High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/10762/2018dismissed

Raghbir v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2018-09-14Mr. Justice Amit Rawal4 pages

!" "#$%$&'

!" "#$%$&'( ( ( ( ) ) ) ) *+,$- "!$!$&"- .% ! !" -/ & &0!+"-% "%1&0"&!% 2'3 42552 2'3 42552 2'3 42552 2'3 42552 -"%"&!' 2-.5$&0 6708# !"7 -!+"1"!$!$&"- 2- +962+ &7 7 -/ & 5527 5527 5527 5527 +" 1"!$!$&"- + % #+ 66"&*"0 !+" -0"- 0 !"0

) ,/ :+$#+ +$% 116$# !$& - 1-"; !9-" -"6" %" + % ,""& 0$%;$%%"0 ,/ -"%1&0"&! &,-$"

7!+"1"!$!$&"-: %!-$"0$& # %"-"*$%!"-"08$0" <)0 !"0 )<)))9&0"-"#!$&%= =7= (>= !+"&0$ &"& 6 0"7 ?

-%+-!@!+"3A !6$#"! !$&$!/7 -& 96": % +"60*9$6!/ -#;;$!!$&* &

"&#"19&$%+ ,6"9&0"-"#!$&%= >= = !+",/!+""%%$&%90*"7 -& 96& &0: % : -0"06$ " $;1-$%&;"&! & !+" % ;" 0 / +" 1"!$!$&"- $6"0 ((

:+$#+: %0$%;$%%"0&= ,/!+$%9-!+"1"!$!$&"-+ 0 19-"0B!+-:&%961+9-$# #$091& ;"%+C0"#" %"0D& )<))) &0+$% 0" !++ 0##9--"0&= <)))!$%-"#-0"0$&!+"-0"-0 !"0= !+ !E -9; & 9!! C 7+#&09#!"0 9!1%/&!+"0" 0,0/ ;"%+7+ 0 9&0!+"%F$& ;"%+#--0"0:$!+%$*&% $& 6 ;; !$& &6"

!%$0" !+"!";11 -$"! 6 -" 7 -&! 6 &06"

!"/"76"

!%$0"&%"76"

! %$0" #"7#+$&76"

!" -7&"#F % :+6"7 -&! #+"%!7 ,0;"& % :+6"7

-$*+! -; &!"-;"0$ 66/7 6"

! -" -; &0 + &0% 0-% 66/7 6"

! -; &0

-" -; 0-% 66/ &0 &!"-$-6/7 6"

! &0 1 6; 0-% 66/7 ,!+ 6:"- B=-0 !+$*+ &!"-$-6/ &0F&""76"

!%$0", #F % :+6"76"

!"/"#-&" &0,!+ %+960"-%66!+",9-&%6"%$&%:"-" &!";-!";$&& !9-"+"0" !+7$& !+"1$&$& !+"0#!-7: %09"!%+#F % -"%96! #--%$8",9-&% :+$#+:"-"%9

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

!+"6$#/:960#;"$&!16 /&6/ !"-!+"0" !+ &0&! % # 9%" 0" !+&%911-! +$%%9,;$%%$&7+"+ %-"

"--"0!!:0"#$%$&% -"&0"-"0,/!+$%9-!$&() () () () !$!6"0 %E -1 6$&*+ E -1 6$&*+ E -1 6$&*+ E -1 6$&*+ .% ! !" -/ & ! !" -/ & ! !" -/ & ! !" -/ & &0 &!+"- &0 &!+"- &0 &!+"- &0 &!+"-H 0"#$0"0 & &0 <<

<< !$!6"0 % E9-"&0"- E9-"&0"- E9-"&0"- E9-"&0"- .% ! !" -/ & ! !" -/ & ! !" -/ & ! !" -/ & &0 !+"-% &0 !+"-% &0 !+"-% &0 !+"-%H 0"#$0"0& = & !+" !+"- + &07 6" -&"0 #9&%"6 - !+" -"%1&0"&!% + % %9,;$!!"0!+ !!+"# %" !+"1"!$!$&"-:960 66$&6 9%" !+" 6$#/ ,"# 9%" !+" 1"!$!$&"- + 0 %+:& ,-9! 6$!/ ,/ # 9%$&* 0" !+ ;"%+79%$&*961+9-$# #$07:+$#+: %19-"0B!+-:&8"-+$%,0/ &0 # 9%"0"I!"&%$8",9-&%& ##9&! :+$#++"#960&!%9-8$8""8"&$&!+"

= +%1$! 6 0 / !"-!+"##9--"&#"!$% 6%%9,;$!!"0!+ !!+"1"!$!$&"- + % 9&0"-*&" /" -% ( ;&!+% &0 0 /% #!9 6 %"&!"&#" &0 /" -% ;&!+% &0<0 /% !! 6%"&!"&#":$!+-";$%%$& %& ,9!+"+ %!9&0"-*(/" -% #!9 6%"&!"&#" &0 /" -% !! 6%"&!"&#" %+$%# %" 66%:$!+$&!+"0"

$&$!$& @+"$&9%#-$;"3!$% 6%%9,;$!!"0 !+ ! 6 9%" C DCI$$D !+" 6$#/ 0"% &! &/:+"-" % /% !+ ! $! :960 116/ !"-!+"0" !+ &0:960&! 116/ !!+"!$;" # 9%$&*0" !+ + 8" +" -0 6" -&"0 #9&%"6 - !+" 1 -!$"% &0 1"-9%"0 !+" -"#-0:$!+!+"$- ,6" %%$%! &#" +" $%%9" - #&%$0"- !$& - !+$% 9-! $% ,9! !+" $&!"-1-"! !$& 6 9%" !+"6$#/:+$#+1-8$0"% %9&0"-' E29-0"-"I+$,$!$&*,-9! 6$!/%9#+ %#9!!$&* !+",0/$&!1$"#"%-,9-&$&*B0- **$&*!+" ,0/ % "8$0"&! -; G90*";"&! !+" 9-!H

-" &/1$&$&$%"I1-"%%"0 ,9!!+"!-9"$;1-! 6 9%"

!+"6$#/7$!:960,"1"-!$&"&!!;"&!$&!+ !$&!+"6$#/ 0 !"0 7 116$# ,6"!!+$%# %"78 -$9%# !"*-$"% #&8$#!% &0!+" %"&!"&#"!+"/+ 8"!%9

"-,!+ #!9 6 &0:$!+-";$%%$& -!+"19-1%" %""F$&*1-"; !9-"-"6" %"+ 8",""&6 $00:&6 9%" !+" 6$#/0" 6%:$!+!+"#&8$#!%:+%"0" !+%"&!"&#"$%#;;9!"0!6$ " &0 !+" #&8$#!% :+ + 8" ,""& $;1-$%&"0 - 6$ " + 8$&* #;;$!!"0 +"$&9%#-$;"+"@+"$&9%#-$;"3$%0"

$&"0$&6 9%"% C DC$D!CI8$$D !+" 6$#/ ! $% 9-!+"- 1-8$0"0 !+"-"$& !+ ! $& %9#+ !/1" # %"%7 !+" #&8$#!+ %!%9

"-(/" -% #!9 6%"&!"&#"$&#690$&*9&0"-!-$ 61"-$0 &0 /" -% !! 6 %"&!"&#" $&#690$&* -";$%%$&% - !+" 19-1%" %""F$&*1-"; !9-"-"6" %"

( 08"-!$&* , #F ! 6 9%" C DCI$$D !+" 6$#/7 6" -&"0 #9&%"6 - !+" 1"!$!$&"- + % %9,;$!!"0 !+ ! $! :960 116/ !"- !+" #;;$%%$& ;9-0"- &0+ %! F"&!+"%911-! !:0"#$%$&%-"&0"-"0 ,/!+$%9-!$&!+"# %"% -1 6 -1 6 -1 6 -1 6$&*+ $&*+ $&*+ $&*+C91- D C91- D C91- D C91- D &09-"&0"-C91- D 9-"&0"-C91- D 9-"&0"-C91- D 9-"&0"-C91- D :"8"-7 ; !+"#&%$0"-"01$&$&!+ !6 9%" C DCI$$D !+" 6$#/ :960 116/ $& ,!+ !+" #$-#9;%! &#"% $" ! !+" !$;" # 9%$&*0" !+ &0 !"-#;;$!!$&*!+";9-0"-+":-09%"0$&6 9%"

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

!+"1"!$!$&"- :++ 0F$66"0 ;"%+,/19-$&*B!+-:$&*%961+9-$# #$0 668"-+$%,0/ # 9%$&*%"-$9%,9-&%:+$#+!F+$%6$ "&!+"&"I!0 !" !+"##9--"&#" $&!+"+%1$! 6"&#"70&! $&0 &/;"-$!$&!+"1-"%"&!:-$!1"!$!$& &0!+"% ;"$%+"-",/0$%;$%%"0 C552D C552D C552D C552D ( ( ( ( ) ) ) ) +"!

"%B +"!+"-"1-! ,6" '

"%B