← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3383/2007dismissed

Gram Panchayat Village Nathupur v. Rattan Lal And ORS.

2020-03-04Mr. Justice Arun Monga19 pages

  



!"# $#%&'&() *+ +

,(&%&-!./-/!"&(0,/1!("2/,12&"'&("33&''&(#/ +++--#..!("

4#/','

!""!(5!. /'+ +++#'-($#("'

) 65+ 

     



    

 

  !"  #

$ %&   '&  ( '&() (&**&    * *      (      ( &

"&   *    ( +

   & & ( & *  & ,

-&   (.& &   

 &&* *     &  .  &&

&   &  .   *              !         

/ !0

   !0

    .&         

    *    

   

    &   .   &      

  4 * (      &  

   &

 3 

$ %   5  

 % &5     *&   (  &  & % *    (&  &    

   &6 ( %   //7    * &6 ( 8&  % 9:   ; <1, *& 5 ( &   ,0  = *   &(&  &  ( &   % &6&

 0/ 0/ !00>& &    .&&6&

   ( .&6&

 0/

!00> ?   ( 

>

)&     & *   

 @(** 

       6        &     %     *  

 & (  (       (     ?*  &          5& &

 *  * %

*  A  &@ 

 B 

 

*  * -            +     (    &    & &  <>>  ,0 

*  **   '&               &    (   

2<0+!

0/

<<<   

  6& 

  

  9CC & . ;

%

*  6&

  0!

!0009DE+ ; (.F& &





 .'& 9

 ; *       *   &   ?*  

*    *& &   & / 4( 5 & &('& &*    F & !00, 4 &* &  &   * G *               *+  C   %  &  *  *    &  & 

& *  (A

@ A   @    %&  * & ( *



%   &   ( '&()     *  (  

& & && & * ( 

 5 '&  

<

               *    &   

* * &*

( &C  

    

     

   

     

     

        

    

! 



        "

   



#$%%& "

"

  '  

 "

)  

*  %"!  +

 '

 !

"

  '

      ,  , "

   ! 



       

!# $%%  

   +  '  !

"  "  (    

  

""

   

 "    # $%-

 

"( "    .  "  

 

  '" 

'  +



" /0  1 ! %"! ,. 2"# $%- 0 

  +

+! # $%-

 

     

 "   "

      ! '



 ' 

  

# $%-

 ,  3

8          &  (        & &  .& &

   && & 

 .&   (  .&&     ( 

4  &    &  

7

,

  &   .& *  .&( &   F

  <70C7 !000C!00 H   *    <7>C/  <<>C!00 C!00, * (     *  (&& &   ,0  %&& (  & & &  

 ! .&6&

*   & (*C / 4 $   (   '         +    



+ 5       

! "

  



 4  (  



"       .+  '   /6   //   78%  78% '

 

"  

"

      

!     "

   *   4    '

 " *  %"! 

"

  '

 %  

 ( "



"  '  '  

69 78%6/  '     // 78% 4   * '   

//  78%6 

"



"  2

 "

  +         *   4 



"  (  

    "

   4  

  '

+



+

+! 

   4

"  

"       

"        

!  

8   

 "( 

 "

     /     

' '

 "  



" 



 !   + 



      

  

"  

 



"  

 + 





    !    

   

++ + 

8  

! +

+(  

 

+   "

+! 

     

"  4 

      "

.+    6  78-6 '

*  %"!   '

  '

          '    +  8

 :

  5 ' "    78-6  .+  06 

 "

  +

       78-6 "  "

+ 

5 (

"

 ; 

 78%6  .

  



 

+!  

    



  

 "      

  ."    !



    

   4

 '

"

  (  1 "

   + !

+   

"       '"



' +.   

' "(



 "(+

 !   '

"

    +! 

  <<<  =   +(

"   

! +

  (

  

"           

  

 / !

   ' &    

" ) 

 // 4

"  

 "  

 "  

  

+

    

     

     ! (

" "



     





+

 "

  

 '" '  

 

  2""  ! +! (   %.+ $"""!  4  >  %  ! 2" % ( "! + "

'

     

8  

 "( 

 "

 

"

 (   3

% (  & (  (  .&   !  ,6&

 (*C

 '  "      "

+ 

+!

"  (

"

 '

      ? '  

 '  +8  - $   "!  .+  78%   /6   +

   "

  

   "!  @+

    

"

   ( +

 '  +  "(

      

!  * ?  2 

  "  '  

  +

 '        

! ' !   !   +.  '"  ! A

!    "     

 '  "

   ' !  

  

   

  "(+  4  

 "   "!  @+  78%0  

 78%

 9069  78%  /6  78%9  06  78%  //6/ 4 "!  B  * '  78%/  '         : C  B+.   

    '  '    ' ! 

"(  +   "!  B  * '  78%    +

 '  + * ? D!   '   1   1'

 



    '  78% '    '  

.       

!   69    +'  +

 '  + 

"(  !      

   +'  ?  +

 '      B  * '  78%   ' //  ' // 4 '  .       

!  

"(    " +        "(+   

+!  

"     &7 

)  =

'  ?  

 '  +8  +     *  %"!  -     "

 "!



    ' +  "(

+!   1   

  

  

 ( "(

   1    

  + 

  



 



 "(    1   

   

"          0/ !

 '     ?

+ 

 !  "!  @+  78-     :. E  ; 

+

 !  78-   6     

!  6"(+ +  * ?  4 

 

(

"

     ( + " '

  

  

 (  %.+ $"""! 4  &>   %   ! ,  2")3

I&  &     &                 G     &    

  6&*   

0!

!000

 

 DEC

4*          *        &   &  (           *    (     5      

 *& (( * %

 * & *  6&& (&*   

%  6&     E  *+ & (&  & 

>  

    .& & 6&

&(&  &C *    2   A         D     

+(          (

   

+! 

 +

"

 - "



 + 



 3  (    

9 &C 6+ ( .&

4  (  -F&   ( *  & ;  



  !

    !  ! +

""



     +



 



  ."

3 *     ( - F&            & ;  



 "!  !

    !

 ! + ""



' "      

.

 

"



+!  D  + ' !  !

+  

  

  ."

$     (&             & ( .&5 '& 

( .&    

/

4&C 

   

& *&  4       &*   +CC       & & &   *  

     - +  

              6&

      0!

!000  %  .&6+ @&  (      & 5

  ( .& 

 '&     & ( .&  %

   @ & ( .&  &

  

<

 %   & 9  / 0< !00,;  &('&&  5        &  6&

  

0!

!000DE +

" &('&&* 9!00,;

   

         6&

           % 6&

  0!

!000DE+   (&  &     

 . "( &  

6&  '&& +

!0

DE  : (*)

 .. 

  *E (  &)(  ( & 8:444 &>..  &    

  &  (.&&

6&



&(   &  4  &  (    

( (&  ( 

%

 . "     &              +  6      

      &  ) *  

 . "    ( (**





 % E &*

 &  &     



 * * * C

 



 

&('&  

      

     

  (     

++"!"#!$/!('-/"/-/!"&(4+"!"# ""!//!$#'2

7**8  !!

%  @& + 6&

  0!

!000          &   

 . "

 

6 @& + 6&

 

0!

!000*      

   % 

    (   

 . "

   & +   (   &(

. "  !,  %

    (.&(* BC,F )     (   9

>!  !00>; B!  

 

 && 

  (    (    &  &   B  

            (& &  % 5 1  

 BC,F ) 

(* 5*       + 

<2< 8&   (      BF )    

 

&( 5E

  %* E

 (  -B  *  &J     ?        10     9    0> 0> !00>;    &     * + 

&  ( & (  (  (   

 (    ?   &     @ *    &  &    &  &    * E

&   (    !2

 <70C7 !000C0 9DE+2 <70C7  DE+1  <71C7>DE+> </1C/>DE+7 <<0C< DE+/ 9 DE-+ ; <<1C<> DE+<!000C0 ;;5   *  DE+ 09,

<7>,0 0,

</ ;DE+

9 0+ <<>07 0, !00 ;DE + ! 9

!00    !0

!00,;  *      + &       = )22&6 (3  & 

 CC    * * (  ( & (&&  % 

'  &  * &&  & &( (&(&&    (  & !1 %   *   @ .+ DE-+ 9 & (; <> C>!* AA+F G   4 (& ( &   (   ( *   (      @*   *-B    

  &*  &   *   ( 



  6&

  0!

!000*  @   !>

4  &     @ && & +   <2<    ( !7 *&  @ * &  % @ &   &   *       *+C  % *   G      <2<  ( 

*  5          

    * 

    &    (&E         &      *

+ 5  

 

   !/

%  *    &  ( '&()     *  (   & && 4  &6&

  > 0< !0 >( -" .&.B >>2!00/9( ; 

 3 K ) &6 (  %        0,

!00> 0

!007 & &2 >3 '& /<2 '& &   * 

% 9 ; (6&1( 

*         &  B&  '& -" .&   &*  9  ;  & 4(& 

 &CC  & . &

    * *  (6*   @      *      &    (  3  '& & !<

8(  +  * &(  .&  &(6

    *   &(6

* >>>2!00/(* *   (.& H*  &*   +   5 +     *(   *&(6   ,0

% (&  &        <2< * &E      +   &      +   

  *(  .&+ &L &  6&  &&

L C* '& & L 

   &   G & 5 +         .B   >>2    !00/  98K ;

   *   (&  * * &(  ,

.& &      &(

7  

E    *L   

    '& @* &    

    (    &6 (  8&   %   9:     ; <1!

,!

D* & 5 <1!( .&(* &   &   ( &  *( +  4*& 

(   @** -B  )  

                  &     *   (

& (  ?   * &&  10  4  ( ((&(* &   (  

&  &  ,,

4( 5 &   &

      '&&&         *      (      &    $   )!9; <1!  

 &(*C  - H6 &)  & ) <<< &)I"""!  I      ' 

 ! + 

" "

   2" 

"

  """!

   



"   "

    ' 

" " "

 +    """! 

 " 

8    +!  '

+! 

 '   

    "   "   .  "  

'  

"

   

"

   ""

   

   """!  3 &  (*&* &   &  *(   $&    ( $*(

 *  *$ .         

    & &  (    &    & &   

,0C,  6&



  

    &   ( 10 &   

& ( * &  &  *   * *$)!9;+

,2

  (&   &  (( AH"F8%8 @* 

&  (          & (  4  &   

( E.&6&

  &2!(&(12

/'+:'+!4&/!'!$ /'+0&4&.--#!.+

  9 0$#%&$#$(

+

+ 99+   E (*C 4   +! 

       .

  

C'

2  D     +!  1  D  4  D              

     '

 H6 4 '

  



 

!      

 ;     

" 

  

        '    +

"

'

   

       

!         

 ! 

6



      ; 

"  "(  



" "!  .+   69/  "!    * '  78-9   "

   9  ,+ 9    "  B  * '    B   9  B  9/

   

'  "(    

     ;  " 

    

 

  

 

"    

&: C  :'

. 64

) ;   "   

(

"

 '

            !

  "   ' 

     '

 ;    

 

      (

   B   0 ;  "!

 @+  

0 78-6  

'          "  "( ;   

     ?       

 :. E

8"

  '

B  +

 '" ;    ";   "   



"    '" ' :. E

 + 

 0 ( +



"

  

"( 



 ;   "   

(

"

   '" '  

    '

 + 

B   0 ' :. E

2 

! +

( +(    (

 

   ( 

+ '

 (

   (  

  

"

     (

 



   0    , 0/ 6 "

+! 

            (

  2

 

      ;   

   

 '     '



" "

 +  " " +





   (    

 

" 

    

+ '

 (

 ; !

   '   ! '  

     '

 ' 

"

( !



   

     

   



; "

 !   

  " 

 + '

      '

  ;  "   

" "    '

   



  "   

   B   0   

      D

!  

 ' 

' 

  + '

     

 '  +    

"

+! 

  3 4 +( A

      D  '

+!

C'

2  D    !  

  

    +

 !

 +     



6  "(   4  D   A

+(     "   + 

(

"

 

"  

 + '  +  

+ "    "(



+. 6  "(+ +!     !  +  2      '   +!   D   

+ '

 '

     

 ! '     

  4 C'

2  D 

    

 D  '   "

 

(

"



" '" ' !

"

+!   D  

  ( '   C'

2  D  

(

"

 

"  "

 



  



'





      D  +

 "

 (

"

   '      

.

 

"

  C'

2  D     1  D  



.

 

"

   D 3 ,1

4  ! & 6&

  .&

(* (*C 2 

  "  '  

  +

 '        

! ' !   !   +.  '"  ! A

!    "  

9   

 '  "

   ' !  

  

   

  "(+  4 

 "   "!  @+  78%0  

 78%  9069  78%  /6   78%9  06  78%  //6 / 4 "!  B  * '  78%/  ' 

       : C  B+.  



    '  '    ' !



"( 9D  &;

,>

%&    (  " 3

 H (6  $  & G  ) G6&

&   (   ,7

?

 &6&

(&(*

 &* 

    & ( .&*  &( *  4

  & *(  .&    (  .&  *       &*&    6&.&

& ,/

4  *     &  (             ( (   & (  & 6&

  (.&(* & ,<

   

  

  !/%2 *0

F B 5 +  M+ B ( M+