High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/10736/2018disposed of

M/S Hometrail Estate Pvt. Ltd. v. The State Of Punjab & ANR.

2018-08-27Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal,Mr. Justice Amit Rawal6 pages

$%& &'()(*+ ",) -&%.$(/ )%$%&0%1%2 &%(%(*&.

3&.)4) 5&6%$%& 4*7$8$*2$*%5&. &)9*2&*%)

.&)&*%+ ".)5:;4-$.<<$.=$/>6&*(.20'$%&=(%5 ".4*&&%<.$=$/>20'$%&$*2 ")4.0(6(*5$>20'$%&

.%5&9&%(%(*&. ".$*:$7 49%$>22/ >4*7$8

5&9&%(%(*&.5$) (/&2%5&9.&)&*%9&%(%(*(-94<*(*<%5& .2&. 2$%&2 ? **&@4.& # $*2 $))&))-&*% .2&. 2$%&2 **&@4.&#=5&.&8A%5&$))&))(*<$4%5.(%A5$)/&0(&2%$@ *%5&5&$/%5'$.&)&.0('&)9.0(2&28A%5&9&%(%(*&.%(*2.9$%(&*%)(* %5&5)9(%$/ *)499.% %5&$.<4-&*%)>.&/($*'&5$)8&&*9/$'&249*$ (0()(*&*'5742<-&*% 4.%(*

%(%/&2$)B

B(*=5('5(2&*%('$/())4&5$)8&&*2&'(2&2$*2%5() 4.%5$) 9(*&2%5$%%5&-&2('(*&)(*%5&5&$/%5'$.&)&.0('&)9.0(2&2%%5& (*2.9$%(&*%)()*%%$@$8/&$)%5&$-4*%'5$.<&2'$**%8&8( 4.'$%&2 %'4//4%$-4*% )$/& -&2('(*&)>&0&*( %5&$-4*%())&9$.$%&/A '5$.<&2 .95$.-$'A>/$8.$%.A)&.0('&)>(-9/$*%))&.0('&)9.0(2&28A %5&2'%.)$)(%()$'-9)(%&-&2('$/)&.0('&9.0(2&2

*%5&%5&.5$*2>/&$.*&2'4*)&/ .%5&6%$%&=5(/&*% 2()94%(*<%5&742<-&*%.& &..&2%%5() 4.%(* #$% &')48-(%%&2%5$%%5&6%$%&5$)9.& &..&269&'($/1&$0& &%(%(*$<$(*)%%5&$ .&)$(28& .& *B8/&%5&649.&-& 4.%=5('5() )%(//9&*2(*<$*2%5&.&$.&'*%.$.A0(&=)%$:&*8A%5&;&.$/$ (<5 4.% (*B () *+ $ ,*)$B # ?

6 ;&.# =&0&.>5&'4/2*%9(*%4%%5$%%5&.&()$*A(*%&.(- )%$A<.$*%&28A *B8/&%5&649.&-& 4.%.&<$.2(*<%5&9&.$%(* 742<-&*%2&/(0&.&28A%5() 4.% %&.5&$.(*</&$.*&2'4*)&/ .%5&9$.%(&)$*2'*)(2&.(*< %5&'*%&*%(*).$()&2>(*4.0(&=>%5&9.&)&*%9&%(%(*2&)&.0&)%8& $//=&2=5(/&)&%%(*<$)(2&%5&.2&. $))&))-&*%2$%&2

**&@4.&#$)%5&)$-&() )C4$.&/A'0&.&28A%5&742<-&*%

(0()(*&*'5 4.%9$))&2(* # $% &'5(/&2&'(2(*< # $ % &'>%5() 4.%5$2 //=&2%5&742<-&*% 5$.:5$*2 (<5 4.% 9$))&2(*B, & , -(

B> # 5.#>$<$(*)%=5('569&'($/1&$0&&%(%(*=$)2()-())&2&/&0$*% 9$.$) .-742<-&*% 4.%(* # $% &'$.&&@%.$'%&28&/=./ D& 5$0& '*)(2&.&2 %5& .&/&0$*% )%$%4%.A 9.0()(*) %5&4*7$8$*2 $.A$*$6%$%4%&)>%5& (5$. (*$*'& '%> %5& %%$. .$2&)5 '%> %5& 742<-&*% %5& 5$.:5$*2 $*2 //$5$8$2 (<5

4.%)>742<-&*%) %5&;&.$/$ (<5 4.% '(%&28A %5&.&)9*2&*%)#$.&(*.&)9&'% 4/$<.&&-&*%=(%5%5&

9(*(*.&'.2&28A%5&5$.:5$*2 (<5 4.%$*2%5& //$5$8$2 (<5 4.%$*2 (*2*.&$)*%.&'.2$ '*%.$.A 9(*(* . % 5/2 %5$% %5& )499/A

-&2('(*&)> 2.4<)> )%&*%)> (-9/$*%) &%' % $ 9$%(&*% 24.(*<$-&2('$/9.'&24.&(*5&.)$*A&/&-&*% )$/&> -4'5 /&)) )&%) 4% %5&(*<.&2(&*%) $ B)$/&B5& 9=&.%(-9)&)$/&)%$@,3 /=) .- *%.A? 1()% 6'5&2(/&3$*2.%('/&

*)%(%4%(*> %5& /$%%&. $))(<*(*< %5& )%$%4) $ 2&&-&2)$/&%%.$*)$'%(*)=5&.&*&.%5&%5&. &/&-&*% )$/&()-())(*<>84%=5&.&%5&&/&-&*%

)$/&()$/%<&%5&.-())(*<$*2%5&%.$*)$'%(*2&)*%

$//=(%5(*$*A %5&'/$4)&) .%('/&

%5& *)%(%4%(* *2($> $ 6%$%& )5$// *% 8& &-9=&.&2 % /&0A 0$/4& $22&2 %$@ * )4'5 $ %.$*)$'%(* . %5& 94.9)& $%%.$'%(*< 3> $ %.$*)$'%(*.$9$.%%5&.& >=5('5()&))&*%($//A$ )&.0('&=4/2 5$0&%C4$/( A$)$)$/&=(%5(*%5& -&$*(*< 6$/&) 2)'%>E .%5&2& (*(%(* )$/&5& ('%(* $2&&-&2)$/&$99/(&)*/A% )4'5)(%4$%(*)$)=4/2 $//=(%5(*%5&)48'/$4)&)

.%('/&

E# %5& *)%(%4%(* *2($=5('5 9&.-(%)&0&.$*'& %5&)&.0('&&/&-&*% .-%5&)$/& &/&-&*%$*2&-9=&.)%5&6%$%&%%$@%5&&/&-&*%

)$/& 9&.4)$/ .%('/&

E# %5&

*)%(%4%(* *2($2&)*%&*$8/&4)%.&'.2$* 9(*(*%5$%(%'0&.))&.0('&)9.0(2&28A5)9(%$/) & .&)4'5$%.$*)$'%(*()94%%%$@>=5&%5&.4*2&. %5& $.A$*$.4*7$83'%>(%=4/25$0&% )$%() A%5&2-(*$*%*$%4.&%&)%8A.& &.&*'&%%5& )48)%$*'& %5& '*%.$'% '*%.$'% . -&2('$/ %.&$%-&*% *&'&))$.(/A(*0/0&)-&2('(*&)>)499/A

)4.<('$/(%&-)>)%&*%)>(-9/$*%)>0$/0&)>=(%54%=5('5

$-&2('$/9.'&24.&.-&2('$/%.&$%-&*%'$**%8& '-9/&%&25&)499/A %5&)&$.%('/&)$)5&/28A%5& //$5$8$2$*2%5&5$.:5$*2 (<5 4.%)$.&(*%&<.$/ %$*2&))&*%($/ .%5&%.&$%-&*%

&.&2%9$%(&*%) $*2&0&*( *&-$A'$%&<.(F&%5&)&$)(*'(2&*%$/% %5&$'%4$/-&2('$/9.'&24.&>*&'$**%84%(<*.& %5$%$-&2('$/9.'&24.&'$**%8&'-9/&%&2=(%54% )499/A -&2('(*&)>2.4<)>)%&*%)>(-9/$*%)>%5&.&8A /&$2(*<%$)(*<4/$.'*'/4)(*%5$%%5&6%$%&()*% &-9=&.&24*2&.$*A9.0()(* %5& *)%(%4%(* -4'5/&))%5&2& (*(%(* <2)>)$/&.2&$/&.>% )&0&.&%5&'*%.$'%$*2'*)%.4&%5&)499/A 2.4<)> -&2('(*&)>)%&*%)>(-9/$*%)&%'$)$)&0&.$8/&9$.%

%5&'*%.$'%$*2>%5&.& .&>&@(<(8/&%3>$)$)$/& 5&)(%4$%(*=4/280(4)/A8&2(

&.&*%( %5&)& $.%('/&)$.&)499/(&2 .-%5&95$.-$'A $5)9(%$/ 2&&-(*< ('%(*>-4)% 8& .$%(*$/ $*2 *%

$.'('$/ 5& 2-(*$*% 94.9)& $ 5)9(%$/ () % 9.0(2& -&2('$/ %.&$%-&*% $*2 ( 24.(*< $-&2('$/ 9.'&24.&(%().&C4(.&2%9.0(2&-&2('(*&)>)%&*%)> (-9/$*%)&%'>(%'$**%8A$2&&-(*< ('%(*8&5&/2% 8&$D)$/&G9$%(&*%-$A5$0&$'5('&$)%%5& C4$/(%A (-9/$*%,)%&*% 84% &0&* %5$% '5('& () '* (*&2%%5&)4(%$8(/(%A $)%&*%&%'5& $'%%5$%$ 5)9(%$/-$A'5$.<&-*&A .(*2(0(24$/)%&*%)&%'> =5&%5&.$)9$.% $9$':$<&.)&9$.$%&/A()&*%(.&/A (..&/&0$*%'*%.$'% -&2('$/)&.0('&'$**%8& )$(2%8&$'*%.$'% .)$/& $)%&*%>.0$/0&.

-&2('(*&)%8&4)&2(*$-&2('$/,)4.<('$/9.'&24.& 5& &))&*%($/ &/&-&*% )4'5 $ '*%.$'% () %5& 9.'&24.& :*&& .&9/$'&-&*%> 5(9 .&9/$'&-&*%> $*<(9/$)%A>=5('5$)$*(*%.(*)('$*2(*%&<.$/9$.% (*0/0&)9/$'(*<$*(-9/$*%=5&%5&.(*%5&:*&&>5(9

? .$5&$.%&%'5&*/A'5('&$0$(/$8/&%%5&9$%(&*% ()%5&*$%4.& %5&(-9/$*%>*$-&/A>(%)C4$/(%A84% )4'5$9.'&24.&()$2-(%%&2/A>$-&2('$/9.'&24.& $*2$)&.0('&%5$%'$**%8&'-9/&%&2=(%54%$* (-9/$*%,2.4<)$*2-&2('(*&)$)$*(*%&<.$/9$.% 9.'&24.&9.(0$%&5)9(%$/2&)*%9.0(2&-&2('$/ )&.0('&) . .&&5& $'%%5$%(%'5$.<&)-*&A> .

2.4<)> -&2('(*&) &%' '$**% .$()& $* (* &.&*'&

(*%&*%%)&//<2)(*%5&)5$9& -&2('(*&)>)%&*%)> (-9/$*%)&%'&$.&>%5&.& .&>(*'-9/&%&$<.&&-&*% =(%5 %5& 9(*(* .&'.2&2 8A %5& 5$.:5$*2 (<5

4.% (*

)49.$# $*2 %5& //$5$8$2 (<5 4.%(*

*$.<4-&*%%5$%%5&2& (*(%(* D)$/&G4*2&.

%5& (5$. $*2 %5& %%$. .$2&)5 '%)> () &*%(.&/A 2(

&.&*%>-4)%$/) $(/9&.4)$/ %5&2& (*(%(*

)$/&(*%5&(5$.$*2%5&%%$..$2&)56%$%4%&).&0&$/) %5$% %5() $.<4-&*% 5$) $99$.&*%/A 8&&* .$()&2 8A 2().&<$.2(*<%5&2& (*(%(* )$/&(*%5&)&)%$%4%&) =5('5$.&&))&*%($//A(2&*%('$/%%5&2& (*(%(* )$/& %5&9.&)&*%)%$%4%& &%5&.& .&>5$0&*5&)(%$%(*(*5/2(*<%5$% -&2('$/9.'&24.&),)&.0('&)

&.&28A%5&9&%(%(*&.) $.&$)&.0('&5&)499/A 2.4<)>-&2('(*&)>(-9/$*%> )%&*%)> 0$/0&) $*2 %5&. (-9/$*%) $.& (*%&<.$/ % $ -&2('$/)&.0('&),9.'&24.&)$*2'$**%8&)&0&.&2% (* &.$)$/&$)2& (*&24*2&.%5&4*7$8.%5& $.A$*$ '% $*2%5&.& .&>$.&*% &@(<(8/&% 0$/4&$22&2 %$@0 5& '*%&*%(*) .$()&2 8A /&$.*&2 '4*)&/ . %5& 6%$%& .&<$.2(*<742<-&*% ;&.$/$ (<5 4.%()%%$//A-()'*'&(0&2 .%5&

.&$)*%5$%(* #$% &'1 (0()(* &*'5 742<-&*% 4.% 5$2 $/.&$2A8&&*'*)(2&.&2 &0&*%5& $ .&)$(2742<-&*% *%5&=.(%9&%(%(*>*4-8&. %5&./&<$/())4&)5$0&$/) 8&&*.$()&2)%5&'/$(--$2&8A%5&9&%(%(*&.())C4$.&/A'0&.&28A%5& 742<-&*% 4.%>=&*&&2*%%<(*%%5&%5&.())4&)5&)$-& $.&/& %9&*%8&'*)(2&.&2(*$*A$99.9.($%&'$)& 5&=.(%9&%(%(*)%$*2)$//=&2 6 1#

"1#

5&%5&.)9&$:(*<,.&$)*&2+ &), 5&%5&..&9.%$8/&+ &),