Dharambir Singh v. Chaudhary Charan Singh
!" #
$%&## !
#'
(%%&
!
#'
)& *+)
, , ,+
! "
! "
, ,-%.-/-- 0
# $%
"&'
(&'& )
+,- &.
&, (&'()
+'/- 0%"
0 1 2 0 0 3*
0 " 0 " " &'
&'
',,40 0
1
0 % "
" 0 0 5(/6" " 2" 0$
# 0 1
2 &'
'& ',7.0" 0 # &'
&4 (&'( 0 0$
8 01 1 2 0 "
&( &.
',79 "" "0 8 # 0
" " 2 )
+'- 0 : " ; (/
" " ; /& 2 0 " &'
&'
',,4 )
+(- 8
&'
&'
',,9 " 1 %
<" &'
&'
',,40"" " '
&&&3+ 0
/ &&&3+ 1 0
9 &&&3+
2 0 " 0 0
0 1 " * *11$$-% ,(-21"-2---%.$3$ -1,-45 -%--%.$* ##6# 7,''
0 (.
''
(&&4)
+.-$
" 0 (9 &/ (&&=)
+ 9-
# > 0 ''
&= (&&7 )
* +4- # "
&'
&7 '&&7" " 1 0
0 " 0 1 0"
2 0
0 0 " 0 (( ''
(&&7 )
* +7-
0 : 0 1 &'
(&'& )
* +,- ? 0 ('
&4 (&'& )
+'&- ""
01 " + % (.
&7 (&'& 0 + $
0 0 01
&.
&, (&'()
+'/- ""% 0 "
"
" @ 1 *8$.-.-%.-%/-93$ ,-"
-2--
6#7, :: *)$ 8$.-2-3$ *; <.4" 49-;-%-2-- =6=7,+ '
# " 1 0
" 8 0 "
'& &/ ',=/ "7&+'(& ) - ? ) 0 "
2 - &( &.
',79"" 8
" 0 " 1 &'
'& ',7.
# 0
"
1
+'
0
*
* +(
0 0 "9&&&+=79&0 "
&'
&'
',,4 %"
"
"(&"" # 0 2 &'
'& ',7.0 " " '(&&+(&/&0 "
&'
&'
',,/ 0" "/&&&+4&&&0 "
&'
&'
',,4 " # ',,7 )- )- )-"
; '9";+= # 0" "( "
&'
'& (&&.00 0
" 00
"
A< ; 44"(&&9"
*
" $ "
"( " '4 ''
(&&4)
+(- &4 (&&= "
+.
# "',,7 " ""
1
"" 0 0
" 01
,0 +
!
!
"#$
%
0 " * -1,-45 -%-6$45-70" ,
0 0 " ""
0 " (.
&4 (&&, # (9 &/ (&&=0 00 "> > 0 % " &4 (&&= ''
&= (&&7
" " ;
0 0 00
'( '& (&&,)
+=- #&'
&4 (&'& 0 " 0 " 1 0""" " " " 01
" 0 0 1 * 49-;,-((2-%3$ 41-,<.*
!6 7,#! 00
0 " " 2 + (9 &/ (&'/)
+'4-0 0 0 ; (/ 00 ; ., 20 " ""( 0 ',,4 0"0 "
(&&. 0 "
# 0 $
"" 01 0" " 1" 1 0 0 * $ ,0 "
0 """
1 " "
""" " > 0
" 0 1 0 " 1" : " 0 $ " 0 (
"
" " "
0 0 "
" #
&'
(&'& )
+,- + & $
! '
"
( '## )"* )
& ( "
! '
"
+ )
% ,
% %
&.
&, (&'()
+'/- + ' -./.0--
'
"1
,
,
+
% # " $
0 " 0 01 0
0 "
)
+(- 0
/&&&3+ &'
&'
',,4 1 0
9 &&&3+ 0 / &&&3+ 0 1 9 '9&3+ )
+'- ?
0
" 0
0 "
+ $
2 0"" " 1 " *
*8-$$(-$ +% -%-.3$ )-$%.1%8.- -%.$*6 # 7:,>:= # + /-
#
!
!
"& !
! !
'
+ !
& !
'
+ ,
+
'
,
! !
& !
' !
#
!
!
, ! !
2
& !
!
"
!
3 !
! & !
,2 & !
4 ,
,
'
" 3 3
&
,
& !
, ,! , , ! 5 (
( 2
#
5-678 -00 ) 9
'
7:-7:78 &
,
&
2 5-;8 - <)'' //:
/=. .
! "#$# # " = < #
) '
& > &
!
>
!
!
&
>( $ > 2 " $"
% "
"" * 0
1 * *
0 "
"1 6
& ,
!
?
@
A 2 A !
>$ + + &
,
$
!
> ? ,
% # 00"0 *
*!"#$ %#&## # # ' #
()## # *
+
* * # ,()#& - %#"
.
* /
* *0, 1(#2 3, 4 3# .
* /
0 0
0 0""
""
" " 0 $
""
"
$
" #
0"0
0%
0 0 # &'
(&'&)
+,- &.
&, (&'()
+'/- % ; ( $ " "
" 0 " " "" " 2 " 1" "1
6 , ,+7 , 0 #'
B @, 4 14B
@' 14B