← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3189/2019dismissed

Balbir Singh v. Baldev Singh

2021-03-01Mrs. Justice Lisa Gill4 pages



     

  

 !"#"$%& '!( )   *+"'"$,( --** .'#/#  * 0"$,(  #-$ $  &%1  23&  333

'#$ % &#("04 '

() 0!

'  555 333) ("#6

'"#+"$,

7$/-'( '"$, ('/,(0" !$'$!"$, / / +'

7 (- $ 6"!) .1 --** 1 $ ( #"*  ("#',/* '#!$  *!( **$,"$, 8/ ,6$

  9- '$ "0"*/ ,:/$"' "0"#"$;)

'(  # <** # 8/ ,6$ $  !'

  =  - ##  +4 * '$  "#  / ,)

'(  ("+ <('+4 #/"

 "*  +4 '#-$ $  > -* " ( # +$ !'  * " > '#-$ $  "*   #/"

 ' -'6 $$  "$8/$!

"$ ' '# "$"$, ( $  > -'#$ ) '6 $!' !("$,/-$ $4-'

# #!'"+ "$ $ /'

(' '# "$"$, ( $  '6 "$ ''"$, "$ - !/* /# $  $846$ # " - ,?# " 0'' "$

-* ""# <$'"$-####"$("#'#" $ *(/#) ?- ,< #!* @"# "$, $ ( #/ ('$ #"   ("# (/#  * " !*  + /#"$, $  $84"$, ( #  --' !( ("# (/#

"6# $ A# -'-'

4 <

8"$"$, ( #  "$ "#-/  $ "

# <# '$ #"  $ ('

$  

$!' !( $ "$ ''"$"

#/# $ $846$ "$!)

< #"*  --** 1 $ !$ # @"# $! "

#* < # $" --** > $ /- !

#

"< !!##"$,("# (/#'6 $ ($'

('$#" ("#(/# '-'

4!* # ?- ,)< ##

 (!/'

'  A#(/#( "'!/'

' "$!*/ "$, (-'

"$!* "< #

++/$ +4 +/$ '4< **'

"# +4 ( $ 

-*"!

"$< #"* 

**<"$,"##/#<''

6 $ (+ #"# "$,#%1  B( (' ""#$ *  -'6 $$ "$8/$!

"$ #-'

4  'C

 B( (' ( ' ((/# "-$# < ' #

/!!

#(<$C  B( ('  ""#$

+*C  D B( (' ( -* " ( # !$!

*  '/ $  6

'"

*  # '6

(!/'

C  E B( (' "( #$*!/##

$ " $ !

/# "$ "*

#/"

C  9 *" 0" $!< #* +4+ (- "# '"

*!/'

 '!$#" '"$, (0" $!$'!' !$!*/  

-'-'

4#  #

+*"#(  ?- , +/

"$, "A# (/# $ (( '",( #7"$8/$!

"$ ( $ '6$!' !("$, /-$"

/"

< #) !!' "$,*4) !'  $  $ > < #'# "$  '6$!' !("$,/-$ $4-'

-'-'

4+4'

"#"$, $4!$# '/!

"$

('$)@!- "$ /!/'#* <-- *"* +4 < *# "#6"## +4

("+0" 8/ ,6$

 = ,,'"0  (''6)-'#$ *( #+$"* 

'$ !/$#*' #/+6"

+ '$ !/'

+*<( 0,'##*4'' "$ !'"$, "* +4 "1'#-$ $  "# ',/ 

* '$ !/'

#+*<( 06"#'

(0" $!$'!'  '#$

> $

$#

,( !!-  (-'-'

4"$ "#-/

'- ,(-('

#/# +4 "$("# -#"

"$"#F **,  - ,A $ $ F- ,A&'0') (#"

-* $-' /! +4 "$

"* +4("6 -* "( *#+$6"#'

$ ) !'- ## "$ 0/' "$ "* +4("6 -* "</* '0 *

-'#$ #/"

( #+$<'$,*4 !'  "#) (/#)-'

4 

 8/ ,6$ $  !'

   9 - ##  +4 ( * '$  "0"* / , :/$"' "0"#"$;) 

'(  # <** # 8/ ,6$ $  !'

= -

("++# #"   ' * '$ !/$#*' $ ( 0,$ ('/,( ("*

#<** #-  (0" $!/'$"#(  $ '''  +4* '$ !/$#* /'"$,

(!/'#( '"$, 

''!' 

-'#$ ( '*"'"*  #/"

( -* " > '#-$ $ *  F *+"' "$,( 0'#/#  * 0 "$,( $ 

$ ('A '$!( #+$6 '$ !/'

#+*< !'

"" !-"# #"

-* $#:@#  $  ;)<("!(<'-' /! +4 "$ #/"

 "*  +4 ("6 ( -'#$  -* " > '#-$ $  '-'

4 "$ "#-/

('"$) ( # +$ (*   + ( # 6 ( -'-'

4 "$ "#-/  "$ ( -'#$

'   < # '*!

#  /$6

** ; #  3 '"

* /'

 ( #-!""!

**4 +#'0 

 !6- '"#$ 

"*#  -'-'

4 6$ "$  "$ $ ( -'#$  -* $  #"

 -* $# :@#  $  ; <"

"*#  -'-'

46$ "$ "$'-'

:@;!/-* <"

(( $  (-'0"/# -*  "*  +4 ( -'#$  '#-$ $ 1 -* ") '0 *#

-'-'

4"$0*0 "$+ #"# 6@"# ('-'

 (3!

*

66"##"$' "$  6

' *  F'

6

$!(

 0'#/#  *+"' "$,(A  "  !/6$ # :@; $  #"

 -* $ :@; <' -* ! $ '!'  +4



''!' 

 " $ @("+"

(8/ ,6$ "$

* F *+"'"$,(0'#/# * 0"$,(A<("!((!* ( 0"* 

">'#-$ $ 3 '$ !/$#*' "#/$ +*  $4

('"#$#/!(-* "$,"$ (<'"

$#

6$ $ $"

('< $4 0" $!-' /! +4 #/+#

',/6$ '

"# +'6

 -'! "$,# "$ '*"' #/"

 -'0 ( - ,?#  +  - -'-'

4 +*$,"$,   !/6$ # '''   +4 + ( * !/'

#+*<'0 *

 "#-/  -'-'

4"# /*4-'0  ,3 !/'

# +*< ( 0 '

/'$  !$!/''$  "$ "$,#   ) + #  /-$ -'-'

--'!"

(0" $!$'!'  G-"$,"$0"< ( $ !"'!/6#

$!#) ('"#$H/# * <)6/!(*## #/+#

*H/# "$* <)<("!("#"$0*0 '!$#" '

"$"$

("#',/* '#!$  * '$ !/$#*' "#/$ +* -"$ / $4"**, *"

4) "$"'6"

4'-'0'#"

4"$"6-/,$ 8/ ,6$

  9- ##  +4 '$ "0"*/ ,:/$"'"0"#"$;)

#<** #8/ ,6$

 = -

("+) <("!(!

**#' $4"$ ''$!+4 ("#/'

"$#!$  * !!' "$,*4) ("# *"# "#6"## <"

($' ' !# # :3"# "**; & '!( )  / ,

B( ('#- 7"$,?'

#$  %#? B( (''-'

+* %#?