*( 
"

# #
"

#
"
" #+
'#
 
#
,!8<8424<
, F#&
'#
#/

" (#
#(
,

"
#
&
&+(#
#
++ '


"
#&& 
'%$
&"# 
"#%


 *#+ 

< :

.4.2424<$

+
*
&
:
6<9
*
"
!

$
"  ) &#
"$
!

$
'
("
% 
,*+#
 

#
.4.2424<$
"
&*+
"

%#(
#&"+
  2:1424<
'"(
 %
#
  8
7"  "  $            $               0   !   +9?(7"( 

  / $ // $  9$? / ( " 0 3 B     0  0  !0  0 )0 +9?($0  3 - >
"


+
*
&
43
*
"
!


*(

##(
#

 8 !

1@2541B 1424<
*
"
((#  #($
!

$
'
("
# #
"
,*+#
 #

.4.2424<$
#
# 
 ) &#
"$
!


'
("$ " 
#(('
,

422>1424<
#
&*+


2:1424< "
#
#(


*
2?2:4245
#'#
;
(

" #( .2
"
+ 
&
*
%&
#
23234245 67
849
#'

+
*
&
:659
*
!


'#

 "
$
'" 
"
&#+
&

%#&#
"
 )& 
'"
.2
#
*+
"
#
*
&
*
"
& +%85.

.!"

!/12 9 "

&!%"

9/!

12 3 1.1.!"

 ..

"
#+ 
G
&
*
&
:659
*
!


"#

#

'

"
7
,
  
   % !

*"
 "
**&
"#
&
:659
%
*
#/

*
"

' ##&"

 "


%/
(

C  C /

%'
"
C  

  C

'#
#(
"(

"#
+
&*+#
*
"
%#(
##&"+
 
"  ) &#
"$


 "$
*
"
#"F
**&
 %/
&
:659
#

#+

%8#8%
"
##&"

$
&#((
&%
*
"
#(&#
*
+
%8#8%
" *#&
#
&&+#&
*
"
&# .4


"

&#$
"
 )&
%&
&
 # ((
8#/ $
&&$
+&"#&#(
# 

((

# #
'"#%
*
%/
"
7#
 #
'
 

&
:659
*
!


"
#(
 
!


"#

%
&++&

#
"
&#

#
"
# 
*
& #
&$

%'
*
" (

*
(#'
(# '

"
;

(
+
,
 8* 9%0  % !

*"
#
'((
#

  
  !

*"
"


&
(*
'"
"
$
"

%/ '
 &
:659
*
!

$
&#((
#
"

# $ "#
$
*
"
&&(
*
"
#($
*
#
**&
*
+ (# 
 
!


&& ($
"
 )&
%&
&
 (# (



# 

#
((
"
+
#(
 
!



 &&(   6%5 "1 0

8412 9 "

+ ".!

 0"

9&!%"

9/!

12

3!"

"1 .< "
% #

"

&#
&(#(
# (" "#
# 
#(
"
"$
'#
&(
%(%

"
((&
#( *
' (
#((
"#
*
0    *
%((# 
/
&%
"*
/&/ #&/

&#"
#
#
+
#&

#/

5 #&&
*+
"
&"#
*
"
(# $
#
#(
"#
&%
"# *
#(
& #
*+
#(
*
 
'"&"
'#
(


#(

"
*#(
&"#
"
& 
'
(#



**
#/
#&&
+## 
"+
 
#+ '
#(
&% 
"+

&#"
"
#
 $
#
#(
& 
* "

   $
*+
%#

#(
&#+  0(


=#/
&&

"
#+
*
"
*#+( ++ 

'"&"
'
+## 
"+
 
'
*" #*

"
#&&

 

(#
"
& 
*
&+
.5 "
;

(
7
,


% &
 

  
  

$   

$ 

$%

!#*"
"#
"(

"#
#(
*
&" (
**&
#
"
#(
&&
"
**&
* !
#  $


&
  ($
%
" "$

+#


 
"
#+
&#(
,
#
"
#
&
#
   **&69

"#
 # $
"
**&
*
+
(# 

#
&#


(

(#

"
&

#&%
&&
'"
& 
* &+
#
"#
"


'"
"
&+#(
#&%
(#

# &" (
**&
#
&"
.? "+$
"
&#(
%#( 
*
&
:
659
* "
!


'#
&"#(( *
"
7
,

&#
*
:.;04 (0 0"909 2!% 20 4  :

 ".!"  !/ 
" .0 < %3 0=$
'"$
"

;

(
+
,
"(
"
&#(
%#( 
*
&
:

659
*
"
!


(%#
## #"
'"*

7#&
"#*
) 7 $" $=  $3 ;   % 0 )  ( // &/ '   $(1  /( $ 2 "

& //  $ 2D0     0  &/ $5    

$   "



-%  %/%* 

 %. %

          6  

    



        "          

  /$    0   ( - .3


"
&
*
;

(
+
,$ 
*
"
&*+
##&"

"( 
#/
   

 "#+&"
#$
(
#*
&#*(
7#+# *
"
*#&
*
"
(%#
&#$
"
*(
"#
"
&#
*
" #&&
&& $
*#((

"
7&#(
&# $
#"
*
"  
"%
&+
#+ 
"
*&+ #+
"
&#
*
+
"
7&
*
7&#( &&+#&$

(
"

"
"#*
7#&
+# #9 "


&(
%(%

&&#(+$ $
#&0
*
& 
*
&+
#
&(#+
"
#+



#
$
"

(
)
& 
*
&+

'# *

##&"


"


#
"# #(
** 
'"&"

%  *+
"
*#&
"#
8 9 

.<
#
24..4242
 

*
((
"#+(#
(#
*
%((# 
/

"
7
* .24
#& 9 "


#(
#
#&&

 
23
#
2:2?424.
  
"
 (#& =#$
*
#+
'"
"
%
& 
#
#(
*

    
*
%((# 
!#)"
"

#
#

%+
%#

#
"( #

#+ *
%
# 
#
&++
#&&
*
((&(
((

"
"#+(#
(#
*
**
%((# 
 
"
&(
+
"
%+
+#&"
# #
 *#&#(
* 9 
0

<142.@
*
#&0

#


"
/'
&
*
&+
 #(
 '#

"
**&
*

 
* (&$
 (#&
=#$
B#(# "#
&9




% #$
<.
++%# (

# *



"
#+
*
"
8# 
#(
"
"
 "
++ #
*#+(
++ 
'%$
(
/!% 3 !3

1.

"#%


##&" 
"
&#
*
*&+
"

"# **&
#(#%
*
"
 &
#
"
$
%
*
" 
*

#
#/



"

*"
(
+((
++%# ( 

"
#
42.>

'#
*
 #
'
*
#
 "
#+
*
"
+"88(#'
+#)
E#
,"#//#(
"
 '#
# (

7(#
"
&
*
&"#
*
"
++%# ( 
.@ !%$
"

"#
#(# 
#%#(
"
#(# + 
 &
43
*
"
!



*(
##(
*
" !


((#
 #(
# #
"
,*+#
 
#

.4.2424<

"$
*
"

'#

&"#(( 
"
+ 

&
*
%&$
"
&(
"#%
*(
#

*
"
((#

  #($
'"
"
#
##(

 $

"
"#

#%#(

"
##
+ 
#"
"#
&(
##&"
"
,
" 



#%#(
'
+ 
#
"
#+
+$
" 
#( "
#
'



+### (
.: "
#/
*

*
&*+
##&"
  &
:
659
*
"
!

$


#+

&*&#$
* "
#

&
:6?9
*
"
!


% 
*
&*&# *
"
&*+
##&"

"

&&(
*
"
#($
* #
**&
 
"
!


&$

(
*
"
,
* 
"#
" **&
*
!
#  $
"
"#

&++ 
" 
*
"
&*+
##&"



'"
" %'

%
"
#&&
*+
)
"
& 
*
&+
.> "
&#
"#

&
*
%&
 

(
649
*
(
?
*
"
!


($
42.<$
*
#/

* "
&*+
##&"

#

"
%
*
&
:659 *
"
!

$
'"&"

(
"( 
"
7
,
&$
" + 
&

##
#
( #(

"/

"&

!/12.

!% 1 42
A"


"
+
*
"
 +
6#9$ #
" 
"
#"
F
'"
"
 ) &
##($
# 
" 
#((#
# #
"
&*+#
*
%#(
##&"+  $
"
'( &+

'"
#


 4. #"
*
"
*"
#


# 
"#*$ "
&"#(( 

"
#
& 
%8H8%
"
+ 
%& &

+#
 
#
"
# 

#
+8&
&"#((  #(($
*
"
#
"#
"
% 
*
"
# +
6#9$
#

 

&+
'
# $
#"
&#



#
#
#(&#

&+
*( 
"


*
"
((#
 #($ !

$
'
("$
F
'"
#
##(
&
# #
" &*+#
*
"
%#(
##&"+
 
"*$
"

+# 
*
)&$
0
"#
( 

%

"
 

*(
#
#
#(&#$

"
 ) &
##($ '" 
"
+#
"'
#
&"#(( 

#((
+ (
+

" + 
%&
& 44 
*"
&
"
 
*
)&$


#(
+
* #
##

+#/
#
&

"
((#
 #($ !

$
'
("$

'"
#

*
'
+"
(#'*((
& "
 ) &
##(
#
&
# #
"
&*+#
*

" %#(
##&"+
 

#

$
#
*"
&

#( #

"
6#9

#((
#(

"
# %
#
#(&#$ 7 (
#
#
(#'*(
 
#*
"#
#((
#**&
 && 
4< "
#
 
"#((

# #

+
#((
" "# %
 (
&($
#
&#

## #"

@<
#

@?
*
"
% &
& 
"
I (
7
,

  
 =

 % !

*" 45 "
#
#(&#

*(
'"
#

*
<
#
*+  #
#
(
((
"
*(
*
"
#
#(&#$
"
#
#

&

+##
 5 

&
*
"
+ 
%& &
 0($




"
((#
 #($
!

$
'

("$
"

& 
"
#
*
#
*"
 5  $
 &
*
"
+ 
%&
&$
&#(
(#

"

( +#/
*
#
(#'*(
# ) &#

"
 ) &
##($
#
&

# #

"
&*+#
*
"
%#(
##&"+
 

4? 
#*+#"$
"
,$
#
"
# 
* 

+

" '

#
'"
"
# %
 %#
# &$
"
#+ 
+ 
'"
( 
#*# &+
%

" 

43 
 
#

&
4@

&
"
+#
&#
(*
"#

& $
"$
#((
" 
#(&#69$
*
#$
#(
# 69

*  <+

+ ,

= 







<+  
+ (= '$  /#%
 "






A""
#/ 1#

J1 A""
# ( J1