High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/17065/2014allowed

Kamal Kumar v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2015-09-24Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal,Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan6 pages

! "

# $%&%'$(&%)

*+,+,-*) *).(.

+%+*%)/%-%%-0+1*).

*.2-0*-+.

"!3 "!3 "!3 "!3

" 5

####

)*.*-+!

") 1%)%0 66%)7%'# 089%+*)+1*2*+,+,-*) ")

**2%: %'/%-# 00,+,-%' 089%+**-*)%'# %)/%-% ")

-,'1%7'%# 089%+*))*.2-0*-+. %-0;

<=<=<= <=<=<= <=<=<= <=<=<=

# 1*,-.+%-+2*+,+,-,.0,)*9+*0%6%,-.++1*)*.(&2+,- %>+1.,+*>/+1*%)/%-%)>%- *8*'2&*-+ (+1),+,*.

9&&*)9,%'>+1.,+*%0&*%.(),-6 .?

&+.

,- )>%- .+%+*#%),0%>%07%.2()91%.*0>/+1*2*+,+,-*)+1)(61 2*-%(9+,-1*'0- @A(2-1,.>,0B;A#C31%8,-6 >**-%99*2+*0 D+1*%(9+,-2()91%.*2),9*, B;#AC3 7%.0*2.,+*0-+1*.2+ ''+&*-+'*++*)0%+*0A @A7%.

,..(*0,-%8()+1*2*+,+,-*) -+*)&.'%(.* +1*)*# %-%&(-+B#@C3, D+1*%(9+,-2),9*7%.0*2.,+*0

7,+1,-;0%/.+1*,..(%-9*%''+&*-+'*++*)+&%:*60 D+1*++%'2),9* 1*>%'%-9*%&(-+BA#@C37%.

)*?(,)*0+>*0*2.,+*0,-'(&2.(&7,+1(+,-+*)*.+7,+1,- 0%/.),-+*-1%'/*%)'/,-.+%'&*-+.%'-67,+1,-+*)*.+ED + 1%. >**- %8*))*0 +1%+ +1* 2*+,+,-*) 0*2.,+*0 +1)** ,-.+%'&*-+. , - @A# @A %-0 @A;

)*.2*9+,8*'/ + ,. +1* 9%.* +1* 2*+,+,-*) +1%+ .,-9* - 0*8*'2&*-+ 1%0 >**- 9%)),*0 (+ ,- +1* %)*%# +1* >%'%-9* ,-.+%'&*-+.7*)*-+0*2.,+*0 1*)*%+*)#%.(&++%'',-6B'%9 7%. 0*2.,+*0 - ,8* 0,*)*-+ 0%+*. >*+7**- @@ + 7*8*)#8,0*)0*)0%+*0 2%..*0>/+1*

,9*)#

#%),0%>%0#+1*>+17%.)*.(&*0-+1* 6)(-01%8,-60*%('+*0,-0*2.,+,-6,-.+%'&*-+. (91%9+,- 7%.,&2(6-*0>/+1*2*+,+,-*)>/,-.+,+(+,-6%9,8,'.(,+>*%),-6

@;@0%+*0A %-071,917%.0*9)**0>/+1*,8,'(06* F(-,) ,8,.,-G# %),0%>%0 8,0* H(06&*-+ %-0 0*9)** 0%+*0 1*,8,'()+.*+%.,0*+1*)*.(&2+,-)0*)%-0 0,)*9+*0+1*

(+1),+,*.+()-,.1.+%+*&*-+%99(-+.

%+*)91%)6,-6 D .,&2'*,-+*)*.+(2-+1*%&(-+0(*%-0 71,91+1*2*+,+,-*)7%.1*'0',%>'*+2%/ 1*)*.2-0*-+.,'*0 %-%22*%'%6%,-.++1*H(06&*-+%-00*9)**0%+*0 %-0 9(-.*')+1*2*+,+,-*)9-9*0*0>*)*+1*.+ 22*''%+*()+# +1%+%.+%+(+)/)*&*0/%22*%'7%.%8%,'%>'*%6%,-.++1*)0*) )*.(&2+,-%-0#%99)0,-6'/#,-+*)&.)0*)0%+*0 2%..*0>/+1* 00,+,-%' ,.+),9+(06*#%),0%>%0#+1*H(06&*-+ %-00*9)**2%..*0>/+1*,8,'()+7%..*+%.,0*%-0',>*)+/ 7%.6)%-+*0++1*2*+,+,-*)+2)**)%-%22*%'7,+1,-%2*),0

-*&-+1 1*%22*%','*0>/+1*2*+,+,-*)%6%,-.++1*)0*) )*.(&2+,-7%.0,.&,..*0>/ 0&,-,.+)%+)#

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

,-.+%'&*-+.>/+1*%''++**#,%-/#%-0+1*)*%+*)+%'.*I%&,-* ,.(910*%('+7%.J7,'('%-00*',>*)%+*K ))*%.-.+1%+7* 7('0 -7 ,-0,9%+*# +1* )*.2-0*-+. 1%8* %,'*0 + 0,.91%)6* .(91>',6%+,- -+1*7),+2*+,+,-#,+1%.>**-9%+*6),9%''/%8*))*0 +1%+ %+*) 1%8,-6 2%,0 D +1* ++%' %(9+,- 2),9*# +1)** ,-.+%'&*-+. 7*)* 0*2.,+*0 , B; C3 - @A# B@ C3 - @A %-0 B;@AC3 - @A;

8*- % +%>('%+,-1%.>**-()-,.1*0,-2%)%;+1*2*+,+,-6,8,-6(+ 0*+%,'.%++%'.(&B'%91%8,-6>**-0*2.,+*0>*+7**- @ @@ + + 7('0 >* (.*(' + *I+)%9+ +1* +%>('%+,-1*)*(-0*)!

&(-+0*2.,+*0 *9*,2+

%+* B#C3 ;A@;

@ @ B#C3 AA @ B#C3 @ B#C3 ;

@ B#C3 ;A @ @ - +1* H,-+ 7),++*- .+%+*&*-+ ,'*0 - >*1%' )*.2-0*-+. %-0;#+1*)*9*,2++1*2%/&*-+.0*+%,'*0 %>8*.+%-0%0&,++*0 8*-,-+1*H(06&*-+%-00*9)**0%+*0 2%..*0>/+1*,8,'()+#%-%0&,..,-+1*'*): +1*9-9*)-*0

,9*, 0**-0%-+7,+-*.. 1%0>**- )*9)0*0+1%+%.(&B##C31%0%')*%0/>**-0*2.,+*0>/ +1*2*+,+,-*)%6%,-.+2()91%.*+1*>+1.,+* ..(91#,+ 9'*%)'/*&*)6*.+1%+%6%,-.++1*2()91%.*2),9*B;A#C3#% .(&B##C3%22)I,&%+*'/%')*%0/.+00*2.,+*0>/+1*

2*+,+,-*)(2+ 7*8*)#,-+1*)*.(&2+,-)0*)+1%+ 7%. 2%..*0- # --*I()* #+1* ,9*)1%.

6,8*--9)*0,+++1*2*+,+,-*))+1*2%/&*-+.&%0*%2%)+ )&+1*,-,+,%'0*2.,+D+1*%(9+,-2),9* 1* ),-9,2%' *9)*+%)/+8*)-&*-+#%)/%-%#7L(-+)/ '%--,-6L)>%- .+%+*. *2%)+&*-+,-+1*,&2(6-*0 )0*) 0%+*0 # --*I()* # %,)&,-6 +1* )0*) )*.(&2+,- 2%..*0 >/ +1* .+%+* ,9*) 1%. ()-,.1*0 +1* ''7,-6)*%.-,-6!

1*2*+,+,-*)9('01%8*.17-1,.>-%,0*.>/

1*2*+,+,-*)9('01%8*.17-1,.>-%,0*.>/ &%:,-62%/&*-++1*%&(-+ 0(*%.2*)1,.7- &%:,-62%/&*-++1*%&(-+ 0(*%.2*)1,.7- &%:,-62%/&*-++1*%&(-+ 0(*%.2*)1,.7- &%:,-62%/&*-++1*%&(-+ 0(*%.2*)1,.79%'9('%+,-. >(+ +1* 2*+,+,-*) 0,0 -+ 0*2.,+ %-/ 9%'9('%+,-. >(+ +1* 2*+,+,-*) 0,0 -+ 0*2.,+ %-/ 9%'9('%+,-. >(+ +1* 2*+,+,-*) 0,0 -+ 0*2.,+ %-/ 9%'9('%+,-. >(+ +1* 2*+,+,-*) 0,0 -+ 0*2.,+ %-/ %&(-+ ,-.+%'&*-+. +,'' )*.(&2+,- +1* >+1 %&(-+ ,-.+%'&*-+. +,'' )*.(&2+,- +1* >+1 %&(-+ ,-.+%'&*-+. +,'' )*.(&2+,- +1* >+1 %&(-+ ,-.+%'&*-+. +,'' )*.(&2+,- +1* >+1 71,91 .17. 1,. ,-+*-+,- + )*+%,- 2(>',9 2)2*)+/ 71,91 .

17. 1,. ,-+*-+,- + )*+%,- 2(>',9 2)2*)+/ 71,91 .17. 1,. ,-+*-+,- + )*+%,- 2(>',9 2)2*)+/ 71,91 .17. 1,. ,-+*-+,- + )*+%,- 2(>',9 2)2*)+/ 7,+1(+ &%:,-6 2%/&*-+ %. 2*) 1,. 9-+)%9+(%' 7,+1(+ &%:,-6 2%/&*-+ %. 2*) 1,. 9-+)%9+(%' 7,+1(+ &%:,-6 2%/&*-+ %. 2*) 1,. 9-+)%9+(%' 7,+1(+ &%:,-6 2%/&*-+ %. 2*) 1,. 9-+)%9+(%' >',6%+,-.

K >',6%+,-.

K (91)*%.-,-6,.9'*%)'/2*)8*).*%-09-+)%)/++1* )*9)0 *1%8*%')*%0/-+,9*0+1%+%+*)0*2.,+D+1* %(9+,- 2()91%.* 2),9*# +1* 2*+,+,-*) 1%0 0*2.,+*0 +1)** ,-.+%'&*-+.%.%'.%.(&B'%9>*+7**-0,*)*-+0%+*.,-+1* /*%).@@%-0@@ ''+1*.* 2%/&*-+.7*)*&%0*2),)+ +1*2%..,-6+1*)0*))*.(&2+,- *2.,+.(912%/&*-+.

.+%-0. 9-9*0*0 ,- +1* 7),++*- .+%+*&*-+ ,'*0 + +1* ,-.+%-+ 2*+,+,- 1*)*.(&2+,-2)9**0,-6.1%8*>**-,-%',M*0>/+1* %(+1),+,*.7,+1(+*8*-%08*)+,-6++1*)*9)0 *7('01%8* -1*.,+%+,-,->.*)8,-6+1%++1*)*.(&2+,-+1*>+1,- ?(*.+,-1%.>**-0,)*9+*0,-%2*)(-9+)/&%--*) 1*%9+,-# %..(91#9%--+.(.+%,- -8,*771%+1%.>**-.+%+*01*)*,-%>8*#7*%''7

+1* 7),+ 2*+,+,- %-0 .*+ %.,0* +1* ,&2(6-*0 )0*). 0%+*0 # %-0 # --*I()* # %-0 )*.2*9+,8*'/ 1*>+1.,+*,-?(*.+,-.1%''.+%-0)*.+)*0,- %8()+1*2*+,+,-*) 1*)*.2-0*-+..1%''>*)**+'*8/ ,-+*)*.+ %-0 2*-%'+/ ,- %99)0%-9* 7,+1 '%7 %+*) &%:,-6 %0H(.+&*-+ +1* %&(-+ +1%+ +1* 2*+,+,-*) 1%. %')*%0/ 0*2.,+*0 +,.#17*8*)#9'%),,*0+1%++1*2*+,+,-*)7('0-+ >*',%>'*+2%/*I+*-.,-**)+1*2*),0+1*2'+1%0.+0 )*.(&*0 *+,+,-%''7*0,-+1*%)*.%,0+*)&.

F 5

G F 5

G F

# " " " "

+*!

1*+1*))**))*0+*2)+*)NF*.C G 1*+1*))**))*0+*2)+*)NF*.C G 1*+1*))**))*0+*2)+*)NF*.C G 1*+1*))**))*0+*2)+*)NF*.C G