High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15824/2016dismissed

Tarlochan Singh v. Managing Director & ORS

2023-10-30Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger13 pages

!"# % &$

"

'"

(

!$ & ") (*+ % "$(

"," $"

- ,

" "

. % '

"/) 01 "

"

02," % &$) 01

,

3 "

!"# % &$

#

# "

("

0"

#

4 ( 5 )

/ 6(

2,(& 07" 8

09(" ) ,

5( "

!"

+(#) .$

$" "

"""

;$ !"

+(#; 7$"+:

""

7" &

#

"*

("$"

,":"

2 ,

( :

(## + / 7&

."

#:) "

( "

,() 7$

""" !"

+(# +#7 *(

!$ "

7"/2

#

$

7"/

$7/ "

,

3

$" "

"""

;" ,&2; # :"

< 2$

7$

7"

##&##:

4

$(

:

$"&

$)

6( ":

"

,:2

2,

# 2

$1

# ,"1

5( "

,(

) 8 4

$" "

"""

;8 4 ;

!$ "

#

, &2 /

&"

,#

1"

2,#:

) $"")

(

"(

1("

7"/ :"

< 2$ )

# 2

&#:) ,":"

2

# " 7"/2

="2 ,#

," ) ##7

(

7" "2

!

"

# $ "

# % "

" # & # '

""

#

,,

+9

$ ("$"

92 > "

% &$

"

% &$ ?("

$" % &$

3 $$"

% &$

, 1#:

!$ (2

@9 @9 % 7" ,# +$# $"

$) 92 #+&$ % &$) "$( &"

0"

"

, 1 ,"

1 (2

,# ") !"

+(# +#7 "*

# 7" "" &

"7"/2) 07" 8

09(" $# $"

1

$7

"1 ,"

:

"

2" "

$

1"

2,#: "2

(2 )

#

7"

+"

("

A"

( #

2,(& 7"

"+ "":

##&#) $ ( ( +#

: #7

2,#:

$7/ "

$ 7"/ 2" $ :"

< 2$

(+2

#"#:

,"1 $ 7"/

$7/ "

"2

8 888 4

7"

4

$( :

$"&

$)

6( ":

"

,:2

2, 2

) $

& -

)

,"

2$

7&

A"

( # 7(#

(+2

""

,#

7"/

$7/ "

"2

8 888 4

) $ # ,,"

92 > "

% &$

) 7$ (##:

""+"

2

71")

1

" !"

+(# +#7

(+2 1 $"7

# ,"( ") ,"

"7"/2)

, # ,,#

,"( (2 ) 7$

7"

( :

&#:)

!"

+(# +#7

$(# $1 "7 1"

" &

, &2 ,"(

") ,"

A"

( #

("$"

,# "# (, & ,

) 7$

7"

$1

(

& ,

#"#:

$7 "2 2,#: "$(

","

(+2

(##:

,"1 $ 7"/ 2" $

:

$1 7"&#:

# ,"1

8 4 ) $"")

2,(& 7" "1

+

# +# +

( :

(## + / 7&

$"

$) #"

( # "," , &2

,, ,":"

(,,"

2,(& 7"

(+2 (*+ % "$(

","

$" ;%;

(":

+:

+#

$ ("

"$(

"," ) 8

1"

7"/

(+2 #

,#

2,(& 7"

,

!"

+(# +#7 ,,"

2"

,# +"

&$ ,"

, 1

""

"6( " + 2

("

&#:) ,":"

7"

2

$1 $" #"

( # , 1 ,"

$1 ,"( ,,"

+/ +#

&"

,# " 7"/2 $ 7"/ :"

< 2$

+"

7"

4

,# $

"1 , &2 ,"

:

22 #:

,"

##&

$"

$)

1"

2,#:

$"

1"

:

"# , 2,#: 2,#:"

+7 " 7"/2 $"

"

7"/2 7"/

,&2

:

22 #:

,"

##&

!$( )

"

( +

7$$"

$"

"# , 2,#: 2,#:"

+7 "

7$$"

7"/

:

,"

#"

2$

"2 ##&

7##

# #7 (

"# , 2,#: 2,#:"

+7 7"/2 , &2 7"/2 7"/

:

#"

2$

22 #:

,"

##& )

7"/2

(+

,# $"

"# , 2,#: 2,#:"

+7 ,&2) "#

,# (,

2 # (,

2

7

=("$"

"#

,# (,

& ,

$1

( 4 $1

" "

#"

( # ="2 ,"(

2

2 #

7##

7 $"

)

2

> "

% &$

"

92

2,#:

4

!$ $"

?("

$" % &$

7"/ (*+ % "$(

","

=("$") ,"(

2 7(# "1# $

$"

,, 2 #"

"

:

#"

( $ ,, 2 :

*( "

"&"

"# (, ?

")

2 ?

( 1$

#

& ( ?7

!$ !"

+(# +#7

"(" ##7

& ( " !

" %) *

+ "

#!

"

" ,)-)%!

+ . + /

0

1 + 3

"

+ 4 .

+

5 !

" "3 . " +

" .

+ +

+ 4

! +

"

""

++ *" 2 + 0

! 6 " 2 + 3$!

"

*" + "

" + "7 "3

""

++ +

" +

+ .

"

"

+

" +

" +

" "

+ + 8 2! + " "

" " !

* " " %)

."

+

"

+

9+'

8

="2 "

" !"

+(# +#7)

+ "1

#

$"& (

(, "# , 2,#: 2,#:"

+7 #

,"1 7"/ ,

8

&2

:

#"

2$

22 #:

,"

##&

" 7"/2 # $"

:

"# , 2,#: 2,#:"

+7 , &2 "

((

% .

8 4 ) "#

+ &"

# ,"(

,"

"7"/2) $ 1"

"

$(# $1 "7 &

, &2B $71") 2

1

(+2

!$ C+# 0,9 ("

#9 : * 0

5 "

5+ ! ))8;< 244 )8

+ "1

("

* "

"

3 +

" 7

"

"+ " %)

+ * /

+ 3

"

" +

" + + = ! /

+

" "

!

! .

+ 4 0 " 8 4 ""

+ " "

"

*

"

" " " '

$"

,#

(,,"

/

!$ ,"

,$"

" ""

*("

&$ ("

($"

1#:

#

2 : > 2 #

!

# ,8% 2 4 %??) 7$"

C+# %(,"2 (" $#

("

@? * A /

" .

+ 4

+ "

0 " 8 A "

4 +

+ 0 " "

"" + /

" " " B "

" /

" !

"

!

"

/

" 0 "

"

/

" " !

4 * "

+

! "!

"

+

+ ! " ! "

+

"

/

" *

! ! /

"

"

/

" 4

"

+

" 0 4 *

"

+ " "

4 *

"

" "

"

+ 0 "

" " " "" ! "!

+ +

+ " " * ! " "

"

+

+! *

"!

" "

"

+

+ 2 !

+ "

"! + " " "" " +

"+ " ! !

+ " " * " "+

"

+ " +

"

" *

A

+

+ * A "

"

" " "

+ "

/

" * !

" + 4

/

" " .

+ 4

0 " 8

" " + "

-

! " ! A " " " " "" C

" " + "

" "

" ""

" 4 *

!

+" ! !

+ !

" + !

""

" "" " " ! + ""

"

" .

+ 4

+

" "

" ! +

" "

" 4 +

"

C "

" "" "

! !

" ""

" "

"

" " " " 4 * !

""

"

"" " !

" A " " " " " " +

"

" " !

" "

" " "

" +

"

+

"

" " @ 7 "&

(

) :

2"

7"

2

&#:

0,,#

)

:) ,

,

*/

$$"

,/ &"

E

3

$$"

","+# E

3