M/S Amar Builders v. State Of Haryana & ORS





  
   


 

"#







 $% &' ()*' +' ,'( -'. /'  + 0* 





 $% &' ()*' +' ,'( -'. /'  + 0*  $ 1 2$  -
$  1 2$ - -
2
- 
22 ' $'-3.4(/)5-' *657/ $' '3(-/(8)5 *65'/0' $',/)'95 **) *6')5'.5


 / '*' /)) *0  '&* 7 7' 0  : "

;;"  !

" 5 7/' /))9   / '*' ** <"

" = >('?"

@57/'A./'7'**/0' B' '(  6'& ))9  0)5 ' 01 7 '&**:"

;;!!

" 57/'/))9/'*' ** <"

"  = >(' ?"C@5 7/'A. / ' 7'**  / 0' B' '(  6'( .0  '* ' 6( '$-''5017'&*
:"

;;"!

" 5/0'7))*7'8' '(6'&))9 0)5'0''

0' #5 D5 #5;<D%?/*'7A&0)*7/"; &//0''/('/9A89('' (& !

5< 5<

%?5/7/**6'/0'5A(/ *'79/7'87'(00)*/0'/0'7 '&* "

;!

"!*!C ;!

"!//0'(7'8 6'.)7*7*6*'/0*7'8
'0 /'5/*/0'7//(9//'(7 /( 7 '*5 A(  '0  '&9 ( /' 7' &. *0*9
00'/(/*0'')6'/ /' 7' 0  / 0' 7' 0'  '(  ))9 A()*9*//(/(5/'7*).7( /*9 6' / *'79 * A(  /6. '  /''5 / 0' (9/ ')  0.&  " ''5 A( / & 7  ')*
0*(/*')9/(*90.

&5 /'0*/(&'(9//0'9'7'8 '.*)/'*/0'//7()*A *9(*')(#C"/'9'&/''5 / 0' >0)* / *(  A  &  / -5 / '7 &')   6)A)  / &'85 7//  *).9 / &). &0)/0'3
)0*(/''/7( 7(*/0'!

" ///0 /7'876'.)7*//0'/&0)*). # E/7'8/0'))9/(/7(*/ 0'A( / 0'**& 7// ))9) *&* '0*    0' '& (A&9 / '0).  (/ /7 ( 5 / 0' ) )*  00) A' '0* ! F /

< -(0'*9 9'5 ') :

'/5 4') (*' )( ! !/*'76'5(/00)7*** /(9/7A)9'.**/&7/0'*C *./ 0''//*).&0)/0'37'A(A) )./'0**/***9/00)5/' )7'&*<"

" 
 '0).5 / '0* 0* ( / /' 7 0(

*').&'&)(! * 'A''&)(!#  / ' 9'& 
 / A 6''* / / 0' / &'A).)*/6/&))**7/9'&*/ (9/>&)&6*&&(** ;!

"<
/ A 0* ( /  * / *'79 7' /** 6'  / 0'"# "!6* >(' ?!
/A)'*/ ))*7'8&).**).7*(*'795A(*( /'''A(A)/0'
/A6''*// 0' / '* / *&*  " '' 7/( 6)(9 / G((&7'8*7/(.*)'G('*(*')( !/ '*
/A0*(/0.&  D5D"5 "

%? * !C5# 5;##%? /6 A &*  / 0'  " ""!

"! * ""

!!

"<'06).5A(/''/0'*).*/>( /'
  ) 0* ( / )).5 / *' 00'6) && 0* / '&&*  / - =4')@ ' '&/'&9/)*"! " 76'5 !*&9/)*"

" 5/*' 00'6)&&57// 7**A. ""$&A')(*9/9'=@= *@H

 = '*9@H  = ()*9@H  =- @H  =

@   =

 @H=@H= $@57***(/7( /''/0'7/.'/()*A '&*)&).5!

" 5/*' 00'6)&&  <'* &9 *** / &0 (/'.  &0).' &. 8 ''&''*7/'&** '9'&
5/''5'*'7(*(9 &&9-(A69'* ('9'' )&('&/7'8* 69/'*)'*()'/0'57*// 0'//))9*/'&/'7'0 6 /(9/ / *(  / 0'  A *  A ' '& A)&/  / ' 7  A &0)* 7/ "; &/  /'  9') ' / / *9 * /  7 /** 6'  / 0'"# "!
/'3*'5//*96' 7*0(*'/'/A'*/'0*</7' -(A6)9'(00). A()*9/0'57// 7 /** 6'  -0&A'5 !

"<  / * A()*9  0'  / '57//(A3&':" ;;!!

" 
'0 ))9 A()*95 /'   ' /'  / 7' 0 '  / '3*'//7/**6''/A()*90)7' &* 6)A) 
 00' / / 0' / &* 6'&  / 0 ')9  '  '(  '*  / 6( '/0'0/(9//0'7'00' '(6'&))9A()*9

# - / 0' / )*  >( / ' 7/ & 0''A*5 7 *  * / / 0'  A 0'&*  *0( / '&  / ' A. 7.  0' 7' 0 G().5/7'0*&* 7 &9  : "

;;!  !

" 5 / ' ' '(6'('*' 6('$-''5 0796/0'

"!7/0()// A()*9 /6  A '(* 7/ "; &/  / '  / 0'//(9//7/**6'5A(/*'79/ 7'8A>(*7'/**6'/0'*/6 7' "

!!

"<*!< !!

"<'C&/'&/* />(/9'&5//7'8/799()) 79 * / / *'79 /6  A '6*  / 0' 6.*//&'9/'(7()*A*'*'& /*'0/*'79
7"< <!

"<5*'7' (*/-(A6)9'5:=

@50(00)./ *'79 ' **) 0(. &&'1 '* = @  / 0'  ' "

 &/ '& / ))&  / 7'8   "D ;!

"<5 / 0' 7 '6* 7/    /  / / 0'9'7'8'.%)70**0''&>* / &)  ' 9'& 
 '0 /'5 / 0' >0)*//*'79'/ '*7/**6'/& ).789*>0'/0'()'A()*9))/&) /0'3/6A/6*A./&/0'79'6* 7/   ** " ""!

"<  /  / / 0'  (9 *).  /69 / &)  / 0' ' /  

06'0'6**'0* '**&*9))9) 9'%A'*'&/0'5/0'7)7//' 05A()00)A'/'0*!F/-(0'*9 9'54')')5:

'/54')!< " '&  )( ! !  / *  / '  76'5 *  **9/00)5/0'7'6*7//7(** "  9 / ). D E / 7'8/A &0)*A. / 0'*()&)./'/A'&*<"

" 
 '0).5 / *  / '0*  / /  * / *'797'/**6'/0'57//87)*9*A./ 0')'** # C!

"!= >('?D@/*'797' /** 6'  / 0' &&*). ' / &A)I  &/'.5)A('*&')/7'8
'*// 0')/*///*'6*/*'795A(/'. '*5/''5/*).7*(/(*'79 ,*&&(** # C!

"!5/0')*&*// 7'8999*0**('*/7))&0)/7'8 7//0()*0'*
('/''*//0'>(* /7'80'*'79(00)*/&5A(7/6'.)70/ 0'(9/')0.& "''5A(7/(969. *)/7'8>(*
/A('/'0*(/)) ('.5 "<57'8/( DC# )7>(*5/''5/*&* (0 "''()*/6A'*
/A('/'0*( /  (&  !; )  0.A) (  7// )G(** *&9 

!

5< 5!C""%?A'6'*'&/0'/''5/)& /0'/*(0.&/A')*A)

/'3*'5/0'/''*//*'79 7' /** 6'  / &/  -0&A'5 ! "! ).H /''5 / '&/'3(A)

0'()*6= >(' ?!@/7//0' /(*'8&0)/7'8))'0(0 !"

" / *' 00'6)&&9C&&A'***)/ '   &9 /)*  "!

"   76'5 (/ * 7 '*'*"

" 57/'7***(/7(   / *' 00'6) &&   <'* &9 /)* 

" ')6*//&0(/'./&0).'&.8 ''&''*7/'&** /'9'&/''5&&9-(A6 9'* ('9'7(*'/)&('& /7'8*

 / 6'. (5 )'* () ' / '0* / '*0')&'.A3//''A')(')6 /*0(*G(A7/0'
'9(*/7//' /'*)./0'/0''/0'/'0* *0(*G(5/''5(/G(A00'0'). ***A./7'(' //'/*5)'*()'/0''' /3(*9&1A)-(0'&(''A))-/ /' ,
*)'0'2* /'=!

<@!-"

*
* /','('62&*=! ""@#-DC  * / '()  >)(  / 7' 3('*  (  6)A).  )'6 '&*.   *'  / (' *  

;

&*'./''5//'0*0).))9)5 /('7'3('*/()*''6*/))9)
 **//9/0').(&)? *'0* 5A(/*'0*/)*'0). *6*() 0.5 A(   '0'6  '0* "  <5 /''5*6''/()*A'*9/'0* 69/'*)'*()'/0'57**. &'/0'7'0 
 '0))9  &)?*5 (    / / *  '& / ' /  A 8 A.

 '0*   ) 
 5 /   6 &&A'  / *' 00'6)&&57///*'*/'&/ ' 
 5   0  &5 / *' 00'6) && 0*/'&&*/-(0'*9''& /'5A()'7/*'7/*****(/' /7(/0' 2'*()'/0'70'9(// *'797'/**6'&5A('&/'*9/*65 0.

?!5   00' / 6* )' ** ;!

"<5 / 0' / (*'8  &0) / 7'8  )) '0 (0 !"

"   / 0'/&*.9'6'0?/*96'/ *'79 0'/7'&5/'7&*).(00).9 *'79    / '*   / **) 0(. &&'  /''5 7 * / / *).  /*9 6'  / *'79   3(* *  A9 '*  6' (0  *).   &0)9/'(

/ 3(*9&  'A)) -/1  =(0'@   /  / / A'  3('*  . )'6 '&*.  '()  *'*&0()/'*0(A(/0'0 )**7>&9/&'/57*//0'5 7//*()*0''&9/'5A('9A9.*). /*96'*'796*'()A)9 G().5 7 *  * . &'  / 0' 7' 07))/&)*&*


































 
























,&)