Sukhmandar Singh v. State Of Punjab & ORS


























    
  
  



   

  
  

  








!

#$
"%"

 &%'
%

" $















(

"$
 !""














#$
"%"

 &%'
%

" $















(

"$

  #



*%+&

"







#$
"%"

 &%'
%

" $















(

"$
$  %&  '
'(

)''     $

,
(% $
'"-
.

#/%"

-

)

0







%

  
 
,
1%%+ )
 
 -
.

#/%"

-


)

0
*%+&

"
 



 
 ,

%% )

"
 -
.$$$"% "
.

#/%"

2

%+-
 &%' ***  

  
!"  3$




$%++
$)$ $%

4"
) $
%$
/
5 $" $

+%4
%

%/"$
% #+#




   

'7
)


8


 -

)%7 
$

5%$

 
"



"
"
" "-
%

%+$
5%$

4

'7
)

$"))%
"4
%

%+





















 

"$
4"
/+%"#

/"
%$
'

)$


.+$
5%$

: -
4

'7
"


4%$
) $

4"
$"))%
"4

"$
4""
/+%"#

/"




   !"  "

'7
)

0


 -

)%7 
$

5%$


4

'7
"
%$
'

"
)%7

$%+%7

)$"




.$$$"% "
 $"

)

"
2%

066
;" 
)%7 
$

)$"

%$
)

2%

066
%

%$
$%+%7




/7
 4"
) 

:

    #  

'7
)


*%+&

"
 )+

+,-./+.0 . 12.      -

)%7 
$
5%$

 

4

'7


:
8


 
3420-+0202.+42.05+64+,62/3420-+0202.,2+ ,  6./!""
%$
'

)"

"
"
)

2%

066

*

;%/"$


6"
$
$"%"

"%"


8




"
"
" "
4%$
/%++






%

$"%7



4%$
 "%++7
)%$$

 


4%$
$"%7




<

-
$"%"$
5



4%$
)%$$

'7
"$
"
 

  
 
3

"$
%#


)+7
4

"
%$
'

$"%"

"%"



$$

)$"


8
%


 
%$
)

"
2%

066


/
'0





















 
=#$ %+
,% $"%"

-
,%

 
3

"$
%#
%+$

%$

$%+%7





3 



%

"
"

 
4%$
#%/%"

#

 



4%$




-
,

:0
 
 

  
 
%$
'

#

'7
"

"0
"%"

#%/%"





$
"%"
"

/% )+


6"
$
$"%"

"%"
)





 
$

)

$"))%
"4


"$
4"
/+%"#

/"
#


.)) %+
% % $"
"
$%


4%$
& /"

  
*7
% "

: -

4%$
% %
) $

4"
$"))% "4
%

%+


"$
4""
/+%"#

/"
+%"
"
%
$ )%%"

/% 
.)) %+
"

"
4%$
& /"

  


3
)$"




.$$$"% "
4%$
"
'

++

'7
4%7
 )" 
+ $-
4
%#
4 >)

 
# %$
?%+


8



 
4%$
4 +7
)"

%$


:
 
)

"$
4 -
"
4%$

%+@

"%"

/

/7


%+"7
)  -

/+ "
%#
'

)"

-
"

-
"

)"
4%$
0/%++


4%$

'%/
"
$
  %+
)$"
#

 
6"
%$
'

$"%"

"%"
"
/

/7

)

"



4+
$##
)"
: -
"

-

4%$

"
" "
3

 
4%$
/%++

'7








$%


4%$
$"%7

'7
"$
"
#

 
6
 4+ -


)

"
2%

066

++
#%/% "
%

% $






















:
)

0



%

:
*%+&

"
 
4

$

'7
"

)%"

"



8



'

$


4%$
)"

%$
)

"
2%

066
 
$'& /"
"
%+
"/





 -
"

-
&

%$
)

"
2%

066


 
3

A$
/%++




  
 
"
"

  
"

"
"
)$"




.$$$"% "
%$
'

/

"
4 -
" 
"4
4"
) $-


'7
)




'

%





%



 


'7
)


8
*%+&

"
 


:


$



%

$$
$
+%"
"
" $%
%$) /"$-
"
4+
%)))%"

"

/

%++7
%++
"

4"
) $
"

-
"

-
" 7
4


" 









$'"$
"%"
"

 
"


"

"
"
"
% 
%#
4



"%

7 %$

  
)$"
'%$

7$
/)+% "
4%$
++ %+
%

 &$"

3


%+$
/%++

$
"

 
4

'7

4%$
) $

4"
$"))%
"4


"$
4"
/+%"#

/"
%

%+$

:
4

'7

4%$
) $

4"
$"))%
"4

%+


"$
4""
/+%"#

/"


3$
"

$
"%"
"
/%++

"
"

:
$
 +7
'

+%"


3
)

"
%$
'

%4%

"
)


8


"
"%
%/" +
(.
% % $"

&

"
)%$$


%)) %+

'7
"
#

 



+ ""

 



"%
$"

)$
 "" )+ $






















""

$
"%"
"

$"
%

"
#

"
$
"
%

/"


3 )


%#


+"7

$%
/% $
% 
# ))" "7

'

 -
%)) %+
4%$
%+$


$$$

% % $"
"

)

"
<
%//
$
 %/" -


+%)$

7 %$-
(.
/+ "
'


3$-
"
%++ %" $
%#

)#

'7
" ?

57
<

/

=$/)+ %7
.""7
%$
)%$$


3

$


)/

%+
++ %+"7
4+
)%$$
)

$
"
4%% "


 

"

:
)

$"))%

"4


"$
4""
/+%"#

/"
%$
'

)%$$


/

)$
 
)

%+"7
4%$
+7
% )"

0


4%$
) $

"
$

+%"
"

57

,%
%% %
,%


"
"
=$"/"
.""

7-
*%"

%
3$-
"
$
%
/%$
4

)


%$
'

/ $"% "+7
$+%/
$
" $
+%"
"
4%"/

$"

"%"

2#

"

"
/%$ $-

4/

%$
'

) $


1

)

# 4
"

"-
"
)%7 
%

'7
"

5%$
$%
)


$
%+$


"
'

4""
'%$$
%

%+$
% " "
%

+%"

-


+7
"
)"

/"
$ 


"

"
"
4/

4%$
)"

4""
"%

"

)

$
6"
$
$ ""+

+%4
"%"
%
) $
4
%$
'

) $

+ 5

/ $
/%

"
'

%4%

)"
%"
"
$%
" 
%# "/

"%"
"4
%

%+


"$
4"
/+%"#

/"
%$
'

$"))

-
" )


/+ "
%#
'

)"

'7
"

"0

)%"

"
%

%$
$
%$
"
$% 
4%$
"/

-
"
$%
/+
/ /"


B






















/ $ +

"

"0
"%"

%$
+

)
%
//+%
$$

+%"
"

$
)" $-
4/
$
%$


0
C


  

 



  
 








 
 

  
 




  






 






 
 
  


 






  
 

  

   
  




 
  
 





  
 








 
 








 
 

 
!
"

 







 
!

  
 

   


 

 

 




#


  


 




 


$


 
 
"

 







 
!

  


   

 
 



!
 



  
 




 


 

 

  




 

 


   

 

%

 



 


 





 

&'  

(  
'


)
( *
+,-.

 $$$/0
 
*.,.

1,2 3
:
3$
"
%+$
"/



 
 
8
!#   $#  %   &  '((     #

/

   -

%
$ 4%"
$+%
$"%"
4

%
) $
4%$
)"

4

++7
4""
"/
.($

$%

# %+
3
)" %4%

%+ 
4%$
0/%++

$
4%$


3

4%$
/%++

"$
"
%

"$
"
++4 &

"$
"

#) $# ) ) *+ #-
























:
(9-
-
=#$
*

/
&

1% %"%%
 
"


# ),  -  #-

: 
(9-

&


9

.

%
%

$
 
"
 * 

)  & ! $" %  . /-

 
B(-
 
3

#% >"%/"

!#  $#4$
/%$
$)%-
$
%$


0
5$
 




 




 





 
60 1 67*6
+8



..*7-
 

 "

 
!

  
 
8 
"

 


9  

: 
 

 

 


 




 

 

 

%




" 
!



!
:





 


  



 


#
# ;

+ -


 





 



 











  
 


   

< 

 

 







 

 

 
$
 





















   




 
$
  


# 
 
= >
) :
+ -



 






 








 




% 
 

% 
   



  
 
 

 


 
!




  




 
 

 



 

  








 
  3


+ "

%'# -
"$
"

$
"%"
)


8



/+ "
'

/ "

"
"
4/

%

4 +7
)"


$

-
"

-
%$
 "+7
'

)%$$


6"
$
%+$
"/

"%"
"$
"

 
#%/%"





)%$$

%+
 
$"%7





















 
8



 
3
$ /

4"
)



 )

-
% +7-


  
 
$
%
/ $ 5

"%+
4"
) <


8



$


"
'

 "

++7



"
"
" "-
" 
)"

"

$'& /"
"
%+
"/





4+ %+$
%#
"

.// +7-
"
4"
) -
% +7-


  




'7
)


8



)$"
%$
)

2%

066
"

%"

%$
)"


4/

%$
%+ 7
'


"
'

 "+7

$-
"

-
4""
 "$

$%

$ $
"
'

$$$






 

$
%
4"
)

'7
*%+&

"
 -
%
) $
4
$
& 
"
)


8



 
%

/+%$
)"
)$"

)

"
2%

066
+
"%
 "
/ $

%"

$
)%$$



%'#

"%"
)" %4%

"






:



 
 -
4"
)






%



  
 
$



"
'

$$'+ 
3
$%
$
%// +7
%++4


3
/%$ )


*%+&

"
 
$%++
4
'

/ $

%$
) 
$
$ #/ /
'7
+
=-

*%+&

"
 
$


"
'

$"%'+ -

$
"
'

)"




6"
 $
4""
$%7
"%"


:
8


$%++
%+$
'

/ $

-
%
/)+ "
/

/7

)

"-


)" 
" "
"


"
4 -

$%
$%++
"
 7
%

/"
)


8
*%+&

"
 " )"
"
"
)

"
2%

066


.// +7-


 


'7
)


*%+&

 
$
%++4


.++


%))+/%" $
%+$
$"%

6773+/
%// +7
























$



%



  
 
% %// +7
/2,82,,+/
.++
)

%))+/%" $
"

%+$
$$$

.++
 


$
$%++
$"%

#%/%"


/$"$
     9'(

)'' : #$


















   

 % 







?
@ 








)
 

>  

?
@ 








)