High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/17718/2014allowed

Subhash v. State Information Commission Haryana & ORS

2016-07-26Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari11 pages

!"#"

$"%"

"" "

$ "

& '() $* + ,-

.//

-1-

-2

+

- "(.

3#4(!

5 55"

$""4"

! " "

" # "

"

$$$

55"

$""4"6!& *) %

""

# &'&()'*

+ ,-.

/

0

" &())&()1 *

+ ,&.

&0 "

003

"

3 )-)&&()1*

+ ,'.

" 3 004

"" %

0

"

#"

/" " # "

5#

+ -7*8,7* +* $ -72* + 0-

* 8*

88--

* + 7 -&) 59 #/

// #/" / "

"

"

/

"

" " %

6# 7 # 8

/

8 # "

"

# / #"

8

/" " # "

/ " " /

" "

/ # "

&')(&()1 *

+ ,). "

"

#

# #

" "

8 #

%

// # #

&((9 * : ;. 0 :5 "

% 5

"

# #

" "

/

%

)

# /

*

"" ./ # #

< & "

8

#

1

/

, # "" #<

"

'

" /

/ "< 9.

"

/

/ / "< "

#

-.

"

#

/ / # ""

"8

+

#

#

: =.

"

/

/ #

# /

# "

#

/ #

# / # ;

# #" ' " " #

0

"

## #

-*1.

#

"

#/ "#

/

8

"" // # #

"

"

#

%

/""

" "

0 "

"

" "

"

#

%

#/ # #

8 # /

/ " "8

+

#

%

" 8

#

/ #

# / #

/ #

&0 2 5 "

*

+ ,).

"

&())&()1*

+ ,&.

# / >"

"

" *5.

?*).

%

"

,

#" / "

"

/ "

"

"

/

"

" " 4 #/

"

/ " /

" 3 / "/ "

104 "" / " /" " # "

5#

+ -7*8,7* +*$ -72* + 3-,*- *. %

"/ "

)@*1.

/

"

"

/

"

#" /

, >"

"

#/5

""

# /

"

" #

7 8

/

## "

"

"

"

/ 8 8 #"

0

/" # /"

" # "

5#

+ -7 *8,7* +*$ -72* + 3-,*- *. "

;

/

"

/

"

/

# / "

"

/

"

"

%

"

5#

+ -7*8,7* +*$ -72* + 3-,*- *.

/

5 "

5# / "#

/

#/

"

" "

""

// # " " + + #

?*).*5.

"

# //

"

" //

%+ "

"

/ "

/ "

/

, "

"

# / # A 8 "

"

#

" / " /

" " "

"

/ " /

/ "

5# 0 )& %

#

""

, /

"

" " 7

"

" " "

"

# / # A 8 "

4 " #

"

#

/

" " #

%

" #

"

+

% >

/

0

#

>" :

"

; " *5.

?*).

% )1 B # / "

/ """

""

/

, >"

"

" *5.

?*).

% %

"

,

# 7

" / "

"

"" #

" / "" +

:

"

; "

/

"

" " 2 "

// " /

"2 #

""

2

"

2

"" "# " 5 "

"

" "

# )' % ""

+ :

"

;/ + "

" *5.

?*).

% "

"

"# " ""

2

"

2

"" "# " 5 "

)9 %

" 8 #

"

/ " /

"

?*).*5.

% )- B

/

" #

#

"# " % # /

"

""

;

?*).*5.

0 :? < 82

8 +-, -1 8*

*).

/ # #

""

"#

# 7 0 +++ +++ +++ *5.

/ "

"

"

/

"

" // " /

" " ""

2

"

2

"" "# " 5 "

/

" D #" ""

;

"

"

# #

#

"

"

## # " /

#

#

/

/ #

/ # #

"

" "%

0

# ""

#

"

/" " #

"

/

"#

" % 3

A

- "22 *

"17 =,18"++

*$ ,

* , * +*

7 0-

7 8*

88--

6 *=* * * + *

7 " & 1 >*?)//"

#

"

"

/ "

"

/

/ # 33

" /

# / +

"

&'*'.

%

" " 4

""

""

/ "

" / " "

"

#

3 % / " #"

!# //5

"

3

A % 3

A

"

/ 0 0 " #

"/

&'*'.

/ "

+

/

"

"

" "" #

# "

/ 0 :)1 %

+

, 12

" "

" #

"

" %

""

/

"" / " "

+" "" #

, 12

9 )'

/ ""

,, /// # # 8 % / , 12

+" # " #

%

" # # " "

#

/ # "

"

12

# "

"

# /

, 12

"", 12

/

"

"/ " # , 12 7 " "8

"/ 12

>"

/ ""

//# "

, 12

12

" ""

#

E

, 12

" +

#

77"

# 12

""

/ "

" # +

#

8 )9

+

"" #

, 12

+ " % 0 0 " #

"/ /, 12

" %

# "

%

# 7

/ +

&'*'.

""

/ " , 12

/ +" "" #

/ " "

# 7

+ )- %

#

/ ""

# / ""

# "#"

"

/"""

/

, 12

# 7

, 12

" "" %

# " "" #

" #

%

/

"" #"

" #" !# # " 3 ;

&'*'.

"

/0 :",

*22= , * @* A*

-. +++ +++ +++ #

""" ""# # 7

# # 7

"

2

" 7

"" #

# "

""

+" 0

#

"" #

"

#

""

"

"

/ # #

=

""

/

0

> ;

% 3

A "

/

/

+

# 7

""

"" #

""

+"

*'.

&'

8

# #

"

"

# /

" " 3

A -"22 *

"17 =,18"++

*$ ,

* , 3-,*- *.

5#

+ -7 *8,7* +* $ -72* + 3-,*- *.

""

&'&()'*

+ ,-.

0

>

#" /

""

/ % # &'&()' *

+ ,-.

0

> %

0

""

" 8 # /

" " 3

A -"22 * "17 =,18"++

*$ ,

* , 3-,*- *. !1=/6/ & 55"

$""4") B* !1+@

B 8 #,

F ,C B " F ,C