M/S Prl Projects & Infrastructure Ltd v. State Of Haryana & ORS




  
      !"# $% &' (!)* +$,)-./"# &0*

1 2)*( 3
!(*4)413

  5*4* 6(!(7( (( 3,*

*8 *
 



 
 
 


      * + & 9,/3)(/!,8 & (,46 :,/8473)( (/(7( (/ !*8 *

3"

&   (,/3)(/!*8  <<<< 
 
 
 ,8 *=*(>?4(*,( 33(3#$ #$ "# $ 8(**3.7*8  ;.7>,),,(*. .(3!>7(*!- 8()8( :   ,  3 8)**  (3 .7 *8   ;@(7( ( 6( (3*3:*8- 8( 13

*8   " * ,  : @ @,!/  % ' ( ),/ ,( 3:(, ( 3 *8   ; * , (7( ( 6( (3*  3:*8- 8( 13

*8   ; **43 ( )  3*   ! -( (: :,8 * ,3(3 ) : 3**8)!3, 8 *( 3,83!,) () (4*@$-  *,(,.3* >.*4.-3 ( 3>?43. )783( 33:(7 *:

3 (4*@ -  *,=73(* 
- ;-  *,*( - ( 3 3( ( 3 (* , A87 - ( 3 3( ! ,   .3 88(( 3(*,*4.-** .

,*#"

#"

"# "(

##,* #"

"# (4*@?4*, 3*.*4.-3 ,*8((

 8* ) ( :,( *- 7/), )(.3( 3, 3 -@ %8) .3'/ *8)7   )(4*@  *!( (*  * ( !,848*!,*)(*(3*(*4 3+@

   



  !"

 "

#$ %$&'  ()    %$&'  () (   *()+   , $ #

 - $ % 



'&%





 -

 $ .

&  / 

'

$ ()



#

 & 

0 $

'"#

  

 1 '$ ' 2 $ 

"

#

#

 &



 '$ ' (  *13+

$ 



 ''

%

 & %$&'  # '

2 

"

#

#

 &



$ 



 ''

%

 &%$&'  #44C 

 !" #$%#& %' 

  ), )( 8@1

#

 &



(, !-( 3*)(

3)8*! ,)4- *0!)(*(*?43.*4.-3(* 8, 3 #&( ) (( *&($(+,-%((% * )*%&#%& ,%'&'.

#$%#& ,%'%(# -

.

',+..$ ) / #)0.% 

* / % ,%'%( .#&))% ' +.&'1 )$0(%#& -  0 '

(%. %(  . (+,-%..

' ,0 &0 ,%''

) .$  ,%''

) + ' ,  '

,&)) ' *) - *+).$ ) .

'

)%3 % 
1&)0&& 45 6 78 * ) & )% ' * -%%-+-90 &)(::; $ , 8  (3-37 !(3  )-87 >,, ) :(3 : @

@  ! , 8 D*   .3 >(*

)(34

3, )(4*@)(7 :4@ !,   .3 >(* -(  ,(  * -( 3(7 (  3)7 * 3 )3.7,!(),(,) )>43.3.(, 3 !- : 6

/ % '/(7( (!(- -4-83! > 7(*  , *8  (* , 8(7  3* >(*  3  *84(,-*( 3) *!, 3

7( )3(3

"# "/*8  ;-  3, 8 D*!(4)(74@ .7*( :,(>(*(. . 3.(3 ! > 7(* ! !4,  :   6 / (7( ( ( :(  (  884 7  A8(  * 8*

 , 8  .7 * 87 %

A4 @ $'  33 (  4 ) ( (8:7 ! *  (3  -*(=( 3?4*3,(. *3>,*4),,(*,) )*! ,*(- 
(3,(,-*(=>(* (3 ( 3. (!3 * .7 (  3 3(3

#$ "# ; 3.(3 , 8  ! > 7(*  , 8  !3 (      #$;E ! "# ; ),( : : ,* 3  , 8  >(* 3*8*3 ! .7 (  3 ( 243:- 3(3;

"# ,*  ),)33,*(- !  ;,(,3.(3(*>,3(> 3,((!*,3 >,(* **,43.8(**3 ,*8 *,(!8(**3,3 3(3 #$ #$ "# $ >,), * -84:

3   , 8*  8

*8   ;*(::3>,,3)* !, *- --3.(  ! ( 83 ! > 7(* !-  :   (7( ( 6( (3* ( 3:*8- 8( 13 (7( (/ % '82)* >**4*(* ,!**>,,,8 D*.3>(* :,7 2)3    , *) 3 *   (**4- : ,(  >(* :,7 2)3>,,,*8 *>24*!3 .()=@* :,8  !>7(* ,(3)33,!* !(4!,*8 *( 3, *) 3 !(4!,8

*>-  3(/,?4- !(.33)(7 4 @  >(* -(  , 3(*) ) ) 833 ! !(4  )(7 4 @  *(.*,* , *(-  , 8  (3-37 33  )(7 4 , @

 .*  ( 7, : */ ,!/,2) D* 3)(

.!(43

  * , (* (. ** ! ,* 8* / > 3)3 , *!( (!!3(A8( :>,7,?4- !)(7 4@ >(*-( 3(3(!!3( ,*:(3,(*. !3 ,*8 *D)(**,(,)(4** 34)3)4.8 : .> ,) ()* ,(!!3(*(*,(,8 33 )(7 4 @  (*    33 8 : >, ,  7 ,  3*   !4, (!!3( >(* !3   .,(! ! , *8 * *( : , ) )*!,.33 @ )78 :,.3 
, !,.3

. :@ )783/) !,.3* ( *!3, (4,7 
 , >3*/ ! , .3 *  @ )783/ , *8 * )(

8 ,.3

,*:4 3( /,2) D*.3>(* 24*!3 
) *4*(!(4*4.-,.3 
(-4 * .3. *4.-3 (* , 8(7  3* )(

   8  , .3 2) D*.3/,!/)(

.?4* 3

,*8 */,!/:,72)3,8 D*.3 ,*. :*4*,?4* !.()=@* :

,!4,(!!3(>,*8)!7 :,-8( )!,@  *(*(*4 3+@ 54444, 7 $ '7"

#

$ $ 

$ 



'&%

$

%

'

$ $



$ '

"

6$ $ 

7

 -6$ # -$







'&%

7$ 

$ 

 % % 

 $ ()7 $  7

 "

# - $

  

'&%

 #

 $ 

 $  '

"

 6$

$ 

4448

! ) *3 : , -84:

3 3/  * )**(7  ) *4, )(4*@!,3(3 ) : 3*>,),>

?43( -7 (.*,*8 *.()=@*(.33 !>7(* , !*!(4)(74@ !* @  .3 ,.()=@* :3* !>(*(-(!)4*!(83 ! > 7(*    ,>* 
 * -7 (   (. : 8*


 *

)**(7!,(4,*) *3,!()*( 3))4-*( )*!, )(**8)(7,(* *!,!(4!,.33)-87>,, -( 3(7) *( 3, (=(  !-33)*

 *( )/! ,(4,7)-*,) )4* ,(( * 7 (3 ( . (!3( 3,(,33 8243),8(7 :, 3*/ -(7 > (= (    >    , A  !  .()=@* : , .33((

,-84:

33 ((3,(.!()*( 3.*3,( , 8  >(* (>( ! , 8)4** * !  )(7 : 4 , @  ! ,   .3  , -84:

3 3/ ,>/ > :7 ,3,(,8 ,(3 8,7*)(7*4.-3,&>,),>(* (* ( -( 3(7 ?4-  
 * (3-3 ,( ,* *  )) *,( !(7 *(3*  , > *(-   (*3 ,* ))8-*/,-84:

33.*3(*!>*+@
   

  

 

     

      



  

     

   

    

    

       

    

     !      

    " 

      

      

 #    $      

    





  

    

     

            

      

 

    

 

   





 

   $%  

   

    

     &     

   

  

 

 %              





 

    ' (   $ )  

  *( +   ,-.--.,"             

 

  '

(  /

  

)  0 1 23*/4(+   

 5 , -84:

3 3/ ,!/ )(7 3*.* , 8 D*)(*,(*!(4>(*(--*(= , 4*.(** ,( , 8  ,(3 !(3  8,7*)(7 *4.- , &  , *  , :4 3   , .(** ! >,), , -84:

3 3 ,(* .  8(**3 ,(>?43(.*, 78(8(!,-84:

33 8 /,!/,(* . ,3:47!8 :

,(!!3(!3 ,*4(:38 : ,8 D*8(!,!*- , * (>,*8,*!!) ,-84:

33 , 7:4 3 >,),,-84:

33>(*8(**3. :(3-37 4*/ *!((* .()=@**,8 ( 3*/,!/(..*@(*3

$  , ))4-*( )*/ , -84:

3 3 * *@(*3  7  ,A ,(.()=@**,8 ,2) D*  3*/,>/48,3 ,>8 *())3 :73*8*3!

%6  5H
 ' 

  6
 $,)-./"# %
 6

6' I( 3D