High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13831/2023dismissed

Kulwinder Singh Kang v. State Of Punjab And Others

2024-05-30Mr. Justice Namit Kumar23 pages

! " !- !'

#$% # '

12 2

1 2

222222 & & '

! -." "&%& '( )%*% '&$ !" 222222! "'

&" /

%!"$'& &%+$% -." 222 & & '

! "&%& '

( )%*% '&$ !" 222! "'

&" 0

!%)

!+%! -." 222 & & '

! "&%& '

( )%*% '&$ !" 222! "'

&" ,

) &"

#$ -." %!%+) 222 & & '

! "&%& '

( )%*% '&$ !" 222! "'

#$ -."

%$- !

222 & & '

! 222! "'

&" "&%& '

( )%*% '&$ !"

!+ +'$% -." 222 & & '

! "&%& '

( )%*% '&$ !" 222! "'

&" / 3 ,

!%"

#$ -." "$

#%!

222 & & '

! "&%& '

( )%*% '&$ !" 222! "'

&" 00

#$ -." 222 & & '

*%#"

"&%& '

( )%*% '&$ !" 222! "'

&" 0 3/,

#$ -." )%!

222 & & '

! "&%& '

( )%*% '&$ !" 222! "'

%!"

#$ -." 222 & & '

! "&%& '

( )%*% '&$ !" 222! "'

/ ,0

+%! -." %"$' 222 & & '

! "&%& '

( )%*% '&$ !" 222! "'

&" /00

#$ -." "!

222 & & '

! "&%& '

( )%*% '&$ !" 222! "'

&" 0

#$ -." *%

222 & & '

! "&%& '

( )%*% '&$ !" 222! "'

&" ,

!"$%!+% -." !%+"%!

222 & & '

! "&%& '

( )%*% '&$ !" 222! "'

&" / 0

, "

#$ -." +% & 222 & & '

! "&%& '

( )%*% '&$ !" 222! "'

&" 3 /,

#$ -." %)% *"

222 & & '

! 222! "'

&" "&%& '

( )%*% '&$ !"

/ 3

#$ -." %!&%!

222 & & '

! "&%& '

( )%*% '&$ !" 222! "'

&" /0

#$ -." "!

222 & & '

! "&%& '

( )%*% '&$ !" 222! "'

&" 0 ,/3

, "

#$ -." "%&% "

222 & & '

! "&%& '

( )%*% '&$ !" 222! "'

&" 3

, % "

#$ -."

!%$$% 222 & & '

! "&%& '

( )%*% '&$ !" 222! "'

&" 3,

, -." "!%) 222 & & '

! "&%& '

( )%*% '&$ !" 222! "'

&" 3/

, "

#$ -."

"%& %+"

222 & & '

! 222! "'

&" "&%& '

( )%*% '&$ !"

#$ -." * %! 222 & & '

! "&%& '

( )%*% '&$ !" 222! "'

&" ,

+%! -." !%- 222 & & '

! "&%& '

( )%*% '&$ !" 222! "'

#$"% $ -." #! - 222 & & '

! "&%& '

( )%*% '&$ !" 222! "'

&" 3 /

, !"

#$ -." *% )

222 & & '

! "&%& '

( )%*% '&$ !" 222! "'

&" %45671 +22"2 8 9:

;"2%<

8: +2# 5 <!

;%< 8 +2%=

:7 ;%< +2:7 > %5?

;%< +2+2"2 5 ;%<

:3,

,;3 2; / ,0;

; 3 ,

; 0

: 8: 8:

@::

,;3/

,; ; /00;

;

; 0

; 3/,

;

<? ":4;%<

@:: :,/3 +2!:5* ?

?;%<

@:: : +2"

:) :;%<

@:: : +2 2"2"

445;%< 8: +2&?<":4"

445;%< : 2 3 /0 +2% >" =

68 +2# 5:" = ;%<

: 2

,0 ;

;

+2$2"2*:;%<

@ 2:

@ 2,:

+2%2"2 :=

;%<

: / ,0

+2B 4:= %:;%<

@ 2:

4:":4- :;%

@ 2:/ +2%5 :59 ;% 3

, < @:: 0

;%<

@::

@ 2

%< / 0

, %%#;5?

*7 : == ; =: 87 :A 8: @:: 6:4:@ :: 9C5:

9 8

:< 9< : ?5: : 2&@ @:: : 6 8 >:

:4 : @ :< %4:595

9 " :: 7

99 : 8 4 : :22 : " 7."

9= = :: 5= 8>: 2 2 & 65 8: @::

6 :9 67 @:: 8 8 88 >:4 " 7 7."

9= 9 :=:4

4 : = 3 7 A@: 23;/ 0 /

,; 8 8: 9 @ 5= 8>: 9 :=:4 4 := 3 7 ( ( > 6<:7;

= 2

D D 598: ":4 4<2 " 5 ?

6 2

2 8:@:: 6

:95%:9

:5: :

>:4:5 8:: 5 ; C5 :4 9.

%A5 867: 6: @::

99 : = <: 82 2 2

5@ =@9:

4 7 ; 67

994:4

=:: =@9

<: "<:!59 4 <:4 <: @:: 2 2 & @:: : 8 8 >:4 "

9= : 4 ) 4: @ @ :< %4:595 +59:@5@ @ " :7 :=:2 $: 9 := : @ 8: @:: : 59 6 99 8 6 : : <: :99 4 3 7 : @ ." :7:::4:=

4 7 ::994 9

6: 72 & & <: =@9 7

%4:595 "<: " :7 8 :::

997 4 < 67

; 8: 8 :59 < <:+= 5= 2 20/067!4: ; @ :< "

" ::; 5?

6; :4 ; 99 @ :< " :: < <: %A5 2 & = 8 @ =594 67 !4: ; @ :< " ::; 5?

6; 5 !59 @ :<"

::%;032 : :@ @5 !4: ; @ :<"

::;5?

6; :4

@ 8<::=

5 !59 5?

6 @ :< " :: !59; 03;

= <:59 =@9 7

@ :<" ::

=:= := = 7 9 = =2!59 0/0 !59 9 8::= =@9 7 7 =; 51 !"!

##""

"$ % # $ """# &% '" '( $' '"! ## "

&2# &

') $! ,2 & ;!59 <6 6@ 967E&5 ?

6" @ :<%4:595 9" :: "<:!59;03F2& 03!59 8 5567E& 5?

6" @ :< %4:595

9"<:" :7"<:!59;

;00/F2!590 00/ 51 !59; !*+*,*-. /0

1 ' "

&2#&

'1$ &$! 2 & ;<: ==

2 2

;!590

00/ !598 = 4 := = @9 78 5 =3 7 7 A@ 5= 8> >: ;8 99: :: 4 4 3 7

5 < <: 8

=@9 7 @@ : 6 :

== 9964 <67 7A::4@ <:: :=

42& : == 51 -!

(345 6"

# 8#;<!(!

8 $

+' #!

9 "#"

! ," + #

## & ' " ' "

$ ' "$

) $ (5$!:

/ 0 '

$"## #9

- *1

"##

/ 0 *$"

$' $

') $ 1' "

'1$& $!

/ 0 *$"

$ '$

'(5$ 1' "

&2#&

') $!

## "

$ #

' "#"

# $

"' !

"#"

# #

;5' !

)<! ## / #0

#3 6

# ! !59;00/; 56 32 & ;!590 !

=67 7!4: ; @ :<"

::;5?

6; :4 ; ,2

;8:@ <: <7= =@9 7 " :7 99 : ::4 4 7 A A@ 5= 8>: ; 8 99 : ::4 4 3 7 7 <: ;8:

= =@9 7 @@ : 6

== 2 2

9964 < <67A::4@ <::

:= 4; 8 92 C597; @:: 6 6 : 4

7 A@ :

,; / 0

, : 8: @:: 8 8 >:4 5= 8>: 9 :=:4 : 4

:= 4 3 7

44:< :

: @ ::4:= 4 7 2 /2 ' :5 : = : ; 8: = 6 :9;8 8:: 6 @:: @@ : 5 :97 8: 5 < :9:4 9

:< =7 @@ 9 <::

% A58:::5 6 : 95: @ 67 = 4:4 ==: @

2" :7 : 8: =7 @::

5 56 9 5 9 5

!59 5?

6 @ :< " ::!59;03: < :9

69 @:: 8:

< :92'=:;: 6 51 4! # #

'#" #:

# " ' " #" "#

/0'

>! ' # 2 $ #

$&# '(5$1 >

$& ') $!+

' # 2 2 $ >! ' # 1 &#"

" #

)< # # -!

# ;

;3 *

3<4 ## ;4! !; ; # "##

/0 '

# "# #

& ## "

$ #

' "#"

# $1 '"' ! "#" #

## ;4! !;

/0'

# # #9 !" /0 *$ "

$ ' $

'(5$ $1 "

&2#&

' 1$$! ## "

$ # ' "#"

# $ 1 '" ' ! (!

# ! ; $ "2 "# $

"#"

1 &#

# #

;5 '

)< / ' '#

0! ?#

;5 '

## % '## '

& $"$ "

$$ '

"$ #"# $ '" " "! "#

1 & # "

;5'

! '"' "

$ $& '1# (5$1

&2#& ' ) $! ' " ' '1# ( (5 $ # &

$ " #

') $!

# & & # #

4('

& &' #$' ' #'''

'$ $ ' !

;5/0'

# #9 @;5! A ' # # # ' ' "

$ /0 % ' # # '

&$ "$ "

$# $ $ '

"$ #"# $ '"" "@!

$ # & # & & '"

' "

$ ' # "$ "#"! $'"""#

/0'

"## #

& ## "

$&& # '"#"

# $ 1 ' " ' & & ) $ # 5)

#& & "##(5 $'"#"

/0'

! " ' # #

;5'

4'B! 5)

;

' "#"

/0 $#!;

;!" ' #$' 3 ##;4! !; ;; / 40&" #'& !& "# ' &' & # "

# "" ## ;4! !; ; & $"# ##

'#! + & " "#" '# >" >CC

##%

$' # '

!#'' ! )! # ! < $ # $ ##

##'" &!!' < ! )!; ;< ' (5 $ & "#"

& $

/ 0 "#! # &'"##

' (5 $ & "## 1 1 & # # !; #

;

;5 '

# ," -!

#;3 *

33<4 ##;4! !; ; ! $'"

"##

## ! ;4!!; ; # 1

! " ':=

& # #" ' '":=

# #

"###

" # $ " # :=

!+ "

"% # $ # "$2# $ #

& $ &

! 2

59 @ :: < 45 @ @ :: < 6 @ <: ==

2 2

:"<:!59;00/;8:@ @ <: <7=@9 7

" : 7 99: ::4 4 7 A@ @ 5= 8>: 8 99:

: ::4 4 3 7 @ <:

=@9 7 @@ :6 6 : == 99 64 < 67A::4@ <:: := 42$ 5 56=: : @@ := @:: : 99 : @:

: 2 2

; ; : 4 := : 3 7 7 <8 4976:

4 7 2$

5 56 6=: == ,2

867 :=

4 65 =3 7 7 7 8 59 97 6 @@9: 9 @@ :== ,2

: 6 =: :

: : == =8:996 @@9: 698: :==:

2 02 ;9 " 5 956=: @ <: !590

"<:!59 6 =: 67 @ 67 = >:4 == : "<: !

!59 8:9 A::4 : 5?

6 @ :< " :: @ 8 < 5 !59 5

!59;03 ;@::

6 99 8 :5 67

4 7 = = ,2

: @ 97 9 4 9 < 9:2 " 5 5 56=: < :

== 6 :=@54 67 @:: : @ 8:@:: 2 2

< 9 59

@ : @5 2 2

@ 8: @:: ;

@ : :=@54 8 7 @:

:: 8@ <: :

@ 67 : * : 52 & ; ::=9: 4 @:: 8 < <: :9 2

,:9 2

D 598:"

":4 4<2" 5?

6 2 2 %=:97; == = = !59 0 5?

6" @ :<%4:595 9" <:" :7"<:!59; 00/; 8: 6 = ,2

; <: %A5 ,; 867 4 := 6 :

:A 4 7 ; A@ @ 5= 8 8>: ; < 6 994 :@8:@:: : ==: 56?= 2/,

D ) 6: ":4 <2 " 5?

6 2' == ,2

%A5 , 6 994 67 @ :: : 7 8: @:: ; : @ : ::4@::

4 7 : @ 97 94 9 < 9: = : :

8: ==

= : !59; 00/2 2 $ H69"5@= 5:( )

*!"#$%; 9 = =5 6:5 7 @ <::

% !592

?54=; 99 81 "! + & ' $

$ #"# ' # $" $#&2#'( $ =D=& "#'

# '

# #

' ##"# '

! + & # ' & "#"

#& &

# $ #

(+, $

!"''# ' $$ &'- ( ) 0

/ 0 !#$$' ! & =

: ?54= $ H69 "5@= 5:

, 1 . !"#$%&'2 ,2 (5;8:9= >:4 == =:!590 ; @ 9:7 ::

6 > 67 5?

6 # # <= : 99 =@9 7 8 < : 4 7 A@ # 5@ GH =@9 78 8 99: 4 3

7 2 @55 : ::

: > 67 # <= 5?

6; !4: ; @ :< " ::; 5?

6; :4 ; 8:9 A::4 @ 8 <::

:=5!59 5?

6 @ :<" ::!59; 03:5 == ,2

=!590 : !59 8: 9:

!59 =: @ <:

@ <: =@9 7 @@ : 6 6 2 2

99 6 4 <67 7A::4@ <:: := = 42 2 )5::

9 :

9 6 > : " 5 ?

6; 4 := 99 =@9 7:7 : = !5 592 3 5?

6:<:9"< <:!59- 95=

;

; : ==

:: 8: :

:!59 4 := 9 6= @ 8:"

# <==@9 72(5 5;: : 69 9 7: :9:

:4@8:@:: 2% =:97; ==: !59; 00/ 6= ,2

867@ <: !590 6 =: 4 := 65 7 2 2& = 6 5@ 67@ =@9 7 <6: 4 7 2&@8: @::

<6 :9 6 5 7 = :

== 8 @::

: <4 :=2 32 ":=:9 :5 9 :4 5 5: 4 :=

= 3 7 7 67 "

$ 7 <: :5: 32 2

, 6 : 5@9 67 : 5 :

, "!"# $% *; 8::8 9 51 ;(! & '# &"

# ##;)!!; 42 &$ $ # ' ') $ ! ;)!+ $&&

# & $ 2#$ >"#"

' & ,# !E # '' >" "

$ % # #

#"# $ $

& "$ '"# $ >"!

1 # # # # #1 ' '

& #

! ## $

<!;)/0 '

'" '!

# #9 <!;)/09 *1 & ## '

$ >" "

'" '' #$'"& '''$ $!:"

#' ' " 1 1 " & ' " $

# & "

##& ! ;!

# "

! # "!*$>" "

(5 $ ' # "

# ' 1 1 "!

"##

#! ;5! # # ## ;)!5!; 4 ' '" (5 $ ) $ &

# % '

1 # $" #"'1

' "

"! * ' "

$ $# ' ( (5 $ # 1 " #

2# "&1 2

' '

' "

#! #

$ # # #"

' ) $ ' ## ;)!5!; 4 & # '

!+ ' & % " ' ''# 2 "

## #! 1 1 1 1 <;! '"

$ $ '" ## $ 1 F!- # ! ' # ##/5(0

" (;<! 6 6 F!- = / 0& & #G "

$' ## 7 $5<#& $

8 8""&!+ "#E''!!5<!E E5!;!5<#& 2 # ' '

>""

$ # '" (5 $ (( $! &# "

" ' # $

$"##!

& # #' > " # # '"'"(5 $(($& # '"$& &!+ +F!- =/ 0 :=

" ## &

# # & 1" % # '1 '

' ' " # #'

&9 !!!!!!!D '& '& ' & # ' 1"

" # # ' $

'"!+##

&# $#

# ! '

'""" ' '

#"#

' "

!'2

'''$

##'''"## ##

' " $ #'' '" ## ## ' ! "

" " '

' #

' 1 # '" ' ' "

$ # # "

$" $ ' $ # # " "

$ &

$ ! +

#" '

"& #"

' ! E#

## ' ' ' "

" 1 ' "

$H #'' #

&# "#' ""

'# $ ' $! ' '

" '#'' "' $ " % ' $ & "

' # "' 1 # G ! " # ' $ # $! E' '$ #''"# ##&

' "$ "

" ' ! B #

$% ' $ #' # & $ "

##'

'& $#$ % ' $!B &

# # # # &# "

# !+' ' "'1#

$ & "2 $ $ # = ' &

# '

' '1 ' "

' "# #' "!B $"

% #

# & # ' ' 4! D & #$' ' $ 2 ' " '

# # ## $ '# & &$ ! 1& #"# G #2! #

" #7 # 6 !7 # '

' '' ### $ " & " "% ! <<!+#' >"# '"'") $ (5$ ' "

# ## ;)!!; 4 $ # I 1 1 1 1 4!6## # '#$'"$# ' >" # '" ''")

$(5$# $

1 D2!

/2 &$ H69"5@= 5

$1 / 01 24

& 0)/ !1 $1 # ""

" 9 4 5@ 5 : : 74 <67 5 5 759 <: :: 2 , :?54=

51 45!B"$ $$ ':

&!B ## : # & $ "!6 : &1 ' " ' 1# # ' $# ) $

# 'E $ !D$ ' "#&:

: # $

# #-!

& ; 5$ #

; ;!+ $&

$#' ' "

###

$: & ' # -! " #!

# '

& # "

" '' " ' # ' "

# # '

# &$ "#! D ' ' &

# $# ## '' 1###" $ # ""# # ! ' & "$ : & ' ' $ "

## "

## #-!&# # & '

# #

# & #'' "# J?

: # & , $ ' J?

:! :

"## ' $ $ ' ' # ' #' # '"# "

" 2 J?

: #! B ' ## & '1 ' ' "

$ $ $ $ "

##&# !

! ' &$ # $ $

K #! 2

<:8 4 :4:5 : 9@ @ ::

9 8;: 5: :9: : 8::=@54

::4 =::@@:: ; = 67:=: 8: 2

, !2"2 @ >:4. 1 B.

!@ 69 1 B.