Gurpreet Kaur And ORS. v. Avtar Singh And ORS.
" #$ % & & '
# ( )(* + ( %
'& & '
,- . .
(%
& & '
Whether only the operative part of the judgment is pronounced? No Whether full judgment is pronounced?
Yes % /0 1& 1 1
1
!
"
!
# $
%& $'(
$
!
) **** 1
1
&
" &
+
,-,"#,".
/
' &
"--
$ ".00%
1 & 2(
3
##0#4,35%
6)#,,,35
/
(
+ 7.8
$
#-,4#,,9 + :
/
FACTS NOT IN DISPUTE #
#-,4#,,9
+ ;
+
!
<5",5"6-.
5
&
+ / = /+
+
#,3#4: +
!
'>5,"50,.0
$
+
+
;
; ) <
+ /
3
6 ?
&
+
5
!
'>5,"50,.0 !" # $
% &'' !
$
(
( % &') * !
+
"
%&',- . !
"$
%&',-*
# (
%&',-* , /
:
& +
3 > +4,8
+ +
/
>
1 0 10
1 - &
5
/ &
+
>
& +
/
%4,8
4,8
( &
/ +
/
9
+ / + /
+
/
/ & /
&
/
0 @
+
.
+ +
5
012#&$3 4
! ! -
0
! !"
(
"
0
! 5
!
0
! ! ) $( (
6 ! # 67- 8-9:9
"$(
$ (
0
! ! (
(
, *$;-
"$
! ! !
" "!
6 !
!
( 6 !
(
! " "! ( & $
# ) (
5 0
! !
+ !"
! )
"$
!
* <4
$)
"$
" 5
!
" 6
!
$
! !
! !" (
(
)
"$
! !
!
"
(
$ 5
$0 "
)
"$
! !
" ! = )
"$ "
!
.)
" "$ 6
5
!
>
, +
$(
(
4
(
# 1'-)-.:
("( ;
?< 4
$(
*;**( # 67-8-9:9
?< "
" $((
(
5
!
7
( " "! $
(
+ "$ ( >
"
@0, 2A)*
@ 8 (
(
A
(
(
#
$(
# .
# *
> "
5 $ ! 0
, +'-
"
@0,2A)*
(
4
-4 ,
$(
(
(
!"
! # 67-8-9:9$((
! !" # ( !" #
$
!
# ) (
5
# ( 5
!
( (
"
0
(
"0
-A ) - $ ! (
" 8 $(
( (
'
(
(
(
( "0 ! (
(
$ ( !
0
6
!
$! 5
#
!$
6 6
! # 67-8-9:9 ! (
$!
$ "(
5 "
0
$ !
"
# $
!
# ) (
5
# ( 5 !
( (
"
0
(
"0
-A ) - $!(
" $(
( (
(
(
(
( "0 ! (
(
$
( !
0
6
!
$! 5
#
!$
6 ! # 67-8-9:9 ! ( $!
$
"(
5 "
0
$ !
" 5
4 ! "(
5
6
(
!
! >A
! A
B)
"$
5
>
!
(
$!
$
(
,
! ! (
(
"
"
,
!
2A)$( "
!"
$(
!
! ( ! :92A) "
$(
!
* "
4 6
!
!"
$(
)
"$
(
$ 6
"
, *$;- )
"$
!, *$;- $ 6
, $;-;* ! !"
( ! ! , $;-
"0
(
"
* "
$
( (
* "
$ ( ( ! ! 9 )
"$ "
$;-(
, .$*$;-&
$
, $$;-
B
! "$
# *#( 0 )
6 "< (:B
* >
! ,
;-
2A) 2A)
$ ( , $;-
(
$!, $;-
A
, ;-
0 ( "$
, $9$ ;-
# *5 "4
"
/ ",
+
&
A
+
/
A /
/
4,4, +
!
"
"" ?
!
" 3 B =5 " +
+
=5# ; /+
+
+ /
A
/
/
!
"
/=5# ; +
/
+
+
&
5B
/
+
"# +
&
/
/
5B
=5"5
+
+
+ +
A
> +
5 B
+
/
+ /
/
:
/
@
A
/
/
&
/ &
;
") & &
/
/ +
/ +
<
/
+ 5+
$ > + + /
+
+
@
+
+
/
&
+ / &
:
/
"6 @ +
/
A /
/
/
@
/
+
& +
;
/
"4 @
+
+
/
C
/
/
/+
/
/
" :
+
+ "- '
A /
/ & 4,8
/
+
"9
/
/ &
/
!
"
+ /
/
/
"0
+
+ / &
5 1
0 06
1
". >
'
Sarla Verma Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another 7
'
1),# + )#
" "
8
+ +
5 D30 >
!
A !
> 6
$ "
7 !
5
6 $(
( (
$
A
$ ! - C;* D ( !
"! *$ -
C;.D( !
"! . $ - C;
D ( !
"! A
A 31
(
!
$
0
$ "$ B
A $!
!
(
2 ( $
!"
$( ! C D ! " !
"@ $ !+ "$
" ( ( !
(!
0
"$ !
( !
$! "( ! $
$ !
32>
!" ! $
" ( ! !
$ B !
A
!
B
!
"7 ( $(
"
!
$
(
(
( !
"
- !
$
A "! - !
"
(!
( -
* * * * * * 42.
! !
6 C.D
! C !" "
>
E$> 6
6 D$( (
9C
"
D$ !"
" "
$ -
*"
$ -
* * "
$ -
* ."
$ - .
. .
"
$ -*
. "
$ !"
(
" "
$ $ -
"
$ -:
"
$ -
"
-
"
#, >
'
National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. 7 4
'
1 '5 8 +
"--"-)5
"-0
$ ".00
+
5 %( E
B
% (
%'(
/ F %E(
/
B
+
%G( ?
+ ;
F 5 / B / &
;
5 D52. )
conventional heads $(
( (A
, + F0
, $
A $ , $$
, $$
>
A > , +
G $
(
>
$
"$ !
!
! ( !
! 1
$
!5 )"5
!
> !
A$
!
$
" ! >
!
>
! !
& ( $ ( ! A
"
!
$ (! "
"
5
($
!"
! " ! >
$ ( " A
! 0
!
$ "$
$
A ! , $$ , .$ , $ " >
! 4 !
-
5 - ( !
( 5 ! !
" "
2
!
B
"
! (! "
59.3 $
B
"
$(
+ ! (
! (
."
$ !
>
!*B$
(
!(.
"
0
(
!(
"
$
! B )
" !
"
A 59.40
(
- " C D A
"$
.B
! ! (
(
(
! (
."
)
B(
(
!(
. "
B(
(
!(
"
!
"
> ! A 59.5@
$
A $ ! ! !"
* *
? I((
!
59.6. >
!
> ! ? J
(
.
+
3 59.7>
!!
" 59.8,
!
$ "$
$
A !,
$$, .$ , $ ">
!
B " "
/ #" >
'
9+
( # -
(")# (* +, (:
0;+;
.
<"&
() +
-;
"
=)=#) + = #"
7 55
1 8
1 #-
< #+ "),#
# :
=;
1),#
+
5 21)6 4
6 '
"
F (
(
!
&
0 $K
K
(
K
K$ K
K$ K
K>
"$ $$
$
$
$(
" $ ( A (
Spousal consortium "
-( (
K "$
'
"$
$
$
"
+ K Parental consortium
$
K $ $
$
"$ $
K * Filial consortium
)
"
"
>
"
6
$
$
" 226
(
+
( -
L
A
+
!
>
$
$
23> ? ) !
$
0
(
4 $
$
!
'
(
))
(76
( $ (
"( (
!
24>
!
(! !"
K
K
('
"F0
$(
$
, .$
##
& /
),,,35
/
+
;
/
@
& / "3# +
B
/
"0 #)
+ &
+ /
+
6,8
#6
+
B
&
+ A
'
5 01
#4 @ +
+
+ />
'
; + & +
,-,"#,,.
/ &
5
5 Sr. No.
Heads Compensation Awarded "
/@
),,,35 # ?
76,8 "#,,35%6,8
),,,( ) E
+
B
"3# #",,35%6#,,H"3#( 6 & @
#",,35%6#,,5#",,( "0 -
E
/ 64)-,,35%#",,H"#H"0(
G "4,,,35 ? GB
"4,,,35 .
'
"-,,,,35 ? 6,,,,35B"
6,,,,35B"
606,,35B# ",
- +, ("
; ( "&'>2>' ? .)* ; (
+ / &
4,8
/
"&>5>3 ? ""
(= (* .
+ )(
@ # !
* ( #;@) #:
( 9-;9 (*
"&2>3>3 ?'2' 33
#-
/>
'
Dara Singh @ Dhara Banjara Vs. Shyam Singh Varma 4'
R.Valli and Others VS. Tamil Nadu State Transport Corporation
1),# + )#
" "
4> 7.8
I
#9
!
)5@
'
/
+ +& +
+
/
; &&
+
3 + ,-,"#,,.&
3
:
& #0
/
1
1
'& & '
)# $ # #
= : 3
: J 3!
= J