Parveen Bali v. State Of Punjab And Others
!"
#$%$!&'
( (
'
)*+ (,+ + )*+ (,+ ,
! "
#$
%
! & ' , - (
(
)*+
,
- ./
$ /0 /
"/ 12 531161'7 ""
52 $
"" .
$ & 5 ""
8$8 / 9
9 /
/
$
"
: /
0
;
'
# /
"
" ,/ # $1<<2 = $1<<< > 9
6.
)*"
= $
$
?3@"> "
*"
/$
/
$ $
/
!
=
"
"
/ 96. 7)*"
$5331 =
*"
A
*" / /$13
/ /$
?A@"> ///
/$ 9
/ =
"
/
"/
$ " 0 = "
" $533A 51
,
- ./ .
/ 0
"
>+ 13 " % /$4 /$ 9 ?
=
$ /241">
*"
15?
4">
& ?
" "
1
"
/$
9
/
5A 533A
"
,
- ./ = " "
"
= "
"
/ % 8$8 / 9 6
/ % 7
/ /B
/
/ =
,
- ./ "
$ + > ,
; > 533A
5'
533< %" " , C> D , =
> 9
,
9
; > 3A = "
9 >
/
(
$
13 533A ,
- 9
; >
$ + > "$ > ,
9 $
/ $ 9 9" *
1<
$$
/ %
"> # 533A '1 3'
533< # "
"+'
657 / / F $ % &" '$"( "$& )&G
.
F
$ %%& * 8 " H / "+E F(&%*"
F
$G 8 '6=I7 "
$
" > / /
/ >
8 "
" $
*
"
<$
55$
"
= "
> /
/
/ " , " 533A $
/ <
$ >
8 '6I7 $ "
> = "
'
" " <
" $"> / '6I=7 " ;$ 533< 53 / 2<J
*
/ A
='6I==7
/ $
"
$ ""
"
$"
" 0
$0
$ > < #
5A 53136'7 $
$
"> 533< '1 3'
8"
/ "+1F#% + ),#% &G
F %*= "
" 9'" #
$ / "+' "- $ % &
F %* 9 "2 ?-A "> %*" F&
* F %*"
= "+E / F&%G
F
$*=" / / "+<
F./ &0 %* # $"> / '6I=7"
$ 31 5313 55
" "" " "
+ ,/!( !& 0 % % 1$%2!% 1 !"
&$ % #3 $4 1 !/5$&6 7%
K13 'E A11B5 5'
$K13 ''
EE1B5 1A '
.K13 131B5 . $K13 2< AA ?
/ K13 ??
AA 521B5 "K13 2E A2 1<1B5
K13 '2 A' 531B5 &"K13 '3 13' 51 < , "K13 'E 13'1B5 1A1B5 .$K11 13?1B5 1< ;$K116 55 ; ?< 1E
* 8 99
:
;"
" "
5313 &"5313 B
"" E?
"
* " .5313 9
; " &"5313 .$5311 B
"" 133
" " ;$
1E > /$ " ?3
( " >$ ,.
*
5< 53136 $
K> K7 $
;
/ % 8$8 / 9
# "
$"> /
34 3E 53156157
$
"> $5313+5311 = "+2/ /F$
'$ + )*"
'
+ "'.'. ' $)&
'*= F' $ "' + '
&'
'+ )+ +'++* / "+E F&%*
F
$* / "+A F&
*
" F $
'
&
* = "+</ / "
F.12
!*= "> "
./
F'
%&
$ * 1'
8
"/ 12
D
=
""
8D 8$8 / 9
9 / 55 5E 3?
5311 *
1'6'7 .
533E
(
55 53116 *+<7 "/ / % / 9 8$
$ %" , " 8"
(
$ "
$ =
/./
> ,
/9
.
*+13 5E 3?
"
$ "
""
55 5311 $ / % 8$8 / 9 %"
0 B /
$ / > /
"
/
9 >
31 8K =
/./
9
/"
$
= " K "
//K " >$" & " " ""
/ >
/ /
$
/ ( ,
./ > "
(
"
+
B / $
9
=
/
" "
$
/ $/ ;
8K =
/./
/
"
$ /
$
B
8
8K
/9 .
$ $
9
=
**
"$ / % 8$
/ 9
5E 3?
5311/ 0 & 5+ $ %"
( 9
/ ""
55 5311 $/ % 8$8 / 9
$ %"
0 /
;
9
"/
$
/ ""
B 6 *+137 =
/./
8K =
/./
$
;
9
"/
$
0
" " " *+13
/$ %" 8K =
/./
0
/ ;
9
=
0 $
$
8K =
/ ./
""
$ %"
/
$ /
1?
( 14 3< 531'
"
& 1-5 $B
$ 8 / L $ %
, " 8" .
9 /
" "
"/ 5311B52 5311 ""
/ %
= "
& 1-5 $$
& '
%$
, $ 6 - 8$ 8 / 9
9 /
"
= ""
1'6'7 .
533E = "
1< 5313 3< 5313 $
$
"># 13 533A '1 3'
533<
$ 533<+5313
=
"
"
$ C)=)M;M! &,9&,L9( ; (=&).L,=9= #;;=9)9=(())D
"
/ 3E = "
""
9""
$ ;
9 "
/ 5311 %" 0
1E
"
$ & '
= " "
1< 53136 $
"># "13 533A '1 3'
533< $7 "
$ >/
= $
/
(
/
'6
7-6
7
+ -3''
' $ '
4''
+ $$ % '
'&' 5'+ )
'$ + +'+ ( "$ ' ' ' 2 00/6 7/!0859:6' # /
' $ & ' $ & '$
'& ;& ' (
$ '' $
4 /" ' <&" =) )& $
$ ' ' $)&
' $
0 + '$$ $ $$ %+ & '$ ' +
* 1A #
9
34 5315" . / + "+
="
*+14
# "> 4 ""
"
$533A 5313
$
" + &
&"
N
L
) .
!
,-.
533<+5313 . '3 6;"14 53137 ; << ?
5313 A< ?
(
51<
"
" !"
533A+533< ,
533A A< ?
,-.
. 533< E4 ; 533< E4 ?
533< A1 ?
(
'5'
?
"
" !"
533<+5313
533< A3 ?
,-.
533<
$533< E4 1?
53137
.533< ?
. $533< E?
?
/ 533< A1 ?
533< ?
533< ?
533< 13A & 533< ,
533< <3 6. 1 1?7 . 5313 1'
?
; 5313 ++ 5313 ++ (
E'4 '
% $
, 533A+533< ,
533A A3 ?
-.
. 533< E?
; 533< ?
533< <3 ?
(
'34 ?
533<
533<+5313
533< ?3 ?
533<7 $533< 'A ?
.533< (
<1
,- .533< ?3 .
6'
533<
. $533< 5E ?
'1 '
53137
/ 533< <1
533< 13E
533< ?
& 533< E< ,
533< <4 ?
. 5313 11'
?
; 5313 << ?
5313 A4 (
A?5 ?
?
533A+533< ,
533A &=#
,-.
. 533< '
; 533< 2< ?
533< ?'
?
(
533<+5313
533< ?
$533< '4 ?
.533< ?
?
. $533< EE
/ 533< EA
533< E4 ?
533< EE & 533< ??
,
533< ?5 ?
. 5313 E?
?
; 5313 E< ?
5313 A3 (
E'?
?
1< ( 9
/
/ $ />/
$
# /
'6II===7
"> $5313+ "
./ > , / / OB% F'
%&
$ G 8"
"> $
""
3E 5315
"/ 12 8
"
">
"
./
$ > 55 53116
"/ 12 53117 # ">
4 67
"
"
$
$
" /
8 "
"
$ "
.
" .
! 6 ,
;H7 0
$ > "
C ">D $* /
""
*+14 69
$7
$.
! $533A+533<533<+ + 4
/ !& 0 &$ % + /& 1 .
!
,.
;H 533A+533< , "533A ?
.$533< ;$533< E4 533< A4 ?
(
1A< 533<+5313
533< AE $533< A5 ?
.533< ?
. $533< 13?
/ 533< A1 ?
"533< <3 ?
533< A5 &"533< A4 ?
, "533< EA ?
.$5313 EA ?
;$5313 A1 ?
5313 A?
(
<A?
# "
" "
0
$ > ">
>
$ $ "> 6
/7 /
""
$
"/ # "> 1'533E
+ 6'7 "
+
.
>
$ (
"
>
/ ">
1< 5313657
5A 53136'7
"> $533<+5313 $
"
D > C
$D *
"+5 "
/
" > 8 "
* " $ " ", " 533A
533< "> $* $">
"" * $ >
$ 8 "
" "31 5313 ;$ 5311
" > / / OB%6 /
$7 "
34 3E 53156157 =
"
D > >
$D 5'
#
"> '6II=7
"
"
B" $
32 3'
5311
B
/ >" =
">
"
./
/ + -,( $$
''& $
=) ' :"(
$ '
= . $ +
& %' 3' + $ &&"
) %
$+ ' ' . +' & ' + )
" ' +
$$ ' ''
'&&' '
% &%3'7
<&"=) '
' + '' $
0 +& ' $
% '
+'+& ' + )
7
<&=) ' 3' $ % ' /4$ %
& '' '
'$$ "
'+
" + '
''
+' ' + % " & + %& ('$ '' & #
' &' "4 % '
'
'$$ "
?( $ ' ''
' &% @
'
" '
&) (' "%
+"+ '
'& 'A B
CD + )
< B"
% /
' ' " % & $$ % '& '* 8 "
0
""
"
./ ""
/ /
$
#
"
$
$ & '
"
$ & ' 467-67
"
$ & '
5?
# & '
;
!"
# 0 "
" $
" $"
/ 0 $ / (
.
"
"
13 533A ( >
.
9""
"
/ 3E 5313 >
" ""
$
,
- ./ ( ""
9""
$$ ;
9 14
%" "/ /"
# "
"/
$
/"
# & ' "
=
"> >
$ 533<+5313 > $
9 K"& 1A?E+8657 5A 5313 $
/
(
/ $
$
" /
=
$
"
$" 5E =
9
*
/
554 9
=
9
> $
"
8
8K "9 <$60
!=/ !"
=1$# =/ - &
>( ,0$? %0@ / / &-
, <
-?E %"'7 . '
'
+ &$$ ' 'A&'
+' '" +"+ $
3'
' %'7 . ' '
+ ' ' & '
' ) %' A&'
' '
' /)&$
* 5A # / "
$
/ .
"
.
! / $"
>
*"
"
M
"
"
" .
/ / "
5< / =
"> $
"
./; > , >
" 13 533A '1 3'
533<
& '"
$
/
"> ( "
./ *"
/
>
$
"> K&
"" K (
/ / $
K + /K &
$
/
"> (
9
/
>
$
1' .
$
533E '3 (
,0$? %0@ / / &<% 67 ( 9
/9
"
9 $
8K "9 $
" % &
'
& ' () %
"
./ /
$
*
$
9
(
/
*
A$&1/
,$&60 > /4 <% 67 9
/
+ -:8 &'
$ $%
% %
'
$ & )
' + & ' '$ & +&
( ' & ' # + )& ' '
$ '$ ' 7 $ $ + %$ $
" '
'
$ " %&" '$
% ' * M/
/
"B
" " > /
" ">$
)
9
" > / ( %"
12 3'
5311 0 +
/
/
/
/ * +13
"
./ "> /
> /
B &
$ /
( ' 9
$5313+5311 $
$"
52
'1 ( /" $ & '
"$
/
"> "13 533A '1 3'
533<"31 533<
'1 3'
">
9 / $">"
/
>/
'5
"
/$
$
" .
! " "
+
/ ''
( "
" /
?A4 46241O15?
">
"
?
;
"
9 /$ (
9 9 /$ /
"
: /
- / ">
*"
" 1
"
90 ""
"$ -8$8 / 9
.
,
./
$ %" , " 8"
-.
'2
.
! ">
9 "13 533A '1 3'
533<K ">K
* "
*
9 "> K
$K K /K K
$K"> ";
9 ,
5< 1<AE *
-3' &&
%& F.F &! F.F %! F.F &0 %! $ ) /
& ' A F ( $ & <& +
'&' $ ?G5 A F =< 73+" &+'' 'D& + ' % $ 6 ' $ "
"
$H/ -!3'' " " +F.F &! F.F %!&&(
%
' $ &&& ' %$
" %F.F&& & +'' & %!I
&&
')
' ' ' !JJJJJ 6!JJJJJ '?
(
"
*"
9 9 " "
533A '1 3'
533<
( , " ( , / $
D
" / $ /
$ > "
'4 9 /
/
/ /
$
" M
/
$/
/ " B "
H / /
'E
( /" & ' "$
$
" //
8K =
/ ./ 6
* +13 5E 3?
53117 "
/ /
M "
$ * " $ // " $ "" " =
/ " * "
"
(
/ $ "
/ $ "
B " * // ( $$ $
"" $ *
/ // (
"/ /$ /
/ $
'A
( 9
/
"
"/
0
0 $
""
$ 8K =
/./ "
B$ %" +
/
$ /
/
;
9
(
"/ 0 ""
"
= "
/ / /
/ / > /
/B /
" // "
/
/
;
9
= $
9
$"
' 9 /
/ /K + /K K + /B
$K-K O6%7K $ & '
67 *" + .
! " 467
">K& ">K "
K
$K
"
" "
$
",
$ "
(
"
'<
( "/" "
=
/ "/ 1'6'7 .
533E
1'6'7+
6! 3' A&'
+' ' "%%&'$ $
'4$ " ' % " $ +'
' $$ ' '
%"+'
&&%
' * ;"
$"
8 / 9 "$ "" /
"
$ = 9
/ ">K
$K (
0 /
1'6'7 "
/
" *+47
"
"
/ 9""
$
K
""
*
/ .
!
* /
0
=
"
( "/ 12 5311 ( 9 /
' 9
$
"" > ( $ " *
"$ / "
( 9
"
" $ ,
B , " >
$ "
(
*
.
>"
$
/"
0
>
$
"
$
M
$ &1/
0 =0 &
$/$%0 6&$0! /$ =16 =16 ( ( '0
'' $)&0
K L 0
''$ K L 0