M/S R S Labour And Transport Contractor Urban Estate Jind v. Food Corporation Of India And Others

I N THE HI GH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDI GARH CWP- 1193- 2017 ( O&M) Dat e of deci si on: - 25. 04. 2017 M/ s R. S. Labour & Tr anspor t Cont r act or , Ji nd . . . Pet i t i oner Ver sus Food Cor por at i on of I ndi a and ot her s . . . Respondent s CORAM: HON' BLE MR. JUSTI CE S. J. VAZI FDAR, CHI EF JUSTI CE HON' BLE MR. JUSTI CE ANUPI NDER SI NGH GREWAL Pr esent : - Mr . R. K. Shar ma, Advocat e, f or t he pet i t i oner .

Mr . K. K. Gupt a, Advocat e, f or r espondent s No. 1 and 2.

Mr . P. S. Rana, Advocat e, f or r espondent No. 3.

* * * * S. J. VAZI FDAR, C. J. ( ORAL) The pet i t i oner has chal l enged t he of f i ci al r espondent s' deci si on f or havi ng consi der ed i t s bi d t o be non- r esponsi ve on t he gr ound t hat t he document at i on was not i n or der . 2.

I t i s not necessar y f or us t o deci de t hi s quest i on. The pet i t i oner ' s r at e i n any event i s not as compet i t i ve as t hat of anot her bi dder . Thus, even i f t he pet i t i oner ' s bi d i s f ound t o be r esponsi ve, i t woul d make no di f f er ence as t he 3r d r espondent ' s r at e i s mor e compet i t i ve.

3.

The pet i t i on i s, t her ef or e, di smi ssed. 4.

I t i s cl ar i f i ed t hat t he i ssues r el at i ng t o t he di squal i f i cat i on on ot her gr ounds ar e kept open. ( S. J. VAZI FDAR) CHI EF JUSTI CE ( ANUPI NDER SI NGH GREWAL) JUDGE

25. 04. 2017 Amodh Whet her speaki ng/ r easoned Yes/ No Whet her r epor t abl e Yes/ No Amodh Sharma 2017.04.25 14:21 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document chandigarh