High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/1036/2018allowed

Gurmeet Singh v. Financial Commissioner Appeals Punjab & ORS

2019-01-08Mr. Justice Inderjit Singh4 pages

! !"# $%&' ()* +&,-.(

/#&# 0" 122# )&34 (#

5#2 # #$ %2-.()1 " (22"62

# 7"-"()1###1 "+)&34) #

+8)1 "

' (# 22" # 2". "

( 2" (8#,4'#2

122" # 8#&43" 3&#9"2 #

52" #: "

(# 22 "( (# & "(.. (

19& 6 2## 4' ( 0" )&34)(.()8(4'("#(#4 , (!#" " )-&:#-(4) (. &( "(#4##& (2

)8( (#4##4'-&:(,-.(((2 # "# 2 8(;,2.8(""',& ) ;6) " ("#".("##(

<#("

(2 ( 2 8# 22 # =,4

4' ( !#" " )-&:#-(4 (. (#22 ,4'

(# 4 3" 4' ( ) 0 >2& !# ) 0 >2&) 4& ( # 2 ) ( 0" 122# ) &346#2

(# , ( "# 4": (

#,2 ## #2

( ( 2 # "# 2 8 (;,2. 8( ( ""' , & ) ;6) 8("(#( "(#4##& ?"

#((# "#'(#4##& (#()8( #"# (#4 (,'+&-.( (2 #"

') (##( "#

)8("(#, ( ' #&4#@& ( 22 , (2 # =,4

<'"#)(##( "(#4"

,2 &4'(, ( 4 ( ( 2 *

4' 2 #. ( "

,2 &. 5"2# ( 4 22 # 19& 6*

?) ( .( ( 4 ) "

# ( ( , 2## 4' ( 0" ) &34) " #&##(#)8("((:2"#&4#@& ( 22 , ( 2 # =,4) " 4 :

(", (2 ( #(#( "

#(8((22" "

#"# :( ?)( )"

#((

" #&### 4##

( (()"

###

((2 8#4"'8#&#.(,8("((#4 & 4 ,2 8() 8("( ( &.( ( (# 4 "

,2 &. (#,4&"#("

&" (2 )8("( (#.('4: "

4'(0"

122# )&34)8(2##.( ?)( 8) "

& #2&("((##( "##&4#@&

( 22 , (2 #=,4&((( "2# 19&6* "("

,2 &. (##( 8"&# "4'(4 (#8#(, ( (2 <("

#(#&4,## #,4'("

( 2#(8((###").

( &.((,2&.

<##22 # 8(("#8("( 4: "

( 8("("# #: 8(. (22" #&4,4'" 22 ,

(2 # =,4 1'#&4#@&#(22 , " (2 # =,4" 4: "

&. ( 22 ,) ( &.( ,' 4 .

. & (# , #,###("#,'4 <8 (4 2 # 8)(, 2## 4' ( 0" ) &34) (.() # #&#4 # ( #, # 4# &2 #&4#@& #) 8("( 22 4 4 ( 2 # 8

"#8("((4#&2 ) (( ( 2 # 8 # ( 4 () ( & &' (# 2 A#, ((#"

,2 &(#( "#(

)8("(#2 (2##. ( ) 8("( #( & ( 4 : "

4' ( 0" )&34

<8 (4 )(82 # 8

B(,2&. 19&6 2## 4' ( 0" 122# ) &346#2

# (4'##

##((#8 & ''"

(#&4#@&"

&" (=,4 4 : "

4'("

,2&( ' , #,##

=,4

#8( &#'.('#&4#@&)8("(,' (:2")8("(8 &4.

. & , #,## (=,4)"4.2##4 ("

,2&( '

#28

!"#$%&'

((#2:.;# $ C# ((52 4$