High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/17088/2015disposed of

The Jai Bharat Co Operative Labour & Construction Society Ltd v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2015-09-16Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal,Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan3 pages

!"##$%&%'()*

+#!%+!,!"-#,!"%.#/!01, '&",1$"%'2$%#"3/"4 #"%"%'#, 6#,&1& 2"!"# 1'7!0!'4"+#,& #&-'4#'"&

,#&#'"(5 ,28,,!94.$!"#,"+#-#"%"%'#, , !7%'4#,3!:944:9 1'7!0 ,2!'7##.2+!,;!94.$!"#, ,#&-'4#'"&' !'4< ,4!,&+!%'94.$!"#, ,#&-'4#'"'= >>>

+#-#"%"%'#,+!&$+!::#'?#4"+#!@!,4!"#'4#,%'!.1, ,#&-'4#'"'=!&!:&"+#"#'4#,-,$#&&

+#-#"%"%'#,+!&$+!::#'?#4"+#"#'4#,-,$#&&'"+#?,1'4 "+!"%"%&$'",!,3"!-:%$3"+# 1'7!0.#,';#'"4!"#4 =

!,!?,!-+"+#-:%$3-,.%4#&"+!"&A%::#4@,A1-""+#:%;%" &= :!$&&+1:40#!::""#4':3"!-#,!"%.#/!01,!'4'&",1$"%' 2$%#"3%'"+#2"!"#03@!3"#'4#,&'$!&#"+#&$%#"%#&!%:""#'4#,, 4'"!$$#-""+#@,A@%"+%'"+#:%;%"&"%-1:!"#49"+#@,A;!30#?" #B#$1"#4 03 %'.%"%'? -#' "#'4#,& ,; 0"+ "+# $'",!$",& !'4 "+# &$%#"%#& < #+!.#!&&1;#4"+!"-!,!?,!-+"+#-:%$3,#C1%,#&"@ &#-!,!"#!'44%&"%'$"&"!?#&"0#::@#4 +#%,&"&"!?#%&@+#,#"+# "#'4#,&%',#&-#$""+#&A%::#4@,A!,#%'.%"#41-""+#:%;%" &=:!$&

':3,;"+#-#,!"%.#/!01,!'4'&",1$"%'2$%#"3!'4%'"+# #.#'"@,A'"0#%'?!::""#4"&1$+&$%#"39%'"+#&#$'4&"!?#,#&+ "#'4#,&!,#"0#%'.%"#4,;"+#,-!,"%#&!&@#:: = '"+#-,#&#'"$!&#"+#"@&"!?#&3&"#;@!&!4;%""#4:3'" ::@#4%4&@#,#%'.%"#4,;!::-!,"%#&+#'"%$#%'.%"%'?"#'4#,& @!&%&&1#4'= &-#,"+#'"%$#90%4&@#,#%'.%"#4,;!:: #:%?%0:#0%44#,&+#-#"%"%'#,!:&&10;%""#4%"&0%4@%"+1",!%&%'?!'3 4#;1,,-,"#&"+#'"%$#%'.%"%'?"#'4#,&4%4'"#.#',##,""+#2"!"# -:%$3'"+#0!&%&@+%$+"+%&-#"%"%'%&1'4#4"1?+""+#,#,#" +!.#0##'$:#!,"+!""+#0%4&@#,#%'.%"#4,;!::#:%?%0:#0%44#,&!'4'" ;#,#:3,;"+#&$%#"%#&,##,,#4"%'"+#-:%$3#&-%"#"+#&!;#"+# -#"%"%'#,&10;%""#4!0%4!'44%4'",!%&#"+#07#$"%'@+%$+%&'@ ,!%&#4

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

5<5 @#!,#'"%'$:%'#4"#B#,$%&#1,#B",!,4%'!,371,%&4%$"%'1'4#,,"%$:#

)+#,#%&'"+%'?"%'4%$!"#!'3;!:!%4#&!?!%'&""+#,#&-'4#'"& +#@,%"-#"%"%'%&9!$$,4%'?:394%&;%&&#4 !"#

$%!&'(!)"*+%!$) ),!&#) !&'((!&#+

*#') -./01/-2 :1$A3