← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/30266/2024dismissed

Avtar Singh And Another v. State Of Punjab

2024-08-29Ms. Justice Kirti Singh16 pages

 1

  



      !  

 "#"$%"&'()!!  $'('*(+"&'(),!!  

         

  ! 

 

        

  ! 

 

         

   )  - ./!/0/        !" #   !  $   !   %&  '(()*+,,(+*+-   .   !   %&  '(()*)/0 )*-1*(+*+- 



2 3#   #     !  !

   44444 0/1!  !

..

 

.  

!     .       5 .  .   . 6 7  .    %67&

 2

9/   *,*++*+-  ! )+- )+) -+/ )-7' #38 *)+  *:*-+*+-  ! )*1 )+0 )+) 9-1 9-:7'%! )*1

& 

!  3  3!  % & +               !  -)1 ''       ! 5       67 )    ; #  

    

   !  5   *)*1+*+- - !! ! 5    !       !  ! 33 8 9+

 99*++*+-   ! )+0 )+) 9-1 9-:7'  !678 9/   *,*++*+-  ! )+- )+) -+/ )- 7'

!  3 "     

< 5    

 .  

   #  

 

% & 

% &  

% & # 

 $  

   3

 .  $ " 

 8  

   3

 2   3!   

"

=  !  5"

  

 > . 

 !

>  . 

  

   3

 "

5 !

!  

    

 2 5           

2

  

5 

!

      

 

 2    "   5    2    "     5   ?3@ 

 3

  5 "

=  "   

   

   5     "

=   !

    .  

  

     8   

 "      "

.

  !

5 !5 ?  

 "          

   5    

 .  "    

 .   #  

 .  "    

  

  

   

# 

 $  

. " !=  

 !.            9+

      "

  

   5 2    !

5 !5 ?  

!



  

5 .  

 5   



"   

"

 

    "

   

 

"   2   .  

 ."   

"

  "

  

"   

.     

" .@     .5 

5!. " ! .2 !

      !

>   .  

       !

'  3  . 

"

. 

  

   5   

  

   

  # 

  "  5 " "  "

  !

   

"  .     

 5  . "  

 "

   .      !   ." != "

    "  A  

 != 

      !

   

= 

#  . 

            "    

 4

    8A 5  */*++*+-  !

  B  ( ( " %

& ?  

     

       $

  3!  . !

   '  3  "

    . 0 3    ! ! 

      ! !! ! "   .   "  C 9,9 ''"!

D8 9/:C?C+*+- $ " "     "

. ,  "   5 

!    !  5   "       5"  

!     5 -       9 + ) 0 , .    , D8 $3$C*0C+*+-C#  

"     "

 +       "    5 

!         5 "    

!      5 9 

    5 +.   @   "

 !C)*17'"

*:*-+*+-!!  

< 5 . 

 



 

#  

 "   +,*)+*+-   "      5 7    @!  7  

       !. " !

   .

  

 < 5   .  

 3  " !

   .

 

!=!

"!

  .

  

# 

 "  

  !C)*17' 

!! !

 

 5

/ @     .  67 9/   *,*++*+- C )+-  )+)  -+/  )- 7'    3  "       $ " 

C 8  

% !

  & . 

C $= 

   

 C  8   

   8   

 C   

     3

  3!      .        

 C   

 C  3  "

  ( E7

  !   "

=  

5 

 .  "          

 3

 !5 ?  

      *)++*+- @  *,*++*+-!5? 

 "

=  . $ "  

   8   

     3

  . 

 $=

!

 



8  

8  

 

  

3

   "

=

  C .5

   9+ >!

!=  

= "  !.    "

$ " 

"

  

   

 8 

"

 

    .  

   $= 

 "

      8  

 

"

  

  . "

"

=   

.5

F  7 $ " 

"

55    .  ."

=    .5

   . .   =  !" 

   .5    

 !.    2   $ " 

 

"  .5  $ " 

!

.

" "

 

.5    . . 

 



"  "

 .5

  8 

!



.  .  . 

 

" "

 6

 .5

. "

 .5 

 .    5 

"   

"



!= 



   



     .5  !

 #  

 5      

   .   '   3    . F  "!.

"  .        $ " 

. 

  "  '   3   "

   .5  !

 #  

$ " 

 

" "

 . !=   . 



"

   . 

=   = .    ?(0:?(0-**      5 . 5      2  $ " 

 .  

   "5  .   

 "  " G D 9/,C?C+*+-      

"    "

-  5 9 +     )   -    "    5 

!        5"  

! 

!

  

      .    D

9//C?C+*+-     #  

 "      "

)  5 9    + )  "  5

!     

  5 "    

!  !

  

    .   D 9/:C?C+*+-   

"    "

- 

    "  5

!       5"  

!  !



   .   H  !!  $ "  

   

   8   

" 9:*)+*+- !! . 

" *,*-+*+-!!   !

 "   

 7

!.   !C+*97'"

9:*)+*+-@  !



   !

   

 !! "

    '

 1   !  C -)1 ''   5     

   ! 5 " . 5 '

 D 

 ! '

     *-*,+*+- : D      !

    .  5        ! 

! !  !        #3 8 9+   99*++*+- "           "   5   

!    !   !  )+0  )+)  9-1  9-: 7'     ! "       !

(!! "   5 

!  

!  +.

!! !  

! !

! )*17'  !     #38 )+

 *:*-+*+- 8 +"

 

 67  !

       58 9" ! "

  (      " =      7 58 +" ! "

 (    7 5 97 58 )"     

 A   5  7 5 8  - "     A  !  

  .

" !

.   8 +  . 5   

  !

# 

   "   .  ! )+) 7' !! 67! !

   ! (!          7 

5    

 8

    

!      5 "      5   

! ! )+0 )+) 9-1 9-:7' 9* D    !

  !

    !

    "

    !   "

 

"     !

   5 " 

    !         !

(!!  #  

 "   

"  7    !

  58 9     

%  $ " 

!

  &"

!

 5 ! )*17'"

!

."   .!

 ! )+07'  " 99

.   5 > .'

 !   

            





  H 99 D  !

  !

    !

     .  5        .     "     

       !

!  ! 5    D   !

       !

   .     *,*++*+- 9+** "  5 !! 

 !  

;  5 !! (    !=  $ "  

  

    !    5      

 " ..  5    

  *,*++*+-  "

  "           

 ! 2  ! 5     

 9

9+ 7          5     !

      !

    !!   !. 

    !       $ "  

  '   5  !!

 =

.  !

!  !    !    

.     5 B  . '

   E!"  

 #  $% $232(45 66"45'! , '7  4$2#2(8'*9'7/. $5!'! '7&"+2&"&'(,!!:! 9)   . . 5   !

        !

 9- 7 #

 & ! '(  )

* '+,*   -  '

 ? !

. "

 !

   !   ! 5 !



!

 ! !

  

5  !  

  !   !! ! ! 90 B  . '

   E!"  

  #   $%  $232(45 66"45 '! ,  '7  4$2#2(8 '*9 '7 /.

$5!'! '7&"+2&"&'(,!!: 

  ( E9+2  "    ! -)1 ''.5

! 5 "  !    A!  !  5  

 5   '

    .

!  $

// ! # 

  0 

 '++*-1,=   '

 . '

?   

 10

E) #   

    ! 5  I 

" !

 A! !

 !   !  .  . !

@     5 !

    !      8

   !

"               !

A  !    .    "  5   !

 ! 

" 

"55 .! !F  !.     !!       !5  

 .5  !

   5 !   !   .    .

 "5 !

 " !!. !"   

   2      !     ! !

       .

   !.      !

 !  !    

"     ! .A . -   .      !   "

 .5     !

  .5   !   ! 

"  .

5

  A       !    5 2 !

  

%&F    !

  = . 

5      !!      5     .      !!      !

!      !   !!  %&          "   . "          !

   

    "

 "  !

    .     %!& F     A!        !     !! 5

 

  

 "5 .!! !

   !

 

 11

% &6

5  ! 

"5!

   

5    .        

    !

    .            .

          !     .  !

       !!         H 9) 7 %  2# " !

  3        %+*9*& 9- '' -:,  3$     =     "

? !

'

 

"   !  A.  !

!       !! 2 '



E:J7   '



   .

5   "   K

 3! 45    ++5    ++' *6 5 

'

   !  !!  "  ;

5  !.    

 '

   A! 

!   !  5  !  5   ! 5   !

 ! " ! !  

"   

 !

'

   7"

  .

 !!. !    !          .  "

!

    !    %&"

   5.!      !! !

..  !L %&  5 !! L %&5   .     !

! L %&  !! !

   

 L %&!

!    .     !! L %& =

 !  L %&          "      ! L

 12

%&   !

  ! " 5     9* 7  .       

 '



         !

     .!

 !

5     "

 . !  ! .    

H 9- 7   !3

2#    %+*+*&+ ''991  '



E9- 2         !!       !

 5     7    '



    5 "    

'

     " "

 !



'

    A! "



 ! .  !

  !

'

 !

           2 '

; !  .

    .!"  !! !

..  !    5  ! =

!! !  !    5. 

   !

  ! 2           "    !"  !     .  !  !   5  ! ! "      ! "    "    !

 ! "  !

 

"  5  '

7   !

.  ! .  !     A! ! 5 "

     !5!  7      

.    "

        5    !

         . !     !        !!  !

..  !. 7               !

   A.       ! !

!

. !

!

 H

 13

9, 7 

  

 !   

 70    %+*99&9'',:-&    !

A

!   ! 5?  ! -)1  '

  !      !      5 "  !  2 '



E1-   5  !               !5B     .   !  !  "   ?

;

5.  H 9/2  

!= .              !

   



5       !

  "

!

    ! 

   !   "

5 '

!

    !      !

5    !      !  .  "

 . ! 

"    

.    !        !

A   

.   !       !

  5  ! !! !

 "   5 !

 !       "       !

   ! . "  5 !. % &    !

            " H 9, 

.   

'

# * 5     !

        !     !      !    !  " !

!    !  )*/    !  905

. .  ;  5   ! "  !    !  )+,    

 "

 5 

 . .  9/ !           !5  !    !  5             7  

 14

  ! A.  %8''2  &  



"  "

( M'

..  !    

   MD   ! ! 

    MD   ! !   A

.     M6! 

 "    M6!  "





   M6!   "



     M 6!          "

 

 .A

5     ?

  3 !             

 

 !!    !        

    !      .  2         3

  9**++*+-   ?

 3 !  !

               A (9   ()  2 

  

"  !

    

     

"  A(-2   5!

 5

"    !!  2 5" "

   !=    

5!

 5

"  !!    =

   

8 

5   !! 



.  " 

   !  $ " 

   91 ?

 

$ " 

"   5 !!

 2 

!

!!   (

 15

4492(&"$/2(8;<466=#'('7 %94$/2(8; '5")  "  

    

 != 

 3   $ " 

 >4$34(/2(8;#'('7*$&""6/2(8; '5"

" 

!  

!= 

 3  $ " 

 +4#645/2(8;#'('704$(425/2(8; '5"

#=!=

"   

 

" 

    

"   

 != 

  $ " 

 & %94$/2(8;#'('704$(425/2(8; '5"

#=!=

"  

 

"   

"  

!= 

 3  $ " 

 "4(?29/2(8;#'('704$(425/2(8; '5"

#=!=

"  

 

"   

"  

!= 

 3  $ " 

7*$&""6/2(8;#'('704$(425/2(8; '5"

#=!=

"  

 

"   

"  

!= 

 3  $ " 

8 45?29/2(8;1"("$45/"+$"94$= '5"

'

 

   

!

 .

 16

9: $    "     5    !  . .       '

               5. "

 5 ! !

  5        !!   !. "

  

  5   "

" !

    +* 7 "  .  ! !!. !"

  "   5   !

  '



 

.           .         !

!  ! 5     +9 3.    0/  ,!!   $   = C NC8       NC8