High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16566/2015dismissed

Arvind Kumar v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2015-12-05Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal,Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan6 pages

!""#$%$&' ()$&*+,- ( ..

"!$!$&"( /"(%,% 0! !" (1 & !2"(% ..

"%3&*"&!%

("%"&!'.

(4 1+,- (02 (- 5*)# !"(!2"3"!$!$&"(

(""3 6 71 &5**75 (1 &

(86"%20$&2 75*)# !"(("%3&*"&!%& 2" (1 & 8$)"%!#6")"73-"&! (* 2"("$& !"(!:"

(""(("*! %!2" (*$&)$!"*&7$&"!"&*"(%&;< (!2"$)"

:7#6%)"(&-"&!8$)"%!#6 (- 8 0"#!(%.5 &*5$% ( (3()$*$&=%"#,($!1%"()$#"

"!$!$&"( %% $7%%,#2!"&*"(3(#"%%2 77"&="$&3 (!$#,7 ( $% ! #7 ,%" < !2" &%!(,#!$&% ( "&*"("(% >2$#2 7 1% *>& & "7$=$:$7$!1 #($!"($ ( 3(%3"#!$)" %"#,($!1 #&!( #!(% $& !"(-% 3 %! "?3"($"&#" % 7% -$&$-,-!,(&)"($&!2"3("#"*$&=$)"1" (% @ 2""&*$&=#7 ,%"<!2"&%!(,#!$&% ("&*"("(%(" *% %,&*"('.

$% % # & $"

(% '

() *+ ,

# , !!

%-"

./0//

12.0345 *1* !

(

6222 , !!

# !

& !

%,,

, !

7 A %3"(#7 ,%"<!2":$**"(%-,%!2 )" &"?3"($"&#"$)" 1" (%$&%"#,($!1%"()$#" 8 (="&$- 7 (-( )!=($#,7!,( 7

(-!2"0! !")!B"&!( 7)!B &$)"(%$!1 & **$!$&!2":$**"( -,%!2 )" !,(&)"(-("!2 & 7 #%$&!2"3("#"*$&=$)"1" (% % ("= (*%3()$*$&=%"#,($!1%"()$#"&71$&("%3"#! &=($#,7!,( 7 (- ! $% !2"# %"!2"3"!$!$&"( !2 ! %,#2 "7$=$:$7$!1#($!"($ %!$3,7 !"*,&*"(#7 ,%"<$%,& $(5 (:$!( (1 &*2 %:""&(-,7 !"*! :"&"$!3($) !"("%3&*"&!%& &*,&%"7 33" ($&=(!2"3"!$!$&"( >,7* %,:-$! !2 ! ( !2" 3(")$,% 1" (% $" ( !2" 1" ( !2"

"?3"($"&#"#7 ,%"> %#&$&"*!!>1" (% &*>2$#2> %!2"(" !"( "&2 &#"*!!2(""1" (%$&!2"1" ( &*!2"(" !"(!,(1" (%$&!2"

1" ( ! $% (=,"* !2 ! !2" #&*$!$& 3%%"%%$&= -$&$-,- "?3"($"&#"$)"1" (%$&%"#,($!1%"()$#" 8 (="&$- 7 (-( )! =($#,7!,( 7 (- 3"(! $&$&= ! !2" #,(("&! 1" ( $% >$!2,! &1 ( !$& 7"&% ( %!2"("C,$("-"&!-$&$-,-!,(&)"( 7 #%5 $!2 %:""& %%"(!"*&:"2 7!2"3"!$!$&"(!2 !(!2"1" (% . 5 . 5 . @5 @. A &* !2"("C,$("*!,(&)"( > % %7 #%5 7 #%5 7 #%5 7 #% &*@ 7 #%("%3"#!$)"71 "!$!$&"( #&!"&*%!2 !!2"("C,$("*!,(&)"( %3"("&*$&=#7 ,%"<2 %:""& $&#(" %"*! 7 #%3"(! $&$&=!!2"1" ( &71!"&%,("!2 !

!2"3($) !"("%3&*"&!%("! $&!2"#&!( #!!2 !!2"12 )":""&$%%,"*$&!2"$(

.@.

),((!2"3 %!- &11" (%5 2 )" 7%:""& 77"="*:1%! !$&= !2 !("%3&*"&!%& &*$(-% (":"$&=(,&"%%"&!$ 771:1!2" -$71 -"-:"(%&"02 -+,- (5>2$%>(6$&=$&!2"$#"!2"

("%3&*"&!. (* &* $% !2"(":1 "?"(#$%$&= ,&*," $&7,"&#" &* - &$3,7 !$&= !2" !"(-% &* #&*$!$&% $& !2" !"&*"( 3(#"%% ! !2" *) &! ="("%3&*"&!%& &* 2"$%%,">$!2("= (*!"?!"&!4,*$#$ 7(")$">3"(-$%%$:7"$& "?"(#$%"4,($%*$#!$&,&*"((!$#7"!2"&%!$!,!$&&*$ !!2" !"(-%!"&*"(3("%#($:$&="7$=$:$7$!1#($!"($ $%&7&="( &

!2"&D:7"3"?,(!2 *"? -$&"*!2"$%%," &*:%"()"* % ,&*"('.

$ #

9!#

# !

.A.

< 2$%)$">> %("$!"( !"*$& !

" " #

!! $!%" !& '

!> %2"7*!2 !!2"!"(-% &*#&*$!$&%$&!2"!"&*"( (" 3("%#($:"*:1!2")"(&-"&!:" ($&=$&-$&*!2"& !,("#&!( #! &*$& %,#2- !!"(%!2" ,!2($!1# 77$&=(!2"!"&*"($%!2":"%!4,*="!3("%#($:" !2"!"(-% &*#&*$!$&%!2"!"&*"( E *)"(!$&=: #6!!2" #!%!2"3("%"&!# %"!2"("C,$("-"&! !2"$&#(" %"*!,(&)"($" 7 #%$&!2"1" ( $%%,=2!! :"4,%!$$"*:1!2"("%3&*"&!%&!2": %$%!2 !!2"("> % &$&#(" %"$&!2" "?3"&%"%(%"#,($!1!2 %:""&%,:-$!!"*&:"2 7!2"("%3&*"&!% !2 !(!2"1" (% . @5 @. A &* !2""?3"&%"%>"("

%@EEE 7 #%5 %@<;< 7 #% &* %A 7 #% ("%3"#!$)"71 2"

#(("%3&*$&=("C,$("*!,(&)"((!2"%"1" (%5 *-$!!"*715> % %

7 #%5 % 7 #% &* %@ 7 #%!$(%!:7,%2!2"$&#(" %"$&("C,$("*!,(& )"((- %@ 7 #%$&!2"1" ( ! 7 #%(!2"1" ( .

*"% 33" (*$%3(3(!$& !" ; 2"$=,("%&!$#"*2"("$& :)"!2"-%"7)"%- 1&!("&*"(!2" $&#(" %"$&!,(&)"(!:" >")"(5!!"%!!2"#&!"&!$&( $%"* &:"2 7!2"3"!$!$&"(!2 !!2"$&#(" %"> %! $7(- *"5(!2":"&"$! 3($) !"("%3&*"&!%5>"2 *# 77"*,3&!2"("%3&*"&!%!,(&$%2!2" 3("#$%" $=,("% % ("= (*% !2"!,(& )"( 3"(! $&$&=! %"#,($!1%"()$#"% 3()$*"* $& 8 (=" =($#,7!,( 7 (-B)! =($#,7!,( 7 (- $& !2"

3("#"*$&=$)"1" (%0"3 ( !" $* )$!%&:"2 7("%3&*"&!%& &* $&!2$%("= (*2 )":""&$7"*2"% -">,7*(")" 7!2 !!2"!,(&)"( :!2("%3&*"&!%& &*$&!2"3("#"*$&=$)"1" (%$%$&"?#"%%

%#(("%!%! &*% *-$!!"*:"(",%!2 !!2"!,(&)"(!2"

3"!$!$&"($&!2"3("#"*$&=$)"1" (%$% %<7 #%2 !"-"(="%$%!2 !

")"&$!2"("C,$("*!,(&)"(> %!:"3"=="**>&! %< 7 #%5%!$775!2"

3"!$!$&"(>,7*&!2 )":""&"7$=$:7"!2"#&)"(%"!2"!,(&)"( :!2("%3&*"&!%& &* ("?#""*%!2"("C,$("-"&! !,(&)"(

7 #%$&!2"3("#"*$&=$)"1" (%"5 %%,#25*&!$&* &1-"($!$& !2"#&!"&!$&( $%"*:1!2"3"!$!$&"(!2 !!2"$&#(" %"$&!,(&)"(!

7 #%(!2"1" ( > %! $7(- *"(!2":"&"$!3($) !" ("%3&*"&!% 2" %%"(!$&&:"2 7!2"3"!$!$&"(!2 !!2"("C,$("-"&! $)"1" (%3 %!"?3"($"&#"$&%"#,($!1%"()$#" 8 (="&$- 7 (-( )!=($#,7!,( 7 (- %3"(#7 ,%"<:"$&= (:$!( (1 &*,&(" %& :7"5$% !! 771-$%#&#"$)"* !2 %=&",&#&!()"(!"*!2 !(!2"1" ( A.

!2"3"!$!$&"(2$-%"72 *3 (!$#$3 !"*$&!2"!"&*"(3(#"%% &*2 * :""&=( &!"*!2"#&!( #!(3()$*$&=%"#,($!1%"()$#"%$&&"!2" %"#!(%,&*"(!2"("%3&*"&!. (*)"&$&!2"1" ( !2"("> % %$-$7 (#7 ,%" %("= (*%("C,$("-"&!"?3"($"&#"2"3"!$!$&"( !!2 ! 3$&!!$-"2 * 3 (!$#$3 !"* $& !2"!"&*"(3(#"%% >$!2,!*"-,(( 3(!"%!!>,7*&!:"3"&(!2"3"!$!$&"(!( $%" #2 77"&="! & $*"&!$# 7"?3"($"&#"#7 ,%"3"(! $&$&=!!2"#,(("&!1" ($" 2" 77"= !$&% ( $%"*:1!2"3"!$!$&"( ("&!

>"77,&*"*&!2">($!!"&%! !"-"&!$7"*&:"2 7!2"("%3&*"&!%$! 2 %:""& *-$!!"*!2 !+($%2 &+,- ($"!2"3(3($"!( B% 3! $& 0"#,($!1 &*"!"#!$)" 7 #"-"&!="&#1$"("%3&*"&!&$%!2"%&

( -+,- (2" (".&!$#"* -+,- (%&0202 17 6 -$% %! !"*!:">(6$&= % 7 %%./"-371""$&!2" (-!2"("%3&*"&!. (* !$% (!>,7*&!:"3%%$:7"(!2$%,(!! ##"3!!2"

#&!"&!$& !2 ! 7 %%./ "-371"" !2" ("%3&*"&!. (* $% $& 3%$!$&!$&7,"&#"!2"("%3&*"&!. (* &*!- &$3,7 !"#&*$!$&% "7$=$:$7$!1 !"&*"(3(#"%% !>,7*:" 33%$!"!&!$#"!2 !!2"%#3">(6 %("= (*% 3()$*$&=%"#,($!1%"()$#"%2 %:""&*"$&"*$&!2"!"&*"(*#,-"&!$!%"7 2"% -""&! $7%3()$*$&=%"#,($!1!!2""&!$("$"7* (" !2" (-5 :,$7*$&=%5 %!("5 ( *% &* !(""%5 %! 5 (- !( #!(% &* =($#,7!,(" $-37"-"&!% &*"&!$("-)" :7" &*$--) :7"3(3"(!1!2" (-!$% (!2")"(&-"&!($!%$&%!(,-"&! 7$!1!%"">2 !$%!2":4"#! &*>2 ! $%!2"&"#"%% (13("%#($3!$&!-""!!2"%! "*:4"#!$)" !> %(!2" ("%3&*"&!. (* ! 3("%#($:" !2" 3(" #&*$!$&% ( C, 7$$# !$&% ( !"&*"("(%% %!"&%,("!2 !!

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

("&*"("(%$%&"$!2"( (:$!( (15*$%#($-$& !(1( @ & )$"> !2" :)"5 !2"(" >,7* :" & > (( &! ( $&!"("("&#"2"3"!$!$&$%5 ##(*$&=715*$%-$%%"*

7,#61 2"!2"(!:"(""(("*! "3(!"(F"%