← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12081/2017dismissed

Ajmer Singh v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2019-05-21Mr. Justice B.S. Walia11 pages

 

           

 !"#$% & " '"(  

  

)* +      !"#  $ %" " "

!"#$%,-.+/  "%* "

"

0"%)%.#"

1.0"2 333  $ %"& "4 . "2"%-"*  "%( -"% ("  +!( " +"$ % "* +   * % $ "* "  % * " 5(" 6  ++ 

. (7!+ *("(   (  ** ! 4" 5(" 68 ++

-%%- *+/- %"(  %% #""2   % 1 /"!

0"2. ++

 5(" 6 . 4" 2$ % % 44 9+  (4 " ,%4 :+( %+ $/**" /4 2;/"269(  

";1. 1 $" " $"!! + *4 ! " $"!!  :$"$6,%4 %" ($%  :+(  ! + 44

 <(442   ;161 $" + *4 !  :$"$6,% 4 $2 7+ %" ($%  :+(  ! + - /4+ "4** !+*" !  

"2"  " % *  $ "* "% 4$% "+" 5(" 68 ++

=

 7+  "+"  0 >74 % #(*"! ("5("6 ++8

.-%"72%+$" ?"%?(!"+"+"?(!"'+-""+*"-%% 0"7% #$%+?

 ?!7  "%*("*  ** ! = @"  %4+$ % 4$ %-"*  " % % * " <("+ +$"  @ ,% /4 " ! 9#: !+;/"2.#"+"%".) %.%2" .-%" "% -  ""++$"  ,% /4:$"$# 4%+ A (+  :$"$  % 2" = " ! %  4 9( ,% 4 $2.?("(B%" ,%0"2#

#4  !! %" "" ""+  C% !! >+/"+

*  :$"/4 /++/"!

++8 =

9%+!++ % *" % "<( <(4   " **42$ " %  "+ *  -+$"/4$"$ " $D+;/"2 "  % %"<(4  /4$"$* +**+5E@ % 0"2 #"/  :$". 4E99 9""$  @"% )(4.   ,% * " **4+ " % + *  + *("(   4  *" ""+ (72% !! .-+4"+( (4/+ "+" 5("6=+/(442-(+** !4" "%*  :$"%9""$ *"!/+5("68++

,% * " (7!+  $ "* " 5(" 6  

7(- 44 -+  .+%!"-" ""+ 

% 1 /"!   B  +  -%%" % ** ! -   7 44+ ""+/4+ (4 -%% !! +" " ,%4 :+(  @ "+. 0"2.  /-  % * " %/$ <("+%<(4 2$+$" " !%9( +/#(+ :+(   1+% '+2 +". #"+" #%%". ) % %" ($% ++( ! +.+%+;/"2 7$" $D+72 %9,:6;1"! "( (+72%% #""2  % 1 /"!  0"2 ++

.  *" -%%.   ;161 $"+*4 !:$"$6,% 4 $2 7+%" ($%+ +( ! +-/4+ "4** !+*" !    ,%  % "(!. % * " 4+ "*"  5("6++

. "7$44 -+  +(2 0 -/".     - B  % !  ,%"(*  % * " 4+   ==8 . -%% - +* +  /+ "+"  ++

 -%  +"    % "* +   ++ % "*"  -%  *" +   ! %  ,% "*"   % * " - " + /+ "+" 5(" 6  ++ = =

   % $" (+ % % * " ++   *   " $D+ +$"-%%-*""<( "** ! %*   :$"/- %+$"* +72%* "7$%" ($% ++( ! +-%%- " $D+72%9,:  ,%* "%44$+ "+" "  ++= =

 72 4$

= -%%- "+"+ 7%"+4 $-% 8   4+?""#$%/ ;  9+ + %"  ?"" #$%>   -44  % -" *  4+ 72 %

* "-"+!+/+ "+"++ 

.72% 4+$%% +$" 7+%" ($%++( ! + " !+!+(/" -   /4+      4  ++ " 4 ** ! + *" !    ,% * " ++   %44$ % +!4  % -" *  4+ 72 %!

 0 -/". ?"" #$% + %" -%  -" *  -" +!+ /+ "+" ++  

 72 % /  @% % (". 4+#F =  =E=   .-%%."! "+"-"(+/+5("6++

% +/"   7 B $ % (+ -%  +$" %+ 7 +4"+ 44$472% "+" %0$% (" FB-./+5("6 ++ 8

.- "+"+%(+-% +$"++*4 !%+ 7 +4"+ (44 + / +  % !*($+ "+" !2 **42 " !*4 2! + ** !   % (E

 + -" $ $   5*" 7 "

=  "%*4+"4  "! + "+" 4  5("6=  4"  (+72%"2 0(! ) (" /4 *! *"!  0$%" :+(  ++ 

%<(4  -"++%" ($%++( ! +72  ;/"2 74%+ 72    "4! " # F$4(". 9( !+ 7;/"(+"# = %;/"2 1"  !!  . 

 + 9(    4 9!* " +4"+(+" "4! +( !442" $D+ "% *("*  !*4 2! * +"/(+"%"41 /"! *" /++ % ! %+ 7 **" /+ 72 % ;/"2 1"  !! 

,% #F 4+ 72 ?"" #$% + %" - +!+ + % "+"*+72%/ @% % (" 8 ++ 

-(*%4+ 0 -/".0 >74%#(*"! ("-%4 ++$ /4 **4    E  . "$ (  #F   

E

4+"F 9""$  "* F+ / )7 #B"" + %".+ ! %"  4(+$%#F 4+ 72?""#$%+++ = 

.$/ *  %(+  **"    7  +(+72 %9,: + % (+ 4"+%- %-%*(4+!.44%+/$ " 7  %+*4 !6+$"-" + (442"//+ )4/5"

 % +   " F  9""$   "*  F+ >  (*"  "*" +(+(+"

E

        

        

 

    

  

        

       

         



 



!""

#$

$

   

   %  

#  

     

    

   

  

  



    

 !""& !""'

 

(





 

     %   #



    

 

 

      

          

          

         

      

     )



 

*  



 

+   

       



,  

     

  

 

-     

         



 

   

-

        





    

 !""& 

!""'

    

  

  .   /+( #$  

 

0 

   

       

( /+(    

    

   .    

2 

  

  

       

 !""&!""'

    .

+ 



     /+(   

 

   

*     

     3 + 

(

 )

   



(  

       

 

 

   

4  5 !"&6      /+( 



3           

  

    2    

  

+     

 

  2   

 



          

  

  %   #



       

(   

  &'  5  !"&6    

(

     2  





   2   

   %   # 

7& "7 !"&6

+ 

  2

     

        



- *          

      2

  

        2 

      

  

+ 

    

        

   

    



        

 

'7

/

8

++ +      /

) !""&!""'       

  

#$    

  

+9 ( /+(       

 2   : 

(

      

  

 

&'

"& !"&6     2  

 

   : 

)           2

  

  

  2

 

         

  

   :





(      2

      %  

# 

7& "7 !"&6

9+ +     2

   

  2       



   

,% * " <(+  % +!4



=6  4+72%!-%%-+!+4 $-%?""

#$%>   8   

+++  4 #F 2  % 7  "! "+"  0 >74 % #(*"!  (". 5("6+6 ++

+8

.%* "

4+%-"* 2.  "7$44 -+  +(2 /- ** !4"5("68++

F"+ (4 "%* " +% !4"42 (+(+-"44 -+  .%%"- "  +2 !4""4  %* "

 ,%  "! + *4 % 7 /%!42 ** + 72 4"+ #"

 1.  % $" (+ % % +$" -%% % * " * ++ %7 -%%%-

"+** !-  " $D++$".%!-<("+%" ($%++(  ! ++- " $D+72%9,:

 " /".*"2" "7$ 44 -+    +(2 - " + /+ "+" 5(" 6  ++ = =

  ,% "+"  "   - *+  % $" (+ % % * "++ * %"<(<(4   "7$** +  % *    :$"  /-  % +$" * + 72 % * "   7$ " $D+  ,% * " %44$+ "+" "   5(" 6  ++ = =

 72 -2   

=

.-%%- "+"+ 7%"+4 $-% 8  4+?""#$%/ ;  9++ %" ,% "+-" *  -" +!+ /+ "+" ++  

 72 % /  @% % (" ,%* "++ %44$%+!4 % -" *   0 -/".  ! -" *  4+ 72 !4"42 (+ ++-" +++4 $-% 8 +!

 7+++%2" /+5("6++

+ % * " %" -" 44 -+     "!  "! "+" *+720 >74%#(*"! ("?""#$%> 0 >74% #(*"!  (" +++ ?"" #$%> #F 4 $ -% %"  + !42"F 9""$  "* F+ >(*" = 

 72% 4+$%%+!+(/"2 (4+ 

"2%4 (" *442 +$"  $"$ %" ($% * + 4"$ ! + -% ( % **" /4  % 9,: + ;1  ,% ++ -%  %+ 7+!+%2"   -"$/  ** "(2 4"  7 +(+72%9,:- %+%/(42

 % ++ 4"$ % . 44 % +/$ " 7   % +*4 !6+$"-" + (442"//+

,%* "4% ($%<(4 +%-" +(+72 %9,:% "!* "+-%%+" $/ "F 9""$  "* F+ >(*".7(%!- (4+ $/ "$% %* " 4!7$44 -+  "/7(% 4! %* " "7$44 -+  +(2*" %2"

. " -%% % * " 4+   ==8 . -%" +" -"(+ %"* + ++%"*"  % * "

 ("(   % +" . % "*"  4+ 72 % * "-+!+72%"* +/+ "+"++= =

 -%4!B$" " %"( (+72%% #""2  % 1 /"!  0"2. ++

 ,% + "   "+" -%44$+72-2 

= .-%%-4(77+ " %"$-% 8 .4+?""#$%/ ; 

9+ + %"  ,% + -" *  - +!+   

0 -/".%* "++ %44$%+!4 %-"*  9 42 %7 "! "+"++

+

5("6+6 "*/42%%* "- B(* " !% 4(!7" + 4+ % *" -" *   2.  4!$ "4  "4* /2" " !%+ *$ "! "+">72 0 >74%#(*"! ("% % -% -"/$4+%+ %44$+ % +!4  %" -" *   ,% * " ++   **" % 0 >74 % #(*"!  (" $ % +!4  % -" *   % 2"   " " % !"  B " ("   2 *" +$  "!  % "! "+" ++ 

 + 8

. *+ 72 0 >74 % #(*"!  ("  % #F 4+ 72 ?""#$%+ %"+ 4+%-"*  42 "4*

4   /2"2.  = ,%* ">%  "+ %/$ **" %+0 >74%#(*"! (" " "%!"%/$+ 2 *" +$  "!  "+"  0 >74 % #(*"!  (" ++ 

 + 8

. % * "    4+   B "4  72 -2 %*"-"*  ,%-"*  4+72%* " %72+42+4%4   ( %* "%/$+ *+ %*    "

8  "+$42 +$ !"%-"* .%! +!+  ' $ %"(

  )* " % B%(" %%"*B$6" +

G6  %%""* "74

G6