High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15427/2016dismissed

Bhupa Sharma v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2016-08-23Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan4 pages

"#$ $%&'&()* + ,-#./0",."1-"

$#&#&($1 3$1'/'

,#"#$ "14"(""(5#.$1'

$'0(5$(#'

1$'$(#)2 1 "-$'. "6&7859%"#$ 1#.$0$#&#&($1 :::

$#&#&($1 &' '$19&(; "' " ,%&$(%$ &'#1$'' /(5$1 #.$ $0"1#-$(# ,%.65/%"#&(8,#"#$ "14"(",.$&'%/11$(#640'#$5 "#9#,$(&1,$%(5"14,%.68,$%#1<8 "(%.7/6" .$&('#"(#0$#&#&(."'=$$( &6$51"&'&(;";1&$9"(%$#."#"

1"('

6&%4&''/$5=4#.$,#"#$9#(< (($>/1$ 2!."'

=$$(-"5$"'/=?$%# %6"1& &%"#&(9&5$6$##$15"#$5 (($>/1$

2!"(5=4"0064&(;'/%.%6"1& &%"#&(#.$0$#&#&($1@/65(@=$$6&;&=6$ #=$#1"('

$11$5/# 1-.$101$'$(#06"%$ 0'#&(; /('$6 @/65 '/=-&# #."# "' 0$1 06&%4 5"#$5 <

(($>/1$ 2!"(5&(0"1#&%/6"10"1"&!=!"

."'=$$( 5$ &($5&$(64&(1$6"#&(#"0'#@.$1$"#$"%.$1."'%-06$#$5"#$(/1$ 4$"1'&("0"1#&%/6"1'%.6 '0$1%6"1&

(($>/1$ 2!'/%.5$ &(&#&('#"(5'"6#$1$5#-$"("0$1&5 4$"1'&( "0"1#&%/6"1A($"'00'$5##.$0"1#&%/6"1'%.6 /('$6"1;/$'#."##.$0$#&#&($1."5?&($5(#.$01$'$(# 06"%$ 0'#&(;( "(5& #.$1&;&("606&%45"#$5< @"'

#.65#.$ &$65"(5/(5$10"1"&!=!#.$1$ #.$0$#&#&($1@"'(#

22 %%/04&(;"5$$-$59"%"(%4"(5"''/%.8%/65(#."9$=$$(#1"(' $11$5 ."66$(;$"''/%.&'=$&(;6"&5##.$%6"1& &%"#&(%(#"&($5&(15$15"#$5 (($>/1$ 2!@.&%.."'$(6"1;$5#.$'%0$ #.$5$ &(&#&(

5$$-$59"%"(%4#&(%6/5$"#$(/1$ 4$"1'$9$(&(1$6"#&(#"A($"'

00'$5#"0"1#&%/6"1'%.6'0$1%/('$68'/%.%6"1& &%"#&(&'"1=&#1"14 &("'-/%."'=4@"4 01%$'' &(#$101$#"#&(#.$="'&%06&%4&#'$6 ."'

=$$(%."(;$5/('$61$6&$'/0("?/5;$-$(# #.$(B=6$,/01$-$ /1#&(

# %(#$(5#."#"5-&(&'#1"#&9$"%#&(&'"($''$(#&"60"1# #.$1/6$ 6"@"(5 @.$($9$1#.$1$&'"(4"1=&#1"1&($''#.$1$&(#.$'"-$@/65=$0$(=4@"4 &(#$19$(#&(=4#.&'/1#=4&($>$1%&'$ 0@$1'/(5$11#&%6$

#.$('#&#/#&( (5&"=4@"4 ?/5&%&"61$9&$@ $#"(#.$1'/=-&''&(1"&'$5=4%/('$6&'#."##.$1"(' $1

6&%45"#$5< (($>/1$ 2!8$9$(#./;.8&''/$5 1-#.$

&%$ 55&#&("6 .&$ ,$%1$#"14 # 9#8 "14"("8 ,%.6 5/%"#&( $0"1#-$(#=/##.$'"-$."5=$$("0019$5=4#.$"=&($#8@.$1$"'#.$ &-0/;($5%6"1& ."'=$$(&''/$5=4#.$

&%$

55&#&("6 .&$ ,$%1$#"14 # 9#8 "14"("8 ,%.6 5/%"#&( $0"1#-$(#@&#./##"7&(;#.$-"##$1/0#"=&($#"(5"''/%.8'/

$1'

1-"(&(.$1$(#6"%7 ?/1&'5&%#&( "9&(;.$"15%/('$6 1#.$0$#&#&($1"#6$(;#."(5."9&(;

0$1/'$5#.$06$"5&(;'(1$%158#.&'/1#&' #.$%('&5$1$59&$@#."# #.$&('#"(#0$#&#&(&'%-06$#$64=$1$ # -$1&#"(55$'$19$'5&'-&''"6 1"('

6&%&$'&''/$5=4#.$,#"#$9#"(5#.$'#&0/6"#&(' %(#"&($5#.$1$&(5(#9$'#"($( 1%$"=6$1&;.#&("($-064$$ 1"('

6&%4%"(($9$1=$#"7$(##.$0$5$'#"6 "'#"#/#141/6$.$'$

2*2 06&%&$'"1$"#=$'#&(#.$("#/1$ ;/&5$6&($' 1#.$"00101&"#$5$0"1#-$(# @.&6$&''/&(;15$1' #1"('

$1 (#.$01$'$(#%"'$"#1"('

$115$1&(' "1"'#.$0$#&#&($1&'

%(%$1($58."'(#=$$(0"''$5 $#&#&($1."' &6$5#.$&('#"(#0$#&#&( "001$.$(5&(;"(15$1 #1"('

$1 '0$10$#&#&($18=49&1#/$ #.$ %6"1& '.$."'(@=$$(1$(5$1$5$6&;&=6$ 1#1"('

$1 "''.$."'%-06$#$5-1$#."(4$"1'&("0"1#&%/6"1A($"'$ #.$ 0$#&#&($1&'#."##.$1&;&("606&%4 < './65.65#.$ &$65"(5 #.$0$#&#&($1'./65=$.$65#=$(#$6&;&=6$#=$#1"(' $11$5"''.$."'

(#%-06$#$54$"1'#$(/1$(.$101$'$(#06"%$ 0'#&(;&$"#9# ,$(&1,$%(5"14,%.68,$%#1<8 "(%.7/6" .$ %6"1& &%"#&( 5"#$5 (($>/1$ 2! ."' =$$( 0$1/'$5 .$ 55&#&("6 .&$ ,$%1$#"14 # 9# "14"("8 ,%.6 5/%"#&($0"1#-$(#."'"6'1$ $11$5#0"1"+&&&! #.$1&;&("606&%4 5"#$5< 8@.$1$&(&#@"''#"#$5#."#C

D %%15&(;648"9&$@."'=$$(#"7$(#."#"#$"%.$1@/65 (1-"664'#"4(644$"1'&("0"1#&%/6"1A($."# 6@'"00"1$(#64&'

#."#'/%.%6"1& &%"#&(@/65(#=$"("6#$1%"#&(1"%."(;$ #.$1&;&("6 06&%4.$%6"1& &%"#&(#@.&%.#.$0$#&#&($1&'";;1&$9$5 &'1$6"#"=6$ ##.$1&;&("606&%4&#'$6 (5$1'/%.%&1%/-'#"(%$'8#.$'/=-&''&( -"5$=4%/('$6#."##.$%6"1& &%"#&(."'=$$(&''/$5=4"(

&%&"6@. @"'(#%-0$#$(##5'86"%7'-$1&#.$1&;&("606&%4&("(4%"'$."5 -$#"0019"6 #.$"=&($##@"'%$1#"&(640$( 11$'0(5$(#(# 1$'1##"%6"1& &%"#&(7$$0&(;&(9&$@#.$&(#$(#"(5=?$%#&9$ 1@.&%.

#.$1&;&("61"('

6&%4."5=$$(&''/$5

22 9$(#.$1@&'$8#.$0$#&#&($1."'%-06$#$5-1$#."(4$"1' #$(/1$"#.$1$>&'#&(;06"%$ 0'#&(; 1"('

$1&'"(&(%&5$(%$

'$19&%$ 9$(& &#@"'"''/-$5#."##.$1&;&("606&%45"#$5<

(($>/1$ 2! &' # =$ "006&$5 "(5 #.$ %6"1& &%"#&( 5"#$5

(($>/1$ 2!&'(##=$#"7$(&("%%/(#8'#&668($( 1%$"=6$1&;.#9$'#'

@&#.#.$0$#&#&($1("(4%"'$#.$01$'$(#0$#&#&(&'(64 /(5$5("( "001$.$('&(#."#"(15$1 #1"('

$1@/65(@ 66@ ;1/(5 1&(#$1 $1$(%$&'-"5$/#

$#&#&(&'5&'-&''$5 !"#$!#%& 6/%74 .$#.$1'0$"7&(;E1$"'($5) $'

.$#.$1 $01#"=6$) $'