← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12337/2017dismissed

Valuers Association And ORS. v. State Bank Of India And ANR.

2023-10-17Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj8 pages





     

  

 ! "#$# %&'' ( ) * **   * 

 * 

+,      & - ) ' *( *'

 '             

     .... ( *'

 / ' )   !       "#$#"$%# &'

(#)%*

+  ,"  --  %.$/"$%0&'

(%/*1  +         !    -  

 .(    2   3'

%4501  +  ' 

  +     +  -  

         

      1!!    &*          ! )       - 

       +          %6   7



&* 7             

      2  3')

%4508 &* 9:7  !    3' )

%450 -+9  

 !  !    ;+ -  <=>    

    --+     +    -   + 1   +!  +  (+:                     2  3'

%450

 -  7 

.( 3'

 %450     +   ! +   !      

1 ' -         +  3      3'

%450 '   

      

         !   "     #  " $

 %   &'( )) )))*    * + 

 %  ! &') ,   *( + 

 %  ! &'-) ,   *)    + 

 %       *)    ' 

 .#"/        "             ''

 ."  #         &'())    " &'())'" 7

      +     +;       -     (9: !

++ -   1

+- +     -!!    9: 7/$$5"$%# ?

!   +    2   3'  %450  

  -    1   (9: -   

 +    + 1   +       +  9:  

       --+     !

  + - !!++ 1  -- -    ! -  +1 9:  

  -!  -  !!- ! -  3  

    -  -    !!   1 9:3  -  !!-   !  +   ! - '  +1          3'%450

  



 +  +:

   - +-     2  3'%450   - +   1$%$6"$%#           3'%450 

+ 

+ 

  @ '  7    +     !

! 

 .(   2  3'

%450

!!  +  !+ !

   

1 ' -      -   -    + -- - +     - +:1 + +      ! - 1  +  

        +    !  7  

+-   2  3' %450

    1  +  +:1     +    9:  7  %455  

  !

            +    +  9: 7  + 1    +:     + !       

  + -           + !  +   !    9: 7           !!     +   +   9:       +! + !       !  ) 1 :  +:3     -

  +-+ +    -

       

    ;

     



 -      +  +   9: 7        79:





!

  )   +:

   1!    -  :     

+:!  3  

+ 79:



  1+ --+  +:

3  +!-  ( -   

+1     9:   

 +!      

           -      

      +      

       1 +1   7    +          ?

    +          -    - +   9: :!  1  

   ! 1 -  +



 +:        !

- )+ 1      !

 + 3  +  - -     !                 -     -   3   +!       -  !

        !

 1  ;

 1   + -+   !!-            +!    + -   ! +    +  +  +:

 !

  1  - +  +       ,%  "  %.$."$%. 1    ) ;   ! ( +     3'%450

  + +  

-        + 9: + !          !     !    ;+      +!  +      -   -   +   + ! +!  !   +  - -                  9: - @     !+ (9: 1    -   -       !           :!         !     !  +



+!!         - +!   +           !

    +        +     

  1   1   + -+    :!     A     !-+!       !! 

-   1   + ;

   !    !    !     1         !-            -          '  +1        

+; -     !        -  

 .(   +       + -- -  + ?

    !                   -'- -  +        9: 1     1      !!          )

 -  ! 1  -+ 

 -'- -    +  



7             

! !

 -    +   1   + 

  1!  - ! - 

     !

-  +    &*  -           '  +1 9:      +    +  +!  !+  9: &*       !      '  +1      1    9: 1  +   1  -    +   9: 1     '    -  

      ! - 1       &*   +  

.( 3' %450

 1   

   1$%$6"$%#         +       - 3   

  ;

     -   +              &*  ! -  '  +1     

+; -   !   -  9:     

 ! -           

&* +: !        +!         1   - +  +



  ?

 -  +



 !            !    +             !   1      + ! +   

- )+ 1      !    +   - + 1    &*   +  

       +     +     3 !

 '  1   ""#     :

   B    + 9: +            !

   1  

+       -   &*   !    -    !  -!!   +   +: ++    '     1   +          

+    9:!7   A  +     ?

  -

 1  7          -  3 -   !  -

 !     -   & *   & *      !  ( *'



'''    

.,* $0*1 . $0*1