← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16731/2015allowed

Mahabir Singh Tanwar v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2023-09-06Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil10 pages

  

        

 









!

"# $%

  $     &$$ $   

$ $ $ !

'( ) $  $    ()   

 



 



    

 "

#

$$$$ $    (%  %

' 

(    ))* ))+

(  

,

  -

 . 

 %/ 0* )0%/ 3)#4



 

- 

   

 354 3%)4 



  2

 6  

' 

 ' 

 

 

  .

   

2 

%)7 



 ' 

 



  .  



)



2  

 -

 

'   

     %5 0/ )00%    2  

%5 

0# %59% %9 0/ )00% 

  

: )) 0/ )00% 8

 

;

 





<

 

' 

 

)) 0/ )00%

, - 

;

 

 ' 

   =

 

    # 8 

6 

8 



 )* 3"4    

 

8



:    

 

8



 )) %% 3*4 2 

= *"/0<3

%5 0/ )00% = *+00<3    





= */0035500<3 

 



= */00<3





>  



2 

   %5 0* .  .?



'  

;

;

 

2

 354

   ( .

*"*+/) %5 

= 9/099<3  

 - 

:

 

 



 -

 





   

38



.

      

 



.

 



6 

 2     



 

 (@3%++9/3)00#   ( 

 

 %9 %% )00#

      )0 )00#

 

 

-





 



, 



(:(

 6 

   

2 

 

 

> 

"

A  

   

 6  

 





     



 





   % "

     



  ' - 



)/ %0 )0%"

3))4

 %/ 0* )0%/ 3)#4



 %* %/ 0* )0%/ 12 3%# 3)#4    .      12 35 3%)4     

  

, 

*    

  

- 

 

-  6   8

(  A3++#3)0%%  +$

       



    ! "# $ $ - 

+

%

&#'

($

 

  ) *+, -$>    =  8 

        %9

 

 6   ( 3   = 

8 A  ( 



 

' 

  2



 

 6   

 32 



 -  12 35 3%)4





 

      - 

 

- 

   

> 

  

2 

)* )00) = *+00<3 



 

   <  -  2 



  

. 

 

'    ;

; 

   ' 

 



#

,

   

   "

#

 %5 0/ )00%

   

  

  %0 )00) 

  %0

, 

      

 

8 

    

2 -   



   

     0/ )00% -



    6 

 >  @ 



=  

A  2

  0# )0%* 2 =3"

=3#  

,    

 "

#

  2 = )%/0<3



= %#003)*00<3 = *+00<3



= */0035500<3

  

 

   

%0   



;



2 

- 

  

 %5 0/ )00)    -     -  

       

.  = 9/099<3 %5





 3%)4  

     

-   

  



>



 



'  









   

-   

     

 

 

   - 



     

 







 



  

 -



 

    %0 )00+   %0 )00+

 





  %0

 - 



 

 

-





, - 

     

-

-

    

 



 

 

  

 

 

  



 

/



 



*

    

 

+

8   



      

( %)38 4

  > 

  %+ %59+ 3 )*4

  $.  #  /#  

  /

## $ 0/#""

1

2#34 5$ 0/#"  6  #  0        .  7





*#+ ##                   

  

         

 

             

-   

 %* 0/ )00% 3%4    

8 



    )* 3"4

    %0 3#4

' 

    %5 0/ )00% ;





 )) 0/ )00%

>





 3    

  

;

  -

  t

  

;

     

 2  .  

2

'  

;



 2 <54



3 2  <54

.

*"*+/) %5 =

9/099<     - 

3 2

%0

  



 

    )*

  

 - 

  3%)4      -

   

 

2 

    

>  

%%

! - .  

(  

, 

-

-

 6   



 

,    

  '

6   8

( 

 A3++#3)0%%  8

        $     

   0/ )0%%     '

 2 (  

C%

&#'

$

     ! *+, -

 

-

-

6  

   



 

  2

'  3 C!         



      " #    

   

   $            %    &''#( ')   

   $

  %     

      

            * 

     %    + ,

-  ./ 0

     " ) $ 1  ./ +%  

 2     &3&&''3   

      ##&''3 ,  .4  .'



                5/ #667         &&8#666

,  .&&

9/  

    

                 -/        .2 . +/ &')3/  

- */           

         $ 

     

            $  / 

     2    *: -      + ,  - ;

</

&''6 # - )#3 =



   

 2         , 2 0

-  .2  / &'44

-$+ &''

$      >   

      





        %      ? / 

  

              

/

    

     &&8#666 ,  .&&

       ,  .&6

               / 2   /

      #43#667

,  .&3

,

-

 3 '

    ( 

    

 

         



 

      

 %* %/ 0* )0%/ 12 3%# 3)#4

 

 6   ( 3   = 

8 A    

  )* 

     

-  

-

 

A  = = 

 

 -



 

%"

,

-

 



 



   -

 %* %/ 0* )0%/ 12 3%# 3)#4    

 12 35 3%)  4 

 







 



$    (

  "# $%



%

@  <    D < )

@    D <