← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13738/2023dismissed

Keshav Gupta v. Union Of India And Others

2023-07-25The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Arun Palli6 pages

CWP-13738-2023 -1- 

      

 

 !"#$ %% & '&# () & % *$  *+ , -./01* 2(34)1*+')3,+-1*2,+5,)162(34)1 , -./01* 2(34)1+*(-+00) & & *7&"85+!5& $& & +&#"53&"! #85( )59:  3;+&&5+!5& &$ <<<<

    &8 

+=#& >&& +$$85&?8:588;  

4  $  9 8 9:   $&5 ;    $&  9 @    1?&? #&  &   $#&$  $$&    211  

=@  4  $&  8   $ $&:? &   88;?&8 A ;&  &&& & B# ?   @$#? &@ 

+=#&   &#? @89:&$- 5; &9:5   &B# @ 9:   $& 

+=#&  &#? @8 &$-  98D  ;&  @@# &?   &$  &   #&    $& ?  "&813?&:&@2

CWP-13738-2023 -21&1=@

&) )#4 8?:D :  & ;& && & & ;     ,E98 #& @: @       &#@ 9#!#&  $&? &$ F

4  $&  $$8 &   211 

=@ #&   "&8 ?&:

 , 8 $$&    211

 =@   "&8 ?&: 5 ;   ; 8 

    &#8  ;   ; 8& 



5 $$8& ? ?&:&@ "&81@88:>&3 13 4 &B#; &79: # & @:!@@#  8&8: ?    !;  8# 5 $? -     )&@ /& #&211

5 ?&:5;   ;@9: @;@!8989: 211+$=/&  @ 211 

=@5;#898 88 &@ @211

=@5&B# & ??&:$&@98 4 $&9???&!9: @@# 9 8 $ 0&#8& $&#9@  $&  !&8: @  ?&:  "&8  $$8 & $$&?    211  =@

 )   211

+!=@

;885 $$&"&8?&:  )8:&8& 211 +!=@ &#8

  &8H @>#? & ?  ?&:9:$$8:?

0&#8#9@ 

CWP-13738-2023 -3-  @> #&&!&8:5;  @:9$&@ 9&&5 &&5 &$@:9&&  $&#& 13?&:

4 #9@@9:8&#8& $&  9 ! @8: $$ 9: 8& #8 &   &$5 ; #9@ !;&8!8# )&@/& #& 211

5;  ;@!89888  

5&$#98 C

588 ;& ;&  ?&:88#$ =@&@9:$&  @211 =@5;#8&@# ?;#8 9   @ &   211 +! =@5   &B# &  ??&:;9& ,#9@  ;;88 ;  >;8? $& @5 $$8& 211

=@

5#58#? $&5  9 $&@   ?  ?&: &   8&  211

+!&#85 # &; !;@#&@:  =@$&8@$8&;    /# *#8 $#98     )&@ /& #&  211

5 !&7 8@ $&  ! &8&#8& $&8? 4 &8!$&8# )&@/& #& 211

5$& 9?: ? ?&:  88;?  

!"#$# %"

#$"  # &% '$ '$(( & )# *$(&( &    +,  # -'$  "#. %   /0$"1 2324 ,)$" $ "5 '$(( & !$"( "#

CWP-13738-2023 -4- %(()$" %)$"/#*"#12324 ,)$" $ "6 7.% % !

 "

 !  

'$(( &"

 $"#68

6&@  $&#8    &5   !     # &5 ;88  !5  &@ 88   #     ?&:@!898 211+$=#&5;  # 211



=@5;#898 88&@ @ 211

 =@5   &B# &  ?  ?&:;#89& 1!8:5  @> 8&  $&9?;88;& @ ?&: "&85; 8@>? &@!898 211+$=/&    @  $$8:? & 211 

 =@5 5    !?5$$8& &@& ? ?&:&@ "&813&8&211

=@ &#8

5  

5;   9&79:  # & @:5! @$#?@@#  I 1!8:5!; &5  $&   "&8 ?&: ; @ 9: @ #  !&$$&9&&  ?#? 9 @   & #?   ; > & ;   &8H    ;#89989@ )#  

0&#8&9  $& !&8:  & 8#    /& #& &8?  211

 ;& & 9:   #&      

       

 G 

5   

    8@ $& && ??&:;&75;  

CWP-13738-2023 -5-  9 #$ 8 9:   3#$&@ #& ! && 

&&&3$80!+$$8 - GCGJ

 4  &B#&@  >?    ?&:    9 @9:# 8?211 =@ 98&$&$8# @#9&#8  #&9# ?&: @88?#$ &@& 211 =@ $& 9& ? ?&:  #&    &  #&@:  &    88   5 ?? ?&:9; =@$& ;#8 !8: 8     )   $&:& @ 9:   $&       ?5  ;#8 $  &E 9=  ;#8 #&?  & #  ;88   ?  & ?&:5 ;    $88: 9 $& 9 9:   &$ ! 8#     )&@ /& #&  211

5 ;     #&  88? 4 #&

 #$& 9&! #&  A&8 &$  &#8&#?!&?@ ! 9&8:#&@8:$$888   :  9 8# 9:   #& & $&@9&@& 8 4  #& &   # & @# #&   @!8 &#8&&# ?!&? @ &  && & @    ?&#  B#: & :@$ :

  & &:88 !9 $&!B#8&@8!8$8:?8 9: #&@8:  &8: @$8@?   $#8$&&99: &#8&&#    @   :  $#&:   

CWP-13738-2023 -6- @ $& 5  &&5   !8?   &#8 & &#  9 $&@  9 @    ?&#  @$8 :@$ : & B#:  &9: &&?   &#8  & @?8  ) >?   !;5   #& &8 #$       3#$&@ #&     

             I C 3#$$ 3 CCD  

            

I C  3 CC            !" 

3 I F 

&;  &$58&#8&  $& 8 &8:      # !8!    $ B#&8:!&9:  #&

  #$&5;   9&@9: 3#$&@#&  )   &#@5 ;    : &  & $?&$&@ $& ?  ?&: ? G 9?@&8@

*+')3,+-1*2,+ ,)162(34)1  +*(-+00) 2("1 2#8:

5

7   &$>?J& KJ-   &&$&98 KJ-