Gopi Ram v. Union Of India & ORS
CWP No. 17312 of 2014 2024:PHHC:052666-DB -1-
!" # $ % ! "# $$%
&$$ "# $ $$ $ & ' (%(%"% % ) *+" *) % ,% &-. * ,% /010%1 %%** %% -.
"*0 $"/ %%% / ****0%)% 1"*% " 1"*%" 230 1"*% / * "* 4 0 %% %"*/ "* % " %%% ,% %* 05"% %
/0%- .,/" *)+% %( %7 %) 8-.,9:) 1%/0 % ;- 1 < 4 "% 0 5"% 2
6
) 1%% 1 %** /0% /%-.,
CWP No. 17312 of 2014 2024:PHHC:052666-DB -2-
$ **0 % " / % +" 1 1% %
/*0%1 % /0%-., 41)= 1%<" +*-
*> 6 ?
)
) 1% % 1 1 %* /
/* % /0 % -., % 1 % 4% +" <" ) % 5" /*0 5" / ) %) **% 1 1 /% *0 1%%% " ,%)% 1= "
% " *% 1% ,% 1 ** % $ - . "*+ / - %;
) "
&$$ 4 1 % % - . ""*
*
@ ;
* * # - .
4 1
%"/ =+ *7+ A: 6 6@ 1"% % = 1% 2
@ - %
5"*0 % ) % 1 "%
% =.*% 4*0 % 1$ & = 1@2 6 " % ") % % % ""**0 % ; +" ;
* % / 1 . + " ( + " ( 6 @@ 6 6 ) *0 $%% %/ 1 1% * % * *"
)
CWP No. 17312 of 2014 2024:PHHC:052666-DB -3-
1
*61 ,% )%")"/ %%%
* 0 @ 6 1% % 1 ) %1) 1 % 1%" 0 3
6 ,%
"/ % % % 5" % -;+ **1 % " "**0**
* 20 /"% 5"1 " % ,% %"/ %%1 /0%- .$ " BB37% /C-.$D: % "*- %$ - .
,%- .
$ %/ - %*)% * 1 E"*0)@ ,% "*- %$ - .
% ""%01"* / /0% *1 % ,%* -.$" &
! " #$ % "" " " " &' ( "
& ) * & ) * #' &
$ %
" + &
%& "
" $( %
,# )
(( %
" + & " " &%-
CWP No. 17312 of 2014 2024:PHHC:052666-DB -4- "&"
&%'
& "
. ( " + &
% /
" $ ) 0 ( " &
% 1 (
/"&0
"&
% " ( " & (
&( "++ %
% &%- (
" &
&%'$ & / !
/ ( " ( " &
/ & 0
" / % /
%
% & ) * " ( "1 "" "
& 0(
2
"
" & ) * %" 0( "
&
"
/ &' 0( ( " &
%
%
) "& ) * 0( " &
% % " & ) *
& ( "
%
. ( "
( "
& ) * /
%3& % ( & & ) * " & "&( "( 0 "
"
4" )&0
) * ) / + ,
( &%'
&
%
% & )
CWP No. 17312 of 2014 2024:PHHC:052666-DB -5- * "
"++ /
&5 " )&0
) * ) /& / +
" ( "&
#' 2" % %
/ " 0
% 2
" (/ ( " $ 6
"
% " "
&
7 % & 8 %
/
!
% % / %
) *
" & "&( "(
$ "") "" % 9& ( "
& &%'!
& % %
"
" 0
% :
% "
%
) *
&
( ( %& %( " & ,%") % - 1%% *0 0 * "*/**1 20 " % % * %0"***%% ,%
"% "/ % % %) / **) "%
1"
% = 4%*/ " 0)%1)%1%1%" 0
6 @ ,% % = % +" % ) 1%% *" &
CWP No. 17312 of 2014 2024:PHHC:052666-DB -6-
") * &2)*) & $ ( 222 & &
., *;*22,6 :<= $.,92:2., .* =, .=,: ., $.!=:2., .* ,2,= >=) =,6)6==,: ),9 ,.: ?=2,6 =@;2 =9 :. = A= 2, :<= == A= " B 4/ &
"" " 2)* " 4 )&#' .C++C5= D9
4 E ,% "/ % % 0
6)% /0 % 0 6 6 3
61"*F /0 %
6)1%%" & :( " "4 4 B 4
% ( "
& & 8
0
"
)&#' )*2 CC5B
%$ 4C/) <, )2 <C5B+ C!)22 C
4C5++C 4 <C++C5C=2D2C 4 E ,% "% "/ % % 1 /0 0)%"* %/ % 3
6% %/ "*/0 0 -.$) %1 * ""
20 ,% % "% "/ % "* +*"7:%-.- "* )%%1 / *11%%%%%" "* 7:%1 5" "*** % * %%+
; %
"%0 % % ) %1) %
"/ %5"/%)%
CWP No. 17312 of 2014 2024:PHHC:052666-DB -7- /0 % +
; 1 1%" <" % 1
%%
$"/ %% % * * %"% % *10 % "* 0 *0 %-.-"% 4 * " @%-.-)2 % +%%- 6
@
* 41) % - . ; % %1 " ,% "/ % % 1 ) % / / " 2 0 % "*** % % 5" ,% - . +
; % " 0% @
6% % $ "/ % "
@ 0 %) %
%) %) %
* % * "/
* %% )%")%1*10 " 1%%* /%% % ""
***
,% "/ % *)%%
* 1*10 %%"
= 1% % *0 0 0 1% % %
)%
%%" *) &- 0;)1% = "
% * ,% - . ;*
<%%
*0 "* % "* " % -.-@)1%%5"205"*0 ;% 1 /0 % %"% %
CWP No. 17312 of 2014 2024:PHHC:052666-DB -8- " * @
@
) 1%% 1 </0 % - .45"*
% % % *0/ "
20 $1 * "%% **% %/ 0 /0%(; "* 20 ,% "/ %%- .,/" *)G*=) **1 )1%%
*0"* 1 **" 0" 0 201%*% 1 %*)/%
*20 /0 " 0 "* *" @ 0 ,% - . ,/" * G*= % * <" /0 G*4%+" % !
,-> B "H > 36
*/%+*"4%+" ,% "/ % -.,) +% % % 1 "**0 % ;- % / % 1%" %"* %1 "*%
) " *
% &# $ "/ %%% 1 */*) /*% ="/ * % % $"%"/ %% % %
""
%* *0* 30)1%% % 10 "* ."%"/ % % 1 % 1% 5"
CWP No. 17312 of 2014 2024:PHHC:052666-DB -9- ) % * % / @ 09
*0 $"/ %-.,%%*0<% % ,% %**%1 "/ % "* "* %- .)@ 7 :) % %
* 2 0 %1)%) *0 ) " "0% % - "* @7:)
"* % / 1% %
* 0 "* @ 0 5"*0 /") ) %
1 % 1)%) /" /** %*
1)%) 01%% "* %-. %@0 /" = % /* $ "% "/ % % * ;-
01% %%*0/ 0 $ % %)%1%C."&" " ( " " % 3& &
D ,%")@0 /" %-.,%%*0<%*
H% %"/ %<" //0%
CWP No. 17312 of 2014 2024:PHHC:052666-DB -10- $ " -$3 +3)4 9/*%"
+"%*" & 5 .
"&
"
"
"
" ((
(
&
((
( &
"( ((
%
(
&
:
( "
((
(
% " (( %
"
&
"&
"
(( : " $ .""
'
& ((
& %/ F ((
%
F D
&
""
3& %(& %" ""
" (( / &
&
((
"0
""
" (( 2"0
%
/
& &
%
""
3&
/
(( &
% &
"
"&( "
0 & & & .&"
( "
0 ((
" (
"9 2 & "
" %"
&
E 2 $ H > @@ & " 7
7 :+A:)( /04%+"% %* % *$ >0 %"11% % 0 ,% +"
CWP No. 17312 of 2014 2024:PHHC:052666-DB -11- %% 10 1**
* %2 0 /" 1 % / %0
*2 0 %*" &
1 )" )(0 $&F -&/
( &
( (
"
((
3& % (& "(
& *&/
(
& )&& 41 ! 3& %
" ' " (
( 3& "
"(
< /! ( ( + "
: ! & "/%&
(( &
3&
( %")(0$& < /""
&"! ""
&" ( /! ( (
+ "3& "
2 &
& /
(
(
(
(3& "
"
+ "(&( " (
%"
/
( ( " ( %
& " "&
% ( &
( ' " ( ""
*&/ & "( $()& "
" %
(
&( ( "
0 D&"& D ! , 11/ / / 1+/ " / 1B " /
! &
( + "
"
(
" 4
D
! D ! , 15/ 1+/ 1B/ 1/ 4/ 4/
CWP No. 17312 of 2014 2024:PHHC:052666-DB -12- /5/+ 1/ " / "
( " 4
/&
( 5 "
2"
(
/
( 1 "
5F "
* "
/
! %
%
"
( " + " (&( " (
%"
/ " ( "B / &% (( ! ,
"
( % ( ' " " E @ ,%A( %4 9/*%"
+" # $%-$6+ )%*% % 0 -*7:7: 7:% + " $ % *1 %"* % 4 9/*%"
+" % %*" & B : (
&((
""
( (
) " & + " !
& ""
(
:
(
""
=&
9( "?
F=&
2
, " & &+ &5 (
%
% &%-
$ ( A222 2
" ( $ ( A222
(( '
("(
/
D
" &51 ; & 6
"
& /
CWP No. 17312 of 2014 2024:PHHC:052666-DB -13-
F ""
%"(
?& & (
% "
( "
(
:% & &51 (
"
2"
3&
&& ""
& (
" ( " &( & (
6
( % & (
&
& 5 "
( " (
6
( " ( 3& "
" &
" (
"6
%(
% & + (
" 6
&+%
%
( (
" ( 3& "
"
+ & 51(
"(
" 6
& + D
" " ( & ( "(
(&(
" G %&/ / ( " (
% & 6
&
(
: H& / 1B
%3&
""
"& "
%
)&& +/ 11/
%3&
%& D )&& +/ 11
&
/ H& / 1B3& & "
& :
3& %
/
/
(
% 6
((/
)
" " $ & :
3& "
%
(
%&)
:
( /
CWP No. 17312 of 2014 2024:PHHC:052666-DB -14-
(
E 6 $ & ! ' $A @67: " </ I 40 63)."**( %%+"%*" & 2
&( & (
I & &I
& % 6
/ %"
(-&
"" /
&
(( &# & (( %
" &
:"
"
((
% " 6
( & &((
A 2"
& (
( " %" &
&
" (( E 3 $ (" ! '-$667+:) 1%*" & 5 : (
5
( (( ((& %
( (
" & 5 : "
) 9
"
(
((& "% &
/ & & "
(
&% ( (
& & %% &(
& 5" ) 2 &%
J :
< % - F
&( & ((
& 5") /
CWP No. 17312 of 2014 2024:PHHC:052666-DB -15-
( "
.
J J
%
E $ " A1. $J@ 2*%4%+"/%%"* /" " "* /0%+
;%1 /0%
,%* " & + . (&
"! F $ "
"
/
9
% " $ )$$/&
/ 3& "
&
&( "! F J ( " " &) &
"
/ 1 $& + '3& "
&J <
% :! F
& :
(
% & ( &
"
9
& %%% ( /
! ( ) "
/ &
&
" " 2 & % 3& %
!
% "
"
" )
$( <
0( "
(
%"
& % ( :
%0 &
& % " %
J? & J
/& "&"
&( "
3&
" "(
2 &
"" & (
(
)
$( / B & %
CWP No. 17312 of 2014 2024:PHHC:052666-DB -16-
" '3& "
( :
(
! &
"
"" /%&
"3& " / / + "
B
% ( % F'3& " F < ( 9
!
& "
( " / &
( F &
" 9
% (
" ) ) ) & )
% % /
& : ( F
(&
&
" (" (
) (&
% "
(
" &(
E
-*=%%5"/*% % %/ %/0
*0 "* 7:% * "0"* ;-. 1"*/
5" * "* )1%%" & C
)& ( & 8
K :
& (
"
& " % % %
& (/ ( "( (
"
&
"
& (
"
& 5 (
/
"
( &%- ) ) ( " %
& & % 0
% & +* +"% +
"%0 "%% *$ " ;% $ - -**" % ,%
* +" * - % ;*
F%
CWP No. 17312 of 2014 2024:PHHC:052666-DB -17- . ) % * 5"% %
%** / / % 1% % "/& 7: % - **" %-1% %/ 7: - % 1 5" %
/*% 7: - % 1 5" "*** % % * +
; +
; , / " 1% % * 1% 6%- "*
,%") % +
; "* 7: % %
**" %-)1%%/ %1 5" % /*% "*** % % * % / " **0 " "% '*0 /" 1% "*** % * ) % /%/0%+
;1%"%/ 5" G 1 % % % % 05"/ % "*** % ** )%
6" /*** H* % -.$7"
:%;15" =
* 01%% " "* $ %%% %/ 0"% 6 6 3
6 0 ,% %/ % 01% % 1= %%
- -.$7"
:) %/ )% 1"*/ @ 0)%**%
*20 ,% 0*
CWP No. 17312 of 2014 2024:PHHC:052666-DB -18- ,%+"* %%
*0 @ 61% %611
% *0 % 0 1 * % % % / % 6 $ % %+")"* % / % *
%% %
. % "*%<" )1%%%/ 5" % /)
% % / * % "* % 1%% % 1% % ; %"* / @0 0"*7/%-.$ : E"*0)@) *1 * " " 2 0%-.$ 1%
*/**1 "0" 20 %0%/ * % + * $ " % )1%%/ % = )/ %/ 20 /*%
" 5"*0 H1"* )%)*= % 0 "0% "
20 %/ 1%% % *0 / /" B 0 (" % %% %*0/ % 1 %% % %% " % 0)1%*% /
CWP No. 17312 of 2014 2024:PHHC:052666-DB -19- *%/
*20% "
* 0 % %% *" /1%" 0 %*/04 9/*%" +" ") 7"
:
,% 1 5" / %
" 1 %%
*0)% 1**1/ "** 01* $ 1%)% / 15"/ %
2 ,%5" 11%%%%/
% /20K @ $ % %+" 1%%% */* % %
% % +" /**0 1% %5" * % % %
*0 0/"% 1%*%*%%/ *** 0% "* 7:%"* %* %%+
;"* %%% )%1"*/ *** 5" */ %1 "" 4 %% / 5"%)%1"*/ *"**
* % "** % 23 0 ,% /0%-.," /* $%* % " % *0* %"* %%
6*" / %
/% / /0 1%1
% %/ % %
CWP No. 17312 of 2014 2024:PHHC:052666-DB -20- %)% /0%-.," / " /* *1 % 6 $ 1%/ = % * *=10%." *%% )1
% %-.,% % # $ * % % % %%-. % "
% 23 0 - *0) % %** / *"* /0 **"* %*0 %1"*/ * %% %230 >*0%**/ % % % / %%"**0
%"% " ,% )%1)%**/ "**0*"* 1%** %%
* 23 0 ,% % */ %** */ % " % "0 " 1%% % *0 %
> 1"*/ 0/* % " % %
%%+"/**0 *<"1"*)%)/ 1%5"**0/0 1 % 3 ,% %** / " 1% " 1=/0% -" %/" 1%% %/ */%+" ,% %** =*/* %"
1%%%% % * %% -" % %** / *0 /"% %/ 0
CWP No. 17312 of 2014 2024:PHHC:052666-DB -21- ,%1 *0
-**
* %**
>
$%
&$$ '
$ $ ! H%% = B LB> H%% /* LB>