High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/10439/2018dismissed

M/S New Patiala Bus Service v. State Transport Commissioner Punjab And ORS

2018-05-03Mr. Justice Amit Rawal3 pages

!"# #$%&%'( )

!"# #$%&%'( ) *+&#,!"%!-! .&#/0%$#1#234 #"%"%'#/ 5& 6#"!"#/!'&7/"88%&&%'#/9.':!;!'3"6#/& #&7'3#'"& *(< =* >>* *(< =* >>* *(< =* >>* *(< =* >>* /#&#'"( */!:>!.&6%?930$!"#9

/"6#7#"%"%'#/ >>* 9 1=4 >>* 9 1=4 >>* 9 1=4 >>* 9 1=4 6# 7#"%"%'#/ 6!& 7/!@#3 / "6# %&&.!'$# ! ,/%" / A.!&6%'2 "6# /3#/ 3!"#3 7!&&#3 ;@ "6# "!"# /!'&7/" 77#--!"#/%;.'!-9.':!;;@,6%$6!'!77#!- %-#3;@"6#7#"%"%'#/ .'3#/#$"%' "6#*"/5#6%$-#$"9 B /&6/"C"6#$"<D !2!%'&" "6# /3#/ 3!"#3 7!&&#3 ;@ "6# "!"# /!'&7/" 88%&&%'#/9.':!;%'/#2!/3"2/!'" ",&"!2#$!//%!2#7#/8%"&

/ 7-@%'2 '# /#"./' "/%7 3!%-@ ' !8!'!>!7./"6!-! 0%! !"%!-!9 =.36%!'!/."#"#7&.!3/!'&7/"/7/!"%'6!&;##'3#$-%'#3 '"6#2/.'3 -%8%"!"%'

./%'2 "6# $./&# !/2.8#'"&9 -#!/'#3 $.'&#- / "6# 7#"%"%'#/ 6!& !%/-@ $'$#3#3 "6!" "6# 7#/%3 3!@& %& 7/0%3#3 .'3#/"6#.':!;*"/5#6%$-#.-#&9 B /&6/"C"6#.-#&<D /

%-%'2!'!77#!-;# /#"6#"!"#/!'&7/"77#--!"#/%;.'!-!2!%'&" "6#/3#/ "!"#/!'&7/"88%&&%'#/ =#!/'#3$.'&#- /"6#7#"%"%'#/6!&&.;8%""#3"6!"&%'$# "6# '<;-# .7/#8# ./"9 0%3# %"& /3#/ 3!"#3 ) E9 6!&

!--,#3 "6# 7#"%"%'#/ " 80# "6# !77/7/%!"# /.89 "6#/# /# "6# !77#!- ,!& %-#3 ,%"6%' 3!@& ,6#/#!& "6# 77#--!"# /%;.'!- 6!& 3%&8%&&#3"6#!77#!-'"6#2/.'3"6!""6#7#"%"%'#/3%3'" %-#!'@ !77-%$!"%' / $'3'!"%' 3#-!@ " %& &.;8%""#3 "6!" '$# "6# 7#/8%&&%'6!& ;##' 2/!'"#3 !'3"6# !77#!-6!&;##' %-#3 ,%"6%' 3!@& "6#/#!

"#/ "6#' "6#/# %& ' A.#&"%' &##?%'2 !'@ ?%'3 7#/8%&&%'/$'3'!"%' 3#-!@9% !'@ 6!0# 6#!/3 -#!/'#3 $.'&#- / "6# 7#"%"%'#/ !'3 !

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

%$%#'"$!.&#%&&6,'#6!&!-& '" 3#'%#3 "6!" "6# 7#"%"%'#/ 3%3 '" %-# !'@ !77-%$!"%' / $'3'!"%' 3#-!@!&&%2'%'2/#!&'& /'"!77/!$6%'2"6#$./"%' "%8# 6# 7#"%"%'#/ 6!& '-@ /#-%#3 .7' "6# /3#/ "6# '<;-# .7/#8# ./" !2/## ,%"6 "6# ;&#/0!"%'& 8!3# ;@ "6# "!"# /!'&7/"77#--!"#/%;.'!-%'3%&8%&&%'2"6#!77#!- "6#7#"%"%'#/ ' "6# 2/.'3 -%8%"!"%' !& "6# 7#"%"%'#/ ,!& /#A.%/#3 " %-# &#7!/!"#!77-%$!"%' /$'3'!"%' 3#-!@!&&%2'%'2/#!&'&"6#/#%'

/ !77/!$6%'2 "6# "!"# /!'&7/" 77#--!"# /%;.'!- ! "#/ !

$'&%3#/!;-#3#-!@ @#!/&6.&9%'0%#,"6#/# 9"6#/#%&6!/3-@!'@ /#!&' /"6%&./""%'"#/ #/#%'"6%&7#"%"%'

%&8%&&#3 1>>* 4 1>>* 4 1>>* 4 1>>* 4

)

6#"6#/&7#!?%'2+/#!&'#3 ( #&+ 6#"6#/#7/"!;-# ( #&+