High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16147/2016dismissed

Bhim Singh v. Sarva Haryana Gramin Bank & ORS

2016-08-10Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan4 pages

! "#$%$&'(')* +

,'-.')/, $#'#')$0 (!

1$0(2( ."03""04")" 0"-')")5")%#,$0( $(6)%$)# (!

* 78 . 9 8. 0$($)#*:

00"3$$) 26#";%3&"#$;0#,$6$#'#')$0 ,$#,$0#,$ $60#$0(<&"<)$=(6"6$0-"4>$"<<=$%# ($$#,$?2%/-$)#@

>$0$$00$%##,$ $60#$00)# A ,$#,$0#,$?2%/-$)#(,2<%>$0$60#$%')#,$%'/$(#@ ::

,$ 6$#'#')$0; =, ="( (('(#")# ")"/$0 ='#, #,$ 0$(6)%$)#:")5;0$#'0$%0-"04")" 0"-')")5;,"(&,"<<$)/$%#,$ '-62/)$%0%$0%"#$%A

))$C20$::B!;6"(($%>4#,$%'(&'6<')"04 "2#,0'#4;3'%$=,'&,#,$62)'(,-$)#0$%2&#')>4#=(#"/$('),'( $C'(#')/6"4(&"<$ (B

'$ <=$0')/%=),'(>"('&6"40- ( B

:# (

: $$&#'3$ )#,$%"#$,'((26$0"))2"#')'$A

B='#,&2-2<"#'3$$$&#="( '-6($%26),'-<('-62/)$%')#,$60$($)#=0'#6$#'#')'(#,$0%$0 %"#$%

))$C2$::!;6"(($%>4#,$"66$<<"#$"2#,0'#4;=,$0$>4 #,$"66$"<'<$%>4#,$6$#'#')$0="(%'(-'(($%='#,-%''&"#')#,"##,$ -"?06$)"<#40$%2&#')>4#=(#"/$('),'($C'(#')/6"4(&"<$ ( B

'$<=$0')/%=),'(>"('& 6"40- ( B

:# (

: $$&#'3$)#,$%"#$,'( (26$0"))2"#') '$ A

B ='#, &2-2<"#'3$ $$&# '-6($% >4 #,$ '(&'6<')"042#,0'#4;3'%$0%$0%"#$%A

B#0$%2&#')>4)$(#"/$

'),'($C'(#')/6"4(&"<$ (B

'$<=$0')/%=),'(>"('&6"40- ( B

:# (

$$&#'3$ ) #,$ %"#$ ,'( (26$0"))2"#') '$ A

B ='#, &2-2<"#'3$$$&# ,$ <$"0)$% &2)($< 0 #,$ 6$#'#')$0 &)#$)%( #,"# #,$ 6$#'#')$0,"%0$#'0$%0-($03'&$)A

B")%#,"##,$62)'(,-$)# 0%$0 ))$C20$::B! ="( 6"(($% ) A

B ,$ 6$02("< #,$ 0$#'0$-$)#0%$0%"#$%

))$C20$::!(,=(#,"#=,'<$0$#'0')/ #,$6$#'#')$00-($03'&$;#,$%'(&'6<')"04"2#,0'#4'$ $)$0"< ")"/$0; ')35$% $/2<"#')B"04")" )=."03""04")"! 0"-')")5

'&$0( ")% -6<4$$(! .$03'&$ $/2<"#')(;

') (,0# 7#,$

$/2<"#')(

7!0$"%='#,"04")" )=."03""04")"! 0"-')")5 .$03'&$ -$)%-$)#! $/2<"#')(;

A ')(,0#7#,$ $/2<"#')(

A7!

#%'0$&##,"##,$6$#'#')$0(,"<<&$"($#>$')($03'&$)#,$%"#$ (26$0"))2"#')'$A

B"##,$&<($>")5')/,20(;>2#%'(&'6<')"04 60&$$%')/(='<<&)#')2$"(',$="(')($03'&$2)#'<#,$60&$$%')/("0$ &)&<2%$%') #,$&,"0/$(,$$#(;0$$00$% ">3$")% #,$')"< 0%$0( "0$ 6"(($% ') 0$(6$&# #,$0$ $/2<"#') B A! "04")" )= ."03"

"04")"! 0"-') ")5

'&$0( ")% -6<4$$(! .$03'&$ $/2<"#')(;

;'(0$60%2&$%"(2)%$0*:

,$ '&$0 0 $-6<4$$( "/"')(# =,- %'(&'6<')"0460&$$%')/(,"(>$$)')'#'"#$%(,"<<&$"($#>$') ($03'&$ ) #,$ %"#$ (26$0"))2"#') >2# #,$ %'(&'6<')"04 60&$$%')/((,"<<&)#')2$"(',$="(')($03'&$2)#'<#,$ 60&$$%')/("0$&)&<2%$%")%')"<0%$0'(6"(($%')0$(6$&# #,$0$E #(,=(#,"#'#,$%'(&'6<')"0460&$$%')/(,"3$>$$)')'#'"#$%

:A:

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

0')&060"#')')#,$

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

,$0$0$;') #,$60$($)#&"($;=,$)#,$0$/2<"#')603'%$(0#,$("-$;#,$62)'(,-$)# 0%$0&2<%>$6"(($%$3$)"#$0#,$0$#'0$-$)#")%0#,"#6206($;#,$ 0$<"#')(,'6$-6<4$$")%$-6<4$0(,"<<&)#')2$)#,'(="4;#,$0$'( )'<<$/"<'#4)#,$6"0#0$(6)%$)#:")5')6"((')/#,$("'%0%$0 . "0 "( #,$ ')G2'04 '( &)&$0)$%; #,$ -"##$0 ,"( >$$) $C"-')$%>4#,$%'(&'6<')"04"2#,0'#4,'( 20#&"))#(2>(#'#2#$'#(

')%')/(='#,#,$')%')/(0$&0%$%>4#,$%'(&'6<')"04"2#,0'#4;=,'&,,"3$ >$$)"'0-$%>4#,$"66$<<"#$"2#,0'#4 ,$<$"0)$%&2)($<0#,$6$#'#')$0&)#$)%(#,"#"(6$0#,$ <$##$0%"#$% +A ))$C20$:: !;#,$%'(&'6<')"04"&#')="(#>$ #"5$) >4 #,$ ,'$ C$&2#'3$ '&$0 #,$ 0$(6)%$)#:")5; =, '(

,"'0-"):&2-: ")"/')/'0$&#0#,$0$(6)%$)#:")5;")%)#>4#,$ $)$0"< ")"/$0#,$0$(6)%$)#:")5 =$3$0; "( >($03$% ">3$; #,$ <$##$0 %"#$% +A

))$C20$:: ! '( -$0$<4 0$&--$)%"#04")% ='<< )# (2>(#'#2#$ #,$ 0$/2<"#')(2)<$((#,$($"0$"-$)%$% )3'$=#,$">3$;#,$0$'()/02)%#')#$0$0$')#,$ '-62/)$%0%$0(%"#$%A

B")%

))$C20$(::B")%: 0$(6$&#'3$<4!;6"(($%>40$(6)%$)#( $)&$;#,$60$($)#=0'#6$#'#')'( %'(-'(($%

8. !

(?5( ,$#,$0(6$"5')/0$"()$% * $( ,$#,$0 $60#"><$ *