Satvir & Anothers v. State Of Haryana And ORS




    
 

"#$$%&'&() 

*"#+&,"(-"(#.$, // $#&#&($,'

0$,'1'

*#"#$",2"("#.$,'

// $'3(-$(#'

 


 


     

,$'$(#)/ ,***".14-+%"#$,#.$3$#&#&($,' , ".15$+*&(6.44",2"("      

.$ $-&%"5*13$,&(#$(-$(#489"2"9"& ",9"'.'3&#"54 :1,19'.$#,"&''1$-"(#&%$&(+&#&(6#$(-$,',1#'1,%&(6'$%1,&#2 '$,+&%$'"##.$.'3&#"5,"3$,&-($2$",(%(#,"%#;"'&' 0&-$ 5$##$,'$,<"%%$3#"(%$%",,2&(6$+$(-"#$&$



"(- #.$3$#&#&($,'.$,$&(>$,$6,"(#$-#.$>,9,-$,,3,+&-&(6 '$%1,&#2'$,+&%$'"(-"--&#&("5'133,#'$,+&%$'"##.$.'3&#"5,"3$,&- ($2$",&$?

#@?

A

.$&('#"(#3$#&#&(."';$$(&5$-&B316(&(6#>'$3","#$ ,-$,';#.-"#$-

/A"(- /&(#$,B'>.&%.#.$ %(#,"%#">",-$-&("+1,#.$3$#&#&($,'4."';$$(#$,B&("#$- @ 1('$5,#.$3$#&#&($,'."'%(#$(-$-#."##.$"%#&( ,$'3(-$(#(&(#$,B&("#&(6#.$&,%(#,"%#&'",;&#,",2"(-3"#$(#52&55$6"5
#."';$$(",61$-#."#$+$(#.16.&(#.$&B316($-,-$,'4>.&%.",$ &-$(#&%"552  >,-$-4  &#  ."'  ;$$(  B$(#&($-  #."#  #.$  #$,B&("#&(  &'  &( 31,'1"(%$##.$,$%BB$(-"#&('"(
(C1&,2BB&##$$"(-"'3$, -&,$%#&('#.$&+&5*1,6$(4:1,19'.$#,"("%%1(##.$3$#&#&($,'

."+&(6  %BB&##$-  D !"#  $

$%$#&E  '#&55  (  '1%.  &(C1&,2  >"'

%(-1%#$-"(-&("(2%"'$#.$3$#&#&($,'."-(#;$$("''%&"#$->&#.#.$ '"B$ 

3((#&%$B#&(."+&(6;$$(&''1$-4>,&##$('#"#$B$(# #.$ $-&%"5*13$,&(#$(-$(##.$.'3&#"5."';$$(&5$-(;$."5"55 #.$&%&"5,$'3(-$(#'.$"%#&(#$,B&("#&(%(#,"%#&''16.## ;$F1'#&&$-;2'#"#&(6#."#%B35"&(#'."-;$$(&5$-;2#.$>,9$,'4>. ."-$",5&$,;$$(1#'1,%$-;2#.$3,$+&1'%(#,"%#,"(-#.$"55$6"#&(' >$,$#."##.$3,$'$(#3$#&#&($,'."-;$$(-$B"(-&(6";,&;$ '

</ $"%.,3,+&-&(6#.$B"F;&(31,'1"(%$##.$%(#,"%#">",-$-,#.$ %1,,$(#2$",*#"(-(;$."5#.$*#"#$&'#."#
(C1&,2BB&##$$."- ;$$(-152%('#&#1#$-"(-&#>"'"#$,55>&(6-1$3,%$''5">4" -$%&'&(."';$$(#"9$(##$,B&("#$#.$&,%(#,"%#

1('$5,#.$3",#&$'."+$;$$(.$",- A .$  '%3$    F1-&%&"5  '%,1#&(2  &(  '1%.  B"##$,'  >15-  ;$ $=#,$B$525&B&#$-"(->15-;$%(&($-##.$-$%&'&(B"9&(63,%$'' ,"#.$,#."(#.$-$%&'&(&#'$5$="B&($#.$+"5&-&#2#.$,-$,'-"#$-

"# (($=1,$'  /A "(-  / >.$,$;2%(#,"%#">",-$- # #.$ 3$#&#&($,'."-;$$(#$,B&("#$-4>$."-%"55$-13( , ".15$+*&(6.4 5$",($-4",2"("#3,-1%$#.$,&6&("5,$%,-'&(#.$("#1,$#.$ ,$%BB$(-"#&('B"-$;2#.$
(C1&,2BB&##$$4'#"#$B$(#'#."#B"2."+$ ;$$(,$%,-$--1,&(6#.$%1,'$&(C1&,2"'"5'#.$,-%1B$(#'"(- $+&-$(%$-152"--1%$-;$,$#.$
(C1&,2BB&##$$.$,$C1&'&#$,$%,- >"'-1523,-1%$-;$,$1'"(-."';$$(3$,1'$-  $",$#.$%('&-$,$-+&$>#."##.$&(C1&,2%(-1%$-"##.$ ."(-'"BB&##$$>"''$,&1'525">$-"(-#.$&B316($-,-$,'3"''$-

/@/ "6"&('##.$3$#&#&($,'&(31,'1"(%$#'1%.&(C1&,23,%$''%"((#'1'#"&(

,#"9&(6'1%.+&$>#.$55>&(6,$"'('",$"''&6($-)/ &!

.$3,%$''&(C1&,2>"'"33",$(#52&(&#&"#$-("%%1(#" %BB1(&%"#&(-"#$-

."+&(6;$$(>,&##$(;2#.$&+&5*1,6$(4 :1,19'.$#,"  "(-  "--,$''$-  #  ,$'3(-$(#  (  &$  #.$  $-&%"5 *13$,&(#$(-$(#    #.$  .'3&#"5  &(  C1$'#&(  (  #.$  '1;F$%#    6,"+$ &,,$615",&#&$'."+&(6;$$(%BB&##$-;2#.$1#'1,%&(6%(#,"%#,'&$#.$ 3,$'$(#3$#&#&($,'
(#$,B''1%.%BB1(&%"#&(-&,$%#&('."+$;$$( &''1$-#,$'3(-$(#(#%(-1%#"(&(C1&,2(#.$"55$6"#&('#."##.$ %(#,"%#,'."-#"9$(<-$B"(-$-.16$'1B'B($2,"33&(#B$(# $B352$$' .$,$%,-"5',$+$"5'#."##.$$B352$$'#.$3,$+&1' %(#,"%#,."-B"-$%B35"&(#'&(#.$("#1,$;,&;$'##.$$=#$(#

'

</."+&(6;$$(-$B"(-$-;2#.$3,$'$(#3$#&#&($,',$(6"6&(6 #.$B"(-3,+&-&(6#.$B"'1,%$5&+$5&.-("%%1(##.$%(#,"%# ,#.$%1,,$(#2$",."+&(6;$$(">",-$-+$(#.16.4'1%.%B35"&(#' >$,$#",6$#$-'3$%&&%"552"6"&('##.$3,$'$(#3$#&#&($,'4'#&554%3&$'#.$ %B35"&(#'>$,$($+$,'1335&$-##.$B &&!

(C1&,2BB&##$$>"'%('#&#1#$-;2,$'3(-$(#(#6 &(##.$"55$6"#&(' !"#$

$%$#&"6"&('##.$3$#&#&($,'*3$%&&% ",#&%5$'%.",6$>$,$($+$,,B15"#$-
#&'(#3$,B&''&;5$#.5-"( &(C1&,2(+"61$%.",6$''"(->.$("%#&(&'3,3'$-#;$#"9$("(- &(C1&,2&'#;$&(&#&"#$--$&(&#$",#&%5$'%.",6$."+$#;$%BB1(&%"#$- ##.$3$,'(%.",6$-#6$#.$,>&#."'#"#$B$(##.$"55$6"#&('(>.&%. $"%.%.",6$&';"'$-"(-"(2#.$,%&,%1B'#"(%$'>.&%.&'3,3'$-#;$ #"9$(&(#%('&-$,"#&( (5$'''1%.%1,'$"%#&(&'55>$-&#>15- ($+$,6&+$"%5$",3&%#1,$##.$%.",6$-3$,'(#B"9$1#"($$%#&+$

// -$$(%$"'.$>15-;$1(">",$#.$$="%#("#1,$#.$"55$6"#&(' "6"&('#.&B"(->."#9&(--$$(%$.$'.15-31#13,,$;1##"5#.$,$ &&&!

+$(  #.16.4  #.$  ,$%,-  >15-  ,$+$"5  #."#  '#"#$B$(#   3$#&#&($,(."-;$$(,$%,-$-;2#.$
(C1&,2BB&##$$(??

"(-'1%.'#"#$B$(#"##.$;##B$+$(%",,&$'#.$'&6("#1,$'3$#&#&($, ( 4  >.$,$&(  #.$  "55$6"#&('  "'  ,$6",-' '$

$%$#&( ."+&(6  ;$$( -$(&$-42$#4#.$
(C1&,2BB&##$$>.&5$1,(&'.&(6,$%BB$(-"#&('( ?

,#$,B&("#&(#.$%(#,"%#."-,$%,-$-#.$'#"#$B$(#'#.$ %B35"&("(#'"(-%$,#"&(#.$,>&#($''$'(%$-$-52'1%.'#"#$B$(#'>$,$ ($+$,'1335&$-##.$3$#&#&($,'"(-#.$2>$,$(#",-$-"%."(%$# %(,(#"(-%,''/$="B&($#.$%B35"&("(#'"(-#.$,>&#($''$' &+!

.$,$%BB$(-"#&('#.$
(C1&,2BB&##$$",$%(#"&($- &(",$3,#-"#$-?

>.&%.."',$%,-$-"%(%51'&(#."#B($2 #,"('"%#&('."+$#"9$(35"%$>.&5$3,+&-&(6$B352B$(###.$$B352$$' ;2  #.$  3$#&#&($,'  "(-  #."#  #,"&($-  B"(3>$,  ."-  (#  ;$$(  3,+&-$- %%,-&(6524
(C1&,2BB&##$$,$%BB$(-$-#,$'3(-$(#(&$.$ $-&%"5*13$,&(#$(-$(##.$.'3&#"5,#$,B&("#&(#.$%(#,"%#;2 6&+&(6(#&%$ .1,'*#,"(6$52$+$(#.16.#.$%(%51'&(."';$$( ",,&+$-"#;2#.$BB&##$$"(--,"'#&%,$%BB$(-"#&('."+$;$$(B"-$4 2$#4#.$,$&'('3$%&&%&(-&(6,$%,-$-;2#.$BB&##$$;"'$-(#.$,"5 ,-%1B$(#",2$+&-$(%$#."#B"2."+$;$$("--1%$--1,&(6#.$%1,'$ &(C1&,2 +!

$#  "(#.$,  &(&,B&#2  #."#  ."'  ;$$(  (#&%$-  &'  #."#  #.$ ,$%BB$(-"#&('#.$
(C1&,2BB&##$$."+$;$$(;5&(-52"%%$3#$-;2 ,$'3(-$(#($%$,#"&(52>15-(#$=3$%##.$%B3$#$(#"1#.,&#2# ,$%,--$#"&5$-,$"'(',#$,B&("#&("%(#,"%#;1##.$,&6&("5,$%,-'

B1'#($%$''",&52,$5$%#"335&%"#&(B&(-;2,$'3(-$(#((#.$ ,$%BB$(-"#&('B"-$;2#.$
(C1&,2BB&##$$3,&,##"9&(6"-$%&'&( ##$,B&("#$#.$%(#,"%#$&(-'1%."335&%"#&(B&(-##"5525"%9&(6 ?
(+&$>#.$"%#'"(-%&,%1B'#"(%$'(#&%$-.$,$&(";+$4>$ .5-#."##.$&(C1&,2%(-1%#$-;2#.$&%&"5,$'3(-$(#'&'+&#&"#$-."+&(6 ;$$(  %(-1%#$-  &(  +&5"#&(    #.$  3,&(%&35$'    ("#1,"5  F1'#&%$   .$ &B316($-,-$,'-"#$-

/A"(- /"(->.&%.

$(#"&5"-+$,'$%&+&5%('$C1$(%$'%"((#'1'#"&((#.$;"'&'"(&(C1&,2 >.&%.."'(#55>$--1$3,%$-1,$"'3$,5">  $4#.$,$,$4&(#$(-,$B"(-&(6#.$B"##$,,",$'.&(C1&,2 $",$4&(#.$"%#'#.&'%"'$4&(%5&($-#3$,B&##.$3$#&#&($,'# %(#&(1$>,9&(61(-$,#.$%(#,"%#"5#.16.&#&'($,$5"#&(6#'$%1,&#2 ,B,$#."(($,$"'( .$,$&'("55$6"#&("6"&('##.$3$#&#&($,' ,$6",-&(6#.$C1"5&#2'$,+&%$'3,+&-$-.$,$&'("55$6"#&("6"&('# #.$3$#&#&($,'>&#.,$'3$%###.$&,3$,,B"(%$#.$%(#,"%#C1"#.$ &%&"5,$'3(-$(#'.$"55$6"#&('B"-$."+$(#;$$('1;'#"(#&"#$-;2 ,&("3,3$,&(C1&,2
(+&$>#.$";+$43,$'$(#3$#&#&(&'"55>$- 
B316($- ,-$,'-"#$-

/A"(- /",$'$#"'&-$ "##$,&'

,$B"(-$-##.$&,$%#,$($,"54$"5#.*$,+&%$'4",2"("4,$'3(-$(# ( ,%(-1%#&(6"(&(C1&,2",$'."6"&('##.$3$#&#&($,''#,&%#52&( %('("(%$>&#.#.$3,&(%&35$'("#1,"5F1'#&%$4"&,35"2"(-$C1&#2
# >15-;$3$(,,$'3(-$(#( #%(-1%#"(&(C1&,2.&B'$5,"##.$ ."(-'"(2#.$,'$(&,,$'3('&;5$&%&"5#.$$"5#.$3",#B$(#4 *#"#$",2"("*1%.&(C1&,2;$&(&#&"#$-"(-&("5&G$->&#.&("3$,&- 1,>$$9',B#.$-"#$,$%$&3#"%32#.&',-$,&55'1%.#&B$

/A/ #.$3$#&#&($,'",$3$,B&##$-#%(#&(1$>&#.#.$>,9"55##$-##.$B&( #$,B'#.$5$##$,'$,<"%%$3#"(%$-"#$-



/ "(-   1,#.$,"%#&("',$6",-'%(#&(1"#&(#.$>,9%(#,"%#&( "+1,#.$3$#&#&($,'13#@?

A<#$,B&("#&(#.$,$"(-%"55&(6, ,$'.#$(-$,'>15--$3$(-(#.$1#%B$#.$,$'.&(C1&,2#."#."' ;$$(-&,$%#$-

$#&#&(&'-&'3'$-&(#.$",$'"&-#$,B'  )$*+

#,$-+# $-"  $-+&

.%$-"
$#*!&%$.#  !+"#   /01231/0 51%92 .$#.$,#;$,$$,,$-# $3,#$,H$'