High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/17141/2015disposed of

Charan Pal Chauhan v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2017-03-21Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan3 pages

!"#$#%&'&()* + ,!+!(!- ,!.,!( #"&"&(#+ '

/#+'.'

0"!"#!+1!(!!($",#+'

#'2($#(" '

) 34 0 5 40 +#'#(")6 +0!(7##85$!(9$8%!"#9+",#2#"&"&(#+ +5#',!8 .2"!9''&'"!("$8%!"# #(#+!-9!+1!(! ,#",#+",# #2+"#+'-%!-(#:'2!2#+;!1<#!--:#$" '##",#7.$=;#("> <#+##++#$"",# #2+"#++(" * ,#",#+",#7.$=;#("',.-$<#+#2+"#$&(",#$&=#'"> 66 66 40

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

66 ,!77!+9 ((#C.+#66 9<."",#!22#!-,!'<##(&-#$!=!&('"",#'!&$ 7.$=;#("!%B.&""!-"!-'%;#'."",!"",#$&'%&2-&(!+12+%##$&(=' .($#+ .-#",#!+1!(!.(&',;#("!($22#!- .-#'9?@9+ &;2'&"&(;!7+2#(!-"1!+#2#($&(='&(%#*,#+#+#9.($#+

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

$#",#$#2!+";#("!-2+%##$&(=' :&",&('&C;(",'+;",#$!"#+#%#&2"%#+"&&#$%21",&'+$#+" &';!$#%-#!+",!"&",#$#2!+";#("!-2+%##$&(='!+#("%(%-.$#$:&",&( ",#=&8#("&;#+!;#9",#0"!"#',!--+#-#!'#",#.--=+!"&"1"",#2#"&"&(#+ !($ &C ",# +#'2('&<&-&"1 + (( %(%-.'&( ",# $#2!+";#("!- 2+%##$&(='+'.%,!-(="&;#,#2#"&"&(#+&'$&+#%"#$%2#+!"#&( ",#$#2!+";#("!-2+%##$&(=' 0!+!'",#'!-!+1+",#2#+&$+;A*"** &'%(%#+(#$9",#2#"&"&(#+:!'2-!%#$.($#+'.'2#('&($.+&(=",!"

6*6 !($",#0"!"#,!'!22!+#("-1("$#%&$#$!<."",#(!".+#",#'!&$2#+&$ !($9",#+#+#9",#0"!"#&'!-'$&+#%"#$"2!''!'2#!D&(=+$#++#=!+$&(= ",#!"#",#'!&$2#+&$:&",&((#;(",!"#+",#%(%-.'&(",# &(B.&+12+%##$&(='

40 * '7D' ,#",#+'2#!D&(= +#!'(#$ ) #' ,#",#+ #2+"!<-# )