High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/17469/2014dismissed

Duli Chand v. Presiding Officer Labour Court & ORS

2023-11-28Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger19 pages

!#$% (%)*+*&,

-..

!/0* 1#,(

.....

%$*$*&,%2 3%2+/+ 1% 2%+*(*,4 ''*)%25 6#7&/2 &/2$5 /24#&, #,( &$1%2+

.......

%+8&,(%,$+ 9 6 .

: :

2%+%,$ 2.

!%%8#;

:&,#;5 (<&)#$%

'&2 8%$*$*&,%2.

:#$*+1 :*,40#5 ! #2=#,# '&2 2%+8&,(%,$+ &.

#,( .

%$*$*&,%2

!/0* 1#,( 1#+ '*0%( *,+$#,$ >2*$ 8%$*$*&, /,(%2 2$*)0%+

&,+$*$/$*&, ,(*# +%%;*,4 # >2*$ ,#$/2% )%2$*&2#2* '&2 +%$$*,4 #+*(% >#2( (#$%(

,,%?/2% 5 8#++%( 7= ,(/+$2*#0 2*7/,#0)/@6#7&/2 &/2$5 /24#&,

1%2%*,#'$%2 2%'%22%( $& #+ 9$1% 2*7/,#09 >1%2%7= )0#*@ 8%$*$*&,%2>&2;@#, '&2 2%*,+$#$%@%,$ +%2<*)% 1#+ 7%%, 2%A%)$%(.

'/2$1%2 82#=%2 1#+ 7%%, @#(% '&2 (*2%)$*,4 2%+8&,(%,$ &.

2*,)*8#0 1*%'

&,+%2<#$&2

&2%+$ $& 2%*,+$#$% 8%$*$*&,%2>&2;@#, +%2<*)% >*$1 )&,$*,/*$= #,( '/00 7#);

>#4%+ '2&@ (#$% $%2@*,#$*&, 1*+ +%2<*)%+ *.%.

. .

2*%'0=5 8%$*$*&,%2>&2;@#, 2#*+%( #, *,(/+$2*#0 (*+8/$% 2%4#2(*,4 $%2@*,#$*&, 1*+ +%2<*)%+5 >1*)1 >#+ 2%'%22%( $& 2*7/,#0 7%0&> /,(%2 :%)$*&,

) ,(/+$2*#0 !*+8/$%+ )$5

1%2%*,#'$%2 2%'%22%( $& #+ 9 )$9 '&2 #(A/(*)#$*&,.

+ 8%2 )0#*@ 8%$*$*&,%2>&2;@#,5 1% A&*,%( 2%+8&,(%,$+ &.

#,( 1%2%*,

1%2%*,#'$%2 2%'%22%( $& #+ 92%+8&,(%,$+ &.

#,( &2%+$ !%8#2$@%,$95 >*$1 %''%)$ '2&@

. - &, 8&+$ #0*)/@1&>;*(#2 #>#0

#,4%.

$ *+ )#$%4&2*) )#+% 8%$*$*&,%2>&2;@#, $1#$ ,& #88&*,$@%,$ 0%$$%2 #,( #$$%,(#,)% )#2( >%2% *++/%( $& 1*@ ,&2 #,= >#4% +0*8+ >%2% 4*<%, $& 1*@.

$ *+ )#+% 8%$*$*&,%2>&2;@#, $1#$ 1*+ +%2<*)%+ >%2% $%2@*,#$%( #, *00%4#0 @#,,%2 &,

. .

#,( #$ $1#$ $*@%5 1% >#+ 4%$$*,4 @&,$10= +#0#2=

5- .

$ >#+ +$#$%( $1#$ ,& +1&> )#/+% ,&$*)% >#+ 4*<%, $& 1*@B ,%*$1%2 #,= (&@%+$*) %,C/*2= >#+ )&,(/)$%( #4#*,+$ 1*@ ,&2 #,= 2%$2%,)1@%,$ )&@8%,+#$*&, >#+ 4*<%, $& 1*@ #,( 1*+ +%2<*)%+ >%2% $%2@*,#$%( >*$1&/$ )&@80=*,4 >*$1 @#,(#$&2= 82&<*+*&,+ :%)$*&,

)$.

))&2(*,40=5 82#=%2 '&2 2%*,+$#$%@%,$ +%2<*)% >*$1 7#);

>#4%+ >#+ @#(%.

1% #'&2%+#*( )0#*@ 8%$*$*&,%2>&2;@#, >#+ &88&+%( 7= 2%+8&,(%,$+ &.

#,( &2%+$ !%8#2$@%,$ &, 80%# $1#$ 8%$*$*&,%2 >&2;@#, 1#( >&2;%( &,0= '&2 (#=+ *.%.

'2&@ .

. - $& .

. - #+ # (#*0= >#4%2 #,( $1#$ >&2;

!%8#2$@%,$ >#+ +%#+&,#0 &, ,%%( 7#+*+.

$ >#+ +$#$%( $1#$ #+ 8%$*$*&,%2>&2;@#, 1#( ,%<%2 >&2;%( )&,$*,/&/+0= >*$1 2%+8&,(%,$ &2%+$ !%8#2$@%,$5 $1%2%'&2%5 1% >&/0( ,&$

7% %,$*$0%( $& #,= 7#);

>#4%+.

2&@ 80%#(*,4+ 8#2$*%+5 '&00&>*,4 *++/%+ >%2% '2#@%(

! " # .

, &2(%2 $& 82&<% 1*+ )#+%5 8%$*$*&,%2>&2;@#, %?#@*,%( &,% :/(1*2 D/@#25 !%8/$=

#,4%2 #+ #,(

&1$#+1 :*,415 !%8/$=

#,4%2 ''*)%2 #+ #,( 8%$*$*&,%2>&2;@#, %?#@*,%( 1*@+%0'

#,( $%,(%2%( 1*+ #''*(#<*$ ?. .

, &$1%2 1#,(5 2%+8&,(%,$ &2%+$ !%8#2$@%,$ %?#@*,%( !1#2#@ :*,415

#,4%

&2%+$ ''*)%2 #+ #,(

&1$#+1 :*,415

#,4%

&2%+$ ''*)%2 #+ 5 >1& $%,(%2%( $1%*2 #''*(#<*$+ ?. #,( ?..

'$%2 )&,+*(%2*,4 2%0%<#,$ @#$%2*#0%<*(%,)% 80#)%( &, 2%)&2(5 2*7/,#0 7%0&> (*+@*++%( 2%'%2%,)% >&2;@#,5 <*(% *$+ *@8/4,%( >#2( (#$%(

,,%?/2% .

, #'&2%@%,$*&,%( )*2)/@+$#,)%+5 8%$*$*&,%2>&2;@#, 1#+ #882&#)1%( $1*+ &/2$ 7= >#= '*0*,4 *,+$#,$ >2*$ 8%$*$*&,.

6%#2,%( )&/,+%0 '&2 8%$*$*&,%2>&2;@#, +/7@*$+ $1#$ 2*7/,#0 7%0&> 1#+ %22%( 0#> #,( &, '#)$+ (*+@*++*,4 1*+ )0#*@ >*$1&/$ )&,+*(%2*,4 $1#$ 1% 1#( #88%#2%( #+ >*$,%++ >1%2%*, 1% 1#( +8%)*'*)#00= +$#$%( $1#$ 1% >#+ #88&*,$%( &,

. - #,( >&2;%(

)&,$*,/&/+0= $*00 .

6%#2,%( )&/,+%0 '&2 8%$*$*&,%2>&2;@#, +/7@*$+ $1#$ 8%$*$*&,%2>&2;@#, 1#( )#$%4&2*)#00= +$#$%( $1#$ A/,*&2+ $& 1*@5 ,#@%0=5 :12* #2;#+15 :12* :#$*+1 D/@#25 :12* #2@%+1 D/@#2 #,( :12* !#=#,#,(5 >1& >%2% #88&*,$%( #'$%2 1*+ #88&*,$@%,$5 #2% +$*00 )&,$*,/*,4 #,(

*$ >#+ #0+& +$#$%( $1#$ 8%$*$*&,%2>&2;@#, 1#( )&@80%$%( @&2% $1#,

(#=+ 0#+$ 82%)%(*,4 =%#2 1*+ $%2@*,#$*&, #,( $1#$ 1*+ +%2<*)%+ >%2% $%2@*,#$%( <*&0#$*&, :%)$*&,

:%)$*&,

#,( :%)$*&,

)$5 1&>%<%25 +#@% >#+ ,&$ )&,+*(%2%( 7= 2*7/,#0 7%0&>.

6%#2,%( )&/,+%0 '&2 8%$*$*&,%2>&2;@#, ,%?$ +/7@*$+ $1#$ +%2<*)% 2%)&2( 8%$*$*&,%2>&2;@#, >#+ 8&++%++*&, 2%+8&,(%,$ &2%+$ !%8#2$@%,$ #,( 1% 1#( @&<%( #, #880*)#$*&, '&2 +/@@&,*,4 1*+ #$$%,(#,)% 2%)&2( '2&@

. - $&

. .

$ *+ +/7@*$$%( $1#$ #0$1&/41 :12*

&1$#+1 :*,415

#,4%

&2%+$ ''*)%25 #>#0 #88%#2%( #+ # +/@@&,%( >*$,%++5 1&>%<%25 1% (*( ,&$ 72*,4 2%)&2( #,( 1% 82&(/)%( 2%)&2( ?. $& ?. #,( +$#$%( $1#$ #+ >&2;@#, 1#( ,&$ >&2;%( '&2 +#*( 8%2*&(5 $1%2%'&2%5 1% 1#( ,&$ 72&/41$ 2%)&2( '2&@

. - $& .

$ *+ +/7@*$$%( $1#$ 2*7/,#0 7%0&> +1&/0( 1#<% (2#>, #(<%2+% *,'%2%,)% #4#*,+$ 2%+8&,(%,$ &2%+$ !%8#2$@%,$ '&2 ,&$ 82&(/)*,4 +/@@&,%( 2%)&2(.

))&2(*,40=5 82#=%2 1#+ 7%%, @#(% '&2 C/#+1*,4 *@8/4,%( #>#2( >*$1 # '/2$1%2 82#=%2 $& 2%*,+$#$% 8%$*$*&,%2>&2;@#, +%2<*)% >*$1 #00 )&,+%C/%,$*#0 7%,%'*$+.

, &$1%2 1#,(5 0%#2,%( :$#$% )&/,+%0 #88%#2*,4 '&2 2%+8&,(%,$ &2%+$ !%8#2$@%,$ 1#+ &88&+%( 82#=%2 8%$*$*&,%2 >&2;@#, 7= +/88&2$*,4 '*,(*,4+ 2%$/2,%( 7= 2*7/,#0 7%0&>.

6%#2,%( :$#$% )&/,+%0 1#+ +/7@*$$%( $1#$ 8%$*$*&,%2>&2;@#, 1#( '#*0%( $& 82&<% &, 2%)&2( $1#$ 1% 1#( >&2;%( '&2 @&2% $1#,

(#=+ >*$1 2%+8&,(%,$+ &.

#,( &2%+$ !%8#2$@%,$ # )#0%,(#2 =%#2.

$ 1#+ 7%%, +/7@*$$%( $1#$ 8%$*$*&,%2>&2;@#, 1#( ,&$ 82&(/)%( #,= #88&*,$@%,$ 0%$$%25 @/+$%2 2&00+5 *(%,$*$= )#2(5 >#4% +0*8+ &2 (/$= )1#2$ #,( ,%*$1%2 #,= )&>&2;%2 >#+ %?#@*,%( +/88&2$ 1*+ )0#*@.

$ *+ '/2$1%2 +/7@*$$%( $1#$ &,)% 8%$*$*&,%2>&2;@#, 1#( '#*0%( $& 82&<% )&,$*,/&/+ +%2<*)% $%2@+ :%)$*&,

)$5 #))&2(*,40=5 ,& 2%0*%'

'&2 <*&0#$*&, :%)$*&,

)$ )&/0( 1#<% 7%%, 42#,$%( $& 8%$*$*&,%2 >&2;@#,.

+ 2%4#2( 80%# 8%$*$*&,%2>&2;@#, $1#$ #(<%2+% *,'%2%,)% +1&/0( 1#<% 7%%, (2#>, #4#*,+$ 2%+8&,(%,$ &.

#,( &2%+$ !%8#2$@%,$ 7= 2*7/,#0 7%0&> '&2 ,&$ 82&(/)*,4 2%0%<#,$ 2%)&2( 8%2$#*,*,4 $& +%2<*)% 8%$*$*&,%2>&2;@#,5 *$ *+ +/7@*$$%( $1#$ (2#>*,4 #(<%2+% *,'%2%,)% *+ ,&$ &70*4#$&2= 7/$ &8$*&,#0 #,( +#@% *+ >*$1*, (&@#*, 2*7/,#0 7%0&> #,( #(<%2+% *,'%2%,)% )#,,&$ 7% (2#>, &,0= 7%)#/+% *$ *+ 0#>'/0 $& (& +&.

$ *+ +/7@*$$%( $1#$ 8%$*$*&,%2>&2;@#, 1#( '#*0%( $& +1&> $1#$ 1% >&2;%( '&2

(#=+ >*$1 2%+8&,(%,$+ &.

#,( &2%+$ !%8#2$@%,$ #,( +*,)% 8%$*$*&,%2 >&2;@#, 1#( 82*@# '#)*% '#*0%( $& 82&<% +#@% #,( #0+& 0%#( %<*(%,)% 2%4#2(*,4 %?*+$%,)% 2%)&2( '&2 2%0%<#,$ 8%2*&( >&2;

(#=+5 )&/80%( >*$1 80%# +/882%++*&,5 2*7/,#0 7%0&> >#+ A/+$*'*%( ,&$ (2#>*,4 #,= #(<%2+% *,'%2%,)%.

))&2(*,40=5 *$ *+ 82#=%( $1#$ #>#2( 8#++%( 7= 2*7/,#0 7%0&> *+ A/+$*'*%( #,( ,& *,$%2'%2%,)% *+ 2%C/*2%(

+#@% 7= $1*+ &/2$ %?%2)*+% *$+ >2*$ A/2*+(*)$*&,.

1#<% 1%#2( 0%#2,%( )&/,+%0 '&2 2%+8%)$*<% 8#2$*%+ #,( 1#<% #0+& 8%2/+%( 8#8%2 7&&;

>*$1 $1%*2 #70% #++*+$#,)%.

%2%5 *$ >&/0( 7% 2%0%<#,$ $& 2%'%2 )%2$#*, A/(*)*#0 82&,&/,)%@%,$+.

, )#+% " $

% & '( ) # ** +!, '-( !.

+'-,5 &,970% 8%?

&/2$ 1%0( #+ /,(%2 /

& 0 & -& 1*

& (

1* ( (

* 2&& 33. &

1* (

& & 4&

! $

& 6 &

-& :$#$% /A#2#$ <.

2#$#@ :*,41 #2+*,1 #2@#25

: -

: .

/ & (

& &

/ &

-& (

& &

7 1*

, )#+% &

- % & '

# **1+1, '-( 5 &,970% 8%?

&/2$ 1%0( #+ /,(%2 E (

/ 8

& 4&

(

/& (

& 4&

(

& 1*

/ '

/& 9

& 31: &

' ;<$ & & = + , >

= +

, 5&

? ! $ &

>- && '

' ;<@ 2 / & < + , ' ;<@ &

& & 1*

( :;33; $ & & 1*

(

& ;.331 A;33; 1* 2

& $ 2 &

5& ' /& 9

& 2 ?

& &

2 & & /

0 2& &

(

& 2 &

& ) ?

1 2 -& 0

/ 8

2 & &

& &

( &

& <&

( & &

& <&

& ?

& <& & 4& & / /& (

& 2 / 4&

& " ; 7

) -&

(

) -& ?

(

& &

& 0 &2 *22#$*&,#0FG

&>5 )&@*,4 $& )#+% 1#,(5 2*7/,#0 7%0&> 1#+ 2%$/2,%( '&00&>*,4 '*,(*,4+ . /

& & 2"

& 3 / &

? '& B& 9 "

& &

)

/ & **3.3 !*; **1 **1*; !**3*A & & ( 9& -

8? < 9&

& /

/ /

.**C< " '

& & 8? <!C 8? <!C: /

: * ? 9 '

8? <C2 1*

5& & & )

' ;<$ /9 2 31: ' " $

/ @ " ? <

8? <C2

& & 1*

&& 1*

)> '& -& /

D @'70 %C - **. 00"<1!; & & )> '& -& / '

" %C 0 7& $ ( / & **. 00"<;13 & & 1*

& & & )> &4 ) ) -&

$& -

" %C

- D /& (

&< &<0 & -&<// 7 9 **3 00"<1 ; 0

)> ) -&

)4 %C '

&& @ **. 00"<!!

& & 1*

@& 1*

(

& 1*

7 <

? &

& & 8 ? '& B& 9 "

< " '

<! & : ( & 8? <!C 8? <!C: & &

! ' 5&

& : < <!

: ( & & &

)

1 (&

& /

& 7

; (& &

& & &

)

" A & &

& # .

8%2/+#0 #7&<% %?$2#)$%( '*,(*,4+ >&/0( 2%<%#0 $1#$ 8%$*$*&,%2>&2;@#, 1#+ ,&$ (*+)1#24%( *,*$*#0 &,/+ $& +1&> $1#$ 1% 1#( >&2;%( >*$1 2%+8&,(%,$ &2%+$ !%8#2$@%,$ '&2

(#=+ 0#+$

82%)%(*,4 =%#2 '2&@ (#$% 1*+ #00%4%( $%2@*,#$*&,.

& #88&*,$@%,$ 0%$$%25 *(%,$*$= )#2(5 >#4% +0*8+ &2 (/$= )1#2$ %$).

1#<% 7%%, 82&(/)%( ,%*$1%2 #,= )&>&2;%2 1#+ 7%%, %?#@*,%( +/88&2$ 1*+ )0#*@.

$ *+ # >%00 +%$$0%( 0#> $1#$ +%0'+%2<*,4 +$#$%@%,$ >&2;@#, $& 82&<% $1#$ 1% 1#( >&2;%( '&2

(#=+ 82%)%(*,4 =%#2 '2&@ (#$% 1*+ $%2@*,#$*&, >*00 ,&$ +/''*)%.

1#<% )&,+*(%2%( 80%# 8%$*$*&,%2>&2;@#, $1#$ #(<%2+% *,'%2%,)% +1&/0( 1#<% 7%%, (2#>, 7= 2*7/,#0 7%0&> #4#*,+$ 2%+8&,(%,$+ &.

#,( &2%+$ !%8#2$@%,$ '&2 ,&, 82&(/)$*&, 2%0%<#,$ 2%)&2(5 1&>%<%25 (& ,&$ '*,( #,= @%2*$ +#@%.

1% 8%$*$*&,%2 >&2;@#, 1#( '#*0%( $& (*+)1#24% *,*$*#0 7/2(%, 82&<*,4 $1#$ 1% 1#( >&2;%( '&2

(#=+ *@@%(*#$%0= 82%)%(*,4

@&,$1+ '2&@ (#$% 1*+ $%2@*,#$*&, #,( (2#>*,4 #(<%2+% *,'%2%,)% >#+ &8$*&,#0 #,( >*$1*, (&@#*, 2*7/,#0 7%0&>5 (%8%,(*,4 /8&, 8%)/0*#2 '#)$+ #,( )*2)/@+$#,)%+ )#+% #,( ,& +$2#*41$ A#);%$ '&2@/0# )#, 7% #880*%( $1%2%$&.

, *,+$#,$ )#+%5 2*7/,#0 7%0&> 1#+ ,&$ (2#>, #,= #(<%2+% *,'%2%,)% #,( ,%*$1%2 8%$*$*&,%2>&2;@#, 1#( 0%( #,= %<*(%,)% $& 82*@# '#)*% +1&> $1#$ 2%)&2(5 >1*)1 1% )0#*@ 1#( ,&$ 7%%, 82&(/)%( 7= 2%+8&,(%,$ &2%+$ !%8#2$@%,$5 >#+ #)$/#00= %?*+$%,)%.

1%2% *+ #0+& ,& 80%# +/882%++*&, 2#*+%( 7= 8%$*$*&,%2>&2;@#,.

&,970% :/82%@% &/2$ )#+% " F

(

8? &

8 5

: 5 1#( &7+%2<%(

#+ '&00&>+ 6 9 & & (

C &

& 1*

( 4& & <& & & &

& 0 4&

) -& & 2

A - & & & -& &

(

& 6 .

&2%&<%25 8%2*81%2*%+ )%2$*&2#2* A/2*+(*)$*&, *41 &/2$ +$#,(+ #/$1&2*$#$*<%0= (%0*,%#$%( ' F

B ' "

2/" 3A1 '& -& 1::5 >1%2%*, &,H70% :/82%@% &/2$ 1%0( #+ /,(%2

6: ( 5& & 4&

) -&

& 2

-& &

& 2

& 4&

& =

& & 4&

& & ?

& ?

-& (

5& &

& &

& 4&

(

& 4&

-& ?

2 -& (

-& (

& &

5& 2

& / (

(

& & &

& & '

(

& (

5& &

& ( 5& &

(

-& /

) -& & 2

. /

& 5&

G & &

-& (

/ &

? ) -&

& -& &

G & &

& &

/ &

-& (

/ &

& &

& & &

6 -.

&,+*(%2*,4 $&$#0*$= )*2)/@+$#,)%+ <*%> #'&2%+#*( 0%4#0 82*,)*80%5 $1%2% *+ ,& +)&8% *,$%2'%2%,)% '*,(*,4+#>#2( 2%,(%2%( 7= 2*7/,#0 7%0&>.

%+/0$#,$0=5 *,+$#,$ )*<*0 >2*$ 8%$*$*&, '#*0+ #,( +#@% *+ #))&2(*,40= (*+@*++%(.

8%,(*,4 #880*)#$*&,

+5 *'

#,=5 +1#00 +$#,( )0&+%(.

-..

+A;+

1%$1%2 +8%#;*,42%#+&,%(

"%+

& 1%$1%2 2%8&2$#70% "%+