Major Singh And ORS. v. Financial Commissioner Punjab And ORS.
!"
# $!%&'($)* +"
# ($,-./0/&
1&2&
$%$33&&+ 2,$4+/$5.$/0/&
&65&
!"#$%&!&% '"#()!
&'
(
$5-./+5%$+ !/6
( 5)$$&&$2+5%$+ !%$$7&65
88888 &% '"*+,
&+./234+$$..5!/5&5$5 "
"
"
#9:2
;554)/ $%$33&&$5
< "
=9:2 ;!/33&&
(
$5-./+$5%2&!/6&243& /$/%+555$5= "
"
9:2 7>;$$66$ 6!5 4) / 6&+ /$5 &7$&5 / 5 5$5 < > "
< 9:2 7=;554)/&&&$%$57$53$55 /3$4$%?/63&/$/&&&$%$57/$5 5&3&&5/4,%&@/2/$./3+32%/&&/$56$&&5$ &6$?.5 /66&6$)+ +$-./+@//$&&/$/ :! "?$$&*3$$&2!$$53$&2.#<?$$& >3$$& !2 ?/@$&+ 6!5 $ $66$ @/%/ @$& $@5 4) / 33&&$526/54)/ $%$33&&
!2/&243&/$+!$%+$&6/&6$9:2
<;+/&/$556$42./3$$5/$&4.$ -./$52&/$55/6& /%7&/$&/$4. /&/$/?/@$&+@/%//)$%7&/$& /6& /$4565!!./4,%&$.$&/!56$6 $?&/$7$ /!$42./3$$5/$&42!$)5&425 $&3$2$4$5/$&4.$-./$5/$&526/ %6%5.& &6:2
+/-$$5$A&3/$&$$5) 4554&&25$5!2/$?&/$7/$&4554 $5$&6$!/-$$5$A&3$5+/2&+/5&25%/$.$ &2&$$4/)&!$@$5$44&7$&5
( 5)$$&&$2+$5 %2& !%$$7&65 &243&/$/@$$&!6&&&&/$4:%25 / &6$5&56%/$$5&42!/$5$&&/$55 6&!$$@$)!3/3$$5+@/$&/2&/$556/$& 4.($,-./% +@/%/&$5,$%/3$$5$5+ /!+/&A2&!2A2$5&42!!B&26 A2$)+32%/&&$2$4$5 /&!$%&/$4$? %&5$4)/$2/&$55%$!$)!%
/$/$5/$5%2&!/6$&+$66$&5/ 6$6 4? $5 ! / @ /$ / & !% $5 3 / &243&&&!(
$5-./+!+/&6$:2 <+5 264)/6&+5&&266/%$&$&/&/$556 /$&4&/@4/66)!$-./+@/%/&!$$@$)!3 /3$$5+/!+/$.23!2A2$5&42!&26 A2$)!$5$5,$%/3$$5&@/)3&6$%5$57
- !255$5/4),%5
/& 2 /$5 %$5 26 / $5 %2& ! / 6&6$5)$&/@/6&$6,25%5@//& 6$+ +/$3$+42:%6/$/$.2$6/:3 6!/$5/$&4.!%7&/$& /)$./ $5 4/%$&!!/%7&/$&+6/$6&&/25/$4&+ @/$& & . /) $ ./+ &62&. / %$2& ! $%/ / /$32&) 3)@+/!5.&554)/33&&$5/
$%$33&&26/5./5!/&&&$%$5 &.7$&5/5!/%$6!%).$$5,2&!5 / %+@/3$5./3$4$%?+/$&$&&.5$)$&&
/$6!/5$5&/2&'7 C
! "
#$%&'%#$
! "
'(%$'%#)
! "
. * + !$%+/$5$5$/$&43$54)/$!35 6$6$!/5 /%$)4//$2/&!25/$ /&&&$%$57+$!&./&6$5$!.. 662) ! /$. / 6$&+ &$%5 / !$ 6$ $66$& /$ / 6& $ 2%&&$) 5$... $ -./+ 6&.4)/$5%2&!/%$$+32%/&&&$%$&! $..$5D./.$ /5&%$4&$54$5$@ $6& /)$$%%5.)$!!35
6&$5&5&3&&5
+/-' *&% , +0 "#()!
2 2 13 +4 56 +1
2 2 +9