Gurmukh Singh v. Supdt. Canal Officer Asr. & ORS.












 

  

 
 !

"#$

$%&'&()
"*
+
  ,-.,/0
1&(20  $#&#&($- 3$-','

1,4$-&(#$(5$(#
"("6
&%$-+
.-&#'"-

#0$-'  $'4(5$(#'

  ! "#$% &'()*
%*) $+&',-%

-$'$(#) -  ,(7"6+
58%"#$+ -
#0$
4$#&#&($- -"#&(5$-
10"-."+
556 ,(7"9+ -
#0$
1#"#$ -  "0"7"(+
1$(&-
58%"#$
:&#0
- -"#$$/
"0"7"(+
58%"#$+ -
-$'4(5$(#
; <<<<<







































*) $+&.

-"*$-
&(
#0$
4-$'$(#
:-&#
4$#&#&(
&'

-
=,"'0&(2
#0$
-5$- 5"#$5
> 
(($?,-$
@!
4"''$5
9*
#0$
1,4$-&(#$(5&(2
"("6 &%$- -  ,(7"6+
6$"-($5
%,('$6
-
#0$
4$#&#&($-
',9.&#'
#0"# #0$
1,4$-&(#$(5&(2
"("6
&%$-
0"'
'$#@"'&5$
#0$
-5$-'

#0$
1,9 &8&'&("6
&%$-
"(5
#0$
&8&'&("6
"("6
&%$-
:&#0
-$2"-5
#
#0$ -$'#-"#&(

#0$
:"#$-%,-'$
AB
:&#0,#
"58$-#&(2
#
%$-#"&(
5%,.$(#'+ &(%6,5&(2
#0$
-$4-#'

#0$
C&6$5"-
"(5
#0$
1,9
&8&'&("6
&%$-+
.,%0 6$''
"'
#
0:
#0$
-5$-'

#0$
"-$.$(#&($5
",#0-&#&$'
"-$
:-(2 (
#0$
%(#-"-*+
-  "0"7"(+
6$"-($5
1$(&-
%,('$6 "''&'#$5
9*
- -"#$$/
"0"7"(+
-$4-$'$(#&(2
-$'4(5$(#
;
',9.&#'
#0"#



#0$
1,4$-&(#$(5&(2
"("6
&%$-
0"5
%(5,%#$5
#0$
'4#
&('4$%#&(

"(5 4-$4"-$5
#0$
/'@'0&7-"
"(5

(#&%$5

#0"#
#0$-$
:"'
(
4-

5$.6&#&( 
#0$
:"#$-
%,-'$
$
"6'
-$%-5$5
"
&(5&(2
#0"#
:"#$-%,-'$
&'
&( $?&'#$(%$
&(
/0"'-"


$%#  
0"8$
0$"-5
#0$
6$"-($5
%,('$6
-
#0$
4"-#&$'
"(5
"44-"&'$5 #0$
4"4$-
9/

-
#0$
'"/$

9-$8&#*+

#0$
-$6$8"(#
4-#&(

#0$
&(5&(2'
 #0$
1,4$-&(#$(5&(2
"("6
&%$-
-$"5'
"'
,(5$-)@ D
   

                

   

                             



       



   



 !"# $%"$ !    

&'( )     



*  +

 %  %,  %,"     



 

 

   -           

       + 

#   .  

 $ 
 

  /           

    



    

 

 0 1201  2  

 0 2 0*20*2 032+

 %,  %,"

. 

 $4  





         %$55  

  /     *  
    

       6 0$
-$6$8"(#
4-#&('

#0$
-$4-#'

#0$
C&6$5"-
"(5
#0$
1,9 &8&'&("6
&%$-
"-$
-$4-5,%$5
"'
,(5$-)@

/

D

$4-#

#0$
C&6$5"-

    4 1

7!%8. .   9
 *   

   

 0 2101 1  

  

 012 0 2 

   +

# . 

 $4   

 

 0 2 0*2

 



  : 

 

 012 0 2   $4,#   +      

  

 ;



  

 

012 0 2
 

/ 



     

  

    012    0 2    



    %$55  *   <=%6 .

  * > 

 

 ?  

  

                    
 

  

 )       

   

 01 0 2/    



 

   



   %$55   











   6 (
%(7&(#
-$"5&(2

#0$
-$4-#'

#0$
C&6$5"-
"(5
#0$
1,9 &8&'&("6
&%$-+

".

#0$
8&$:
#0"#
#0$
1,4$-&(#$(5&(2
"("6
&%$- 0"'
(#
"58$-#$5
#
9#0
#0$
-$4-#'
$
0"'
(#
2&8$(
"(*
-$"'(&(2
"'
# 0:
#0$
-5$-'

#0$
1,9
&8&'&("6
&%$-
"(5
#0$
&8&'&("6
"("6 &%$-
"-$
:-(2
$-#"&(
"%#'
0"8$
"6'
(#
9$$(
(#&%$5
$(#"&6&(2
#0$ "%%$4#"(%$

#0$
"44$"6
0&'
&'
:0"#
'%4$

#0$
"44$"6
&'
"8&(2
(# "58$-#$5
#
#0$
"-$.$(#&($5
9"'&%
-$=,&-$.$(#+

".

#0$
8&$:
#0"#
#0$



."##$-
-$=,&-$'
#
9$
-$@8&'&#$5
"#
#0$
6$8$6

#0$
1,4$-&(#$(5&(2
"("6 &%$-

$',6#"(#6*+
#0$
-5$-

#0$
1,4$-&(#$(5&(2
"("6
&%$-
&' '$#@"'&5$
0$
."##$-
&'
-$.&##$5
9"%/
#
#0$
1,4$-&(#$(5&(2
"("6
&%$- %(%$-($5
:&#0
"
5&-$%#&(
#
5$%&5$
#0$
."##$-
"-$'0
&(
8&$:

#0$ 9'$-8"#&('
."5$
"98$+
.,%0
6$''
#0$
-&8"6
%(#$(#&('

#0$
6$"-($5 %,('$6
-
#0$
4"-#&$'
-
#0$-
"55&#&("6
$8&5$(%$
:0&%0
#0$
4"-#&$'
&(#$(5 #
-$6*+
:&#0&(
"
4$-&5

#:
.(#0'
-.
#0$
5"#$

-$%$&4#

%$-#&&$5 %4*

#0&'
-5$-
0$
4"-#&$'+
#0-,20
#0$&-
%,('$6
"-$
5&-$%#$5
#
"44$"-
9$-$ #0$
1,4$-&(#$(5&(2
"("6
&%$-
%(%$-($5
(
;  -&#
4$#&#&(
'#"(5'
5&'4'$5
 .0+  *) $ .1 &',-% 3 3 24 .5 67 .2

3 3 

.: