High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12046/2017disposed of

Court On Its Own Motion v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2018-02-07Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan4 pages

!"# #$%&%'( ) !"# #$%&%'( ) !"# #$%&%'( ) !"# #$%&%'( ) *+"'%"&,'-"%'

*+"'%"&,'-"%'

#"%"%'#+ #"%"%'#+ #"%"%'#+ #"%"%'#+ .#+&*& .#+&*& .#+&*& .#+&*& /#0/!'1%2!+/!'1"/#+& /#0/!'1%2!+/!'1"/#+& /#0/!'1%2!+/!'1"/#+& /#0/!'1%2!+/!'1"/#+& #&3'1#'"& #&3'1#'"& #&3'1#'"& #&3'1#'"& ( ( ( ( 4 5 6

7 4 5 6

7 4 5 6 6 4 5 6 6 4 5 6 6 4 5 6 6 +#&#'"( + -%" /!'8%0 19$!"#

+"/#0/!'1%2!+/ +6!":!3!; !%'0 11;6;%$%"+#'#+!; '1%!,%"/ +6/%9:/%+0#'"+!;9"*'&#;

+%'%&"+: #!;"/!'1!-%;:#;

!+# +6!'1##3*12%;0 11; 0!+:!'! + !2-/!'6/*-!'0 0*'8!< +6*9%+6#/2!;06#'%+6"!'1%'2*'&#;,%"/ & !=!'=&/!6!,/'#:0 11%"%'!;9";#!1#+

+0/!'1%2!+/ >>>

8!:7*-!+%""!;0 +!;

8!:7*-!+%""!;0 +!; ?

) ?

) 6"!"*&+#3+" %;#1<:"/#+#&3'1#'"?0/!'1%2!+/ %&"!=#''+#$+10&*<8#$""!;;8*&"#A$#3"%'&

%$#""!2"/#&!-# !"!33+3+%!"#3;!$# &"!'1&1%&3&#1 ?

'"/#&*?-"*'"%$#"!=#'<:!+%'1#+6%'2/6%1/*0 '"/#<!&%& '#,&3!3#++#3+"+#2!+1%'2@-'"/;12%+;0,/,!& +#"*+'#1 +- "/# 0 /!'1%2!+/ ,%"/*" "+#!"-#'"0 ' "/# 2+*'1 "/!" "/# !"/#+ "/# 2%+; $*;1 '" 3!: B ;!$& + &*$/ "+#!"-#'"0"/#&!-#,!&"+#!"#1!&!*<;%$'"#+#&"5%"%2!"%'!'1

*-<#+#1!&

0'"%$#,!&%&&*#1" 0 /!'1%2!+/ "/+*2/ %"& %+#$"+0 6"!"# *'8!<0 6"!"# !+:!'! !'1 "/# #!;"/ 6#$+#"!+:0 /!'1%2!+/ 1-%'%&"+!"%'0 /!'1%2!+//#+#!

"#+'@ '"%$# -"%',!&%&&*#1" '%' '1%!0%'%&"+: #!;"/!'1!-%;:#;

!+#!'1+ +*'

&!%'0#'"+!;9#+'-#'"6"!'1%'2$*'&#;!$$#3"#1"/#'"%$#' %"&<#/!;

#3;:<:,!: !

%1!9%"'<#/!;

+#&3'1#'" /!& <##' %;#1

%1!9%" +6!"%&/ 22!+,!;0%+#$"+#'#+!;#!;"/ 6#+9%$#&0!+:!'!!'1!

%1!9%" 6/6!"%&/7*-!+0'1#+6#$+#"!+:" "/#9#+'-#'" '1%!'<#/!;

+#&3'1#'"%'%&"+: #!;"/!'1 !-%;:#;

!+#/!9#<##' %;#10,/#+#%'09!+%*&3;%$%#&%'1%$!"%'2"/# &"#3&0,/%$/!+#+#C*%+#1"<#"!=#'<:9!+%*&!*"/+%"%#&/!9#<##' #'*-#+!"#1 !'1 "/# &$/#-#& %'"+1*$#1 + "+#!"-#'" 9!+%*& ":3#& 3!"%#'"&%'"/#+#&3#$"%9#6"!"#&!'1'%' '1%!5#!+'#1 $*'&#; +"/#+#&3'1#'"?0/!'1%2!+//!1 %;#1&"!"*&+#3+"

' @ 0,/#+#%'0&"#3&,/%$/,#+#"!=#' +"+#!"-#'" "/#

!<:2%+;!&'"%$#1%'"/#'"# "/#;#!+'#16%'2;# *12#'"/#<!&%& ,/%$/03+#&#'"3#"%"%',!& %;#1*'1#+*<;%$'"#+#&"5%"%2!"%'0 /!9#<##''!++!"#1 D /#;!"#&"&"!"*&+#3+"<:,!: !'!

%1!9%" +#9% !:!;0+ #&&+0#3!+"-#'" #1%!"+%$&0!*"/+%E#1+#3+#&#'"!"%9#0 06#$"+? 0/!'1%2!+//!&<##' %;#1"1!:"/!&<##'0%'"#+ !;%!0&"!"#1"/#+#%'"/!""/# !<:2%+;0'!-#;:0/!/!",!&%'%"%!;;:

#A!-%'#1%'#1%!"+%$0 19!'$#1#1%!"+%$&#'"#+0'

9%1# D ) 0,/#+#&/#,!&!19%&#1!'1 !1-%""#1%'"/#&3%"!;,#9#+0&/#$*;1'"2#"!1-%&&%'!&"/# 3!+#'"& "/# 3!"%#'" /!1'" $-# 3+#3!+#1 +"/# &!-# /#

3!"%#'",!&+#C*%+#1%'1+!1-%&&%'"1%&$*&&%'1#"!%;!'13;!' %'9#&"%2!"%'&"1#"#$""/#+#!&' +/#+*'*&*!;,#%2/"2!%'!&,#;;

!&"!&&#&& +"/#$-3;%$!"%'&"/!"-!:<#!&&$%!"#1,%"/<#&%":

'3!+! "/#&"!"*&+#3+"0%"/!&<##'&*<-%""#1"/!" 3!"%#'",!&!1-%""#1' F %'"/##1%!"+%$'1$+%';2:'%"

!" 19!'$#1 #1%!"+%$& #'"#+0 9%1# 1-%&&%'

DD) !"%#'" ,!& !1-%""#1!&G H !'1!;; <!&%$ ;!<+!"+:%'9#&"%2!"%'&1'# +#9!;*!"%' /#+<#&%":%'$;*1%'2 <+!%'%"*%"!+: +## $&"/#/&3%"!;/!1'"$/!+2#1!':

!-*'" +"/#"+#!"-#'"+%'1+&"!: "/#3!"%#'"!&3!"%#'",!& +#$#%9%'2 +## &#+9%$#& %#"%$%!'0 /:&%"/#+!3%&" !'1 /:&%$!;

'"/+3;2%&"!'1%"/!&!;&<##'&"!"#1%'"/#&"!"*&+#3+""/!" 9!+%*& 3/:&%$!; #A!-%'!"%'& "/# 3!"%#'" ,#+# 1'# !'1 "/# "+#!"-#'" %' "/# +- 1%#"!+: -1% %$!"%'& !'1 /:&%"/#+!3:

+#2%-#' +#C*%+#1 " $'"+; /#+ ,#%2/"0 $++#$"%' 9%"!-%' 1# %$%#'$: !'1 &*33;#-#'"!"%' ,%"/ $!;$%*- !'1 %+' &*33;#-#'"& ,!&1'#*+"/#+%'3!+!& !'1F0%"/!&<##'&"!"#1"/!" ;;,?*3 !$"%'/!&<##'"!=#'!'1"/#3!+#'"&/!9#<##'!19%&#1$!+# *;;: /#'#A" ;;,?*3!$"%'%&1*#%'-%1?#<+*!+:0 )/#&!%13!+!& +#!1!&*'1#+(?

/!""/#<!<:/!/!",!&&$/#1*;#1 +! ;;,*3 9%&%" !'1 "/# 3!+#'"& "/# $/%;1 ,#+# 1*;:

$'"!$"#1I%'

+-#1+#2!+1%'2"/# ;;,*39%&%"!

"#+ F ) /# 3;!' ,!& " 1 2#'#"%$ %'9#&"%2!"%'& +"/#+ !-%;:-#-<#+&!'1&"!+""/# 3!"%#'"'5#3"%'/#+!3: 6*<&#C*#'";:0"/#<!<: ,!& <+*2/" + ;;, *3 <: "/# 3!+#'"& '

@ !'1,!&1*;:!""#'1#1<:+#9%!:!;

+ /#1$"+&$'1*$"#1 *+"/#+"#&"&'"/# <!<: !'1 /#+ 3!+#'"& /# &!-3;# + 2#'#"%$

&!-3;#& 3!+#'"& /!9# <##' &"+#1 !'1 &#'" "

#'2!;*+* 5!< ,/%$/ $'1*$"#1 "/# %'%"%!; 2#'#"%$ "#&" "/#<!<:*+"/#+"/#<!<:/!&<##'&"!+"#1 '!'+!;-#1%$!"%'"+#1*$# !"!<&+3"%'!'1 1# %'%"%9# "+#!"-#'" ,%"/ ;#3"%' /+-'# ,%;; <# &"!+"#1!

"#+$-3;#"%'23!+#'"&"#&"& F /!" "/#+#!

"#+ "/# <!<: /!/!" ,!& <+*2/" +

;;,?*3 %' 9#-<#+0 /# 3!+#'"& !+# /# 3!+#'"& !+# /# 3!+#'"& !+# /# 3!+#'"& !+#

;;,%'2 "/# !19%&# $!+# *;;: !'1 "/# $/%;1 /!&

;;,%'2 "/# !19%&# $!+# *;;: !'1 "/# $/%;1 /!& &/,'$'&%&"#'"%-3+9#-#'"#+,#%2/"%&&"!<;# &/,'$'&%&"#'"%-3+9#-#'"#+,#%2/"%&&"!<;# &/,'$'&%&"#'"%-3+9#-#'"#+,#%2/"%&&"!<;# &/,'$'&%&"#'"%-3+9#-#'"#+,#%2/"%&&"!<;# !"@=%;2+!-&!'1/#+-<%;%":/!&%-3+9#1 !"@=%;2+!-&!'1/#+-<%;%":/!&%-3+9#1 !"@=%;2+!-&!'1/#+-<%;%":/!&%-3+9#1 !"@=%;2+!-&!'1/#+-<%;%":/!&%-3+9#1/# 3!"%#'" %& 1*# + '#A" ;;,?*3 %' -%1?#<+*!+:0

)H F '9%#, "/#!<9#0' *+"/#+!$"%'%&$!;;#1 +!&"/# 3!"%#'"%&<#%'2"!=#'$!+# <:"/# +-"%-#""%-#!'1 "/#,+%"3#"%"%'&"!'1&1%&3&#1 !$$+1%'2;:

7 5

7 5 #<+*!+: 0 ) #<+*!+: 0 ) #<+*!+: 0 ) #<+*!+: 0 ) 6 5 6 5 6 5 6 5 =!'$/!'

/#"/#+&3#!=%'2I+#!&'#1J #&I /#"/#++#3+"!<;#J #&I