Jagjit Singh Ahlawat v. State Of Haryana
!"#"$%&& '("
)"$'**+
--&
/ .#0#
.1 -&&
#2$3
% .&/"$3* "4) $".35!
4,"
* .&&)& *$3".
435!
4 .
.&)
"#*) "$"44 .1 & .& &)&
"4) $".35!
4,"
* .& $"#*)$"435!
4 . !62+ #&
*"#"#
"$0$3 .) "$78.& && .'.
. "$ !
."$' &
3&:&.
30$3 .) "$#74747:474 74 74
+"!
)
"$ .4 "# ."!
0.0'.
6& * #4 ,*"!* . 3 !"#"$ 2.
"3
$3#.
"$#
$!
#"3 $'
+9 .' 2
"5 .02 0#"$' )!"
$3 "
. "!
.# $ '
"$#
.#* 3!66"
03 #&8& !..
91 #"2*$"$' 0$3# )!"
14 ,*"!*
. 4,
. !$# .0!
"$20.2# #&0."$'
"$5
"$4
.,
3$&&
;< #.
* #"$# .06
+"$2
"$' $=
!!0$ )!"
1>
,"
,$?'
$# 0 !!0$ !62+ )!"
$3 * 3 #*"
*"#
!!0$ . !!0$ # *"# !+#
"$#
3#*,$ #$ #"# .'
39"++#& 1 9 $ "!
3 *
"$ *"# !
!62+
"$ "$5
"$4!* $, #2.
3"$ 0.
$&&& 0."$' ."
+4
.65
."$
."69 "+4,*"!*, #3 !+"$ +
."
+0.
$ 8&&& , .4
3 33"
+ ) ##"$# 03'
4 0.0'.
65"3 .3 .3
3&&'.
3"$
."69
. ,"
* 3".
#0..
$3 .
?0
$&8&&*
.3"3$ #0..
$3
. #0'* @
$#"$ "$
."6 9 "+4 90 , !+"$ +
333"
+) ##"$#03'
40.0'.
6$ 8&7&& *
.4
3 "+
0$3 .) "$78.& &&4,*"!*, #3 !+"$ 35"3 .3 .3
&:& 2 ##
3 33"
+ ) ##"$# 03'
4 0.0'.
6& *
.4
.65
"$0$3 "$78.& && .'.
.
.9 "+9 +
33"
+) ##"$#03'
40.0'.
64,*"!*, #3 !+"$ 35"3 .3 . 3
3 &:&& * @ # .6 .3
3&:&,0+3.
#0$3 .%
;8< A& .6 .0# + "+ 4 "
"# .
".#
"$ "+ 3 $ 9 + !!0#
. #
="$' "$
."6 9 "+ 0$3 . ) "$ 78 .& &&, ++, $3* 36"
"$
."69
"++ &8&& *
.4 * 3"3 $ #0..
$3
!0.
$3 65 #09# B0
"$ #
="$'
@
$#"$ "$
."69 "+.3 .3
3&&9
*"# 0.
$ 7&8&4 ,*"!* , # 3 !+"$ 3 $ 8&7& !!0# 3 , # 3".
#0..
$3 !0.
C3& .
?0 1
.
*,"
*& "++ * 3"3 $ #0..
$3 0.
$3 "+
"$ #
="$' !$!
##"$ "!"2
.1 9 "+ $ 8&:&4 ,*"!* , # 3 !+"$ *"# 0.
5"3 .3
3&:&& & * "#$!* $'
"$ !".!06#
$!
# !
#"$!
!+"$"$' . !!0# 32
="$' @
$#"$ "+.3 .3
3&&,*"!* # 3 !+"$ *"# 0.
5"3 .3 . 3
3 8&7&&
$30$+ ## "# !* $'
"$ !".!06#
$!
,*"+ !$#"3 ."$' #09# B0
"$$9 +
!!0# 34!$!
##"$ 9 "+!
$$ '.
& .
.4
# ,.$'+1 ##
2.
".# $ 91 '"$'
$ #0!* 9
"$ *
.+"
$ 65 3 $ *"# + $3?. 3 !"3 0.
& , # 0$3 90$3 $ 30 3"#!+# .0
0#
"$ "+ 3 91 *"6
.+"
*"# 0.
& )0.2."#"$'+1 $0'* "3 5"
$$ @ +$',"
*
"$ "# 0.$"#* !0$# + ,*
;7< # .
2.
"$' *"6 ,*"+ "+"$'
0$3 . ) "$ 78 .& && $ *"# 9 + 4 ,*"!* , !+"$ *"#0.
5"3 .3 .3
3&:&&) "++ *"# !0$# + ".6 3 "$ *"# "3 5"
@!
2.
"$4 $
"$ *
$ "+ 3?,"
,$?3 !"3 3 "$ $1 !0.
# $
91 !!0# "3 "3 5"
"#
3 $ &:&& & $ 5"
, 95 $3 !".!06#
$!
#4 "
"# #0''
0.
"$
"$ !!0# 3
."#$ !+
$,"
* !0.
,*"+
="$' 3"#!.
.1 .
+"
9 # #0!* +#4 * "# $
!$!
##"$ # 2.
.&D * *
.3+
3!0$# + . $3* '$ *.0'* !
"+ &
3) $".0$# +
."$' .
.4 !$
$3#
+# +1 9
$ "62+"!
3 "$
95
#60!*
30."$'
2.!
## "$5
"$4
3 .
++ '
"$#
!62+ & "# 0.
.!$
$3
,* .# !62+ )!"
1, #= 2#"
$* $!
!# $34 1 "$ 0.$4 '
2.
'
"$#
.& "# 0.
. !$
$3
,*"+
39
$"$(03"!"
+!0# 314
.."5
,"
#$
$3#0!*#
* 39
$.
30!
3"$ ,."
"$'"$
;:<
.6 3
3 &&4 90 # * != 3 0 .6 "3 #
& "# 0.
. #
.."$' 5 .1 #*.
."3 "$
."6 9 "+ '.
3 30."$' !0# 314
# 9
$ "$ !0# 31 #"$!
3
"& & &&& "# 1
0.
. #096"
"$5
"$* ##"$!
$!62+
."#$ +$'
..
B0".
3 ."$
..'
"$4* .5 $+ .'
3$ "+91 *"#0.
& $34$ $'
* .
2+1 "+ 91 #2$3 )
4 "
"# #096"
3 )
!0$# +
30."$' "$5
"$4"
#.
++
@2 $3"
0.
)!"
1 * 3 9
$ 3$ .
030+ +14 #60!* #$1
.+1 03"
#!$30!
3. 22.5 .#
$ 03"
!$30!
330."$' ."3 7 , # $ 22.5 $1 6 . )!"
.$ 03"
#!$30!
3& "# 0.
.#096"
"$ "$#
!
4 EE+ 91
. .0$# "$ !..
#>
3 ,"
,$ ."0#
"& &
#&44:?>
#&44?>
#&4844? "$ !
#* .6 )!"
1 !!0$ . *"# .#$ + 0#
#&4:4? ,
$#
*"#
.#$ + $=
!!0$
#&44? "$ !!0$ *"# 2 .#$ + 62 $1 "& & *+
+2 .# .6
.#
"$ *"# ,
EE+ #&444:? +$'"$' )!"
1&*0#4 . . 3"#6"## +
"$* #9
$6 &
;<
$". 0$# +
."$'
!62+ ##096"
=
2"$'"$5"
, EE+ .0$$"$' "$ !..
#4
. 3 # $ .5 !$!
##"$ .
"+& F*"+
.."$' $$ @0.
#& &7;++ "5 +1<4"
"##096"
"3 3!06 4,*"!*"#
!!0$ $=4!+
.+1
9+"#* 030+ $# . 0$3# )!"
191
*"# !!0$ $3?. !!0$ # *"#!+#
"$# $3?.,"
+ !
#* .*"#2 .#$ + 0# & F*"+
"$' #096"##"$
!0$# + .
. .
'
.3"$' # 9 !="$' 4 +
3) $".0$# + . !62+ #096"
$2"$ "6 4
$1"$
.& F*"+
.6"$' "3 .0# #6 *, '
"+ .6 *"# 0.
4 "
"# #096"
"3 !
$$ .!$#"3 #"# .'.
!$!
##"$ .
.9
."$' +
3!0$# + . #43 "$3 $16 ."
"$
"#+"
9+
3"#6"## 3& *"# 0.
* @
3 "$ 3
"+4 + 2#"
"$ $ "!
3 33"
+ ) ##"$# 03'
4 0.0'.
64 ,*"+ 3 !+"$"$'
.G#
"$ . .9 "+&* "3 +2#"
"$6 = #"
+1!+
.G#!$30!
"# ##0!*
* #$ .5
!$!
##"$ .
.9 "+&* EE+ .0$#"$
;< !..
#& *0'*4
3 ) $". 0$# + .
# *
5"+1 .
+"
3 02$ 4 1
$ 9$ "3 # ,
.#*,$.6 91.$9 +
.9 *"# 0.
4 .
.4 " $1& *
"$' !0# 3"
$ 2#"
.#
$'+ .' 2
"5 .02 0#"$' )!"
14 "$#
3 "+"E"$' . !$# .0!
++"
320.2# #4* #"2*$ 3 "3 0$3# $3?. !$5
*"# .#$ + 0# & *0#4 *"# 0.
"# $ "$!+"$ '.
!$!
##"$ .
.9
$5"
, 95 4 "$3"$'$6 ."
"$
"#* 913"#6"## 3& "#6 !+
9# .5
"$#6 95 $+1 . 20.2# # "$#
.3 $3 #* ++ * $
$ !"#"$ "$!
&
! && 3# F*
.)2
="$'?
#$ 3% #? F*
2.
9+ % #?