High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16579/2015dismissed

Pooja Devi v. State Of Punjab & ANR

2018-04-17Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath4 pages

!"# #$%&%'(

)* )* )* )* +! #,%-.%'/0 #"%"%'#/ 1& "!"# 2'+!3!'4!'"5#/ #&6'4#'"& 7(8 97 7(8 97 7(8 97 7(8 97 ::7 ::7 ::7 ::7 /#&#'"( 7/7!'+:2.!/5!/.!;4,$!"#;

/"5#6#"%"%'#/ 7/%""!;;2'+!3 ::7 ; ::7 ; ::7 ; ::7 ; 5# 6#"%"%'#/; !<<#=#4<> ! .%'/; /#&%4#'" ,%<<!=# !=!'! :!<!'; 2<<?!<; %&"/%$"&5%!/62/;3#<'=%'="$5#42<#4!&"#;%& ! /!6# ,%$"%. #/ ."5#/ 9!@.% #,% <4=#4 ! $/%.%'!< $!&# !=!%'&" :2<?%'4#/:2.!/;&' 5#/&%&"#/%'<!?-'!'!'0;,%4#*4!"#4 ) 2'4#/ #$"%'& A ABA BA "5# '4%!' #'!< 4#; * /&5/"D"5#8E!'4#$"%' "5#/"#$"%' 5%<4/#' /.#@2!<

#'$#&$";C /&5/"D"5#$"8E!"<%$#"!"%' 2<<?!<; &5%!/62/ /"5#$..%&&%' !<<#=#4$/%.#%'?5%$5!&#&&%'"/%!<?!& 5#<4 ,%4# #&&%' !&# * A 5# 44%"%'!< #&&%'& 24=#; &5%!/62/ $',%$"#4 :2<?%'4#/ :2.!/ / "5#

#'$# $..%""#4 2'4#/ #$"%'A ABA BA "5#!'42'4#/#$"%' "5#$" ,%4#5#//4#/4!"#4*))!'43>"5#/4#/ "5##,#'4!"#;&#'"#'$#4 :2<?%'4#/:2.!/ /.!@%.2.6#/%4 >#!/&3#&%4#&"5#%.6&%"%'

%'# ;B 5# !66#!< 6/# #//#4 3> :2<?%'4#/ :2.!/ 3# /# "5%& 2/"!=!%'&""5#/4#/ $',%$"%'!'4&#'"#'$#4!"#4*))5!&3##' !4.%""#4 !'4 "5# /#$,#/> %'# 5!& 3##' &"!>#4 ,%4# /4#/ 4!"#4 5#6#"%"%'#/5!&.!4#!6/!>#/ /=/!'" $.6#'&!"%'%' "#/.& #$"%'A

"5#4# /%.%'!</$#42/#;

AC /&5/" D"5# /8E 3#%'= ! /!6# ,%$"%. %' "#/.& "5# D,%$"%. $.6#'&!"%' &$5#.#8'"% %#43>"5#,#/'.#'" 2'+!3; #6!/".#'" .#

!%/& !'4 2&"%$#4!"#4 A!&6#/?5%$5A;;B%&"5#.!@%.2.<%.%"

%@#4 /6!>.#'" $.6#'&!"%'""5#/!6#,%$"%.%'$#;"5#!66<%$!"%'

/=/!'" $.6#'&!"%'?!&'"4#$%4#4'#?!>/"5#"5#/;"5#/# /#; "5#6#"%"%'#/5!& %<#4"5%&6#"%"%'%' ?5%$5 !

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

24=#;&5%!/62/;%&#'"%"<#4 /$.6#'&!"%'2'4#/"5#$5#.#$!<<#4"5# D,%$"%.$.6#'&!"%'&$5#.#8

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

%' "5# 6#"%"%'#/ / =/!'" $.6#'&!"%' '<> ' "5# =/2'4 "5!" "5# <#!/'#4 2/";?55!46!&&#4"5#/4#/ $',%$"%'!'4&#'"#'$#;5!&'" 2/"5#/ 6!&&#4"5#/4#/ =/!'" $.6#'&!"%' '.>$'&%4#/#46%'%';"5#6#"%"%'#/$!''"3#4#6/%,#4 "5#!.2'" $.6#'&!"%'"?5%$5&5#%&#'"%"<#4"%'"#/.

"5#/!'4"5#$5#.#!'4!&&2$5"5#/4#/6!&&#43>"5#

9;&5%!/62/%&5#/#3>.4% %#4!'4!4%/#$"%'%&%&&2#4""5# 9; &5%!/62/ " /#$'&%4#/ "5# $!&# "5# 6#"%"%'#/ / "5# =/!'" $.6#'&!"%'2'4#/"5#D,%$"%.$.6#'&!"%'&$5#.#8"%& 2/"5#/4%/#$"#4 "5!""5##'"%/##@#/$%&#&5!<<3#$!//%#42"3>"5#/#&6'4#'"&.2$5<#&&"5#

9; &5%!/62/; / "5# 6!>.#'" $.6#'&!"%' " "5# 6#"%"%'#/; ?%"5%'!6#/%4 "?.'"5& /."5#4!"# /#$#%6" $#/"% %#4$6> "5%&/4#/

) 5##=%&"/>%&4%/#$"#4"&#'4!$6> "5%&/4#/"3"5"5# /#&6'4#'"&!&?#<<!&"5# 9;&5%!/62/ /$.6<%!'$# -::7 0 -::7 0 -::7 0 -::7 0

)* )* )* )* 5#"5#/&6#!G%'=B/#!&'#4 ( #&B 5#"5#/#6/"!3<# ( #&B