Garg Marble & Sanitary House Barwala v. State Of Haryana & ORS

 
   
   
   
   
  
  
  
 



!"# #$%&%'( )



!"# #$%&%'( )



!"# #$%&%'( )



!"# #$%&%'( )

 !*+,!*-.#!'/!'%"!*01&# #"%"%'#* 2& "!"# !*0!'!!'/"3#*& #&4'/#'"&
,(5

,(5

,(5

,(5 6, 
77,  6, 
77,  6, 
77,  6, 
77,  *#&#'"( ,*,3!'6!.%'+.!8/9$!"#8 *"3#4#"%"%'#* ,*!1*!-3,31'"!8 8!*0!'! ,* ##4!:,!'$3!'/!8/9$!"# **#&4'/#'"  77, 8 ;6< 77, 8 ;6< 77, 8 ;6< 77, 8 ;6< 3#4#"%"%'#*3!&4*!0#/ *"3#%&&1!'$# !=*%"%'"3#'!"1*#   $#*"%*!*% * >1!&3%'+ "3# %?41+'#/ .#""#*@*/#* /!"#/  )  -0 =3%$3 !44.%$!"%' * +*!'"  $?4#'&!"%' %'"#*?&   1%/#.%'#& /!"#/

)  3!&-##'/#$.%'#/ '-*%# 8"3#4#"%"%'#*3!&"3#&34%'"3#'!?# !*+,!*-.# !'/ !'%"!*0 1&# &%"1!"#/ !" "3# ?!%' *!/ !*=!.!8 %&"*%$" %&!*'   ! %*#-*:#1"%'"3#&34=3%$3=!&#A"%'+1%&3#/-0"3# %*# -*%+!/#!'/.&& 
8

@&1

#*#/-0"3#4#"%"%'#*=!&*#4*"#/-0 "3# %*# 

%$%!.& 3#*#!

"#* "3# 4#"%"%'#* ?!/# !' !44.%$!"%' * $?4#'&!"%' %' "#*?&   "3# 1%/#.%'#& /!"#/ )  8 %&&1#/ -0 "3#

%*#$"*8*-!'6$!. /%#&8!*0!'! *"3#.&& $??#*$%!.4*4#*"0  &?!..&34:##4#*&8*#3*%=!.!&8 !/%=!.!&8:3:3!@:%&:='#*&-#$!1&#  %*#8#.#$"*%$!.3!B!*/&8 ./&8#!*"3>1!:#&*'!"1*!./%&!&"#*&'
.!1&#

 )   "3# 1%/#.%'#&8 "3# ..=%'+ 1*-!' 4*4#*"%#& =#*# /# %'#/ " -# #.%+%-.# *$?4#'&!"%'( C 3414"!*#! 

&> ##" *,1'%$%4!.
*4*!"%'8  &> ##" * ,1'%$%4!.
1'$%. !'/   &> ##" * ,1'%$%4!.
??%""## 
#3*% )
!/%


73:3!@:%&:D  !-.#&!*#!.&4*9%/#/%'"3#
.!1&#E "3#1%/#.%'#& ,1'%$%4!.
*4*!"%'8,1'%$%4!.
1'$%.!'/,1'%$%4!.
??%""## *"3# 41*4&# !=!*/%'+$?4#'&!"%'8=3%$3!*#!&1'/#*( C;!<,1'%$%4!.
*4*!"%'( *
!"#+*0 6&&%'14##& F $?4#'&!"%'   34 ;14" 

!?!+# 14" 

&> ##"< .!$

.!$

-#"=##'.!$" ).!$

-#"=##').!$"

-#"=##'.!$" E.!$

) -#"=##'E.!$"

#0'/

 73:3!@:%&:

14" 

)

)

-#"=##' ) " 

-#"=##'  ".!$

.!$

#0'/.!$

) #3*%@!/%

14"

)

-#"=##' )  "



#0'/ 

;-< ,1'%$%4!.
1'$%.( *
!"#+*0 6&&%'14##& F $?4#'&!"%'   34 ;14" 

!?!+# 14" 

&> ##"< .!$

.!$

-#"=##'.!$" ).!$

-#"=##').!$"

-#"=##'.!$" E.!$

) -#"=##'E.!$"

 

#0'/

 73:3!@:%&:

14"

)

-#"=##' ) " 

-#"=##'  ".!$

.!$

#0'/.!$

) #3*%@!/%

14"

)

-#"=##' )  "



#0'/ 

;$< ,1'%$%4!.
??%""##&( *
!"#+*0 6&&%'14##& F $?4#'&!"%'   34 ;14" 

!?!+# 14" 

&> ##"< .!$

.!$

-#"=##'.!$" ).!$

-#"=##').!$"

-#"=##'.!$" E.!$



) -#"=##'E.!$"

#0'/

 73:3!@:%&:

14"

)

-#"=##' ) " 

-#"=##'  ".!$

#0'/.!$

) #3*%@!/%

14"

)

-#"=##' )  "



#0'/ 

3# !44.%$!"%'   "3# 4#"%"%'#* * $?4#'&!"%' =!& !44*9#/-0"3##$*#"!*08,1'%$%4!.
??%""##8 !*=!.!""3##

#$""3!" 3#3!/&1

#*#/.&&""3#"1'# 
8

@%'"3# %*#%'$%/#'"=3%$3": 4.!$#'  =#9#*8"3#!44.%$!"%' "3#4#"%"%'#*3!&-##' /#$.%'#/-0 "3#*#&4'/#'"& ?1$3.#&& "3# 1- %9%&%'!. 

%$#* ;
%9%.<8

!*=!.! ' "3# +*1'/ "3!" "3# 4#"%"%'#* /%/ '" 1.

%.. "3# "#*?& !'/ $'/%"%'& "3#1%/#.%'#&%'$#8%"=!&'"/%&$.&#/%'"3#%?41+'#/ .#""#*@*/#* /!"#/  )  !& " 3= "3# 4#"%"%'#* /%/ '" 1.

%.. "3# *#>1%&%"#*#>1%*#?#'"&8"3#4#"%"%'#*?!/#!*#4*#&#'"!"%'=3%$3=!&'" /#$%/#/#'$#8"3#4*#&#'"4#"%"%'3!&-##' %.#/%'=3%$3!

"#*'"%$#8"3#

  *#&4'/#'"& 3!9# %.#/ "3#%* *#4.0 !'/ 3!& &"1$: " "3#%* &"!'/ "3!" "3# 4#"%"%'#* %& '" #'"%".#/ * $?4#'&!"%' !& 3# %& '" $9#*#/ -0 "3# 1%/#.%'#&-#$!1&#"3#1%/#.%'#&!*#?#!'" *"3#&34&!'/'" *"3# +/='& 6#!*'#/ $1'&#. * "3# 4#"%"%'#* 3!& !*+1#/ "3!" +/=' %& 4!*" "3#&34!'/"3#*# *#8"3#.&&&1

#*#/-0"3#4#"%"%'#*%'"3# %*# ":4.!$#%'"3#+/='3!&"-#$'&%/#*#/%'"#*?& "3#1%/#.%'#&8 #&4#$%!..0 =3#' "3#*# %& ! *#$??#'/!"%' ?!/# -0 "3# #$*#"!*08 ,1'%$%4!.
??%""##8 !*=!.!%'"3%&*#+!*/ 6#!*'#/ $1'&#. * *#&4'/#'"   3!& &1-?%""#/ "3!" "3# 1%/#.%'#& =#*# ?!/# * "3# &?!.. &34:##4#*&8 *#3*%=!.!&8 !/%=!.!&8 :3:3!@:%&: ='#*& !'/ * "3!" ?!""#*8 "3# !*#! %& !.& 4*9%/#/   "3# &34"=3%$3"3#1%/#.%'#&=1./!44.0 *#A!?4.#8%"%&&1-?%""#/"3!" "3#1%/#.%'#&=1./!44.0""3#&343!9%'+"3#!*#! 

&> ##"% %"%& &%"1!"#/ %' "3# ,1'%$%4!.
*4*!"%'8  &> ##" %  %" %& &%"1!"#/ %' "3# ,1'%$%4!.
1'$%. !'/   &> ##" %  %" %& &%"1!"#/ %' "3# ,1'%$%4!.
??%""##&%'$#%"%&!$!&# ,1'%$%4!.
??%""## !*=!.!8"3#*# *#8 "3#4#"%"%'#*3!/"4*9#"3!""3#!*#! "3#+/='%'=3%$3"3# %*#": 4.!$#=!&?*#*.#&& &> ##"3#*#%&'&1$3!9#*?#'"?!/#%'"3# 4#"%"%'!-1""3#&%B# "3#+/='84*-!-.0"3#4#"%"%'#*:'#="3!"% "3#&%B# "3#+/='%&?#'"%'#/8=3%$3?!0-#?*#"3!' &> ##"8 "3#'3#=1./'"-# 1'/#.%+%-.# *$?4#'&!"%'

#"3!"!&%"?!08&%'$#"3#4#"%"%'#*%&$.!%?%'+$?4#'&!"%' %'"#*?& "3#1%/#.%'#&8"3#*# *#83#3!&"$?#=%"3%'"3# 1*$*'#*&  "3#1%/#.%'#& *"3#&!%/41*4&#%*&".08"3#4*4#*"0 "3#4#"%"%'#*

E =!&'"!&34!'/%&*!"3#*!+/='!'/&#$'/.08% %"%&"-#4*#&1?#/ "3!""3#+/='%&!4!*" "3#&34"3#'"3#4#"%"%'#*3!&"4.#!/!'/ 4*9# "3!" "3# &!%/ &34@+/=' =!& '" ?*# "3!'   &> ##"8 -#%'+ &%"1!"#/%'"3#,1'%$%4!.
??%""##8 !*=!.!'"3#!-&#'$# '#$#&&!*0 4.#!/%'+&8 "3# 4#"%"%'#* =1./ '" -#$?# #.%+%-.# * "3# 41*4&#  $.!%?%'+ $?4#'&!"%' !& "3# 9#*0 41*4&#   %&&1!'$#   "3# 1%/#.%'#& =!& " +%9# %??#/%!"# *#.%#  " &?!.. &34:##4#*&8 *#3*%=!.!&8 !/%=!.!&8 :3:3!@:%&:='#*&=3=1./&1

#*-#$!1&# %*#8#.#$"*%$!.3!B!*/&8

./&8#!*"3>1!:#&*'!"1*!./%&!&"#*&!'/.&#"3#%*.%9#.%3/3#*#=!& '&1$3%/#! +%9%'+$?4#'&!"%'""3#4#*&'&=3&#&34&!*# "3# -%++#*&%B#"3!''#?#'"%'#/%'"3#1%/#.%'#&%'$#8"3#*#%&'&1$3 4.#!/%'+ " "3%& #

#$" "3!" "3# 4*4#*"0 %' /%&41"# %' =3%$3 "3# %*# ": 4.!$# =!& !-1" "3# &%B#     &> ##" -#%'+ &%"1!"#/ %' ,1'%$%4!.
??%""##8 !*=!.!8"3#*#&4'/#'"&!*#=#..=%"3%'"3#%**%+3"%'3./%'+ "3!""3#4#"%"%'#*%&'" 1.

%..%'+"3#-!&%$*#>1%*#?#'"& "3#1%/#.%'#& !'/3!&*%+3".0"1*'#//='"3#$.!%??!/#-0"3#4#"%"%'#* "3#*!*+1?#'"%&*!%&#/ '9%#="3#*# 8/'" %'/!'0?#*%"%'"3#4*#&#'"4#"%"%' !'/"3#&!?#%&3#*#-0/%&?%&&#/ ;77, < ;77, < ;77, < ;77, <

)



)



)



)

              
 3#"3#*&4#!:%'+@*#!&'#/ ( #&@ 3#"3#*#4*"!-.#  ( #&@