← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/771/2021dismissed

Dualat Ram v. Financial Commissioner,Haryana And ORS

2021-09-06Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih,Mr. Justice Ashok Kumar Verma5 pages

-1-

     !"!#! $% &$'()!%*  !)#%!  

  +,- 

.    

    

      

 )/ )0 1 .

%02 !3("%'$4 "$#$4 "#"%#"4! !3("%'$4 "4!55$% "% 

     !

  4!55$% "%6' "  #$  !  "% &' (&(" )

! ,

!



*  &" &- (&"% )

 

 , )  !



 )

  

-2- (  . ! !     ! 

 )   

/ 01 , ! 



%3434!  2)

!$ #

  "%05  1$ !   ! 

1     , )

  1 !

 6 7 1

!

 8 ! 



9!  "%%- "%%8 :2

*,   )     * 

9  !    ! 

 !   506(91;

   *'< &  #

 , )  ,

 *  =1     (( &6 "%%%  !    !     &5 "( (&&% ,

 " 7  .,    *   ! 

  , )  !        

))/ 5'5</ "63'1&4  *'< &    ,

* )

1 !

17   ) , ! 

  #   

 )

    "( &( (&"5)     ! *  !  )

 )   

   (( "" (&"6  #  !  ,  *

,

!

,   )

     "% &' (&(" 

 +*  !    #  $   )

 ! *   !

!  5  $

   ! 



 

 

)  ! , #

 

) ,

-3- ! 

 !

,



* 

   !

 %& !   2)#

 "''83!> ?4 #

 )  *

   *  ) ;   -  @   

 !

 *

*

1)  0   

 !      

  

,)     7  ,,   *2 

   ;  ,

 

! 506(91 

 ! <!"%%- ) "%%8   #

 , !  *     (& &0 "%%' ) !        *  !



!

 * 

! , ) !   ,         

 )    )              ,  

   "- 6 "%%' ,

,   !7  !

/ 8 ,   ,   !    

 ,

!  )

     *

,  ,

! 

1  )  ! 

! *   ,

!  (( &6 "%%%     

!   "- &- (&&(3

= 164  ! , 

! ) !

  !    

-4- ,) 

)  

 

%&3"4 34 !   ,         )     ) !!,  *,    

1   # 

1  )

  "%%%,) 

)    ,!

%&354!  

! A   "8 &- (&&( 3

=  164  ,  )

  B

  )

 !!=        ! 

1

     

1

 )

 !   

     

   , !

%& 3(4,    ) )  *   

!

 ,  , )  , !!=  

! 

  :

 

  1C, *    

) !! 

)  !  !

  "8 "" "%%' ) !    )  !  

 !  ,  ! 

  

  C     , 

 , 

%(!  ,       ,  

 !    "& 5 (&&-   (6 5 (&&-   !   

=1  *  

 !   * !! ! =         

1

)  ! )"" 

  5 "( (&&%, ) 

-5- 6   !  !



                  

*!   

=      

 )

       *  !  

 * ! 

! ;

 C

  )

 

 !   @

   !

, 



!  8  C   , !   )  ,  !       

 , *   ;

 !

$ 





 !  / "''61$ 1(&("    ! * 

4!55$% "% $#$4 "#"%#"4! '$)#" '$)#" 

1 .

  &5